I've loved this place for so many years but I have to say it tastes like they've fallen off. Pizza doesn't taste as good as it used to taste for years. Something has changed, I'm thinking the sauce. Service and family that runs the business are amazing and seating in the shop is dismal at best. Time for me to re-evaluate the other shops in town and make a switch. :o( read more

Village Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Goshen, New York

Village has delicious pizza and generous family specials. The garlic knots are pretty top tier.

We were in the mood for some local pizza when visiting Legoland, so we came over to Goshen and found Village Pizzeria. The service was extremely friendly and welcoming! We ordered several slices of pizza, which were generously sized (regular, pepperoni), and house salad. The food was delicious and just what we needed after a busy day building up an appetite. They offer a couple of tables inside and a few outside, but otherwise it seems it is mainly carryout. Free street parking after hours was available just around the corner at the time of our visit. read more

Village Pizzeria - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Goshen, New York

Best pizza around and it's not even close. If I'm anywhere within 15 Min of it I driver there read more

My pizza had someone's form of payment in it. Use to be my favorite pizza place in Orange County for 25 years but going downhill over the last two years. mistakes happen, it most times I order I feel I made a mistake. read more

Amazing pizza cooked by an amazing family! We had the friendliest and most accommodating service here! They were so kind and welcoming to us even knowing we were drifters passing through town on our way to Harrisburg from Albany! They only have a few tables inside and it primarily seems like a thriving take out business. They accommodated our group of 6 anyways! And what's really crazy is that the food was even BETTER than the top notch service! What a pizza!!!! Plus the antipasto salad was delicious and beautiful, the eggplant and chicken parm's were super and the portions were generous! If I ever find myself in this part of New York again, I'm going to find my way back here! read more

We came here two weeks ago, and the pizza was amazing. The staff was friendly and the prices were also really good. My only comment to the management/owners is that in the hotter months, you should give employees at least a fan to circulate the air. There is no AC, which is not a problem for the customers, but at least management should be considerable towards their staff to give them proper work conditions. I was disappointed only in that. read more

The food is absolutely delicious. The slices are on point. The owner and his wife are also the sweetest people. This is the spot for a good dinner. read more

What can I say about Village Pizzeria! Been going here for many years and their pizza is amazing! They are always friendly and very welcoming! It is a small establishment and not much seating, but I've always ordered and picked up. I've never had food there that I didn't like! They have done a lot for the community, (especially during the pandemic) so if you're ever in the area and you wanna try amazing pizza this is the place to go!! Yummy!! read more

Amazing fresh pizza! Tried the graffiti, vodka Sicilian, and grandma slice! Fair pricing and great service! Would definitely go back.

Way too busy and unable to handle there popularity. Kitchen is too small. Need to move.

Village Pizza in Goshen seems like a great family restaurant. Great food, friendly service, and an overall really good customer experience. Definitely a welcoming spot to grab a meal read more

Service perfect Hole in a wall but smells amazing.. you can smell it before you open the door.. amazing pizza so amazing two pies are going home with me to Virginia.. perfect Italian spot. Frankie playing in the background you know you in the right spot read more

See all

This place is good. PERIOD. It's unexpected and very small interior. But this place has good crust and great customer service. If I'm up in this area I am going back! The white slice was decent, the plain is where it's at. The Margherita slice is ok. I was hoping for better quality mozz and whole leaf basil. Overall, the place fits the bill and is reasonable. read more

Village Pizzeria - Margherita Slice - Pizza Near Me - Goshen, New York

See all

Food was amazing, atmosphere was great, everyone was super friendly, and Uncle Paulie is the goat

The food was tasteless. I have had better jared sauce. The chicken parm had little Flavor. Ended up throwing out $50 worth of food. Would not recommend. Maybe their pizza is better. read more

This place is in our top three for Orange county . Reminds us of Westchester quality. Worth checking out-try their personal white pie.

Pizza straight from the hole in the wall. I don't mean to call this place a hole in the wall because this is some of the best pizza I have ever had, but it literally is a hole in the side wall of Goshen with 3 tables and the BESSSSSST Gluten Free pizza I have EVER EVER EVER had. Have you ever had a great gluten free pizza and then you get to the crust and you're like 'what happened?' ..... well ..... this gluten free crust is REMARKABLE!!!! They import it straight from Italy! The owners daughter, most gracious and informative gal, guided me towards what is and isn't gluten free on the menu. It turns out someone close to her is also gluten free so the place being familiar with the allergen, is a bonus! (There are some pizzerias carrying gluten free pizza without knowing a single thing about it). So I love that they are knowledgeable in this regard. My mother hasn't quite found a GF pie that tickles her (difficult to please) tastebuds quite like wheat-grain pizza dough, but I think this may be the winner!! I will take her here for Mother's Day and wait for the reaction and review from my Mama herself. read more

Village Pizzeria - Gluten free pizza - OMG - Pizza Near Me - Goshen, New York

BEST Cesar salad I have ever had!!! Pizza was delicious. My children gobbled it up! Delightful service. The woman was very kind and efficient on the phone. When we picked up our food, too small to eat here, she offered a place to enjoy ice cream. We brought it back to Legoland resort and had a nice meal in our room. Better deal than what they offer for food. Highly recommend! read more

Yaaaas!!!!! This teeny little spot was a hidden gem to say the least. Super cheap and super amazing real deal NYC pizza. The employees were fantastic as well! Great place to hit for a lunch after Legoland!!!! read more

Village Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Goshen, New York

Our favorite dining experience while in Goshen (only 5 min from LEGOLAND). The absolute friendliest staff. And what about the food? Well it was FANTASTIC! You MUST try their meatballs, whether it's solo, in a Hero, or on a pizza. We ordered the Jumbo special - 2 large pizzas, large baked ziti, and large antipasto salad. A ton of food for ~$40 (slightly more than $36.99 because we added toppings to the pies). This deal is available everyday, just have to pay cash. I wasn't expecting much from the ziti or antipasto, but was quite surprised at how delicious they were. The salad was loaded with toppings and had plenty of deli meat and cheese, I didn't even need to add dressing or vinegar/oil. The ziti was meatless, but didn't seem to be missing anything because of the ricotta added to it. And that pizza was a highlight - we enjoyed our taste of NY-style pies! There's not much room to eat-in, as they function more for take-out/catering; however, the staff were so kind and brought out another table and chairs so we could all eat there, rather than going back to our hotel. I would come here just for the friendly encounter; the food is a HUGE BONUS! read more

See all

I've been going to Village Pizza since Sal opened in Goshen from Queens 40 years ago. It was so great to have a pizza place that reminded me of pizzerias in NYC. Sal's family, son, wife, grandson, granddaughter have carried on the tradition with great food, friendly customer service, and knowing how their customers like their food. Can't say enough good things. Best pizza in Orange County - located in Goshen. Evelyn Campbell Hall, NY read more

One Bite, Everyone Knows the Rules! This slice was delicious. Great undercarriage, nice snappy crust, good sauce, and great customer service! I asked for pepperoni, I got all the pepperonis lol. Great spot! 8.5 read more

Village Pizzeria - a small child in a chef's hat - Pizza Near Me - Goshen, New York

See all

Wonderful pizza made by a wonderful family! Just be sure and order ahead otherwise there will be a wait!

While driving around upstate NY, we stopped in this little town to refuel - both literally and figuratively. We stumbled across this little pizza joint and were blown away by how good it was. Just as good, if not better than any pizza you'll get in the city. Perfect crust, cheesy, not too much sauce, and semolina on the bottom made it the perfect slice read more

Delicious Pizza !!!! I'm from Brooklyn where pizza is THE BEST ..... villiage pizza tastes just as good we are regulars - service is always good too . read more

We are from out of town now but I used to live in NYC -- this pizza was AWESOME! So delicious!! We got the scrambler, slice of pepperoni, and drinks. Everyone was so nice and friendly when i picked it up and it was all packed up for me to carry easily to my car. Would totally come back if I lived closer!!! read more

Amazing customer service, friendly atmosphere and incredible pizza. All it takes is one bite and your in love. Will definitely travel the 2 hours from CT.. read more

Glad Goshen is in my future travel plans as I'm looking forward to eating here again! As a fellow reviewer said, the pizza is excellent! Just the right amount of everything to make it a great slice! Will order additional items in the future. read more

We are visiting from Maryland and stopped at this pizzeria. Not only was the food amazing the customer service was stellar! They were super friendly and welcoming as soon as we walked in the door. My five year old is usually super shy and they made him feel right at home. We honestly felt like family and we have known them our whole lives. We opted for Bacon Pizza, Caesar salad and a Meat Stromboli. I would recommend 10/10 for food, ambiance and service! We can not wait to go back! read more

Village Pizzeria - Meat Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Goshen, New York

See all

My bedroom is larger than this place but these folks somehow manage to put out a massive amount of food for hungry locals and masses from LegoLand. And there is a reason why they are so busy - value! That stromboli for $15 will feed 3 people. What else is good there? Everything. Especially if you are visiting LegoLand hotel, skip the meals there and drive the 2 miles. Get the whole pie too. Skip the slices. You want the whole thing. You need the calories for all the walking you will do at LegoLand :-) read more

The shop reminds me of the city, as well as the pizza and the wings. Being able to find and establishment like this when you move to a new place, it makes you feel like you are right back where you came from. read more

Fresh and tasty pie, super friendly, family feel for a little Italian joint, get it to go, read more

Village Pizzeria - customers at the counter - Pizza Near Me - Goshen, New York

Full disclosure, we are from Tennessee, where the typical pizza decision is "does Papa John's or Pizza Hut have the better coupons right now?" We ordered two pizzas for our family of five: one plain ol' cheese, and one white pizza with half veggies, half chicken/bacon. It only took half of each pizza to fill up five starving park-goers and the white pizza in particular was a revelation of flavor. I cannot speak to whether Village serves "pizza as good as *insert borough here* but I don't really care either. After three days of LegoLand, Village delivered wonderfully in terms of both flavor and overall value. read more

Great slice and good service. Quick and easy to conveniently grab and go. Can't beat the price for two slices and a can of Pepsi for under $10. read more

Awesomeness John Paul and his staff were amazing! The pizza fresh ,delicious and oh boy ,I wanted more! The conversation was entertaining. I felt like back home in 'NYC. The food and the atmosphere were perfect. I will definitely be returning.Its a must visit for everyone! read more

Came to town for Legoland. Searched reviews for local pizza in the area. We tried a couple shops and Village Pizzeria was one on the list. By far the stand out and really great! I called in the order, drove down and easily found a parking spot. The shop is small and all working there were kind. The shop is locally owned and I highly recommend supporting this business. If you're passing through or staying locally for the amusement park I would absolutely recommend leaving an order and experiencing Village Pizzeria for yourself! No doubt best pizza in town! read more

The best service I have ever received. Great NY style pizza. If you are even remotely near this place - stop! Such a gem.

Excellent pizza by far in orange county ny. Town of goshen. Absolutely delicious. Nailed it withe sauce cheese and crust. read more

Village Pizzeria - This is by far the best pizza in orange County. Right down to the crust. Amazing . - Pizza Near Me - Goshen, New York

The food is sad and tastes bland. There is no seating either for the most part and the 3 seats inside are quite gross. The service of time is the only positive I have but I would rather wait a few minutes for something good. read more