It doesn't look like much from the outside, but inside was nicely decorated with Italian pizza…read moredecor with Italian crooner music for ambience. Friendly server took our orders and the drinks and food came out timely. Our loaded nachos were good, though the nacho cheese was a bit runny and pooled in the bottom. My grandsons loved their pepperoni calzone and Mac and cheese. My personal pan Meathead pizza was very good; tasty with a nice crisp crust. My wife enjoyed her chicken Tuscany pizza. Both personal pizzas were bigger than expected and very filling. Would definitely stop in again if in the area.

Had supreme pizza for 1 and wife had cream of mushroom soup. Both were serviced warn and were very…read moretasty. I had a bloody Mary with plenty of trimmings. Will eat there again soon.

I graduated in 2022 and have not been back to this place since '23 but I still think about this…read morepizza so often. The pizza is perfect, garlic knots, are perfect, and if you have a chance to see the owner, he's amazing! Could not recommend this place more. (Also check out his Italian restaurant next door)

I've been so curious about this place and finally got there! The two slice special saves you a few…read morepennies. Slices are heated up perfectly. It was 6 PM and the place was empty, but there was plenty of pizza to go around. It was fresh crust, light and tasty, and the toppings were delicious.

The pizza & pizza cookie were awesome! Best pizza in the area! Also, manager on duty when I called,…read morewas beyond helpful.

Called first time, no answer. Called second time, they answered and then hung up, called the third…read moretime and finally got to place an order. Order was missing items when delivered. If paying with a credit/debit card, they charge you a card fee of 3.5% and then tax you on that fee on top of your order. The pizza's over all where okay but I would not order again. Ordered regular crust (not thin) and it was very thin and floppy. Sauce is bland. There are other pizza places in the area that are way better for the same price.

Best pizza and gyros in Watertown. Everything on the Phil's menu is delicious I bring my family…read moreto Phil's often.

I went to college in Watertown, and eating off campus was a treat. I tried Phil's after getting an…read moreEntertainment Book coupon for BOGO. I quickly used the rest of my coupons and any others I could find. I never had a bad meal at Phil's. Whether pizza, gyros, burgers, salads, or sandwiches...it was all delicious and served with care. Yes, the restaurant's small, but that just means the servers can pay better attention to the few tables there. I assume it gets packed on weekends, so check it out for a weeknight dinner. You won't be sorry.

Pizza pit never disappoint!!we've been going to many different restaurants for years. Each location…read morehas the same great pizza. I have to say lake mills was over the top! We had the delux and let me tell you it was loaded,hot and fresh The service was fast and staff was friendly. I like that they deliver too.

Staff is very kind and welcoming, pizza is very good. place feels like going back to my home town…read more place feels a little small but thats alright!

I have heard great things about Salvatore's for years, but had never tried it before. We stopped in…read moreon Friday evening with a large group, and we had an incredible time! Our friends from Chicago were staying at an Airbnb in Sun Prairie, so we made the trek from the west side of Madison to meet up with them. They had called ahead of time, and even though they don't take reservations for groups that large, the staff said that they would make a note of it and have a spot ready to go for us. Between our 3 families, we had many young kids in tow, so I was apprehensive about a long wait. The minute we walked in, however, we told them our name, and they immediately led us to a large table in the back room where we were quickly set up! The vibe of the place is really fun, with exposed brick walls and fun art. One of the coolest things was for the kids - instead of crayons, the menu comes with Wikki Sticks. These kept the kids occupied the entire time! Absolutely genius. Despite our large table, our waitress had no trouble efficiently taking orders and getting us our drinks. I was shocked by how quickly our food came out - everyone was digging into their meals 25-30 minutes after we had arrived at the restaurant! The service was absolutely top notch, and the pizza was phenomenal. I ordered the tomato pie, and it was everything I was hoping for - gobs of delicious homemade red sauce, plenty of cheese, and fresh basil. I ordered a 10", and I'm not ashamed to say I only had one piece left to take home with me!

This place is outstanding. The atmosphere at the main location is amazing, with a great bar,…read moreexcellent service, and a really welcoming vibe. I especially love sitting in the back because the kitchen is open, so you can see the team working. I've been here a few times now, and the pizza has been consistently excellent. The service is always great, and everything I've tried has been delicious. I've enjoyed the chicken wings, and the shrimp lime dish was very good as well. I've also had both the 16-inch and 10-inch pizzas, and they were fantastic. The real standout is the sauce. Their ingredients are fresh and high quality, but the sauce is what makes the pizza special. It's honestly better than any other pizza sauce I've had. I've tried Day One Pizza, MOD Pizza, and Luigi's Pizza, and this place is right up there as a great experience all around. Highly recommend!

Best. Pizza. Ever…read more Their stuffed pizza is amazing and the sausage they use is my absolute favorite. Bumbles Best is my favorite and I always have extra for the next day!

Ordered a pizza and some cheesy bread for pick up and it was done on time. The ambiance and staff…read moreare fine. Very bummed though because I feel like this could be an excellent pizza place but the pizza was just about burned. It was very dark. The cheesy bread WAS burned... I threw away all the outside edge pieces and I had to peel the bottom off of the ones I ate. Next time I order I'm going to tell them to make it "light". If it's still burned, we won't be going back.

Three of us had the lasagna and found it very tasty. Two of us had it with Italian sausage and the…read moreother person had the homemade meatballs. I would order it that way next time. Our fourth had a pizza which he said was also delicious. Our server was very attentive and pleasant. The environment is OK could use a little TLC.

Pros: -Good pizza…read more-Nice staff -Easy parking Cons: -Underwhelming steak sandwich -Some items over-seasoned We recently tried out Marty's Pizza on Mother's Day because it was my MIL's choice. She has great memories from going to a different Marty's location for work lunches years ago. Apps: -We started our order with some of the mozzarella sticks, which my wife and MIL liked (I'm not huge on breaded mozzarella sticks, so I didn't try them out). Mains: -Pepperoni pizza (Wife)-- really good thin crust pizza -Spinach lasagna (MIL)-- over seasoned to me, but my MIL seemed to enjoy it -Steak Sandwich (Me)-- not great, one little slice of overcooked, thin steak with some cheese. It also came with a cold side of fries. Overall, I would stop back in for pizza but probably would probably skip for anything else.