I thought the gentleman that helped us was so knowledgeable. He understood what types of cheeses we…read morelike and guided us.

We love the sandwiches but the people working here are so so rude. Everytime we come they are nasty…read moreto everyone in the store for now reason. After years of coming, we're not returning anymore - can't stand giving business to people who clearly hate their lives and their customers

Cute market with many items and options. Perishable and non perishable items like jarred foods,…read moreoils and spreads are available. Coffee menu looked good. There is a hand written menu on the wall but everything is pre-made in the showcase or refrigerated area. There are a few areas to eat there but most people I noticed got their food to go The falafel salad was very fresh and didn't taste like it was stale or old, always a worry when things are pre made. They say that everything is made fresh daily, and it showed. Perfect spot for a quick and easy meal or bite and with healthy options

Cute store with Korean flavors that caught our eye. We had bbq chicken which was okay. The reuben…read moremelt was big. You have to specify to them to make the food hot. They just did a quick toast om most of the food we purchased, which did not taste good until i asked them to make it hot. Took 1-2 mins. Would come back again to try some other items.

Overpriced prepared foods market that unfortunately has delicious food. It's a pretty small space,…read moreso you may have to weave around people, but the selection is huge! There were SO many things I wanted to try, but the sticker shock reined me in. We opted for a crispy chicken lettuce wrap and chicken Caesar wrap. I was pleasantly surprised by both! But next time I'm probably gonna give in and try some of their baked goods as well. The only thing is I wish there were tables and chairs, but it's more of a grab and go place. We were lucky to find benches outside for a super quick meal

Recently, I was in the Hamptons and we stopped here after hearing about how amazing it is and it…read moredid not disappoint. We got a small blueberry lemon loaf cake that my mom took to our cousins, peach raspberry muffins that were ginormous and so delicious. I added on the viral chicken fingers and honey mustard plus sea salt chocolate chip cookies, and a couple other things. The chicken fingers were delicious, I can see why everyone loves them. I would say the muffins really were the best and definitely a must buy. We got there and it wasn't too bad a line but generally getting there after lunch is your best bet. The staff is super friendly and helpful. Definitely will be back again!

I'm a deli guy. Living in Texas for past 11 years I was thrilled to find this place for…read morebreakfast.... And for lunch. Breakfast sandwiches of course in the morning. The all American and hamptons classic were excellent sandwiches. My wife wouldn't let me eat here every day of vacation and the only reason I didn't is because I love her dearly.

I guess I've been coming here for 30 years now. Still reliable, fast service, I love the coffee…read moresince I like plain coffee that hasn't been roasted to death. Breakfast sandwiches are simple and uncomplicated and taste great. And you can get a full meal without having to mortgage your house.

They had some of the best apple cider donuts and chocolate chip cookies I've ever had!read more

Not that racist! I was hesitant after reading Yogi's 1 star review, but the employees were…read morefriendly, delicious apple cider donuts made to order. I kinda wish they were a little racist but these folk must be colorblind!

Javier, the sweetest soul I've ever met, helped me find everything I needed for my family's dinner…read more He was incredibly attentive and patient with my limited knowledge of cheese. I'm glad to know that Citerella hires such a great team!

The pre-made breakfast sandwiches were very disappointing. They are extremely expensive at $8…read moreapiece and lacked flavor, tasting like powdered eggs. The other pre-made items also feel mass-produced and appear to use low-quality oil. Given how convenient this location is for me, I really wish the quality matched the price.

Food is sub par. Staff charges based on skin color. Owner has no real control over his own…read moreemployees. Don't waste your time. There are so many Spanish delis and regular delis nearby that offer better food and are fair with pricing.

Very cute; only, I believe they may have been understaffed today. Our order was mixed up with…read moresomeone else's. There was a lot of confusion and oversights including not having coffee. There were only two people there and they were filling take out and catering orders simultaneously. Not sure I would come back. I did add an extra star because the staff was hospitable despite the confusion.

After having tried their food at catered events, I had been wanting to check out the Loaves and…read moreFishes actual store for the last 10 years. Everyone always gripe about their pricing, but everyone still uses them, lol. I guess Loaves and Fishes should thank their friend, Ina Garten (the Barefoot Contessa) for publicizing it as one of her favorite places in the Hamptons. It's definitely expensive, but so are most other places in Sagaponack, and the surrounding area. I've had a wide variety of their food at gatherings. Top notch and always really fresh. However, I must say that the in-store selection is pretty limited. I get that the store itself is small, yet cute, but just know that the food options are fairly minimal. For our first visit, we got some typical picnic foods (fried chicken, cold deli salads, etc.). We also got a very small portion of their lobster salad. I've always liked it, and just wanted a small taste. I say small because it went for something like $75/pound. I've been told that it can go for $100/pound. For me, that's ridiculous. There's no high end caviar on it or anything, lol. Honestly, I've had my go-to spot for lobster salad here, and this place is NOT it. I've always loved their desserts. Like every single thing I've ever tried. But, at the store, I got a slice of meringue cake that they just brought out, and it was THE BEST!! Omg, it reminds me of meringue cakes I've had in Europe, but could never find as good in the States. I'd be willing to pay anything for THIS. Haha. On our first visit, customer service was great. On our second visit, the employee (an older woman) was really unpleasant. She didn't even want me taking pictures of the store (not of her). Strange.

I am so happy that I did not read the reviews before we went here this weekend- I am obsessed with…read moreIna Garten and have been wondering about this place for years- and I had the best experience. I had questions and the staff took the time to answer everything. I bought salads and sandwiches and cake, cookies and everything else I could get my hands on. The prices are comparable to what I pay at specialty food stores in Maryland and Delaware. So glad I took the time to stop there.

Solid 4 Stars for a quick convenient lunch while out on the East End for the day. I had the roasted…read moreturkey panini with herbed brie, tomato, and Barcelona vinaigrette on this rustic ciabatta bread. Oh mylanta and my stars! My insides sang such happy songs while I devoured my panini. So much so that after leaving the Cafe I said to myself that I still have my discount from post wedding registry I ordered a panini maker off of Williams Sonoma. That's how damn good the panini was. The coleslaw was meh but the standout was the panini. So much so I've already made a mental note depending what time I leave Montauk after my annual work trip I may stop in here. I don't care if I sit by myself because it was that good. Golden Pear you can count on me coming back for more!

Edit: from the owners response below, their lunch sandwiches are not buttered. I recommend that…read moreanyone who wants this sandwich to confirm this when you order because it appears some of his staff are unaware. This place serves mid food for insane prices and we only go there because there's few options nearby to grab lunch before hopping on the Jitney. Every pastry I've had there is mediocre. Every lunch I've had there is mediocre, but in this case it was a little less than mediocre. The sandwich was incredibly dry, needed sauce, dressing, mayo, something. Instead they buttered the bread??? Who butters a lunch sandwich. The lettuce and tomato at least provided some (albeit limited) moisture. Pasta salad was fine.