We were in town recently for a sporting event and decided to pick up a pizza after. I called ahead at like 5 p.m. and was told there was at least an hour wait. I mean, it was a Saturday - so - okay, but 5 p.m. is so early to be on that kind of wait already! We ordered a medium pie and the garlic knots. Even coming in after the hour wait, our order still wasn't ready and we waited for probably another 15-20 in the restaurant before it was done. At this point, I'm expecting this pizza must be better than anything else I've ever tasted. Unfortunately, not so much. The pizza was huge - I give it that. A medium was more like a large/extra large at other places. It's not the best NY style pizza I've ever had, but it wasn't the worst. The garlic knots were interesting -- VERY heavy on the butter/garlic topping stuff - so much so it cakes the bottom of the pan. I can see why that would appeal to a lot of folks, but for me and my kids, we found it to sort of just make the knots soggy and mushy instead of that nice balance of dough crisp bread and flavor. Overall, probably on the 3 1/2 star scale for me with the wait/service issues and mostly average flavor. read more

See all

Divine food, for sure it's the best pizza I've ever had, hands down. Very friendly staff, always welcoming. They never fail to deliver, literally.. no pun intended. If you haven't gone yet, what are you waiting for? read more

When my daughter got remarried they had Brooklyn pizzeria cater the reception. The marriage didn't last, but I can't forget that lasagna!!! Best I ever had! I guess I'm going to have to drive all the way to Goldsboro and get a tray. We froze part of it, it came out like it had just been made. This is some good food, people!! read more

I was in your restaurant tonight and seen and heard one of your employees yell at, what appeared to be a delivery driver, who lookedlikehe was in his 50's. This might fly in Brooklyn, but this ain't Brooklyn. It was highly unprofessional behavior. The delivery driver appeared to have gone ahead of the line and was waiting at the far end. He didn't appear to be pushy or demanding attention. To embarrass a customer or even a delivery person is not acceptable especially in front of appropriately a dozen other customers. read more

The service was so so slow.... Horrible wait time due to getting door dash orders out..

A slice of pizza from here always takes me back home to New York. This is my go-to spot for a fresh, humongous slice, and it never disappoints! The staff in the back are always nice, and the restaurant has a welcoming, family-friendly vibe. read more

Pizza was burnt on one side. It was paper thin on the nonburnt side.wasnt even in the oven when we arrived after calling in the order 15 minutes prior. First time it was unsatisfactory. Will try 1 more time and if bad then will go elsewhere. Dough boys is the same type pizza. Hung up when we called without giving price or time to be ready. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pizza I think - Pizza Near Me - Goldsboro, North Carolina

Trusting my fellow Yelpers, we ordered a Large Brooklyn Special tonight via Uber Eats (which was slower.than.CHRISTMAS) yet far cheaper than the DoorDash option here on Yelp and on The DD platform. With that in mind, I am seriously missing the Gopher delivery service that doesn't take a cut of small business' sales and is far more efficient. Gig workers - Check out Gopher(dot)io- It's a NC company, too. I digress. The pizza itself was remarkably great. Next time, and there will be a next time, we'll opt for a medium with extra sauce and a longer (well done) bake time. Cost for this beauty delivered was $29.20, not including tip. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Large Brooklyn Special - Pizza Near Me - Goldsboro, North Carolina

OMG, this is the best pizzeria I have ever been to in North Carolina . there is nothing you could say about this place hands down. They won't be any other place that I will go to here in North Carolina other than Brooklyn pizzeria service is spot on. very clean very and very friendly. read more

Pizza size is wild! Ordering a large is like ordering an XXL anywhere else. Cheese tastes great. But anything else is lackluster and pretty greasy. If you're looking for quantity over quality, send it. Otherwise, a small cheese will feed your family of four. read more

Food was really great. It could be a little cleaner Worth going to. Service was good - many people there. read more

Beat food EVER ! Have never had nothing bad. Eat here all the time. Great, friendly people !

I got a pepperoni pizza and it was one of the best New York style pizza I've had. The young lady was patient and sweet to us. Overall definitely would come back . read more

Credit where credit is due, this was a very New York-y place, from the utilitarian ambiance, steady crowds, and floppy, cheesy pizza. I ordered mine in person and ate dinner there, and probably a dozen people left with takeout while I waited (wish I'd called ahead). What arrived was a massive pizza of which I could eat only two slices, despite having skipped lunch that day. I got half peppers and half mushrooms, neither of which were fresh, which was a bit disappointing but they weren't bad. I was baffled that someone apparently ordered an extra cheese pizza, given the thick and richly flavored layer that comes by default. It wasn't quite as well done as I'd like (I reheated the leftovers a bit more), but it was definitely a satisfying pizza. I added some garlic knots, which came literally drowning in a layer of parmesan and butter, which I used to dip some pizza crust in as well. The price was right, and while the place has limitations (strictly a dairy and wheat operation, limited toppings, not much besides pizza), I'm betting it's the best pizza for a long ways. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Goldsboro, North Carolina

See all

Food is always amazing, nothing I have ordered there has been a problem for me or my family. Service is great also!

Best pizza in town love it great Italian subs Everyone is welcoming and place looks good read more

Place isn't much to look at, the menu and seating are from the 80s, but so are the prices! THATS A GOOD THING! Monstrous pepperoni slices, $2.35... two is plenty. Not to mention the garlic knots order for $2. Wife and I love this spot, great pizza! read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - That's four slices for the two of us. Plenty to fill ya up! - Pizza Near Me - Goldsboro, North Carolina

I've searched the eastern NC region for true, Brooklyn style pizza, and was pleasantly surprised to finally find it in Goldsboro! Upon arrival today, I was immediately greeted by their host who listed their options and started my order. The large slices were ready with a minimum wait, and the service was personalized for me. Seating is relaxed and comfortable, just like an authentic Brooklyn restaurant. The slices were perfect, and delicious! I love it, and will definitely be back! This is the best pizzeria! read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, and Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Goldsboro, North Carolina

Got two cheese slices to go. Pizza was pretty average. Slices had a lot of flop. Service was great read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Two cheese slices - Pizza Near Me - Goldsboro, North Carolina

Great food great service best pizza spot in Goldsboro. Food was ready fast! The Brooklyn special definitely worth trying.

The food is awesome . The establishment is always clean . Staff is very friendly The atmosphere is family like . I would definitely recommend Brooklyn Pizzeria for anyone looking for good food with a clean family environment . read more

I was briefly in Goldsboro and stumbled on this pizza place. The pictures on Yelp made me hopeful and curious about this TOTALLY REAL DEAL BROOKLYN PIZZA!!! The sauce didn't overpower. The cheese was perfectly portioned and melted and the crust sealed the deal!! I will gladly travel the 40 miles the next time I'm missing NYC pizza! read more

Love the pizza. It's been our favorite place to get pizza. Always hot and ready to eat if I'm sitting in or if I ordered to go.

We are all entitled to our own opinion, right? Well here is mines: Parking: 5 Location: 4 Ambiance & Décor: 3 Customer Service: 5+ Have you ever purchased a pizza the size of a TRASH CAN LID for $16?? Well last night me and my crew swung through Brooklyn's Pizzeria in Goldsboro NC and made history. Their 20" pizza is gigantic! The individual slices are so big you need two plates to lay it in. The parking situation was cool. They have a private lot connected to a shopping center so its all good. The location was great as it was right off the main highway. The décor is kinda MEH... but it's a Brooklyn style pizza shop so what else would you expect. The service rendered was great. The guy behind the register was courteous and friendly. He gave great suggestions and he warned us about the pizza size (check out my pics to see for yourself). Great Job BP! read more

The customer service was rude. left my order for last on the fryer after the rush. But i was one of the first at around 11:30 but I saw people come in and leave while in my car. When I went in there was no line an no one was cooking my steak. I ask the girl what was the hold up she said i told you it would be forty minutes quit abrasive. No you said thirty five and bitch it has been forty minute. So finally after watching someone come out the back he "started" to make my order. After forty five minutes waiting my order hadn't been processed. But all those other people just came and went. But I digress After getting home I threw the food out because I didn't like the fact the food was left unattended. I will never recommend this place I'm glad I have the review option so I didn't have to act angry or out of control like they were looking for me to do.Because little girl could have gotten all the smoke. But yeah Imma be mad about not getting my money back. But it was only twenty bucks so I'll add it to the donation for the season read more

To whom it may concern:called your store asked an employee about the onions that come on the pizza could we replace them with banana peppers he said yes.I also asked him did jalapeños and pineapple come on the pizza he said yes.The pizza arrives from DD with lots of onions no banana peppers and no pineapple or jalapeños!Call back up to the store same guy answers asked him why did you not do what I asked he just hangs up the phone,real professional your employees!Called back to talk to a manager he's too busy to come to the phone!The employee says we can't do anything about it just call DD wow $25 pizza and no one wants onions on their pizza.A award winning pizza company that can't own up for their unprofessional employees and can't do a simple thing like not put onions on a pizza!I hope this reaches a actual manager or the owner because my family was really looking forward to this pizza and was disappointed,not to mention DD wouldn't do anyThing about it so now out $25 for a pizza we couldn't even eat.Award winning my ass!! read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Onions onions more onions i didn't want!! - Pizza Near Me - Goldsboro, North Carolina

Had to bring a pizza up here to my crew in Cary. They love it. Was in Goldsboro hanging with my mom and brother. So I made a pit stop at Brooklyn PIZ. They were packed and rolling out them pies. Still taste great. Before I heated it up, my homies ate up some slices. Lol. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Takeout - Pizza Near Me - Goldsboro, North Carolina

Nice people good service But coming from California you expect to have veggie ,meaning vegetable not can food I am sure that they can do better read more

The pizza was awesome and the service was excellent! They were very busy at lunch but coming keyed our take out order quickly.

I've been going to Brooklyn Pizza for years even way back when they where in the Dudley MarMac area. They never disappoint from the Stromboli to the slices of Pizza even the greeting you get when you walk in. Brooklyn forever read more

A couple days ago and I ordered a 20-in pizza one of the specials and when I got there I can't say they were rude but they certainly weren't welcoming, because they didn't say anything to me. They didn't say "may I help you" or "how are you".... .... just kind of leaned in expecting me to speak.... so I gave them my name they brought my pizza over.... the only words they said were the total of the price..... I handed them my card, finished the transaction and I didn't get even so much as a "thank you" or even a "git outta heah" when I got home I opened the pizza box and it was a 20-in pizza stuffed into an 18-in or 16 in pizza box all bent around the edges. It was also undercooked to the point there was some cheese that hardly melted if at all. Nice! I thought to myself ... "self, you can live with this" so I began to eat it. About halfway through a slice I smelled the odor of rotting food coming from, yes you guessed it, the pizza. No, I'm not claiming that they sell rotting food but this was my experience and my pizza had rotting ingredients on it somewhere because it smelled like it came out of the garbage could have been the mushrooms could have been the meat I'm not sure. And no I don't order fish on my pizza and YES I do know what anchovies smell like. Now I'm home alone for the next two weeks because of my family's summer vacations and I thought I'd go by there and get a big pizza eat a slice or two and freeze the rest for later this week. But I ended up throwing away a $25 Pizza and not eating it though I did get to eat the $25. Anyway I thought that was terrible. I could have even put up with the bad service and the bent poorly presented Pizza. Why? Because the pizza actually tastes pretty good and I believe the price is actually decent. But when you combine the poor service a pizza stuffed in a box it's too big for, rotting ingredients AND the pizza is undercooked...... ..... I just can't recommend.. I want to recommend very much because I'm new to the Goldsboro area and I've only lived here about a year and a half and I actually like their food..... ......so that's a bit of a conundrum...... ..... I guess I'll leave this review up for a while and go back to their store and try again later ...at my expense. Maybe I'm just a glutton for punishment instead of being a glutton for pizza because I'm certainly not getting any food that I want. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - This is what I found when I got home with my Pizza order from Brooklyn Pizzeria: An undercooked, sloppy looking,bent pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Goldsboro, North Carolina

We were driving from Raleigh airport to Wilmington and needed lunch. Looked this up on Yelp and stopped on our way through. First thought was that it's in a strip mall and really no "ambiance". Didn't matter because boy was the food great! I had just a slice of pepperoni, it had to be at least 1/4 of a large pizza. Crust and sauce was delicious. We also ordered sausage, and sauce stromboli that may SIL could only eat half. We added an old order or garlic knots which will have with scrambled eggs in the morning. Service was relatively quick and very courteous. If we're out this way again, we'd definitely stop in again. read more

The pizza has a very good taste to it only when it's not burnt I've gotten two pizzas there the bottom was burnt black I don't think that's good and then they made the Uber guy paid the difference that ain't how it works in my book. The pizza shop should be paying for the pizza. read more

I got delivery of a large cheese pizza with added pepperoni. Took about 45 minutes longer than originally promised, since it was a Saturday night and apparently a peak time. But when it arrived (via Grub Hub) it was hot and juicy. Nice New York style pie -- thin crust and lots of gooey cheese, especially in the center. Not so much on the edges. Nothing terribly special about the taste, unfortunately. But it checked all the right boxes for a decadent treat. read more

No where near NY Pizza! Generic tasting meat and cheese and crust was dry. Do not waste your money.

We did takeout and both the Italian salad and large (enormous!) veggie pizza were delicious. Very friendly counter help. Not much ambiance inside so I would say choose takeout, if you can. read more

Perfect NY pizza crust! This place was super busy but they got our pizza ready quickly. They were totally cool about making a vegan veggie tomato pie: tomatoes, onions, peppers, mushrooms, olives, no cheese -- tasty! Everyone was wearing masks, they had plexiglass between customers & staff, plus two air purifiers in the dining area. read more

Best pizza around Goldsboro! I love NYC and this is the closest I can get to NYC Pizza! I typically order out and will eat-in occasionally. They are so consistent and never disappoint! My favorite is classic pepperoni! Definitely a Goldsboro staple! read more

Got a bacon, ham, pineapple pizza and it was amazing! Had it DoorDashed so I can't speak on service or ambiance. However, from the time of order till I got it was very reasonable for being out off of Perkins. read more

New York style pizza at its finest; minimal grease, although it's up to you if that's a plus. The cheese is milky and tasty, I think you'll love whatever pizza you get. Don't forget to blow! The only thing keeping this establishment from five stars with me personally... no stuffed crust (It's the future of pizza, embrace it!) read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pepperoni, mushrooms and extra cheese pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Goldsboro, North Carolina