Keystone Tools &amp; Supply

Downtown hardware and general supply store for all of your basic needs. They don't have the…read moreselection of the big box stores, but they have a great selection and awesome deals on LED lightbulbs. Sometimes there can be a long line because there's only one register. Prices aren't always clearly marked. Prices for key duplication are a little high. You pay for the convenience. Free 15 minute parking in front, awesome! Solid 4 stars .

Very friendly family run business. Every time I arrive they are proactive in helping me find what I…read moreneed quickly. Great local business.

Hornungs True Value Hardware

2.7

(9 reviews)

I saw a recent advertisement from Hornungs True Value Hardware for granite-colored clay pots…read moreheavily discounted. I had to stop by to check out the granite-colored clay pots, which are the same granite pots I buy for my houseplant collection at a local nursery for much higher prices. The staff was friendly and helpful when I couldn't locate a medium-sized coco liner. My liner was damaged, so I was able to get a discount. Thank you, Hornungs. I find that smaller businesses like Hornungs consistently offer better customer service.

Good place for yard power equipment service and picking up miscellaneous hardware store items…read more Prices are normal for a True Value, not really a value. Walmart, Lowe's or HD generally less expensive. Turnaround time for equipment service (snowblower) tune up was less than a week and $100. Not bad and not too much time considering the season is upon us. While waiting to drop off my equipment, there were several customers waiting for a register to open. Unfortunately the store was a little understaffed and they were getting annoyed to have to wait for me before they could check out. Some additional training for the younger employees would probably help so that they could be more attentive when there are people waiting. I know it's easier to hide at the back of the store than to wait on customers, but that's your job folks. When I picked up the snowblower, I was in and out in about five minutes. Not too bad.

Weist Hardware

(8 reviews)

I was able to get keys made. They had a great connection from which to choose, and the people…read moreworking there were really nice. Great experience! Looked around briefly, and the prices on various things appeared very reasonable to me. I'd recommend going here for hardware needs.

Great local hardware store and small engine repair at reasonable prices. Took my two lawnmowers…read morehere for service when they both died the same day leaving me with no options to cut grass. Less than a week later, both machines are up and running for under $200! Old-time, friendly service made me feel at home and happy to patronize a wonderful local business. You should go here too!

Hometown Hardware

4.3

(7 reviews)

This place is awesome. I believe it is multi generation family owned. Its not flashy like the big…read morestores but they have a decent selection and pricing. Where they shine is the service. You walk in the door and you seem to be able to ask them anything. They find it for you. You can buy any qty it seems. For example 1 bolt or screw. We get water softener salt and they always load it for you. When your a home owner that is not really handy the service means the world. I always try there first. I have had them order things for me also and have in some cases better prices than the super big stores. This is the kind of business that needs to be supported.

Unfortunately this place has closed permanently. I'm so disappointed. It was great for picking up…read moreodds and ends instead of having to run all the way up to Home Depot or Lowe's.

J & W Hardware

4.3

(10 reviews)

This is a great store with great service.I can call and order anything and always get it right away…read morefrom the store. Very helpful people. Most always go beyond.We will keep using them. Better local then the big box stores and we love to support local.

For years I've said this is the unhelpful hardware place as no one ever has a clue when I go in…read morethere. Between the nasty paint guy and everyone else looking like a deer in headlights over simple questions, I'm convinced they exist only bc of how far everything else is. When I was in over the weekend, I was told I could bring in my rewards coupon to have adjusted since I left it at home. Today, when I went to do that, they told me they would have to charge my account again for the entire purchase amount. I have never in my life heard anything so ridiculous and I've been in retail a long time. Honestly, don't waste your time or brain cells going there.

Hepfers Ace Homecenter

3.3

(9 reviews)

Not sure why the bad reviews! This is my neighborhood store. It's Convenient and the prices are…read morecomparable to if not slightly higher than the major chain stores! Some products may seem pricey like a Traeger Grill but overall comparable. I check online before I want to make a run! Service all the years and different owners never had a problem! If I need to ask I actually look for the employees who have nothing going on or in a bunch! They're always willing to help! When I purchase a heavy product they always find an associate to put it in my vehicle! Glad they were open on a storm day I needed to restock on some winter products!

Good place to shop. Most clerks ARE friendly. Hours are good. Plenty of free parking - with…read morehandicapped spaces.

Hornung's Hardware

3.7

(31 reviews)

I like shopping at Hornung's TruValue Hardware because of the personalized service. There is always…read moreStaff around to assist or answer questions.

Took the lawn tractor I bought from Hornung's a couple years ago today for a repair. It's mowing…read moreseason so I suspected a significant delay but instead I was told that they didn't care that I bought it from them, they won't taking any repairs from anyone. Wow! That's lousy customer service!!!. Had they told me when I bought it that I was on my own for repairs I would have purchased elsewhere. Very disappointed!!!

The Home Depot

2.6

(28 reviews)

I stopped in The Home Depot to purchase a mailing box and tape, but as a garden enthusiast and…read moreplant Mom, I couldn't resist stopping by both departments. Large new selection of houseplants and a nice early selection of annuals, evergreens, and perennials. The staff here is helpful and friendly, even though I didn't need help locating the box and tape. I do appreciate the staff's help and expertise when needed. When you look up Home Depot items online or via their App, product location is always listed. Generally, a good experience when I shop at The Home Depot, even if I'm buying a cardboard box or some tape.

This Homme Depot has the best paint service person. I can't believe I forget her name. She helped…read moreme picked the perfect color for my re-do bathroom job and helped me under every step of process. Now let's talk about plants... FLOWERS = LOVE THEM. You can't beat the prices and the staff is always helpful with tip about what grass seed is best and how to grow a beautiful flower garden.

Carpet & Tile Mart

3.8

(16 reviews)

Working with Jess made the process of choosing a countertop, backsplash, and flooring so easy. Jess…read morelistened to what I wanted and showed me which products fit. She was able to answer ALL my questions. Her knowledge of materials and design choices made this a great experience! I HIGHLY recommend Carpet and Tile Mart in Mechanicsburg and Jess!! Renee B.

This job turned out good but sure didn't start that way. The staff at the store were all very…read morehelpful. We selected our laminate flooring and scheduled the measurement. Kayla came out as scheduled and did the measurement in a professional manner. We agreed and made payment as per the company's stipulation in the beginning of December 2023. We also scheduled the installation for January 8th. Well; the installation was pushed back twice because we were told the installer was backed up on another job. This wouldn't normally be a problem, but we have everything packed up for our two largest rooms except the largest furniture. The installer was supposed to contact us to look at the project prior to the job. That never happened so I called him the day before to make sure he planned on starting before moving the large furniture. They did show up on Monday as scheduled but that's were it got worse. They apparently couldn't scribe around the fireplace stone and became frustrated. They then both hop in the truck and run to Harbor Freight to get blades for the tool they needed to use. When they returned they said that didn't work. They then decided that they recommend undercutting the stone with a masonry saw. Well cutting masonry is extremely dirty so I said if that's the plan, I want it tented to keep the dust to that area. That was it for the first day....about three rows were installed. Laughable but I wanted to cry. The next morning he called about 10 am and said he is at Home Depot and the cost of materials was going to be around $500 plus about $300 additional for labor. I told him I would pay for some but not all of this because he never showed up to look at the project as stated on our contract and he showed up totally unprepared to get this job done correctly. He then told me he is an independent contractor and isn't in any contract with me so he isn't coming back! I immediately called Amber, the manager who within minutes had another installer that she could reassign to the project. She assured me that they will be able to get things corrected. She sent out Remi and Carlos. Well they stayed late that day and finished the living room before leaving for the day. They obviously knew how to scribe around the fireplace and didn't need to undercut the masonry as stated by the previous installer. By the end of the second day the entire project was complete and done in a very professional manner. The first picture is the flooring attempt by the first contractor after the first day. The second is the completed flooring at that location after Remi and Carlos took over. Thank you Amber for getting involved and sending these guys out to save the day. They will do all my flooring going forward!

Earth Tones Hardscape

4.7

(3 reviews)

I wanted to take a moment to update this. It took awhile but Jeff did send his team back to address…read moremy concerns last fall. They fixed everything and then some that I hadn't even noticed. All in all I am satisfied and would recommend Earth Tones for your hardscape project.

These guys did a great job on my brick mailbox. Very responsive. I highly recommend them.read more

Keystone Tools & Supply - buildingsupplies - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Keystone Tools & Supply also viewed

Bomberger's Store

3.6

(31 reviews)

I moved to Lititz.. 22 years ago and my son and his family have shopped there for 30 years !!…read more It's owned by the most wonderful family and they train all of their employees to have a great knowledge of their areas of their business.. They carry everything from lawn tractors to outdoor furniture and all kinds of bird needs . I always love to shop there . They have house hold products.. Once u shop there , u will be repeat customers .... There are very respected as a family that cares about u .. they have everything and the prices are great and everything they sell is a quality item .. they have great priced costume jewelry... greeting cards .. I love to go there for every season ....especially Christmas!! They have everything !! If u have never shopped there ..put this great place at the top of your list ... they are easy to find .. North Lititz ., go on 501 and head north.. you'll be so happy to explore this great place with great employees just waiting to serve you !!

They're so helpful. And it's huge - they even have great treats for your four legged friend…read more (Sophia was too shy to eat hers in front of people but scarfed it down in the car)

Longeneckers True Value

3.3

(12 reviews)

From rentals to tools, appliances to houseware - also a great place for finding unique and not so…read moreunique but appreciated gifts! First stop for gardens and holiday needs. Friendly helpful staff too!

Very disappointed in writing this poor review. I bought all of my appliances when I moved into my…read morehouse a couple years ago. In less than 5 years my fridge is not working properly. My ice machine stopped working and I had issues with my water getting warm. I had a reliable appliance company take a look at my fridge and the motor blade was off the shaft. The person that looked at it told me if I didn't have anyone look or do anything to the fridge since it was installed that it was installed incorrectly. He also told me I should start budgeting for a new fridge within the year because the compressor was not cooling down enough. I discussed this with the manager Jeffery Reese via a call and then text. He was very dismissive and rude when discussing this matter with him. I was very displeased with how he handled this situation and I will not be going to Longeneckers again for any appliances and would consider getting appliances elsewhere as they don't install properly and the manager will not listen and be condescending.

JB Hostetter & Sons

3.5

(28 reviews)

Yeah I pretty much love this place, It has a vibe, a vibe…read moreyou don't get from the big box stores. This day I came in to get some knives sharpened. (Something else the big box stores don't do) while Zack was taking care of that for me, I walked around the store once, and no less than 5 employees greeted me and asked if I needed help. FIVE!! Are you kidding me? This place is incredible!

Prices on most all merchandise grossly overpriced compares to the old true value items. Will…read moresimply avoid going to this store in the future.

Hornung's Hardware

3.7

(31 reviews)

I like shopping at Hornung's TruValue Hardware because of the personalized service. There is always…read moreStaff around to assist or answer questions.

Wilhelms Hardware

(8 reviews)

I've been going to this store for more than 30 years, its the best!! Recently I needed a part for…read morean old lamp. Sure enough they not only had the part but showed me how to install it, the service is GREAT and so knowledgeable. Wilhelm's is the hardware store you want to go to, forget about the Big Box stores. Frank W.

THE coolest store to walk into! Reminds me of the ole days, when my dad would take me to the local…read morehardware store to get stuff for his projects. The folks that work there are just as you would imagine, local small-town guys that have done a little of everything. They don't pester you, but if you have a question, they are right there to help. What a great option to dealing with the corporate hassle. Cudos, my friends!

B & G Lumber

(3 reviews)

I'll admit, I'm a bit biased: I love hardware stores. That said, this is one of my favorites…read more These guys are awesome. Perfect example of superior customer service over the large corporate chains. Prices reasonable on building materials, and selection much larger than at first glance. Don't hesitate to check these guys first if you're in the area, chances are they will be the only stop you need.

I recently bought a house in Elizabethtown and this place is a Godsend. If you're a local…read morecontractor or just have an itch to build things this is much more spacious and has a much greater selection than you would think just looking at it. For me, a novice at all this stuff Pete, the owner, and their longtime employees will walk you through the basics of the projects you are working on.

PaulB Hardware

4.1

(9 reviews)

We are not handy people. We are not knowledgable on many things you purchase at a hardware store. I…read moreappreciate the staff so much at PaulB for always being so kind & helpful. Today I asked for products that were on every end of the store. I asked for advice on fixing my hutch which has cracked wood. I spoke to so many employees and everyone had good advice and actually did service with a smile! It's so refreshing. The store is so easy to navigate. It's clean and well organized. I don't know how the prices compare to a big box store, but I can tell you I'd rather pay a bit more to include helpful service so I don't care if PaulB is more or less costly. I appreciate the care.

Just my opinion.....Paul B. is well stocked but beware.......the prices are many times no bargain…read more A small bottle of Startron for the car was above 16 bucks. That same thing at WalMart was something over 8 bucks. Other things compared to WalMart were 20-40 percent higher. I'd recommend shopping around....WalMart.....Ace hardware...Home Depot...Lowes.....or online.

Weist Hardware

(8 reviews)

Grainger Industrial Supply

(2 reviews)

We needed the product ASAP, Grainger had it for online order and ready for pickup in less than two…read moredays. Pricing was good and quite honestly our only option, so no complaints there. Easy pick up at the supply store in suburban Harrisburg. Friendly staff and in and out in less than two minutes. Perfect.

I was searching for safety harnesses and after trying several different locations, this was…read morerecommended to me. I walked in, was greeted immediately, and was able to get what I needed quickly and easily. The only glitch was when they told me my credit card failed (due to their error in entering the information) giving me a little scare, but that was handled quickly and easily. The service was quick and polite, and I was able to finally get to my job site to do something constructive.

The Pro Gallery