We've passed this place for years, so finally made an effort to stop. Cheese bread and pizza. The…read moreapp was pretty darned good. The pizza (Luigi's Special) was nice. It wasn't the best ever, but it was a solid attempt. Very cheesy! Toppings were good - the sausage was tasty, but there wasn't a lot of it. The kitchen was quick. Service was lovely - Brielle was our server, and has that lovely Wisconsin essence. The shop is standard wooden table pizza place type of atmosphere. We will certainly stop back sometime. The pasta dishes we saw coming out looked pretty good, and worth a try.

All you can eat Fish fry is awesome....thats a 5. Probably…read morethe best in the area. Parm/Beer nuggets good as well. Everything else great for area but unfortunately...that's all that's in the area. (Wouters next door doesn't count...might as well be a toaster over bar) Nice "stop on by" place to grab a bite Sat-Thursday but don't make it a special evening...drive to Green Bay or Appleton for something different. But... Friday is the day you wanna go for fish!

Lively little gem of a place. Stopped enroute from…read moreMinneapolis to Michigan for lunch on a weekend road trip. After looking up Gluten free meal options in the area, we found "Three Brothers" on Yelp. Called ahead to confirm that they had this option and they confirmed. When we arrived we were greeted with an enthusiastic "NORM!" Yelled out by the bartender... once realizing it was a false alarm that we were not "Norm" ( a regular patron) we had a laugh and were welcomed in just as if we were locals. Twas the best gluten free pizza I have ever had.... seriously.. the joyful spirit of the folk was uplifting- Best Wishes Three brothers, From the Ladies Two

The chairs are extremely uncomfortable. The floor is really un level. The restrooms are right off…read morethe small eating area and there is a steady bad smell. Waitress was very helpful and told of up charges and offered alternatives. Food was so so. Salty so if you have water retention issues, ask them to use less. Burger was extremely dry. Overall the food was just ok.

Food was amazing! Service was perfect. Both servers were amazing. Drinks were kept full and the…read moreappetizers were soo good! Glad after 3 years I tried this place! Love the family atmosphere!

Steak sandwich was really good. Came on garlic bread with grilled onions and mushrooms. You got a…read morechoice of fries or chips I instead got the soup of the day which was tortellini. Soup was filling and had lots of tortellini and sausage in it. Had lots of flavor. We had the sausage pizza and had ordered a pepperoni to go. Pizza sauce had lots of spices and flavor. We had 2 beers on tap as well. Service was fast and server was friendly. Restaurant was clean.

People were very friendly and we felt welcomed. The…read moreatmosphere was rustic as expected and the food was great!

This pizza, y'all! I would be ECSTATIC to have this joint near me in Milwaukee and as luck would…read morehave it, it's about a mile and a half from my northern Wisconsin hideaway in the Nicolet Forest. Bear Paw has a lot to offer, including: kayaking, lodging, gear and incredible food. It's in a stunning location, very near the Wolf River. We had a " pub style, plank pizza". It was loaded with fresh vegetables and meat with a medium thickness crust. A crunchy, yet tender crust, at that. I can't wait to go back. Eric, one of the owners and operations manager, was cook, bartender, server and entertainer. He does it all with a smile and makes you feel right at home. I highly recommend you try this place. It's on a stretch of Hwy 55 that winds and dips and while it is fun to drive, is a puke factor "8" out of 10 when I'm driving with my cat. Yeah, I drive with my cat.

FANTASTIC pizza. Super odd vibes when u sit at the bar and all you listen to is staff talking all…read moreclumped up at the end tho. The other thing is those high tops are cocktails only, why? You can eat at the bar? I don't get it :(

Been here quite a few times. Pizza seemed a little burnt and dry. Not enough sauce…read more Was a little disappointed this time. Service was good and we enjoy the atmosphere.

New pizza is good and chicken is good staff helpful Clean…read more,service is great, morning breakfast,lunch dinner and time convince store Hour 5 Am -12Am

if I could give a negative review to Piccadilly pizza I absolutely would. First of all this place…read moreis very rarely open, that's what I've been told on at least 10 separate occasions. second of all, they're beyond rude at ALL times, and lastly they NEVER all of the ingredients to make the pizzas they offer on THEIR menu. That's probably a good thing because the kitchen was filthy when I went in there.

We went with a group and the food came out hot and close to the same time. The waitress did a great…read morejob with the big bunch

Always love their Friday Fish! They have the best fish around, and are generous with their walleye…read moredishes.

Stopped back and dined in, having the Taco Pollo again! It came out in less than 20 minutes, was…read morehot, fresh, and tasty. TV's, games, fire pits, and indoor and outdoor seating. Counter service for food and drink.

We stopped to get pizza from Pizza Bros for dinner. A group of 5 women split two pizzas and it was…read moreenough to fill us up with a couple leftover slices. We got the pesto Presto and Pulled Pork BBQ. Both were great! There were a lot more fun pizza flavors on the menu I would like to try next time I'm in the area.

While the Margareta pie makes it worth the drive, the traditional hand tossed pizza is da bomb!…read more This is best wood fired pizza on the Penninsula ! Call & pick up ... the online order seems to shut down by 6p.... Leap frog your effort & just call it in... it's all good!

Delicious pizza option in Door County! The pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and cooked in a…read morestone oven, giving the crust a great texture and flavor. They're also very flexible with customizations and offer gluten-free options. The restaurant is primarily outdoor seating, which is great on a nice day, although there are a few indoor seats available. It can get very busy, so be prepared for a longer wait during peak times. Overall, the fresh ingredients and tasty pizza made it worth the wait. Definitely a good casual pizza stop while visiting Door County! Thank You

Best pizza we've had so far in NEW! Service was good,…read morefriendly atmosphere, lots of locals. Totally would recommend for their amazing pizza. Only drawback was we weren't aware that this is a cash only establishment. My hubby realized it when he observed everyone was using cash for their purchases. We did find a VERY small sign on one of the doors as we were leaving saying it was cash only, so lesson learned. Couldn't see an ATM in there either, so we were just lucky that we had cash. Not the most convenient way for many people to complete their transactions in this day and age when most people don't carry cash at all. Otherwise, great place & recommend!

Best pizza in northern WI. This bar/grill is a must stop after a day of swimming at Newton Lake…read more No frills just great pizza. Service is great. Just note this is a cash only establishment.