We are not from this area but chanced upon LGC last year and bought our first couple of homemade pies to take home. The shop owners are warm and friendly and appreciative small business ladies. Our choices last visit were a delicious Door County Cherry and fresh out of the oven Blueberry Peach masterpiece . . . so fresh that it we had to let it cool a bit before asking for a couple of forks to eat right there at the counter! They have pot pies as well in addition to jams and honeys and soon to add Anderson Chocolates. If you are anywhere near the Lake Geneva area, head west from town for a visit . . . you won't leave empty handed. Make it a destination . . . You can thank me later! read more

You have to get Julie's triple berry pie! One of the best pies I have ever tasted...and I love fruit pie!

The pies are great! They had lots of other food like preserves and canning item. A lovely store to visit and get many kitchen, food and gift items. read more

Lake Geneva Cannery - Front is store - Specialty Food Near Me - Delavan, Wisconsin

Not happy with the pie I purchased. I purchased a pecan pie and still will be looking for a pie place that bakes pecan pie like they do in the south. This is not it sorry. read more

This place couldn't get any better! Sauce Heaven for all you sauce aficionados. I bought too many to describe. If you can't find it here it hasn't been made. But talk to owner's husband and he could probably concoct it. But my Number one pick is Sweet Bourbon Glaze over grilled pineapple and jalapenos. Oh and they make the best strawberry rhubarb pie I ever had. http://www.lakegenevacannery.com/index.php?route=product/product&product_id=581&search=bourbon read more

Best pies and crust. Have bought many over the past 3 years. Open year round. Taste of fruit pies is not too sweet and the crust is perfect. The best pie place around, plus extras at the shop. read more

These fine folks are cranking out phenomenal pies. The service is always very friendly and the product quality is outstanding. Their Caribbean jerk rub made for some wonderful ribs. Can't wait to try the hot dilly beans I picked up for the Bloody Mary bar this weekend. read more

Staff is awesome! The variety in the store is amazing! Beware: the nuts are hot!!! Lol. Plenty of sauces and jams. Very unique store in its own right. I wish I could buy out the whole store! read more

Lake Geneva Cannery - a table with apples on it - Specialty Food Near Me - Delavan, Wisconsin

Wow! Hot sauce, salsa, marinade and BBQ aficionados rejoice! The Cannery in Lake Geneva has everything you want and more! I happened to walk in with my family by chance and we were very happy we did. The owner is quite a character and he was extremely generous in letting us taste a sample of any sauce we requested. They've got a lot of yummy stuff and from the labels I read, the products are made with all natural ingredients. Next time I go back to Lake Geneva, I'll definitely be returning to this place. read more

Hot Sauce Heaven!!! This place has it all, from the mild to the tongue melting. They have a variety of different hot products, not just hot sauce. I recommend trying the ghost pepper peanuts and sampling a few of the hot sauces before you buy a big bottle. The staff there is knowledgeable, the place is clean, and if you are a hot sauce hero, you'll leave with a smile on your face. read more

Lake Geneva Cannery - a sign on a brick building - Specialty Food Near Me - Delavan, Wisconsin

HOT SAUCE HOT SAUCE!! Holy WOW do they have a selection of hot sauces!! From very tasty mild, to call the fire department and ram the firehouse down my throat hot. They have it all. The staff that works there is very welcoming. And open to talking. I recommend if you're in lake Geneva, make sure to stop in. If you like hot with good flavor. Get the 'Mango meltdown' bottle. Just don't put to much on your food or you'll be sorry lol. read more

One of the best stores in Lake Geneva. The owners Darrel and Julie were some of the most courteous and helpful store owners I have ever had the pleasure of doing business with. I have seen a couple not so flattering reviews by two disgruntled customers which I have to say are totally not so . In both it referred to their children and being offended by the owners and the signs,unfortunately these signs are necessary due to customers such as these that do not parent their children and teach them manners. While I was on a recent stock up trip to the store I saw such a customer come in with three of her children and she was literally feeding them lunch with the samples, this is totally unacceptable !!! the chips and samples were fresh as well as the store neat clean and the owners a wonderful couple just sharing their knowledge and help with all customers. I highly recommend Lake Geneva cannery to any one who loves quality service,quality foods and quality pricing!! read more

I have to disagree with the previous review. I went there yesterday and had a great experience. It's nice that they have so many samples to try, but after working for 10 years in retail I understand why they have so many signs asking people to be sanitary with the samples as so many people are not. The staff is very polite and made sure we were finding everything we needed. One employee even put my infant daughter's sock back on after she took it off. We got the cocktail sauce and the pork and poultry moppin sauce. The pork sauce tasted great when I tried the sample and I can't wait to cook with it. They also have a great selection of hot sauce from hot to really hot all organized by heat level. I would have bought some but I already have too many including a ghost chili sauce with capsaicin extract. We will definitely be back next time I'm in Lake Geneva, and by that time I will need more hot sauce. read more

We were welcomed in by Darrel. The selection was overwhelming ! We found the signage to be whimsical and appropriate. Darrel didn't pressure us to buy, but he did offer samples of a few of his favorites. We hadn't planned on it, but we couldn't resist taking a couple of items home. We enjoyed chatting with Darrel. We will definitely stop in again, I have a few more items on my list... read more