Wow! We ordered subs here for the first time and we are so happy! I ordered a chicken Caesar wrap and it was stuffed full! LOTS of chicken, plenty of croutons for crunch! I made 2 meals out of it! My husband had the chicken BLT 12". Again, stuffed full! He just added a little more mayo when he got home - but that's his preference. Will ask for more mayo when we order again. We will definitely make this our go to sub shop! read more

I've been wanting to check out Key Wear Sub Shop hearing the word of mouth. So I stopped by today on a bike ride and had a really good italian. Feels like a great locals place, super friendly service with the women working the counter and making the subs. Great menu! Even said goodbye to me by my name! No reason to go to a subway when you have this here. read more

Key West Sub Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Englewood, Florida

I stopped by Key West Sub Shop while in town and WOW -- I'm so glad I did! The sandwiches were unbelievably fresh, and I got mine pressed, which took it to the next level. The bread was perfect, the ingredients tasted super high quality, and the flavors were on point. The ladies working there were so sweet and welcoming -- you can just tell they care about their food and their customers. They mentioned they've been open for 18 years, and honestly, it shows. That kind of consistency doesn't happen by accident! I seriously wish they were closer to Tampa because I'd be there every week. If you're anywhere near this place, GO. You'll be glad you did! read more

See all

Great staff, great food. Not much else to say. Convenient, great value. And the staff is always there for you. read more

Amazing staff, service and last but not least food! I moved to the area four years ago and have gotten various suds, wraps, and salads a multitude of times Each and every time they exceed expectations for a sub shop and I have been completely satisfied. I'd like to recommend a favorite but I can't! So many choices and everything I have tried this far has been delicious!!! Highly recommend them and I'd like to pass along a special recognition to Dillon. He's an awesome guy and a pleasure to deal with. Extremely polite, professional and has a bit of a comedic side in him. Well I can't think of anything else to say other than if you haven't tried their food, you've been missing out. Highly, highly recommend Key West Subs Sincerely John Rotonda West read more

Tucked away in this quiet center, found this authentic Cuban restaurant. Been there twice now and would recommend for something different, yet pleasant enjoyable Cuban food. read more

Wonderful busy little sub shop, great team behind the counter, friendly fresh & fast. Lots of people order & pick up. Very large selection of sandwich's. read more

Fresh, fast and varied menu. Also, have panini--which they call "pressed". ' ' read more

disgusting customer service, extremely rude when special request was asked never coming back to this establishment

I have not been to this location but I used to eat at the location in Englewood and was in there most everyday when I was working. They were awesome and the owners were so friendly. read more

Fair prices. Plenty of meat in the subs. But: the quality of some of the cold cuts was not what I expected. Service was very good and quick. I love the sayings they post. read more

Best subs around. Fresh, made to order. They take care of the smallest detail and are nonplussed with unusual requests!

Small place that delivers big flavor!! They are a great place to pick up subs anytime you have a craving! The bread they use is OUTSTANDING! The Cuban sandwich made here is terrific! We also really loved the pizza sub and the Italian sub-but the stand-out here is the KEY WEST! The house made dressing really compliments the crispy lettuce and the sub roll-and the use the perfect ratio of Turkey! We found this shop because of the yelp reviews!! Thanks!! read more

See all

For the branch birthday celebration, we chose sandwiches from Key West after hearing all the rave reviews. Three Cuban Pressed sandwiches and one Reuben, the order was hot and ready the moment I walked through the door. The employees were friendly and greeted me immediately! They made me feel welcomed and appreciated. The sandwiches were amazing, made to perfection and fresh. Prices were very reasonable. I will definitely make this a highly recommend if you are in the Englewood area. Great service, nice on the pocket and tasty eats. read more

Key West Sub Shop - Cuban Pressed - Sandwiches Near Me - Englewood, Florida

See all

I tried this place for lunch when I was in the area for work. I was looking for a local sandwich place and this popped up on my yelp. The older lady who greeted me when I entered wasnt polite, very matter of fact. I ordered the Italian. The meat didn't taste fresh and the bread was dry. I was disappointed. Won't be back. read more

Great subs along with great people. Make a great sub shop. They listen to what you what want special on your sandwich.

This sub shop is awesome. The food is well worth the price, it comes out pretty fast and they even come by and make sure you like everything. I had 1/2 of the Hemingway pressed sub and 1/2 of the pressed Rueben and they were both so good I couldn't tell you which one I like best. FYI I did split with my brother to get to have some of both. So there is that. Haha Not to many places have subs better than Publix but this one for sure does. Enjoy. read more

Key West Sub Shop - Menu - Sandwiches Near Me - Englewood, Florida

See all

After missing an opportunity to grab a Cuban sandwich in Ybor City, I couldn't fight the urge any longer and decided to order one at any local shop that offered them. Luckily these sandwiches are wildly popular not just in the major Cuban hubs of Florida (aka Tampa & Miami), but in the smaller, more remote regions as well. Key West Sub Shop seems to specialize in pressed sandwiches, so ordering a Cuban here was a no-brainer. For good measure, I also ordered one of my all-time favorites - a classic Italian. Let's start with the good - the Cuban was exactly what I was looking for. It was the textbook recipe - ham, lean pork, Swiss, pickle, and a generous slathering of mustard. I was a little surprised by the absence of salami, which is pretty much a staple in the Tampa region (Englewood being about an hour and a half south of Tampa), but there's nothing wrong with the "classic" version. The Italian was a different story. You know how you sometimes complain that there's too much lettuce on subs? I think Subway gets this a lot - not enough meat and too many veggies. Well, it's possible to have too little lettuce as well. And that was the case here. I actually enjoy a good portion of lettuce, tomato, and onion on my Italians (while keeping a good meat ratio). The cool, crisp lettuce and juicy tomatoes are a perfect contrast to the spicy, tender meats. Without that balance, the overall quality of the sandwich degrades rapidly. Stick with the pressed sandwiches here and you can't go wrong. I just wouldn't be too eager to venture into many of the other offerings. read more

Key West Sub Shop - Cubano - Sandwiches Near Me - Englewood, Florida

See all

I am a Pub Sub lover. However, Key West Subs bread is softer and more meat! Give them a try. You won't regret it!

Sandwiches were so delicious and the service was great! If you want a quality sandwich at a good price come to Key West.

Lunch was good I found the Key West Sub Shop in the Tiffany Square Plaza and sat in my car while checking out their menu online. Once I was ready, I headed in. I didn't notice a menu inside but no doubt there is one easily viewed. I already knew what I wanted, their pressed sandwich called Hemingway. It is a roast beef with cheddar, with a special sauce of BBQ sauce, mayo, and light horseradish. The person at the counter was on the phone taking an order. Once done I was asked what I wanted but at the same time they turned to give the other order to someone else. Not a good start, a little pet peeve of mine, give me your attention when you ask me a question. Got past that slight and we were off and running. I ordered the Pressed Hemingway. There are few seats inside, all occupied, so I headed outside to sit at one of their sidewalk tables. It was a very nice day to sit outside. In well under 10 minutes, my sandwich was delivered to me, and it looked great. I understand Hemingway's favorite sandwich was peanut butter and onion, but he also loved game meats, so this was in line with Papa and also much more edible than PB & O. While I thought the sandwich was a bit too mild, it was a good size and a good sandwich. The roast beef was sliced thin and very tender. This was not that brown sliced little moisture stuff, this looked very good, very appetizing. I saw a sign that would indicate their meats were Dietz & Watson. Good choice. My once order taker even checked with me while I was sitting outside eating to be sure I was doing ok, so back in my good graces. It was a good lunch. read more

Key West Sub Shop - Pressed Hemingway - Sandwiches Near Me - Englewood, Florida

The food was average. The price may be a little bit too high, but not outrageous and I got the food to go. Not sure if you can eat inside

Being from South Jersey originally I have yet to find a good "HOAGIE" in Florida. If you're from that area you know what I mean. We tried Key West Sub Shop on our way to the beach and these there good "SUBS". The shop was busy when we stopped in but our order was taken quickly and friendly. We watched as the two the ladies made everyone's subs. It's was nice to see the efficiency each order received. The subs traveled well in cooler on the way to the beach where we enjoyed them. We will definitely go back but I'm still in search of the best "HOAGIES" in Florida. read more

The Thanksgiving sub is my favorite, it has the turkey, mayo, stuffing and cranberry sauce. Nice people working every time I've been there. Service is quick. Small shop with tables to eat inside. read more

Great fresh food . Great staff ! Very clean inside.... Great healthy food choices.

Everything was fresh and very good. Definitely a must try! They are very friendly and quick.

I got the smaller sandwich and it was good. Nothing spectacular by any means. The people working there were nice. No complaints at all but I am not rushing to go back. I would choose to go to Publix and get a pub sub first. Maybe I was looking for life changing...? read more

At first glance not the prettiest place but the staff was nice and I wish they would had clean the tables they was kinda dirty (food) me and my friend ordered the Ruben and Cuban both sandwich had the ups and downs the Cuban was really good and also the Ruben only problems was that they put to much sauce and both mustard and 1000 island and the middle of both sandwich's was cold if they would've pressed them more I would've giving it a 4 star read more

I feel bad doing this because I don't leave 1* reviews often. A few weeks ago my husband suggested I get him a ham & cheese hoagie. Our neighbors go here. How bad could it be, I thought. So I went & ordered a ham & cheese sub and a salad with ham & cheese. Maybe it was supposed to be a Cobb salad. I got home & opened the bag & it was a big box of ... sub lettuce. That's it. My husband was disappointed in his sandwich. He's warned others away from this place - he said they just threw the meat and cheese on in lumps. It was ok quality - at least cold - but this place isn't inexpensive. I can best describe the small shop as "dismal." You can do better at Publix or Wawa. Same food types, better quality, not scary dirty. I'm only putting this because there are 5* reviews - all are older so maybe once upon a time it didn't cost twice as much as it should for a box of iceberg lettuce & a hunk of boiled ham, American cheese, and a sub-Subway roll. read more

The bread was really good and the service was exceptional. The subs were average except for the bread.... Not bad if your looking for a sub to eat but nothing that was mind blowing or put them above other places. I would try again just because of the customer service! The young man forgot a sub in our large order and chased us down to give it to us. Not many people would do that!! read more

Stopped by Key West Subs today and ordered the Pressed Cubans - very good sub. Sub was pressed and crispy, generous amount of meat and pickles etc. The ladies working and taking our order were friendly and kind. Definitely going again. read more

I Love consistency when I go to a restaurant and Key West Subs is always consistently delicious! I always get the reuben and it is seriously amazing. 10/10 highly recommend read more

I don't eat meat, but I can tell you that they make excellent vegetarian subs and wraps.

Excellent subs for the price. Great flavor and friendly and fast service. Good selection of subs and daily specials.

They don't make any of there roast beef , turkey, corn beef , pork probably getting there meats at Walmart or Sysco foods their rolls r hotdogs bread will never go their again read more

Did a pick-up of subs and they were delicious. The service was great and prices were reasonable.

The older lady who works there is super rude! Won't ever go there again because of the attitude. Went in and wasn't greeted by anyone and felt very uncomfortable. read more

We got a club sub and a Greek salad wrap and both were delicious! We took the lunch to the beach and it was the perfect beach food too! Totally recommend and the staff was so great and friendly! read more

Had spent the morning on the beach on a hot, humid Florida day, so we looked like heck and were covered in sand. We wanted something good for lunch but wanted it to go so we could go home and de-sand before we ate. This looked like a great stop and it was! The sandwiches were excellent - my Reuben was hot and delicious, and had been cooked in a panini maker which I liked because it held together much better than most Reubens do. All the sandwiches we got were excellent, and you could get chips and pop too to go with your meal. Would love to go here again sometime! read more

Tish took excellent care of us. The sub and stuffed tomato were delish! Thank you for a yummy lunch while we waited for a tow truck!