Great farm stand that grows what it sells. They are one of the best on Long Island and even have…read morelocal watermelon all summer. Love this place. No eating on the premises unless you bring your own melon knife and trash bag.

Impressed with the variety and quality here. They can get away with 1.50 / lbs of bananas right…read morenow because they are one of the best in the Hamptons. Some people talk about friendliness from the staff but I feel like they are asking for too much. To add insult or compliment to "injury", my vehicle was probably the cheapest in the parking lot, lol. If I was running a farmer's market that so many flocked to, I would do the same for pricing. But also for that reason is why I offer 4 instead of 5 stars.

Overpriced prepared foods market that unfortunately has delicious food. It's a pretty small space,…read moreso you may have to weave around people, but the selection is huge! There were SO many things I wanted to try, but the sticker shock reined me in. We opted for a crispy chicken lettuce wrap and chicken Caesar wrap. I was pleasantly surprised by both! But next time I'm probably gonna give in and try some of their baked goods as well. The only thing is I wish there were tables and chairs, but it's more of a grab and go place. We were lucky to find benches outside for a super quick meal

Recently, I was in the Hamptons and we stopped here after hearing about how amazing it is and it…read moredid not disappoint. We got a small blueberry lemon loaf cake that my mom took to our cousins, peach raspberry muffins that were ginormous and so delicious. I added on the viral chicken fingers and honey mustard plus sea salt chocolate chip cookies, and a couple other things. The chicken fingers were delicious, I can see why everyone loves them. I would say the muffins really were the best and definitely a must buy. We got there and it wasn't too bad a line but generally getting there after lunch is your best bet. The staff is super friendly and helpful. Definitely will be back again!

Horrible place and a complete rip-off. They don't post the prices with the produce like very other…read moreproduce place in the world. Instead they put prices overhead on a hard to read board--and most of the prices are missing. When questioned about this fraudulent practice, A high school girl rolling her eyes rudel,y and calling herself "Madeline" said "that's they way we do things." That's why they have so few customers. Nobody in my neighborhood shops there. There is fresher organic produce at King Kullen up the road and they don't try to trick you about the prices.

Tons of Organic Produce at The Green Thumb Farm in Watermill. They have a large selection of…read moreorganic and home grown vegetables and a small selection of organic fruit. Their squash was fantastic on the grill.

They had some of the best apple cider donuts and chocolate chip cookies I've ever had!read more

Not that racist! I was hesitant after reading Yogi's 1 star review, but the employees were…read morefriendly, delicious apple cider donuts made to order. I kinda wish they were a little racist but these folk must be colorblind!

Cute market with many items and options. Perishable and non perishable items like jarred foods,…read moreoils and spreads are available. Coffee menu looked good. There is a hand written menu on the wall but everything is pre-made in the showcase or refrigerated area. There are a few areas to eat there but most people I noticed got their food to go The falafel salad was very fresh and didn't taste like it was stale or old, always a worry when things are pre made. They say that everything is made fresh daily, and it showed. Perfect spot for a quick and easy meal or bite and with healthy options

Cute store with Korean flavors that caught our eye. We had bbq chicken which was okay. The reuben…read moremelt was big. You have to specify to them to make the food hot. They just did a quick toast om most of the food we purchased, which did not taste good until i asked them to make it hot. Took 1-2 mins. Would come back again to try some other items.

The best of everything! No need to go to grocery stores all summer long. If they don't grow it,…read morethey bring in from other farmers, bakers, etc.

Lovely roadside farm stand. The vegetable quality was top notch. They had a lot to offer in variety…read morebut the winner was the corn! It was so good!

Very clean store Parking right infront of the store…read moreNice selection of cookware Bakeware, juicers, coffee makers etc. very friendly staff

I don't usually post reviews but the staff here was so rude today I felt I needed to post a 1 star…read more Take your business elsewhere.

Very ample parking and looks nice. I did end up getting a nice picture and pumpkin but the…read morecaucasian man ringing us up was a bit off. It was laughable. Lmao I'm going to sum it up. After ringing up our items we said "Thank you" in English and he said "De nada" and the tone was just off and seemed a bit condescending. How does he know if I speak Spanish? What kind of stereotype is that? If I would have replied, "I'm sorry I don't speak Spanish." What would have happened? It was weird and I won't be back.

I purchased the apple crumb pie and it was perfect! Perfectly sweet apples with a buttery crust and…read moredelicious crumb topping! We warmed it up in the oven and were going to serve it with vanilla ice cream, but it was so good on its own that the ice cream never made it out!

Love this place. You can shop socially distanced at the small storefront, paying by cash or card on…read morethe honor system. The cheeses are very good. But I come for the raw milk. It's rich and creamy and outstanding. Sure, at $8 per quart, it's not cheap dairy. But it's worth it. (At that price point, though, I wish it came in a refillable glass bottle rather than plastic.)

I knew of Mecox Bay Dairy from the Montauk farmers market where I had bought extraordinarily…read moreflavorful filet mignon and cheese from them a few years ago. I was so happy to see them this weekend at the Southhampton Art show and bought some more meat and cheese. Then I read the Yelp reviews talking about the Milk .. WOW! I had made cheeseburgers from the chopped meat and they were so tasty we just had to go get some more. The fresh raw milk is off the charts delicious. Definitely worth the trip and the extra $$ for this unbelievably fresh and yummy product! Your friends and family will ask "Where did you get this, it's so good?!"

Javier, the sweetest soul I've ever met, helped me find everything I needed for my family's dinner…read more He was incredibly attentive and patient with my limited knowledge of cheese. I'm glad to know that Citerella hires such a great team!

The pre-made breakfast sandwiches were very disappointing. They are extremely expensive at $8…read moreapiece and lacked flavor, tasting like powdered eggs. The other pre-made items also feel mass-produced and appear to use low-quality oil. Given how convenient this location is for me, I really wish the quality matched the price.