I tried this place with a friend and ordered takeout to eat back home. Considering we ordered a…read morebasic margarita pizza, I didn't expect much, but was VERY pleasantly surprised. It was delicious! Even from taking it home (and even reheating later) the crust was crispy, the toppings stayed fresh, and the texture overall was delicious. She picked it up so I didn't get a peek inside, but I would happily give this place another shot.

One of my favorite local restaurants. You can't beat the prices and I've literally never had…read moreanything bad from here. The pizza, the pasta, the calzones, are all amazing. In fact Up North became so popular they had to move across the street from the original location to have more room. If you come to Goldsboro this is essential dining!

We were in town recently for a sporting event and decided to pick up a pizza after. I called ahead…read moreat like 5 p.m. and was told there was at least an hour wait. I mean, it was a Saturday - so - okay, but 5 p.m. is so early to be on that kind of wait already! We ordered a medium pie and the garlic knots. Even coming in after the hour wait, our order still wasn't ready and we waited for probably another 15-20 in the restaurant before it was done. At this point, I'm expecting this pizza must be better than anything else I've ever tasted. Unfortunately, not so much. The pizza was huge - I give it that. A medium was more like a large/extra large at other places. It's not the best NY style pizza I've ever had, but it wasn't the worst. The garlic knots were interesting -- VERY heavy on the butter/garlic topping stuff - so much so it cakes the bottom of the pan. I can see why that would appeal to a lot of folks, but for me and my kids, we found it to sort of just make the knots soggy and mushy instead of that nice balance of dough crisp bread and flavor. Overall, probably on the 3 1/2 star scale for me with the wait/service issues and mostly average flavor.

Divine food, for sure it's the best pizza I've ever had, hands down. Very friendly staff, always…read morewelcoming. They never fail to deliver, literally.. no pun intended. If you haven't gone yet, what are you waiting for?

I frequently head to Sugar Hill Pizzeria on Sunday evenings when I have work in Kinston. I always…read moreorder the same thing, a supreme pizza, so I can't speak for all of the other things on their menu. But I've enjoyed delicious pizza each time I've visited. The staff is friendly and helpful.

Thank you to Sugar Hill Pizzeria for hooking us up with a free pizza after a long night working a…read moregas leak outside the pizzeria. The guys from Wright Traffic of NC appreciate you greatly. The pizza is great and the staff are friendly.

I love Crick's Pizza !! Actually.. I love absolutely everything about this place.. the food is…read moresoooo delicious Their homemade marinara sauce is the best I have ever tasted..(I always order extra sauce in dipping cups) I have so many favorite items.. The meatballs in marinara sauce with the mozzarella cheese baked on top is out of this world!! Along with the fried mozzarella cheese sticks, the baked lasagna, their salad.. I could go on and on .. and last but not least.. is the PIZZA I love ordering the 2 slices lunch special !! Heck, I LOVE ALL their lunch specials... One of the nicest things about Crick's is how much their Faith In God shows in everything they do...when I call in for take-out, I always feel better after that call!! Now, all I can say to the people reading this review is to RUN, not walk to Crick's!! You can thank me later!!

Not a terrible place, could be a lot better, could be a lot worse. Food is ok, price is also ok…read more The restaurant itself is small and nice, pretty clean as well.

I love their hot subs. I get the turkey and cheese. I add ham. The pizza is awesome too.read more

Pizza always good and hot. However, person taking my order over the phone was not listening and…read moreput the wrong toppings on my pie. Not what I wanted but ate it anyway .

The best pizza in Goldsboro! I love this place! Service is great . They are so friendly. the pizza…read morecant be beat! Pizza by the slice too!

Had a great meal at Mimmo's earlier tonight. Food was great (bring back the pistachio cheesecake,…read moreplease!) but what really made our night was Gabbie, our server. Gabbie was warm, welcoming, attentive, funny, and very good at her job. In a nutshell: "We went to Mimmo for the food. We'll go back for the hospitality."

Amazing service. Amazing food and drinks. My boyfriend and I were recommended the kale salad, which…read morewe were scared to try, but it was FANTASTIC. Pizza was amazing. Had great drink recommendations.

I ate here recently for the first time with my hubby, son, and brother. We all loved it! We arrived…read morewithout a reservation on a Friday night, and had about a 25 minute wait. We were sat right in front of the kitchen, at the end of a shared table. We loved seeing all the different pizzas being made and how efficient the team worked. To start we had the ricotta dumplings and the kale salad. Both tasted fresh, unique, and delicious. We then shared the soft egg pizza, the brussels sprout pizza, and the pizza americana (cheese) for the little guy. We enjoyed all of them, especially the brussels sprout. An added bonus to sitting where we did is that the gentleman preparing the pizzas made an extra and offered it to us. We were stuffed so we declined, and he gave it to the kitchen staff, but it was nice of him to offer!

Pizza was disappointing. Threw half of it away. This was not a NY pizza. Staff was friendly but…read morefood was not good

Pickle Festival 2023. We popped in here for a cold beer and food that did not include a long line…read moreat a food truck. If their performance and food quantity during the busiest day in Mount Olive history is any indication for the rest of the year--go without hesitation! The owner greeted us immediately upon entering. The beers were ice cold and they had a hot pizza special boxed up and ready for purchase. No wait. The pizza is really good. We've ordered pizza from here before on other occasions and it has never disappointed. Servers are on top of their game. Even with the crowds the restroom and dining room were clean.

Of all the Papa John's locations this one is the best I have been to. Yes it takes longer on busy…read morenights and weekends but they are a great bunch who seem to work together well for the customer.

I have ask everything for them not to put pepercinicinisand garlic sauce in my box.And they did…read moreanyways.And the pizza wasn't really good.I will not spend another penny on this place again.I have one question to ask.I called the papa johns number.Why did a doordash diver deliver the pizza.Has all your driver quit.