Best part is that you can order by the slice!! It's a little pricey lol but sometimes you have to live a little. Overall the pizza is really good and the service is fast. I have been a couple of their locations and this one is probably one of the better locations. The waitress was very friendly and made me feel welcomed. I would go again based on the service alone. The pizza is good though but you need to eat it hot! read more

My job always getting Johnny's to cater for lunches so I decided to stop by one day for myself. The parking was easy, the service was good, and the food was tasty! I opted for the chicken bacon ranch wrap and a meatlovers pizza! Its always nice to support a small town restaurant! read more

I ordered dinner for my husband and me. The Philly cheese steak was horrible! The meat was nearly black and dry. The sub was burnt with the ends unable to be chewed. The mozzarella was not even noticeable, and the green peppers were not on the sandwich. The mozzarella on the Caprese Salad was obviously old, as it was rubbery and hard to cut with a fork. I was really disappointed. I have eaten at the restaurant in the past, and the food was good. Won't be ordering from them in the future. read more

Terrible Manager experience. We ordered a Veggie pizza and due to the amount and size of the toppings, the pizza was flooded when brought out. The crust was wet and sloppy and it basically fell apart. They offered to remake the pizza but by that point our stomachs were turned off. The best they would do was 10% off the one pizza, when I asked to speak to the manager he completely ignored us and never came to speak to us. The waitress was amazing about it all but we will never be back. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

Been coming back weekly and food, service, and overall feel of this restaurant has really grown on me. Emily and her trainee Kayla are awesome to say the least. Like be served by siblings and it is great, as well as the chill atmosphere. Always quick to greet and make you feel welcome and at home, IMHO. I will not return to Olive Garden as long as this gem is open for business! As no surprise, I will definitely be returning to this establishment for sure! read more

See all

Look at this crap!!! What is this? I mean literally .. what is this abomination ? Where's the other half of my pizza??????? And the mess on the other end was disgusting. DO BETTER. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Medium pizza with chicken, jalapeños, & pineapples. (Supposedly!) - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

See all

It was Saturday Feb 21, 2026. We arrived at 6 pm. There was a large crowd in the dining area. We sat in a booth next to the window. My gf and I had jackets on and noticed it was very cold. I mentioned how cold it was to the waitress. She replied they had just got the a/c fixed. I told her it was 60 degrees outside. All the ceiling fans were run at full speed. I asked to have the ones over us turned off. Besides being cold I hate when my food will get cold before I can eat it. Waitress replied they had to stay on due to health reasons. HUH! That's a new one. We moved to a booth that was not under a ceiling fans. Gf ordered a Mediterranean salad, while I ordered a calzone. The salad came out in about 5 minutes. It took another 10 minutes for the calzone to arrive. All this time I could feel the cold air from the a/c on my face. I remarked to my gf that my nose and cheek was cold. The waitress said they didn't have any clean knives, would I mind waiting for a clean one. The calzone is nice size but the bottom of it was hard to cut. Wasn't burnt, but took a steak knife to saw through it. It did taste good, as well as the salad. I've been going here for a few years now, never experienced it being a meat locker. I understand that the cooking area gets hot and the restaurant tries to get cool air there but at what cost to the patrons? read more

Pizza is as good usual. We asked for fries with cheese and bacon since deluxe cheese fries are no longer on the menu and we were told management would not allow them to do it. Really? You can't add cheese & bacon to French fries. Ok!!!! The music is always good. The are now using Ken's ranch. They use to make their own ranch or at least it tasted like homemade. read more

See all

I order from them when I am in town for work about 3 times a year and they never disappoint! I usually order pizza and love it. This last time I tried the lasagna and it was delicious. Always nice to have a go to restaurant when traveling and this one is always a winner! read more

I came in recently to pick up a to go order and there was a customer being very demeaning and condescending towards the to-go orders worker, shout out to her for having excellent composure bc that man was very rude and passive. read more

So delicious! If you haven't been, you're missing out! If the plain cheese is delicious, imagine all the toppings! read more

See all

The customer service received from Emily is awful. I will not return, I was in the area and wanted to try something different. Once I arrived the staff were just congregating, it took awhile to be acknowledged for a takeout order. Once approached the lady finally acknowledged me and I said I would like to place an order to go and she stated someone else will have to take your order. She then made contact with someone else and told them I wanted to place a to go order and she believed it was for pizza. The lady approached the register and said hi what do you want? I said a medium pizza she then provided the price, swiped card and placed my card and receipt on the counter and walked away. This place won't last much longer. I should have looked at the reviews before coming to this establishment. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Avoid - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

Your app sucks I ordered and the food is no available and you still took the money from my account read more

Highly recommended. Closest thing to legit pizza you can get in the south. Pizza's are consistent in flavor, cook times (not burnt/not raw).

They have an amazing menu and great food for the price you can't beat it! Everyone is so friendly

Very good. And soooo much better than the Conyers location. Honestly I don't see how they are both Johnny's. The Covington location is bigger, has a sit down restaurant, TVs & a bar. Pizza was very good too read more

I tried this location twice and both times were a disappointment. My garlic knots were extremely undercook and the dough was basically gewy on the inside. Wings tasted old and I asked for honey hot I just got hot. Last time they forgot to put the sauce on my wings and I had to drive all the way back for a new order. When I called to complain knowing they didn't cook the garlic knots throughly they said they would have a manager call me in the morning. Honestly save yourself some time and take the trip to the johnnys pizza on Salem road! read more

Remarkably having visited the "Big Apple" several times, this was my first experience with New York style Pizza. And while I'm sure Johnny's is a fine example, the thin slightly charred crust ain't my thing. I guess I've been spoiled by too many Pizza Hut hand tossed Pepperoni-Lover's ... that's the Atlanta way. As for their Hot Wings, while properly cooked and meaty enough, they lacked any heat what-so-ever. And aren't those Three pitiful looking Celery slivers? read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

See all

Pizza was over cooked and inconsistent. Dry, salty and requested extra cheese but was not. Disappointing pizza at best. read more

My son and I weren't feeling well on July 20th, so we ordered Johnny's through DoorDash. When our food arrived, our order was wrong. My son ordered the chicken parm dinner but received a chicken parm sub. I called Johnny's and they said we could either: drive over and pick up the correct dish or they could write down my name and number and credit us on our next order. Since the whole purpose of ordering DoorDash was because we didn't feel well enough to leave the house, I opted to have them write down my name and number. I decided to order food again on the 25th and redeem the credit. The gal on the phone said my name wasn't written down in their "book" and they wouldn't honor the credit until the owner called me back. How long is that going to take? She also stated that the order was placed as a sub.... I told her I could send her a copy of my DoorDash order proving that I ordered the dinner, but she said nothing could be done right now and hung up. No idea if the owner is calling me back or what??? So my Advice- if THEY screw up your order, drive your sick self across town the same day. Don't trust they will honor a credit they promised without a huge hassle. Below is my DoorDash receipt- Chicken parm dinners are $12.99, the subs are $8.99. Clearly, it's their screw up. I'll post an update if I ever get a call back with a resolution! UPDATE: The owner messaged me back the same day, apologized and honored the credit. We ordered food tonight and it was fabulous! read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - My DoorDash receipt:Chicken Parmigiana dinner is $12,99 their chicken parmigiana sub is $8.99 - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

The best calzones!!! Great fresh food and always nice and warm when delivered! thanks read more

We started ordering from the Covington, GA location a few months ago and the pizza was always good. Our recent order placed on 5/8/23 was NOT GOOD! We ordered $70 worth of pizza's. One of them looked like it was cooked the day before and just given to us. My mistake for not looking at the food before leaving the restaurant. We drive more than 30mins to get to this location frequently m Oxford, GA. Every order we have placed has been in excess of $50. I called 5/9/23 and spoke with the manager Jacob, who assured me he would call be back with some type of resolution as of 5/15/23 no one has reached out to me. Needless to say, my family and I won't be back! read more

It was tasty. I'm new to the south, so I ordered a variety of things to try. Staff friendly. I ordered a cheesesteak, pizza, and buffalo wings, which were all ok. Definitely a spot I would love to revisit! read more

Great food. Good prices. Wonderful staff. It's an all around pleasant dining experience.

This is what a 23 dollar Margherita pizza looks like from them apparently. We used to go here all the time, it's sad how far downhill they have gone. Literally just had this delivered by DoorDash. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - This is just dough and sauce. Don't hurt your eyes looking for the mozzarella and basil. - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

I've had Johnny's plenty of times that's why I was surprised when I got pizza yesterday and got all the way home and my pizza was burnt. I had order something else. Not happy read more

Usually order meatball parm subs here (quite often in fact) and there were alway 4 meatballs and a nice helping of fries or chips - today I was a bit disappointed to find they've cut back the serving size of fries and only had three meatballs on my sub. Probably an oversight but I think I'll steer clear for a while. Sorry Johnny's - this is a fail on your part today. read more

Not sure what has happened to this place but it has gone down hill. Second time here in the last month, service was extremely slow. Our pizza order came out wrong and burned again. Spaghetti and meatballs came out ice cold. Watched kitchen staff screaming and fighting (verbally) with each other. Saw our pizza sitting ready for pick up but our waitress was busy on her cell phone. Don't think we will be back, which is sad because it used to be such a great local pizza place. read more

This was one of our go to lunch places. We have been eating here almost every week since I retired in 2016. The food is still good but we really miss the homemade chips as we would share chips and fries. The last two times we have been here the air conditioning was not working. Today the beer was warm. Tried a different brand and it was warm. I hope they can get their act together. There are too many options in Covington nowadays. The service is always good. read more

I don't know how they call this a business they should be shut down they proceed to hangup before I could even finish my sentence not to mention they forgot my 3 beverages that were 2 dr.peppers and 1 coke I am very disappointed in these people and I know there mamas raised them better read more

just had a strombolis. and the flavor was ok considering all I could taste were the veggys there was no meet I paid 13 dollars for a veggy steombolis. read more

I try Social Security disability cases at the hearing office just down the street on Eagle Drive, and if my hearings are around lunchtime, Johnny's is my go to spot for lunch. I have been to several other locations and the pizza is almost always consistent and usually very good. This is not a place for high end pies like Antico or Varasano's. It is also not nearly as expensive. If you are looking for a reasonably priced quick slice or two with salad, you can't go wrong with Johnny's. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

This is the worst restaurant in Covington. The staff is similar to the keystone cops. I had to go back becuase they said my debit card did not go through. Well, first they canceled the transaction becuase I asked for Turtle Cheesecake. They are rude. I will go to Nancy's in Conyers. Johnny's is the worst and is poorly managed. read more

Food and service are terrible now. My two sons ordered calzones, they both came out so undercooked and soggy they literally disintegrated when trying to pick them up. Our pizza the last two times has been undercooked and not like it used to be. I hate to say this will be our last visit. read more

They lost a loyal customer today. My $27 pizza was missing half cheese on some of the slices. Company policy says I have to bring it back. I don't have a car hence why I spent the extra $15 to have a GrubHub. They refuse to give me credit or reimburse me for any of the money that I spent. Pizza should have never went in the box and sent out to a home. Anyone can look at it and see that it is not up to expectations. read more

By far the best food in Covington and the staff is amazing here! They take their time and prepare your food exactly the way you want it prepared ! read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Mediterranean salad!! Simply amazing!! - Italian Near Me - Covington, Georgia

Great lunch spot. Wanted a salad and passed by this spot. The server was very friendly and the food was awesome! The lasagna was the bomb.com Wish this location wasn't so far away from me or I'd be a weekly customer. read more

Called to place a large order on a Saturday for Saturday night. Though I had hoped that it would be able to be delivered, I was told that wouldn't be possible due to the time I wanted it delivered. A bit later I received a phone call from a manager who was away in Boston. He had heard about our order and wanted to call to let me know that he valued our business and wanted to be a full service restaurant. He had found a way to have our order delivered. The service that we received from Johnny's went above and beyond. Instead of cold pizza like we usually have when we have to pick up, the pizza arrived piping hot in warmers. It was wonderful. Though Johnny's is a chain, this location doesn't feel like it. I would totally recommend Johnny's in Covington! read more

Amazing food! I was there yesterday & came back today for another calzone, All meat & extra ricotta. Sooooo delicious! I always buy their food it's the only pizza we have, Generous portions, amazingly seasoned. Customer service on point ! read more

First off I wanted to thank the entire staff for working during this difficult time. I so appreciate you providing a very efficient takeout service. The pizza was great! I will be back soon :) read more