Great food and great people! It is super conveniently located to the hospital down the street, even if you don't live in the area it's an absolute life saver to have this place in your back pocket when you are up there for anything. Quality food, quick, and fair prices make it an easy stop for yourself or anyone you may be looking out for (they will not want the hospital food!). The fam and Adrian that run this place are super cool and care about their customers, this is the sort of pizzeria you want to see stay around for a long long time. read more

I ordered in advance through the Yelp app, but it did not go through to the store. Needless to say, the pizzas were not ready. I had employees and customers waiting and it wasn't a good outcome. Still, Marco and his manager made the best of it and prepared my pizza. Apparently, Grubhub (via Yelp app) cancelled my order. read more

Long Island Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Spring Valley, California

See all

All the way around great. Food, service, folks. Always just pick up. Get the carnivore!

Great neighborhood pizzeria. You can taste the quality in the ingredients. I'll be back soon!

They never pick up the phone how am I supposed to order? No online ordering either. Can get better service at little ceasers just down the street. read more

Had a supreme and a white pizza. Both were amazing. We played a couple games of pool and the owner challenged me to a game. It was a very kool experience. Like being family and I can't wait to go back. There is a big screen TV for game day and plenty of seating. read more

Best Pizza in the area. Perfect flavor and it's always on point. Closest we have found and people always rave when we bring it to parties

Great pizza and great price! Had a nice conversation with the owner the other day, great guy, very honest. His pies are quality, and he could easily charge more. Chooses not to because he likes his regulars. read more

Marco went out of his way on Thanksgiving to make us a pizza even though they were closing up. The pizza was phenomenal and the service was amazing. I'll definitely be back. Please come by and support when you get a chance! read more

An incredible local hole in the wall! The owner and his daughter are absolutely kind and have great customer service! The wings and pizza are so addicting!! Love this place! Best kept secret in Spring Valley. read more

We have been loving this place recently! My boyfriend is from Long Island and is always missing New York pizza. He's so picky about pizza and thankfully this place fits the bill. I can be picky too, but this place is awesome. OH and they cook their pizza fast! read more

Great pizza and great service a place to go to if you want good NYC pizza. All the right things were in place for NYC place

What a local gem! I've been driving by since we moved to the neighborhood, but hadn't taken the chance on a new adventure. So glad I did! Ordered online and picked up in the store (pro tip: call in the order directly and save on service fees! I'll remember for next time.). They are so friendly and welcoming, and I couldn't wait to get our hot piping pies home to eat. The classic cheese pizza piled with toppings to order was just as you'd hope, with a nice chewy crust - not burnt on the edges, my dining partner pointed out. But we were really thrilled with the Grandma Pie - thin crust, splashes of sauce, and tangy cheese. Delicious! Can't wait to return! read more

I like Long Island Mike's Pizza, but I was very sadden to learn that they stopped offering pizza by the slice. That was my go to every time I visited. I really hope they bring it back in the near future. Two slices and a beverage was a great way to roll for a quick lunch. read more

I've been here a few times, usually for takeout, and I've ordered the buffalo pizza or wings and they never disappoint. It seems like a family-owned and very friendly. I would definitely recommend! read more

Long Island Mike's Pizza - 16 Buffalo Wings - Pizza Near Me - Spring Valley, California

Good food! It hit the spot. Only thing is it has a pool table but no balls to play so we were a little bummed about that. But the food was definitely we're going back to next time we are in the area. read more

Long Island Mike's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Wings - Pizza Near Me - Spring Valley, California

See all

I placed a phone order for an 18" meat lovers pizza. I was told it would be ready in 15 minutes. I got there and the pizza shop looked very clean and organized and was greeted with smiles by a friendly staff greeting me by my first name. The gentleman at the counter made pleasant conversation and thanked me for the business. Brought the pizza home and it's fantastic. I appreciate the great experience. read more

Long Island Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Spring Valley, California

love the calzones here - and the pizza/cannolis are great too! friendly family runs the place - they recognize you which always is appreciated. read more

Love that this opened right in our neck of the woods. It's super cute and vibing on the inside. The gal that works the counter, she is bilingual, has to be as nice as they come. She is genuinely happy when you walk in!! They are friendly and welcoming. We ordered take out. It was made fresh so took a few minutes. Bubs got the cauliflower and said it was very good. All in all we will definitely be back.... The reason for 4 stars is they are definitely priced higher than other local pie shops and more limited hours of operation. read more

I tried this place out for the first time, and when I first walked in my boyfriend and I were greeted by two very friendly employees. Service was amazing and the pizza was made quickly. The pizza was reallyyy good! It's not too greasy like others, which is something I really enjoy. Definitely recommend to anyone and will definitely be coming back. :D read more

Always my go to favorite pizza place around. Pizzas only take a couple of minutes so it's quick and tasty. Either taking it home or having a few slices there while playing pool is always a good time. read more

Friendly staff. Really good pizza. Meat lovers hit the spot if that's what you're craving while pregnant!

Yummy pizzas and the garlic knots are a must- Only downside sometimes it closes early - Never have eaten there though. Seems quite large establishment for a pizza joint but none the less the pizza is great! read more

Love this place. They are located in a bit sketchy location and parking lot is horrible but their pizza is worth it!. The crust isn't hard like a lot of pizza places do. Their toppings are yummy. Most of all the staff is amazing! read more

Long Island Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Spring Valley, California

See all

When I was there I was the customer in the building. The pizza and salad came out quick. The pizza is just how I like it. Thin crust, New York style, simple and floppy. My favorite toppings are Pepperoni, Jalapeños and garlic that's it. It is delicious, great tomatoey, mozzarella floppy goodness. A little hard hard to eat without the toppings falling off. But that's the texture my mouth prefers. Salad was cold and fresh also good. Wish that they more choices for salad dressing but ranch, and Italian woks for me. Menu is not large, but the quality is great. I recommend! I'll be back. Update this time: Bland pizza no flavor. No Tabasco or any hot sauce. No bleu cheese dressing, no soda fountain, no atmosphere not coming back. read more

I was browsing pizza spot for my son and I. We try to be professional pizza tasters but fail short of that. We love ratings New York style pizza. Cheese pizza is the best. I also love their buffalo style pizza. Top notch pie's and I highly recommend this spot to pizza lovers. They don't do slices or have the Sicilian pie available all the time but the flavor/ flop/ crisp of the the pizza is a must try. This was our very 1st visit here and I'm very happy that we stopped by. Note: I ordered the 8pc buffalo wings and they were super hot and crispy. This is a must order on the side so you can dip your crust in. Oh yeah See u again !!!Buffalo Chicken read more

See all

Great Family run pizzeria! Marco cranks out top-notch NY-style pies while Stephanie & the rest of the crew are friendly and customer-oriented. Excellent value! Crust is thin, foldable yet crisp with just the right amount of chew. White meat pie and Mushroom momma are standouts, but everything is good and well proportioned. Salads are Fresh and good-sized Pro-tip: Take advantage of Mon & Tues special by grabbing an additional cheese pizza on top of whatever else you're ordering. Tastes great reheated (or even cold) You'll thank yourself mid-week. read more

Long Island Mike's Pizza - Half white me pie for me. Mushroom momma for the momma. Half cheese and pep for the kids (and me). - Pizza Near Me - Spring Valley, California

I don't like a lot of American pizza because it's usually too salty and lacks the natural flavors of its ingredients, but I found this place and finally have somewhere I know I'll like the pizza. Crust that's both crispy and chewy, cheese that tastes like milk, tomato sauce that tastes like real tomatoes, and fresh toppings that retained their own flavor amongst the other ingredients. Aside from that, the interior was clean and beautifully decorated, you can tell it's a small business with passion. The guy who served us was very nice and clearly cared about good pizza. On top of it all it was a reasonable price for very above average pizza. read more

Long Island Mike's Pizza - Grandma Pie - Pizza Near Me - Spring Valley, California

We are lucky to have this pizzeria in our neighborhood. We order from them all the time and they're pretty good. But we recently put them to the test ordering 11 pizzas for our daughter's birthday party and Mike's totally crushed it! We got so many compliments on the pizza and the pesto over was a huge hit! We should have gotten more of that and the pepperoni jalapeno. Those went quick with the parents! Everyone loved the pizza and the customer service was terrific. The pizzas were ready on time exactly as ordered and the lady even helped me out to the car. We'll be back soon! Especially for that pesto pizza! read more

10/23/2019 UPDATE: Always a great pizza when I come here! Glad today I also had the pepperoni and sausage! The sausage was very flavorful and well seasoned. I like the sweetness of the crushed tomatoes in the pizzas. To take my slices up a notch, I bless it with a few sprinkles of granulated, some parmesan cheese and crushed peppers- magnificent!!!!!! Always a clean establishment. Friendly staff. And love how they are finding ways to make some improvements. For example, ones dine in sliced pizza is not served on 2 paper plates, now it's on a wooden board like the ones they pull pizza outta the over but it's smaller and not heavy. Wax paper is place on the board then the slices. Such a cut way to sever up some deliciousness! And cost effect and going green in small ways m, but it all helps the environment in the end. Be mindful not to throw the tray/board in the trash. Near the trash can is a bright sign for the trays to be placed there. If one hasn't, come try a slice. Ask about modifications or additions, or customize a pie and enjoy it!!!! Initially reviews below.... Love this pizza!!!! Omg sooo happy there is one in my neighborhood and that makes it taste even better than the other location. Nice variety of slices in the window to choose from. The buffalo chicken was amazing!!!! The chicken was tender, the buffalo to ranch sauce was proportional. The white meat lovers with spinach, pepperoni, bacon etc... did I say bacon, YES!!!! Anything with bacon is good in my book!!! That pizza was a hit. Very satisfying!!! I even used the crumbs of bacon and pepperoni that fell off and recycled it on top my buffalo chicken and it was great!! Lol Very friendly hostess and the manager!!!! Yes this is the same quality as the other location but this is what Spring Valley needs!!! The manager said he's featuring different pies and it's making people try new items. That's awesome. It's new, clean and adequately supplied with all Your pizza needs. This is one pizza I don't feel guilty eating because the crust is thin but the quality and flavors are very satisfying!!! Come ona d grab a slide for $2 cheese or any specialty for $2.75 but the BEST deal is the 2 combo slices with a drink for $7!!! Don't forget to try a garlic knot too ... 50 cents for one or 6 for $6.75 and comes with a nice chunk marinara sauce, yum!!! I'll be back!!!! Thanks Long Island Mike's in Spring Valley CA. Way to represent!!!!! 07/30/2018 update .... the meat lover pie is packed with soooo much flavor. Them meatballs are on point!!!! I usually don't do the meatballs but I'm a fan now!!!! My roommate loved it and the buffalo chicken was on point!!!! Thank you for a great pie, friendly service and quality pizza!! Told ya, I'll be back and back again 10/06/2018 update: what's new: carry out special on Monday's and Tuesday's cheese only $10. Now you can get a comb with 2 slices with toppings and a drink for $6.50. Drink is $1.50. Slices with toppings $2.50. Taxes not included. Plus THE PIZZA IS STILL AWESOME 02/02/2019 Another great meal!!! Pizzas always hot, fresh and same quality as expected!!! Thanks guys! read more

See all

Food is always good Service is always friendly Price is a great value We love this place read more

Great deal. Lunch special Tue-Friday 11am-2pm 9.99 12 pie 2 toppings or a specialty pie with canned soda. The dough is really tasty and moist. Not dry like other places. Fresh topping and homemade sausage. read more

Long Island Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Spring Valley, California

Amazing local pizzeria! Fresh toppings and amazing crust. The staff are all nice people including the owners of the place too. Overall nice welcoming atmosphere and good food!! read more

This is easily one of the best tasting and bang-for-your-buck, pizza places! Especially if you're wanting that NY style bigger slice, slightly thinner crust, but not cracker thin where it breaks apart. The cheese and sauce ratio is always well-balanced, I've waited to do a review just to test the consistency here a few times and I'm officially impressed and satisfied every time. Great friendly service, solid prices compared to the competition, and never too busy that you're waiting an unreasonable time for a pizza. P.S. TRY THE GARLIC KNOTS! read more

Second time eating Long Island Mike's Pizza. Same as the first. Real good pizza. We ordered the meat lovers. Good big salads. The highlight was the meatballs in sauce and mozzarella cheese. Thought it was appetizer but it's a meal. Great flavor and very filling. Support local business especially the good ones. Long Island Mike's Pizza is one of the good ones. Eat here. They are also on Uber Eats. Have them deliver. read more

See all

I really appreciate East coast pizza places like this. You can order a pizza, the pizzas options are great. They also have a pay by the slice option & they always have lots of pizzas to choose from already pre made. If you get the pay by the slice option you get your food almost immediately, otherwise call in or be prepared to wait. If you haven't tried east coast style pizza then you are really missing out. In New Jersey, New York specifically they do their pizza crust extra toasty and thin, I love it!! Ricotta cheese is commonly used as a topping & it is amazing. There are lots of culinary options in this area and this pizza place more than holds it's own against some fierce competition. Don't be afraid to try this place for one minute, it's good pizza all the way. The ambiance is sort of like a sandwich shop, and everyone is friendly. Try it, happy eating !! read more

Long Island Mike's Pizza - House special and the pep - Pizza Near Me - Spring Valley, California

See all

My hubby (K) is from Long Island so he knows pizza... this place is legit! The owner Marco, his family, and staff are wonderful people who clearly love what they do and take pride in it. Their love is reflected in the food! We are working our way through his menu. Our faves (so far) are the meatball roll... droooool, all the sandwiches, baked ziti, Grandma Pie (see photo), cannoli's, and any variety of pizza! OK, so I can't vouch for the buffalo chicken pie but don't blame Long Island Mike's! I had a very bad experience with a buffalo chicken sub from Subway a few years back. Don't ask... Their delivery option is great for those who prefer to stay home. Just double-check their delivery hours since they have changed due to COVID-19. V & K read more

Long Island Mike's Pizza - Sicilian Pie - Pizza Near Me - Spring Valley, California

Although the pizza be fallin apart , i love the thin. Pizza with lots of flavor lol ill eat it like a sammich. No complaints

Great pizza, check! Superior customer service, check! Reasonable prices and weekly specials, check! Been in this establishment a few times to pick up their individual slices that are available during lunch. I've always been very pleased with their pizzas. Wearing a mask, I basically fumbled pretty badly with my order. My grumbling, masked covered voice and slightly overheated mind thought I had ordered and paid for 2 pizzas. I was a bit mad at myself, when I realized my blunder when I approached the counter to collect 1 pizza. I apologized for my mistake, then proceeded to order another pizza. The cashier who took my order insisted on comping my pizza, even though it was my fault. Customer service and satisfaction is something that makes this place stand out. Will be returning here to remain a loyal customer. read more

Long Island Mike's Pizza - Large Cheese and Pepperoni/Sausage pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Spring Valley, California

Great East Coast pizza. Highly recommend. The crew working there are very friendly. One of the few truly authentic East Coast Pizza.