Our first time here.... Definitely go back!!…read more Hubby had the Chicago dog.... He is SO happy to find it authentic, tasty & fresh! I had S'mores Sundae. Such a delicious treat! Nice & clean shop Thank you

Came back again after 3-4 years. The plain waffle cones are still just a dollar extra. The ice…read morecream is still yummy; however, today i felt the scoops were a little on the small side.

It is so so so good…read more I like darker chocolate ice cream usually and this place has a really good one. And their biscoff flavor REALLY taste like bis off and I think the cookies are mixed in. Most places biscoff barely has the flavor. Even tho I prefer chocolate, their other flavors were also REALLY good. Wish I lived nearby, they are way better than Kelly's ice cream . Also bonus since their spoons and bowls are recyclable (no pic, ate it too fast)

The was the place to be on a hot May evening. We stopped by to grab a couple ice cream cones and…read morethere was quite the line. They offer a great selection of ice cream flavors. We were told the ingredients were locally sourced if possible. We ordered the banana pudding and straight strawberry along with a dip of parent trap in waffle cones. The flavors were tasty and the ice cream a good creamy consistency. The prices are on the high-moderate side. The staff were very friendly.

Cold Cow is an absolute must-stop on the way home from any trip to St. Augustine! We've been coming…read morehere for years, and it never disappoints. They have more flavors than I can even remember--truly something for everyone, including sugar-free and dairy-free options. The "single scoop" here is absolutely massive; at most other places, it would be considered a large. It is incredibly well-priced (under $6!), so you really get your money's worth. I got the Dairy-Free Coffee Almond Fudge, and it was fantastic! While I wish they had a few more dairy-free flavors to match their massive traditional menu, I love that they don't upcharge for the dairy-free options. That is a huge win in my book. The vibe is exactly what you'd want from a local mom-and-pop shop: kitschy, eclectic, and covered in cows. They even have rocking chairs on the front porch to relax in. The crew is always friendly and helpful, too. Pro-tip: This place is popular for a reason! If you're visiting on a weekend, be prepared to wait a bit. Trust me, though--it is so very worth it.

Just wow, the ice cream here is great. A very long list of homemade ice creams. 3 of us enjoyes the…read morerich, creamy goodness along with a line of people. I had the Coffee Crunch, whose coffee ice cream tasted like coffee for a change (not some lame watered down flavor). Others had chocolate flavors which really impressed them. I got the toddler size which would.have been a small anywhere else. Place was cute with tables and chairs, and Adirondack rockers too.

Had to venture out of downtown to find this location after the Hypolita Street location closed…read more The side quest to St Augustine Beach was well worth the time. Cousteau's creates the best milkshakes I have experienced in my 60+ years. Thick and flavorful, my go-to is the Be Still Cody, served with espresso whipped cream. I arrived as they were opening for the day. Counter help was friendly and ready to meet the work day. He was responsive and efficient and made our order quickly. Interior is much larger than the now-closed Hupolita Street location used to be. It is also well climate controlled with plenty of seating.

This is a very unique place for a sweet treat. Though not really specified in their name, they are…read morealso an ice-cream shop with Mayday Ice Cream. If you like that ice cream, you'll like the selection here. HOWEVER, the milkshakes are not made with that ice cream. I can only speak to having the Whirlybird waffle and Mayday ice cream, not a milkshake. The Whirlybird was ok. My waffle was a bit tough; I can't tell if that was because it was stale or because of how the apples had soaked into it. The apples weren't that special, either. They were a bit overpowering and made the whole thing a tad sloppy. If they were diced apples instead of sliced, it might have been a bit easier to eat. The whipped cream and vanilla ice cream were a great accompaniment to it all, though. The insides are very clean and neat. Everyone there was friendly and attentive. They served us a great many samples as we decided on what to get. I would come back again to try a different waffle creation. They did have serval that sounded great. And the ice cream is great, as usual.

Kaylee is amazing and so kind!! The ice cream is sooo good and it's right next to my favourite…read morebeach spot! I will definitely come by every time I'm at the beach now!!

Cute little ice cream shop with the sweetest woman working…read more She made our day - we were planning to just stop in and grab ice cream quick, ended up chatting with her while eating our ice cream. My daughter asked to go back just so we can say hi again before we leave

If you're reading this review- just go!…read more Sooo delicious with a variety of flavors. The ice cream is sweet and creamy without being so decadent that you can't finish a 2 scoop serving. The shop is adorably set up. We walked in on a father and son playing a game of connect four on their wall, and walked out to a small family sitting on the outside bench just chatting. So homey and sweet. But right alongside the great ice cream- major shoutout to the patient and amazing staff. We sampled over 6 flavors with no judgment haha...ended on two orders. Mine: Banana Pudding & Coffeehouse (10/10) Partners: Graham Central Station & Coffeehouse (he finished before I did )

What fun spot to stop for ice cream located it is in uptown St. Augustine. Our server was so…read morefriendly and patient with us. And the prices were very reasonable. I had two scoops, Key Lime and Coconut Chocolate Almond, absolutely delicious with great flavor and add ins. And well priced for $5.25. My daughter and her boyfriend both had ice cream sandwiches which were served on warmed cookies with a scoop of ice cream in between. Inside the shop is decorated with Polaroid photos and a Connect 4 board is hanging on the wall which my kids played a few games. Best ice cream shop we visited during our vacation in St. Augustine.

The food is amazing. The best things about this place is the simplicity of the flavors and…read moretoppings. Back to basics. The atmosphere is cozy and very welcoming. The service is incredible. We hit it off immediately with the owner. The staff is patient with answering questions. They give some samples to try of the cones they make. Would definitely recommend to everyone who loves soft serve.

Service was fast a friendly. The soft serve is definitely "extra" as it's the creamiest and also…read moredensest (not a bad thing) soft serve I've probably ever had. It tasted like serious calories - again not a bad thing - LOL. I will say I don't think the extra cost for waffle cones was worth it.

Had the strawberry matcha ice cream and it was AMAZING! So sad we don't live close by, I'd be there…read moreall the time. Staff was so nice and the shop is adorable.

After a Cuban sandwich lunch we were in the mood for something sweet - and just a few doors down…read morewas Mayday ice cream. There was a line, but it moved and our wait wasn't very long. The one complication of the line is that it made it hard to see all the flavor choices with your view blocked. We ended up choosing Triple Vanilla(My wife) and Espresso Chip for me. The few tables inside were taken so we enjoyed our choices outside in the sun. This ice cream was excellent, not your run-of-the-mill typical ice cream. It's advertised as small batch ice cream made with premium ingredients and that's exactly how it tastes. As a sweet tooth satisfier it definitely hit the spot!

Yum!! absolutely delicious!!…read more I had the strawberry shorty Sunday 100% recommend that you try this place!

If you come out after a hard day of shopping at Bass Peo Shop and need a sweet treat, definitely…read morecheck out this place. Just two minutes away near World Golf Village, the Turtle can meet your sweet needs. We had the Turtle Club in small size and it was more than enough: packed with real ice cream, thick chocolate topping and big pecans. It was creamy, gooey , crunchy, and just yummy. But if that isn't enough, they top it with a turtle cookie! Seating is limited to a few tables and a bar inside with a couple of tables outside. Service is friendly and quick. You can even watch your treats being made.

I got the pumpkin spice ice cream, and I thought it was really tasty. It didn't seem like a very…read morebusy place, and the prices were pretty standard for the area. The other reviewer mentioned not liking the flavor he got, and having problems with the owner. We didn't run into any issues, and we were proactively offered tastes of whatever flavors we wanted before committing to the full cone. I have had better ice cream, so not giving it 5 stars, but it's really not a bad place.

Owner is a cat calamari, and this place is purely a tourist trap. Now I know why I never went in…read morethis cream hell. I asked for pistachio but after one little half bite I told him tasted off and asked if I could swap for another flavor, the owner agreed and scooped another ice cream, - but then he charged me for both, insisting, even after I reminded him that he agreed to giving me something else. Maybe he is losing his mind? I asked him why he thought I would want to pay for both, and he got extremely boiled up angry and wouldn't give me my credit card back after I asked him five times, he threatened to call the police on me, I told him to go ahead. Then instead of arguing any longer I just paid and threw out the ice cream. This probably happens often, otherwise he would have been cool about it.