I really enjoyed this place. I thought the decor was super neat. If only i was that creative. I thought it may be a little bigger upon research but its nicely laid out. The staff was super attentive. It was also really fast with every part of the meal. I think they are good at the listed menu items which could be why they don't have a super large menu, but the pizza and calzones and mozzarella triangles are done well. I think the buffalo chicken calzone would have been the best thing i have ever had that was a calzone. Highly suggest this. Totally perfect taste with the real deal of not just ranch buffalo chicken but with blue cheese, Too. I would like to go back and I tried to do something cute but I really blew my shot at picking the right music. I do appreciate that they have the touch tunes juke box. I always take advantage when I can. I also appreciate that the pirates were on. And they won. read more

Bartender Haley screamed at us, told us to 'get the fuck out' because we complained one time 6 mos ago that our food was cold. I don't think aggression is warranted especially towards regulars. No person should tell anyone to 'get the fuck out' read more

Had take out with my wife. We got a Capo pizza, the buffalo garlic wings, fried mozzarella, and the fries. Best meal in a while! Could not recommend a better spot to take someone visiting Morgantown. read more

This was our first time eating at Lefty's. It's small, but quaint. We sat at the bar and ordered wings and the pepperoni balls. The service was great, the food was good and the beer was cold. read more

waitress yelled at us out of nowhere literally said 'get the fuck out' from the bar while we were sitting at the table her name was H-A-L-E-Y. Literally signed up for yelp because she told me to leave a yelp review read more

Food was great. There was an only one waitress and she did a great job with service for it just being her.

A little on the pricey side but probably my favorite pizza in west virginia since I moved here about 6 years ago.

Wonderful pizza Wings are great but I was there yesterday and my wife's chicken was cold and my chicken parm was burnt. read more

Very disappointing and poor customer service! My husband and I stopped in this past Monday evening around 6:00 pm, and although there were four empty four-seat tables available, we were told they could not sit only two people at those tables. It was unbelievable to us that they would turn away business. Do not think we will return. read more

Tried this place cuz I drove by it. I'm in town on a work assignment and I was looking for dinner. I found this on a drive to another place and I just detoured into the parking lot, and I'm glad I did! I got the Detroit style margherita pizza (pan pizza with a thicker crust) and it was lovely. I had thought I would have some left over, but I just kind of kept eating and then it was gone. So I will need more soon. read more

Best in the area for wings and Detroit style pizza. Always local brew on tap from Chestnut Brew Works and ShortStory. read more

See all

I would sell my soul for these wings. Made this yelp account just to review Lefty's. So sad I didn't know about this place sooner. anyways 10/10 wings. read more

If you're looking for a good-no GREAT Detroit style pizza get yourself to Lefty's ASAP. WOW it exceeded our hopes and expectations. Excellent crust. Excellent sauce-just right, not too sweet like some places can be. Perfect amount of cheese. So far we've gotten sausage and pepperoni and sausage, pepperoni and banana peppers. The cheese bread was also VERY good as were the onion rings. Good beer selection and a really fun cocktail menu that reminded me of the fun yummy drinks we've had on cruise ships. Wait staff were fantastic and attentive (but not TOO attentive lol). We will be regulars here for sure. Might need to log some extra miles on the treadmill I will try to remember to take some photos next time we go before diving in lol read more

One of my favorite pizzas is the house special Detroit style. Blue cheese,peppers, bacon, red onion and pepperoni so delicious. Swanson Calzone stuffed with meat is super yum. Everything is so good. They are making home made ice cream that is a must have ! read more

See all

Great every time we stop here. House special Detroit style never lets me down. Staff always acknowledges you when you come in the door. Great food. Great service and great price. read more

Fries are incredible. Do not skip out. Wings are good too, but not a variety of sauces to pick from. Fries make up for it. Service is fast & friendly :) read more

First time ordering from Lefty's and it didn't disappoint. The house special had some really good flavors, with the sweet and tangy sauce standing out. Crust was crispy, buttery and flaky. $13 dollars for a personal, if not slightly bigger. read more

This is such a cute spot! The food was so yummy and tasted fresh. A place you want to make sure and see while in town. Staff was friendly and personable. read more

Food is a 10/10, very good and fresh. From the wings and fries to the pizza and calzones. Can't go wrong! The decor/ambiance is also very cool and clean, especially for Morgantown! Service is maybe a 5/10 and the reason for 4 stars. This is based on the only 2 occasions of dining in I've done here, the rest has been carry-out. I will preface it with, the wait staff is generally pretty responsive and attentive. However, the first time after we paid our bills, someone in our party paid with cash and the waitress came over and loudly said, "are you going to leave a tip? I'm getting ready to leave", he gave his tip and then she proceeded to stay at the bar for the next hour.... The second time, the restaurant was maybe 25% full and we had a party of 7 and they sat us at a tight 6 top. When we went to take the empty small table beside us as well so we could not be sitting in each others laps, one of the waitstaff, not our waitress, came over and rudely asked us to try and squeeze in one table.. keep in mind the restaurant was only maybe 50% full MAX the entire time we were there. I could maybe see if there were people waiting for seats but the restaurant was largely empty and not busy at all. Sad.. This is why I recommend carry-out and not ruining your time with the possibly rude staff. read more

Wanted to charge me for a small container of ranch dressing for their fries on a takeout order, but it comes with the meal if you dine in. They even argued with me over this principle. They lost longtime customers over this. Sad. read more

Brilliantly and consistently delicious. We've ordered the tavern pizza, the Detroit style pizza, the calzones, and a few sandwiches. All the ingredients each time we ordered tasted very fresh and high quality. The dough is crispy and full of flavor. Staff was always responsive and friendly every time we visited. This is our favorite spot in Morgantown. read more

Beat Detroit style pizza I have ever had!!!!!! Perfect crust! Great toppings!! Excellent salad as well!!!!!

Friendly staff, fantastic pizza (especially the Detroit style), and great salads. This has quickly become one of my go to spots in Morgantown! read more

This place made our food 3 hours before we asked to pick it up and then did not believe us when we called and asked for picture proof. Very unprofessional and rude. read more

This place has super high quality pizza, wings, salads, calzones, and even homemade ice cream!

Best pizza in Morgantown! First time having a Lefty's pizza this week - we had the Margherite. Crust was perfect, sauce had so much flavor. I raved to my girlfriends. Looking forward to our next pizza night! Thanks guys!! read more

Tried wings and a calzone and both were delicious! I don't know what they put on their fries, and they're delicious too