The dumbo location is a tourist trap. So you get what you expect. That being said, my son wanted a lobster roll, we used to go to red hook, So we walked over from pier 6. Because it's a tourist trap, you need to read the menu and options ahead of time, don't expect the counter person to ask; do you want a pickle? Want the lobster roll warm? 4 oz? 8 oz? Extra butter? $50 bucks for a 4oz lobster roll, small clam chowder with oyster crackers, and a bottle of water. My son was happy. I'm glad this isn't a regular thing. read more

Loved it ... Delicious chilled lobster rolls and coleslaw on a hot day ! The service was fast and reliable. The wait was a bit tedious but once we got to the counter it was a well worth! The price for the rolls are steep! So beware read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Overall: Pretty good lobster rolls, but the wait times are insane and the prices are high. The good: The sandwich was well worth the wait, I'll give them that. The lobster and the bread roll were both heavenly, and it was nice to be able to enjoy a beer along with it. Location is top tier, as you can enjoy your meal under the Brooklyn Bridge. The not-so-good: The wait time was atrocious, waited in line for 25 minutes and then had to wait another 20 minutes for the food to come out. 1 cashier, 1 window to order and pick up - I understand their limited footprint, but if you have any sort of plans, 45 mins to just get food in your hands is a long time. And the prices are high, even for the chips and drinks. read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

No pictures... But that was amazing. We've been to the location on the Upper East Side, but being in Brooklyn this foodie weekend, we dined under the Brooklyn Bridge! I had the lobster roll with a cup of clam chowder. The flavors on both was amazing. The lobster fresh and delicious, with a crisp on the toasted roll. The clam chowder was chock full of clam meat and perfectly seasoned. My wife had the crab roll with a cup of lobster bisque. I couldn't resist sneaking a couple of big slurps of her bisque and found chunks of lobster in the flavorful bisque. Very friendly service even though it was a tiny place under the Brooklyn Bridge. A wonderful experience for visitors to Brooklyn, though a tad expensive for a daily working lunch. read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Right under the Brooklyn Bridge! - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Pretty good. Nice to go to on a beautiful day. A little pricey but that's expected. Combo comes with lobster roll soda and soup. read more

See all

I think I find most places in NY amazing. But I haven't had great Lobster in the city UNTIL I tried this grilled cheese. UMMMM I easily could've went back for another one if I hadn't walked away. This was SO good I am still thinking about it and it's been a month:) read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Listen, if you have in your menu different types of lobster rolls, they supposedly have to taste different, no? We had 3 different rolls and all these truffle or spicy something tasted just plain.. read more

We had the BEST experience at Luke's just before Christmas. It was a super cold day and when we approached we weren't sure they were open - but the employees immediately saw us walk up and waved us around back to sit inside to order and eat. They were super friendly and the service was great - as were the lobster rolls ! I had a great conversation with one of the employees about them possibly opening more Luke's Lobster locations in the south (where I currently live) and I just generally can't express how much I enjoyed not just the delicious food but the experience we had being welcomed and chatted up by the employees. If you were one of them who was working around lunchtime on Monday 12/15, thank you so much for not just serving us good food but for being so lovely on a very cold NYC day! read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Stumbled upon this lobster shack before heading onto the ferry. Love how tasty and fresh the lobster meat was. Definitely love the truffle butter the most out of the 3 sauces (lemon butter and spicy honey butter) read more

See all

I tried the sampler where you can taste the lobster with 3 different butter options and it was phenomenal! I did pay extra to have it heated. I would for sure go back here and eat again. The price was fair. And the service was fast. read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Fast casual spot (walk up to go window) with delicious lobster rolls. Beat my expectations. Located right under the Brooklyn Bridge with outdoor picnic table seating with a beautiful view of the east river. The 4oz lobster roll was pretty good size for a lunch serving and it came with chips and drink. I ordered a specialty lobster roll - spicy honey butter, so good. Hot Honey and pepper flakes over chilled lobster on a toasted buttered bun. It was $25, but worth it. I'm from California where just a regular deli sandwich is already $20, so to get a lobster roll combo meal for a few extra bucks seemed like a deal to me. Really hit the spot after walking across the Brooklyn Bridge. The staff was really friendly as well. Worth a try! read more

See all

Came here to try out this place while walking around the Dumbo area during a hot day. It's located in a pretty cool spot near the waterside, so you can see views of the city and bridge. There was no line at all when I got there, but that might've been because of the strong heat and sun outside, so my experience of service was quick and easy. Food was good, the roll was nicely done. But I think my highlight was actually the clam chowder. Lots of potato, clam, (oyster crackers that I was given) were in the soup! The prices at this location are pretty high here though, but overall a good place to try out some seafood soup or rolls, such as shrimp, crab or lobster. read more

Hidden gem when you visit the bridge. Very tasty lobster roll and service was great. Price is not bad considering you are in NYC. Everyone loves our order. read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I love this location for Lukes! The roll flight (with crab, lobster, and shrimp) was tasty but definitely on the pricier side. It's great for a quick bite and stroll along the waterside. It's also nice to go to the grass in the park afterwards. read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My friend and I shared the Luke's Trio which includes a 2 oz lobster roll, 2 oz crab roll, and a 2oz shrimp roll. The meat was pretty dry and there wasn't a lot of flavour in my opinion. Still, it's in a good location to grab a quick bite and eat it by the water with a view of the bk bridge! read more

See all

Came here on a weekday, the workers were so lovely and helped us split our lobster roll without us requesting. It was a lovely surprise that they went out of their way to do that. read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The lobster is absolutely amazing, but the service is top notch! Tracy (manager) is one of the nicest people I've met, here in Brooklyn! Her energy and spirit truly transcends into her food! Chenai and Keenan were also truly wonderful and made our experience unforgettable!!!!! We will absolutely be back!!! read more

See all

This place has become something of a tradition for me to take people when I have friends or family in town. We meet in Manhattan, walk the Brooklyn bridge, go straight to Luke's, and watch the sunset from DUMBO. It's a great way to impress an out of towner, and, as a local, a very enjoyable experience as well. Luke's has my favorite lobster rolls in town. They're all delicious, and have a great meat to bread ratio. I love that for the price of a large lobster roll you can get the sampler of three, which is what I usually do. Also highly recommend the slaw here - it's the perfect side. read more

If you like lobster rolls this is the spot! Super chunky pieces of lobster, can be ordered hot or cold. Not too much restaurant seating but if you don't mind sitting on grass, there's a big grassy area right behind and if you go in the late afternoon the grass is all shaded by the Brooklyn Bridge with a perfect view of Manhattan. read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The lobster rolls here are absolutely amazing. Ordered mine hot and it was the best roll I've had. The area is sooo pretty and the workers were so kind. 10/10 read more

This is probably on me for ordering a lobster roll for delivery but it was really not good. I actually ordered the Luke's Trio (lobster, crab, shrimp) and the only one I even remotely liked was shrimp. The seafood didn't taste fresh and the melted butter has hardened and congealed by the time it arrived. I've had Luke's in store before and it was much better, but overall I definitely won't be stopping by again soon. Updated: The business responded that the food is meant to be eaten in the "timely manner". It sounds like the restaurant shouldn't offer delivery if they know the food can't handle sitting long enough to be delivered??? read more

So I just got a hot dog here for $5.44. I usually never get food from them, but I was starving so I wanted to try this overpriced hot dog. Hot dog is ok. I've had better. If you want condiments, they won't put it on the hot dog but on the side. The bun is not a regular hot dog bun. It's kind of like a variation of a regular hot dog bun and a slice of grilled white bread. I don't know, but it kind of feels like a tourist trap. Now the service...horrendous. The guy who served me clearly has no idea about hospitality. Extremely disrespectful to customers. I was really shocked and appalled. read more

See all

Luke's Lobster in Brooklyn Bridge Park is a nice little food stall with good service. We tried the lobster flight and thought it was great! It comes with three 2-oz servings of lobster rolls. The bread was perfectly buttered and warm and crunchy. I docked one star because the meat was almost ice cold, but we all prefer them warm + the Honey flavor one was a little bland. The other two flavors were pretty good. :) read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Lobster Roll Flight - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I admire with their lobsters. Visited them a few time and will definitely visit again. Recommend this restaurant

This is a hidden gem! Lobster rolls were amazing - a little on the pricey side but 100% worth it if you're just grabbing a quick bite. read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Lobster Bisque Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Beautiful Saturday afternoon long line and some wait time. Was able to find a table outside so I definitely had a great view of the bridge.Was able to get a table while waiting for my food. Lobster Rolls are delicious and meaty and the kettle chips are so good.. read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Menu - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

It is hard to pass by the fresh smell of lobster, so I decided to check this place out while in DUMBO. Got the larger size lobster roll (6 oz) with clam chowder. Personally, I prefer having warm/hot lobster roll, so got the butter one that is served hot. Loved the combo of hot clam chowder with the hot lobster roll - DUMBO breeze is a plus. Definitely consider this place when you are nearby! read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Classic - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This review is going to be quick and to the point. If you are in the area right underneath the Brooklyn bridge on the Brooklyn side you must stop if your a fan of lobster rolls at Luke's lobster. Service was great and friendly. And the view of the bridge is the bestseller read more

See all

My two friends and I are visiting NY from Anchorage, Alaska for a few weeks, and we went through almost everyday for our meals in variety of restaurants- big or small. We didn't expect from a small free standing building for such a delicious sea food. The lobster roll was not only delicious, but also filled with pure lobster full of its meat. read more

Small little lobster roll for way more than I wanted to pay for. The roll had a decent amount of lobster meat, with not too much mayo. Just perfect. Texas toast/roll was toasted just enough and the overall lobster roll was good. I just wish it was bigger read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The Luke's Lobster is somewhat expensive but they do make super super delicious lobster rolls. They are super generous on the lobster portion. If it says 4 oz it is 4 oz. I ordered the Truffle Butter Lobster roll. Oh wow that was delicious. It came with a bag of chips for $25 ( 4 oz of lobster roll). There are many add-ons options or making it a bigger meal options. I decided to stick with just the lobster roll and the chip. I didn't want to pay extra given that Luke's isn't cheap especially when converting it to Canadian dollar. There are limited seating on site. I managed to find an unoccupied rock to sit on. there are a few benches nearby; however, those benches are not reserved for customer's of Luke's. I definitely recommend trying Luke's Lobster. You will not be disappointed. read more

See all

$25 for a 4 oz lobster roll is way too much. It was also not even that good unfortunately. The bread, caked with butter and a very simple lobster filling w little bits of seasoning just did not work together for me. It's not the worst I've had but not the best either. There is only some shabby outdoor seating and service was just alright, so I don't think I will be coming back here. read more

We came to Luke's with the cravings of the sea. The menu is comparable to the other locations with a tad increase in prices (location, location, location). My usual $25 lunch was $29. I like how there are multiple sizes for the rolls and add-ons, the customization is always a plus. The staff was friendly and service was quick for my order. My friend on the other hand who ordered directly after me had to wait a while. Everything was fresh, but the clam chowder was saltier with tougher clam pieces than usual. Still salvageable with some added milk/cream, reheated at home. The location is great and easily accessible, and there were a few cute tables to enjoy our lunch, but the mosquitos were on full attack in the day time. We left very quickly after eating, due to being a meal for the aggressive insects. I'll be back with the deep woods Off or Skin so Soft spray. read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Crab roll - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I love lobster rolls and I loved Luke's Lobster when I used to work in the city. I had decided to pick up some rolls for an after-dinner treat. When we arrived to the tiny shack, there was two people waiting on line and a few people eating in their outdoor area. They had both a QR code and a menu displayed to order. The menu available online had different prices than the one displayed on the counter. I got the three roll (shrimp, lobster, crab) and lobster bisque to go. The cashier was friendly but, at one point when my neighbor wanted to change their chips he spoke sharply. I thought that the rolls were a bit small for the price. Each roll was about the size of my thumb and was devoured in two bites. The bread was a bit stale and did affect the taste of the roll. I felt like the roll itself wasn't very flavorful. The lobster was creamy and was delicious. If you like Hale and Hearty's lobster bisque, you will find this one to be tasty as well. I also like that it included small bits of lobster. read more

See all

What an incredible little stand! This place is located under the Brooklyn bridge and was a highlight of my trip! I got the trip and honestly it was one of the most incredible things I had here! If you're thinking about it, this is a great place to try! read more

This Luke's Lobster location is right alongside the waterside under the Brooklyn Bridge. It is a relatively small location, with a good flow of customers purchasing lobster rolls - however, there was never a long line. I bought 2 original 4oz lobster rolls, as well as 1 original 6oz lobster roll. Overall, the lobster was extremely tender and tasty, with a good amount of lobster with each order. If you are coming to try out these lobster rolls, be prepared to spend a lot of money. For these 3 lobster rolls, I had paid just over $90 usd. With the amount of lobster, I can say the price is justified, but it is still a lot of money, especially for street food. On a side note, a great experience is to purchase these rolls and sitting on the benches or tables lined alongside the water, as there is a great skyline view of NYC across the water. read more

See all

We went to Luke's on a recommendation and after trying, I'm glad we went however, these three halves were $27. But the views and the ferry ride back to manhattan make it all worth the experience. read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Delicious warm lobster roll. We ate in the park right next to the shop. Highly recommend.

I'm not that into lobster rolls ... that was until I had these : D They're fresh, buttery and I love the seasoning. The meal specials are awesome. Plus they have lots of covid precautions and outside eating right on Brooklyn Bridge Park. I've never had a problem finding a seat. I honestly almost don't want to review because I'm afraid if I share everyone will crowd the place! read more

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park - Lobsta - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Delicious. Would preferred warmer lobster, felt quite cold for our expectations. Other that that was great.