Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Kelsey’s Coffee Sauce

    5.0 (1 review)

    Kelsey’s Coffee Sauce Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Kelsey’s Coffee Sauce

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Anthony G.
    394
    1663
    22553

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Shorty's Steakhouse - House salad

    Shorty's Steakhouse

    4.0(107 reviews)
    70.9 km
    $$

    Shorty's Steakhouse (Garrett, Indiana) - looking for a unique steakhouse, not too far outside Fort…read moreWayne? Shorty's is one of the Salvatori's Restaurant Group offerings that is located on Main Street in Garrett. Head north on 327 to the downtown area. Shorty's is set in a small and older building located on the east side of the road. You will need to park on the street - which isn't an issue in Garrett. As I said... Shorty's is a smaller venue. The building holds about 10 people at the bar and 90 inside dinners. The outdoor patio appears to seat about 50 people. Shorty's is always busy - especially on Friday/Saturday nights. So, make a reservation via their website. The larger side room can hold bigger groups of 8-14 people. Otherwise you are limited to a table of four. Upon entering the restaurant you will quickly encounter the host stand right at the door. There is no real foyer area to wait for your table. You may feel uncomfortably close to a stranger if things are backed up. The bar area is one of the first things you see. Legend has it that this bar was relocated from a Chicago area business who had it installed in around the time the 1893 World's Fair was in Chicago. The bar wood work, design and finishing are gorgeous! Very inviting. The older part of restaurant retains the decor of the old building - attractive dark wood interiors/fixtures, green plaster ceilings and hardwood floors. All are very comfortable and welcoming. The host and service team were very friendly and helpful. There was plenty of help to hustle drink orders, refills and follow up. The kitchen is very small. Food orders may take a bit of time when they are busy. So be prepared to relax, enjoy a bar drink, converse and admire the renovations. Shorty's has a decent variety to offer on their smaller food and drink menus. They are more than just steaks. In general, most items are a bit pricey...but probably normal for most area steakhouses. Here is a run down of the food we ordered: -Table Bread: nothing to special; white bread roll with a firm exterior and soft inside with basic butter; tasted like it was freshly baked -House Salad: nice sized salad with a fresh taste and ingredients; several side vegetables and cheese to dress up/accent the salad; the honey mustard dressing tasted familiar - probably not made in house -Crab Cakes: my wife loved her crab cakes; tender, full of crab and seafood tastes; nicely grilled exterior -Prime Rib & Baked Potato: delicious taste, tender and smaller amounts of fat; my medium rare request seemed to be more medium as I didn't see much pink coloring; the real horseradish lacked the usual bold kick that I except. The potato was baked perfectly and accented with the usual dollops of smooth butter and sour cream. Good steakhouse choice. Overall, Shorty's offers good food & drink selections in a unique setting. Remember, Shorty's is a very popular place and fills up quickly. Therefore, plan ahead and make a reservation. Shorty's is definitely worth a trip to Garrett to give them a try.

    Stopped in Monday night for dinner with the team, some of the guys said they hadn't been since a…read morefire broke out and was impressed with the expansion. Delaney took great care of us and offered us bread and butter, I was a little disappointed b/c they were not warm and had a slight stale taste to them. I opted for their crab cakes and their parm dirty rice, I enjoyed my meal and I highly recommend stopping in if you're in the area!

    Photos
    Shorty's Steakhouse - Soup and margarita

    Soup and margarita

    Shorty's Steakhouse - Table bread

    Table bread

    Shorty's Steakhouse - Crab cakes

    See all

    Crab cakes

    Baker Street Steakhouse - House salad

    Baker Street Steakhouse

    4.2(382 reviews)
    53.4 km
    $$$

    We had reservations for 4 on Wednesday night…read more We were seated quickly and our server came by to take our drink orders. I had a B.A. Smoke on the Water. It's very unique with a smoky flavor. We started with a couple appetizers, the Smoked Gouda Crab Dip and Shrimp Cocktail. Both were delicious. For dinner my wife had the Pan Seared Salmon and I had the Chilean Sea Bass. Maybe the best I have ever had. Buttery and flaky and the Risotto was excellent. For dessert we had the Carrot Cake and Cheesecake with Berry Sauce. Both were phenomenal. Our server did a great job taking care of us. It was pretty loud so we did have a little trouble hearing each other at our table. There were two large parties close to us.

    Today was Husband's birthday so I surprised him with a meal at Baker Street. We have been once…read morebefore and that's been a few years. I remembered it was good but today..? We were seated immediately. Nice corner booth. It was nearly empty so we had a very quiet, romantic atmosphere for his Birthday Meal. Our server, Megan, was very friendly and on top of things. We ordered crab cakes for an app as well as a cup of French onion soup each. We could make a meal on that alone. The crab cakes were fantastic and the French onion soup was to die for. INCREDIBLE! The pretzel bread with cinnamon butter is very tasty. The butter is so soft and filled with cinnamon. We then ordered the filet medallions with wild mushroom risotto. We love our steaks medium rare. These were cooked to perfection. Melt in your mouth goodness! The seasoning was amazing! Very delicious. The only issue was the one long strand of hair on the edge of my plate. I spoke to the server about it to make sure better care is taken in food prep in the kitchen. She said she'd talk to the manager. Husband received a free birthday dessert. He chose the warm carrot cake drizzled with caramel and walnuts with cinnamon ice cream. It was moist and so delicious. The birthday candle was a nice added bonus. Will definitely be back!

    Photos
    Baker Street Steakhouse - It's my birthday!!!!

    It's my birthday!!!!

    Baker Street Steakhouse - Caesar Salad with anchovies

    Caesar Salad with anchovies

    Baker Street Steakhouse - Spiced old fashioned

    See all

    Spiced old fashioned

    Kelsey’s Coffee Sauce - coffee - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...