Johnny&#x27;s New York Style Pizza

Time for an update since my last review! I'm happy to say that after 13 years, I'm still coming…read morehere! Best of the best. Served fresh, made to order, hand sliced meats and cheese right in front of you, veggies sourced locally and melt in your mouth cookies. When they say it's a freshness you can taste, they aren't lying. Notoriously they only accepted cash or check for years, but they have finally ventured out to accept venmo and cash app. There is an ATM inside though if you need it. But do not let this deter you! It's well worth it. Lots of seating inside. During lunch they can have a long line but it moves quick. You also have the option to call your order in ahead. Oh, and any sub can be made into a salad.

I stopped in to check it out. Located in an older strip mall at the very end. Bright and clean…read moreinside. Staff friendly and helpful. Menu is simple but you can add pretty much what you want to your sandwich. I got the Super Sub #9, which is a basic Italian style without the salami. Bread is thinner than many sub shops but that leans to an easy to eat and well balanced sandwich. The meat is the star of the show and the flavor was very good and fresh. They accept cash, card, cashapp and Venmo. Overall a nice spot and will likely stop again when coming through this area.

Bread Baked Fresh Daily

#10 brians special

See all

Grilled Chicken Salad

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.6(7 reviews)

1.0 mi

This place has potential, but it really needs to improve. There was no greeting or acknowledgement…read morewhen I entered the store and I stood there for several minutes while several staff members went about their business. Not great on the service there. Another thing that needs to be acknowledged is that for whatever reason, the meat used here is VERY salty. Deli meats are known to be salty, but this has a kind of extreme aftertaste. At first I thought it was just me, but a family member happened to bring home Firehouse subs for dinner by chance right after I got home with my sub from Jersey Mike's. In comparison, there was a complete difference in the taste, and Firehouse didn't taste salty. The place is clean for what I saw, so no complaints there. This place has potential, but it needs some changes.

I literally order a giant sub from them twice a week! I order the same sub, the same way & it's…read morealways made the exact same way every time. That's what I love about this place. The always fresh food and always consistent food. They are very consistent and that's hard to find around here lately. Consistency is key, freshness is key & friendly employees are key! Jersey Mike's hit a home run with all three! Try Jersey Mikes if you haven't yet!

See all

Moe's on Madison

4.1(28 reviews)

Very impressed with this establishment! The atmosphere is pleasant and the music was great…read more Moe's offers a very diverse menu that adds a nice flare compared to some of the other restaurants downtown. The Brussels are a great starter I would recommend. The Tripleta sandwhich and side of garlic herb fries were delicious and full of flavor. Drinks were also well made. The service was impeccable! Our waitress, Paris, was awesome. She went well above and beyond what is typically expected, so shout out to her. Overall, Moe's is a fine establishment that brings fresh life and flavor into downtown Dublin. I can't wait to come back and explore more of the menu. Thank you to the staff and chefs for a wonderful experience. I highly recommend anyone to dine here!

This is the first time since Moe's opened that I've been slightly disappointed…read more Ambiance was off. Instead of the Puerto Rican music and nice video board playing of sites around Puerto Rico, there was R&B music. I remember they used to make virgin mocktails but not on this trip. They said they can't make them. I ordered a sweet tea. I barely could drink it. I had to water it down significantly. It was so sweet, it was sickening. My husband asked for a Medalla beer, which is a Puerto Rican beer, but they didn't have it, despite us having had it before. Oh well. Ordered a mojito since rum is also a big drink on the island. They did not serve it with fresh lime or mint and rather have us a rum drink with sour mix and a lemon. Now, food. I miss Puerto Rican food. I ordered the pollo asado, which was supposed to be topped with onions, but wasn't. My husband got a market priced steak. It was okay. Not great. No crust on the streak, chewy and didn't come served with a knife. He was trying to use a butter knife to rip it apart like a bird on a carcass. In total? $91....

See all

Company Supply

4.3(313 reviews)

Tried their famous delta chicken and it was delicious. Chicken cooked to perfection with green…read morebeans. Great spot to try if visiting Dublin. Great service from staff! Dimmed ambience to enjoy your food.

Ok good but not if you are celiac…read more They at least let me know everything was probably contaminated such as the steak getting cooked where the bread goes. Nothing is marked GF / gluten free on the menu. I ended up eating a plate of lettuce with no dressing or croutons. Meh. The people were nice. But if anyone in your group has gluten sensitivities, this probably is not your spot.

Dining/bar area

Pulled chicken sandwich

See all

Entrance/exit doorway

Lou Ann's Biscuits & Burgers

4.2(25 reviews)

1.8 mi

In town for an appointment and found this place. A little off the beaten path on the industrial…read moreside of town. Drive thru line was wrapped around the building; a good sign. Clean with a retro style. I believe the building started life as a "Burger Chef" way back when. Staff friendly. Simple breakfast menu loaded with biscuits but I tried the breakfast bowl with grits, eggs, cheese and bacon. Very flavorful and needed nothing else. Highly recommend Give it a try!

Great breakfast and lunch, fast service! Would definitely recommend! Be sure to try the blueberry…read morebiscuits!

Inside

Country ham biscuit

See all

Firehouse Subs

3.0(10 reviews)

1.1 mi

Is this my go-to sub place? No. Will I eat here? Yes. Will I typically get it to-go and not eat…read moreinside? Yes. It is a rather large location for what is inside. Lots of room being unused. And everything seems sticky. Kinda like a Waffle House; why is everything wet and sticky? That's why I typically order online for it to-go. I also don't have to deal with the staff. With that being said, the staff you get typically varies throughout the day. Your older-ish staff is during the day and the younger ones are at night. The younger ones like to goof around, joke around, take their time and not care too much about initiating customers. It's almost like they're playing rock-paper-scissors in their head about who is going to the register to take an order. Now, once at the register they're usually pretty friendly. Moving along, I do enjoy most of their sandwiches. I don't recommend putting any vegetables on the hot sandwiches unless it's pepper, onions, mushrooms, etc. Produce like lettuce and tomato will just become mushy and wilted. I enjoy the hot sauce bar. Please, do not get rid of the sauce bar. Decent variety of chips and of courses, you can't go wrong with the cherry limeade (unless it's our of flavoring....).

Zero stars for this restaurant! Poor poor customer service and service is awful. 5 employees there…read morebut only 1 actually working. Food was deplorable...low quality. Will not return!

See all

Club on a sub

Paula's Fried Chicken

4.8(23 reviews)

2.5 mi

Take it to go! For the fried chicken with rice and gravy and Mac n cheese. It was all pretty good…read more Definitely not the best chicken I've ever had. Probably not even top ten. The inside of the place is a dump too, so I would plan on taking my order to go. If you're looking for a good home cooked meal in the middle of nowhere, Paula's hits.

It never fails. Paula's fried chicken is . Again. My first stop in Dublin. Staff is friendly and…read morewelcoming. The prices are reasonably cheap. What do you expect from a historic hole in the wall. Either takeout and go. Or sit at the run down tables. It's clean inside. Whatever you decide, make sure to get your large half and half.

See all

Pork chop sandwich

Zaxbys

2.4(12 reviews)

1.3 mi

Never had anything bad from Zaxby's yet. They have good, flavorful food and their service is fast…read more They do pretty well, too. Usually a line wrapped around the building. I deducted a star, however, because of a bad attitude from management once. This was a one time, thing, however, and has not reoccurred.

I have it an 1only bc I couldn't give them a zero! Avoid…read morethis pit at all costs! It smells like a septic tank inside and they never get the orders correct nor in a timely manner. It would be different if it didn't happen 75% of the time. If you must, don't use the app. You will be waiting until the cows come home for your food. The other store across town is just as bad! Avoid both Dublin Ga Zaxby's unless you like cold food, poor service, and like to smell manure.

See all

Deano's Italian

4.5(186 reviews)

Solid wood fired pizza, well priced! Creme brûlée was…read moredelicious and on point! We'll definitely be back!

Everything!! The best experience, the best food, the best service, everything!!! Took our family of…read more5 here this evening and so glad we did! We tried a few different dishes (chicken parm, spaghetti with meatballs, pizza, fettuccine Alfredo, greek salad, and the best bread! We had a short little wait time so we chose to walk across the street to the little park and hang out. It was so beautiful with all of the fountains, waterfalls, & the swings! The whole atmosphere was nothing short of amazing! Thank you for a lovely evening Deano's!

Fun decor

Lasagna

See all

Options at the bar

Your Pie Pizza

3.6(21 reviews)

Giving it three stars because it was DoorDash and I've only tried it once, but this pizza was…read moredismal. First, I got the keto cauliflower crust. That might be part of it. But most of the time this type of crust is crispy and light. In this instance, it was dry and crumbling and flavorless. The toppings I got were lackluster: chewy sausage with no seasoning, the vegetables were okay. The cheese was bland and by the time it was delivered, congealed. Caesar salad was just a little Parmesan, lettuce, and the dressing. Fair enough for rural Georgia, but at 4.39 a little cheap (and I didn't get a fork). The soda was flat and tasted like it came from a machine that hasn't been cleaned in years. They have basic options like "make your own," "two topping pizza," and "pepperoni," as well as signature pizzas (lineage supreme with all the toppings, BBQ chicken ranch, and hot honey pepperoni). Nothing crazy. I do like that they offer 10 inch personal options for some of them. They also have sandwiches and wings as well as some pasta dishes, but if they can't do the pizza well, I have little faith in getting al dente pasta or a crispy, seasoned sandwich. Probably won't take a change to try this again. I can still taste that dusty ass cauliflower crust in my mouth.

Unfortunately, we were not impressed. One large pizza was $24, the bottom of the dough was blackish…read moreand the toppings were just ok. Will continue the search for good pizza in the area.

Your Pie

See all

Your Pie

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Ella P.

0

2

0

8 years ago

Lacking customer service all around. Food does not hold up to Johnny's standards.

John J.

0

11

1

10 years ago

I ate there once worst pizza ever service not good either

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Johnny's New York Style Pizza also viewed

Deano's Italian

4.5

(186 reviews)

Solid wood fired pizza, well priced! Creme brûlée was…read moredelicious and on point! We'll definitely be back!

Everything!! The best experience, the best food, the best service, everything!!! Took our family of…read more5 here this evening and so glad we did! We tried a few different dishes (chicken parm, spaghetti with meatballs, pizza, fettuccine Alfredo, greek salad, and the best bread! We had a short little wait time so we chose to walk across the street to the little park and hang out. It was so beautiful with all of the fountains, waterfalls, & the swings! The whole atmosphere was nothing short of amazing! Thank you for a lovely evening Deano's!

Brian's Giant Subs

4.8

(120 reviews)

Time for an update since my last review! I'm happy to say that after 13 years, I'm still coming…read morehere! Best of the best. Served fresh, made to order, hand sliced meats and cheese right in front of you, veggies sourced locally and melt in your mouth cookies. When they say it's a freshness you can taste, they aren't lying. Notoriously they only accepted cash or check for years, but they have finally ventured out to accept venmo and cash app. There is an ATM inside though if you need it. But do not let this deter you! It's well worth it. Lots of seating inside. During lunch they can have a long line but it moves quick. You also have the option to call your order in ahead. Oh, and any sub can be made into a salad.

I stopped in to check it out. Located in an older strip mall at the very end. Bright and clean…read moreinside. Staff friendly and helpful. Menu is simple but you can add pretty much what you want to your sandwich. I got the Super Sub #9, which is a basic Italian style without the salami. Bread is thinner than many sub shops but that leans to an easy to eat and well balanced sandwich. The meat is the star of the show and the flavor was very good and fresh. They accept cash, card, cashapp and Venmo. Overall a nice spot and will likely stop again when coming through this area.

Saltwater Fishery

4.1

(89 reviews)

In town for an appointment nearby, on a Friday afternoon, so walked over for a late lunch early…read moredinner (4pm). Arrived between the potential crowds so only a handful of customers at this time. Establishment is located in the historic area of downtown Dublin. Parking out front and around on adjacent streets. Inside is very well decorated and designed. Mixture of modern meets rustic and wide open. I was seated right away at the window. My server was Evan and he was very helpful as we discussed a few items on the menu since it was my first time being here. Having grown-up on the coastlines of the country, I really like seafood. I chose the dinner grouper finger plate with coleslaw and fries. I was not disappointed. In fact, this was some of the best fried grouper I've had anywhere in middle Georgia. Fries were well seasoned, shoestring style and the coleslaw was very smooth with no bitterness. The only thing that took me by surprise were the hush puppies. They are sweet and so I had to inquire about them. I found out they were made of funnel cake style batter and not cornbread. They were more like a small dessert to me. Good, but I would've preferred regular hush puppies. Outside that, the meal was very, very good. The service and friendliness of the staff gets high marks as well. If you're in the area, give these guys a try.

OMG....SALTWATER FISHERY... so disappointed in the service we received it is almost a slap in our…read moreface to be treated so badly by someone that actually made sure she wanted us to know she was the manager lol as if we were afraid to let her know Kristina or Christina was very disrespectful and need to truly respect her customers. We gave them 3 strikes so we are out... no need to go back to a business that do not respect the customer. To be truthful the food is not tasty and not worth the money they charge , we are truly not impressed by Saltwater no service rude manager fishery. Do not let them disrespect you as a customer spend your money on a business that appreciate the customer.

Firehouse Subs

3.0

(10 reviews)

Is this my go-to sub place? No. Will I eat here? Yes. Will I typically get it to-go and not eat…read moreinside? Yes. It is a rather large location for what is inside. Lots of room being unused. And everything seems sticky. Kinda like a Waffle House; why is everything wet and sticky? That's why I typically order online for it to-go. I also don't have to deal with the staff. With that being said, the staff you get typically varies throughout the day. Your older-ish staff is during the day and the younger ones are at night. The younger ones like to goof around, joke around, take their time and not care too much about initiating customers. It's almost like they're playing rock-paper-scissors in their head about who is going to the register to take an order. Now, once at the register they're usually pretty friendly. Moving along, I do enjoy most of their sandwiches. I don't recommend putting any vegetables on the hot sandwiches unless it's pepper, onions, mushrooms, etc. Produce like lettuce and tomato will just become mushy and wilted. I enjoy the hot sauce bar. Please, do not get rid of the sauce bar. Decent variety of chips and of courses, you can't go wrong with the cherry limeade (unless it's our of flavoring....).

Zero stars for this restaurant! Poor poor customer service and service is awful. 5 employees there…read morebut only 1 actually working. Food was deplorable...low quality. Will not return!

Company Supply

4.3

(313 reviews)

Tried their famous delta chicken and it was delicious. Chicken cooked to perfection with green…read morebeans. Great spot to try if visiting Dublin. Great service from staff! Dimmed ambience to enjoy your food.

Ok good but not if you are celiac…read more They at least let me know everything was probably contaminated such as the steak getting cooked where the bread goes. Nothing is marked GF / gluten free on the menu. I ended up eating a plate of lettuce with no dressing or croutons. Meh. The people were nice. But if anyone in your group has gluten sensitivities, this probably is not your spot.

Holy Smokes BBQ And Catering

4.3

(104 reviews)

Sigh... I can't put every bbq spot as 5 stars, this is a 4…read more Banana pudding was delicious, the meat was decent. I have had better. It didn't just wow me like some of the other bbq spots here in Ga. Would I go back, sure as it is close to Warner Robins. Would I try somewhere else, yes also. This is not a bad place, it was good. In fact some of the best nana pudding I have had in ga.

Had an appointment in Dublin and looked for somewhere new to us to eat. Numerous people we asked…read moretold us we wouldn't be disappointed so we went. It's tucked away in a strip mall next to Kroger. First time I saw it I thought it was a Vape shop but paying closer attention it was the bbq joint. Walking in it has a rustic country flair. Steeping up to the counter the young man was very helpful is describing everything. My wife ordered a pulled pork sandwich with cowboy baked beans and fries. I ordered the pulled pork quesadillas with mac n cheese with banana pudding for dessert. All the good was very good. The stand outs were the quesadillas and the cowboy baked beans. Least favorite was the Mac n cheese; it was a bit gritty. (-1) Recommend you give them a try.

Boneyard BBQ

4.6

(34 reviews)

Good service good food good prices in a clean And…read morepresentable atmosphere. This is a jewel In a town with few options.

First timer…read more Brisket: 4 stars. Otis good, I will have it again but I have had better. The moist meat was good but it lacked some of the smokiness. The lean meat was perfect! Texture is very good! Onion rings: 2 stars. They were bland :( Cake in a cup: 5 stars. Key lime cake. Very good and moist!! Service: 5 stars. Reylem was accommodating! Good southern hospitality in a mom and pop business :) I will come back again!

Little Caesars Pizza

3.0

(3 reviews)

I know it's hard to get people but do some training of the ones you get and teach them to value the…read morecustomers that pay their salary. No sauce and little cheese. Just not up to LC standard

It sucks, If you want bread, cheese and pepperoni this place is for you. They barely put sauce on…read moreany of their pizza even if you ask.

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.6

(7 reviews)

This place has potential, but it really needs to improve. There was no greeting or acknowledgement…read morewhen I entered the store and I stood there for several minutes while several staff members went about their business. Not great on the service there. Another thing that needs to be acknowledged is that for whatever reason, the meat used here is VERY salty. Deli meats are known to be salty, but this has a kind of extreme aftertaste. At first I thought it was just me, but a family member happened to bring home Firehouse subs for dinner by chance right after I got home with my sub from Jersey Mike's. In comparison, there was a complete difference in the taste, and Firehouse didn't taste salty. The place is clean for what I saw, so no complaints there. This place has potential, but it needs some changes.

I literally order a giant sub from them twice a week! I order the same sub, the same way & it's…read morealways made the exact same way every time. That's what I love about this place. The always fresh food and always consistent food. They are very consistent and that's hard to find around here lately. Consistency is key, freshness is key & friendly employees are key! Jersey Mike's hit a home run with all three! Try Jersey Mikes if you haven't yet!

Burger King

3.6

(10 reviews)