They call this place the most expensive grocery store in the hamptons but I must admit its great…read morequality and most of their food is delicious! The prices is not for your grocery run every week. Its those type of places where you get curious so you go and buy to see whats the hype is all about. I've tried a lot of food here. I've had their chicken fingers that cost around $35, lobster salad for $49.29, shrimp cocktail for $47.50 and a lot more. Cute ambiance and the store is not that big. I think if you're that curious then go and try it atleast once. The chicken fingers is not that good if you don't buy some sauce for it. I recommend buying their buffalo chicken balls instead. That one is pretty tasty.

Overpriced prepared foods market that unfortunately has delicious food. It's a pretty small space,…read moreso you may have to weave around people, but the selection is huge! There were SO many things I wanted to try, but the sticker shock reined me in. We opted for a crispy chicken lettuce wrap and chicken Caesar wrap. I was pleasantly surprised by both! But next time I'm probably gonna give in and try some of their baked goods as well. The only thing is I wish there were tables and chairs, but it's more of a grab and go place. We were lucky to find benches outside for a super quick meal

Great cheese. Went on a tour with Volunteers of Guild Hall.They sell unpasteurized milk that is…read morevery healthy. They also sell meat and pork.

Love this place. You can shop socially distanced at the small storefront, paying by cash or card on…read morethe honor system. The cheeses are very good. But I come for the raw milk. It's rich and creamy and outstanding. Sure, at $8 per quart, it's not cheap dairy. But it's worth it. (At that price point, though, I wish it came in a refillable glass bottle rather than plastic.)

So when I went last summer I do have a memory of the people behind the counter being oddly rude…read more But when your sister actually goes and deals with that and just brings food home it forces a review of just the food. And I can say that was the best crab cake I've ever had in my life. And I'm from Maryland. You can tell my influencer level photo skills leave a lot to be desired but trust me it was phenomenal. Plus our 6 month old will officially be able to say her first real food will be from L&F. And she seemed to love that. My sister goes on the regular and everything she gets from there is great. So hopefully they have fixed the staffing issues by sending them to etiquette classes. But if you're going to try the food u don't think you'll be disappointed.

After having tried their food at catered events, I had been wanting to check out the Loaves and…read moreFishes actual store for the last 10 years. Everyone always gripe about their pricing, but everyone still uses them, lol. I guess Loaves and Fishes should thank their friend, Ina Garten (the Barefoot Contessa) for publicizing it as one of her favorite places in the Hamptons. It's definitely expensive, but so are most other places in Sagaponack, and the surrounding area. I've had a wide variety of their food at gatherings. Top notch and always really fresh. However, I must say that the in-store selection is pretty limited. I get that the store itself is small, yet cute, but just know that the food options are fairly minimal. For our first visit, we got some typical picnic foods (fried chicken, cold deli salads, etc.). We also got a very small portion of their lobster salad. I've always liked it, and just wanted a small taste. I say small because it went for something like $75/pound. I've been told that it can go for $100/pound. For me, that's ridiculous. There's no high end caviar on it or anything, lol. Honestly, I've had my go-to spot for lobster salad here, and this place is NOT it. I've always loved their desserts. Like every single thing I've ever tried. But, at the store, I got a slice of meringue cake that they just brought out, and it was THE BEST!! Omg, it reminds me of meringue cakes I've had in Europe, but could never find as good in the States. I'd be willing to pay anything for THIS. Haha. On our first visit, customer service was great. On our second visit, the employee (an older woman) was really unpleasant. She didn't even want me taking pictures of the store (not of her). Strange.

On our way back from visiting the Montauk Light House and Museum our route took us through…read moreBridgehampton, Suffolk CountY NY II was around 5:30 so traffic was slow I spotted some cute pink chairs and what looked like giant lollipops and ice cream cones so I pulled over! My granddaughter had just mentioned she never had a sundae really what luck! This ice cream shop is very cute and you get to make your own sundae or whatever you desire ! The Ice cream is fresh and delicious , the caramel frozen Yogurt tastes just like the best ice cream you've ever had!! The mintiest mint flavored ice cream!! Everything is So delicious I If you like a long drive or possibly spend the weekend in Bridgehampton or Montauk you won't be disappointed ; there's plenty of places for dinner but I only recommend Sundaes for dessert !! AND don't miss the candy room in the back yep your kids will love this place and so will you!! They have a large variety of ice cream flavors delicious so many choices !! Topping are sooo good and you won't believe the selection from sprinkles to chips and more! I must mention the friendly staff and they also sell cute headbands ( little ice cream cones print) made by Katie B Boutique Shop! Made in the USA!

The store has a great selection of frozen yogurt and ice cream, along with rows and rows of new and…read morenostalgic candies. It's a shame that some people feel the need to leave a bad review because they got caught eating the candy in the back room. There are signs all over the place that say "no sampling" and that people will be asked to pay for the sampled candy. Eric shouldn't have been surprised. Go to Sundaes on Main! As long as you pay for the candy first you won't be disappointed.

They really are great organic farmers who know what they are doing! Their cannabis products are…read morethe best.

Great market for fresh produce AND great specialty products - wine, artisanal beef jerky, yogurts,…read morebutters... I will be back!

Amazing options for groceries and cooked food! Everything in the hamptons is so expensive and this…read moregrocery is no exception but compaired to all of them I feel like this one has a better price because you can still get a fair amount of food for less then $20. I mostly get some cooked stuff here like their fried chicken, shrimp, rice and more and it was delicious! Their grocery items is pretty expensive. I remember getting less than 10 items for $100+ already. Then again its the Hamptons. I really like that they also have space to eat outdoors. Staff are friendly and very helpful too. If you're visiting around here, this is a good place to grab some cooked stuff and bring it to the beach or picnic!

Javier, the sweetest soul I've ever met, helped me find everything I needed for my family's dinner…read more He was incredibly attentive and patient with my limited knowledge of cheese. I'm glad to know that Citerella hires such a great team!

Horrible place and a complete rip-off. They don't post the prices with the produce like very other…read moreproduce place in the world. Instead they put prices overhead on a hard to read board--and most of the prices are missing. When questioned about this fraudulent practice, A high school girl rolling her eyes rudel,y and calling herself "Madeline" said "that's they way we do things." That's why they have so few customers. Nobody in my neighborhood shops there. There is fresher organic produce at King Kullen up the road and they don't try to trick you about the prices.

Tons of Organic Produce at The Green Thumb Farm in Watermill. They have a large selection of…read moreorganic and home grown vegetables and a small selection of organic fruit. Their squash was fantastic on the grill.

Very clean store Parking right infront of the store…read moreNice selection of cookware Bakeware, juicers, coffee makers etc. very friendly staff

I don't usually post reviews but the staff here was so rude today I felt I needed to post a 1 star…read more Take your business elsewhere.

An update: There are…read moresome really excellent coffee shops on Long Island, but there is no shop like this one. Not even close. The coffee is that good. It's one of the few places in the world that the line of customers transcends all boundaries. Billionaires, builders, artists and house painters all in the same line getting their favorite coffee from one of the nicest guys you could ever know. Coffee so good, you won't see the name on the door of a nondescript commercial building in a gravel lot by the train station. I don't get here every day like I used to, so I grab a couple pounds to keep the house stocked. This place is like a favorite shirt for my soul.

WORST EXPERIENCE ACTUALLY EVER. The woman behind the counter was the rudest person I've ever met…read moreand ignored us when we tried to use the bathroom after buying a pastry. I've never felt so disrespected. Absolutely livid at this experience. This woman should be fired immediately.