Best Sicilian pizza I have ever tasted. The chicken parm is one of my very favorites!

Best pizza in town I've had it a bunch of times it's my go to spot The chicken bacon ranch and buffalo are my favorites read more

A hidden gem in Mastic. I have been searching for the best chicken Marsala and I finally found it!! Nicely decorated, clean, restaurant with great service as well. My husband loved the muscles and the delicious cheesecake. We will definitely be back. Highly recommended. read more

See all

My wife hates the sauce. Happy wife happy life. Veal parm dinner was satisfactory. I get delivery most of the time. Have a blessed day.

Mama Lisa's was an excellent choice for Italian food. Great food, great portion size and very nice ambience. The server was awesome.

Amazing!!!! Excellent Gluten free Italian. So many menu items and I always feel fine after eating here.

Lovely place. Very good food. Real nice people. Lots of choices. Bring the family. Been there twice while visiting LI. Sent others there and they liked it as well. read more

Another horrible service here, this is what they charged me $11 for. 2 slices with extra cheese read more

Mama Lisa Restaurant - "Extra cheese pizza" - Pizza Near Me - Mastic, New York

Very nice family restaurant. Good for groups or by yourself or as a couple Food has been seats delicious. Many great choices to pick read more

Mama Lisa Restaurant - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Mastic, New York

I ordered from mama Lisa. Chicken parm dinner with a salad instead of pasta. Not only was the chicken delicious, but they gave me a full salad instead of a side salad like most itialian restaurants do and did not charge me extra. I highly recommend Mama Lisa's if you are in the area or door dash. read more

I stopped in on a whim. I am glad I did. The chicken cutlet parmigiana hero was delicious! Restaurant and bathroom were very clean.

Update: Came back to retry it again, Alfredo got better but still wasn't the same as how it used to be. Everything else I ordered was good. Their Marinara sauce though, it is the definition of Plain!!!! It's a shame because the sauce comes on the side with mozzarella sticks, fried raviolis and the sauce for the chicken parm. If the Chef reads this, please change it, it would make everything so much better. Even if you taste it you would know what I'm talking about. Ragu Sauce is probably even better. It just needs a spice or too. Or maybe serve the mozzarella sticks with Vodka sauce if you don't want to change the sauce. But I love this place but, a shame the marinara sauce is plain read more

Mama Lisa Restaurant - Al Pasta Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Mastic, New York

Fantastic Italian authentic square pizza! I loved each every bite. I got the Grandma / Nonna. I met the owners Nino and Moses are just two friendly down to earth true Italian gentleman. I commend their staff for the service and friendliness. The place is very clean and that's a sign that owner care. The ambiance is open space and plenty of room for small intimate setting to large Italian style family dinning. read more

I love their chicken and shrimp Parmesan. Their pizza is fresh and delicious. Their meatball and Italian are my favorite to order. I've personally never been there to eat but when I call to order my food they are pleasant and have amazing customer service. read more

Extremely disappointed, chicken Parmigiana Hero was chicken cutlet cut up with melted mozzarella, lack the sauce. Gnocchi has grease on the edge of the tin, and sauce had a funky aftertaste. Pizza was alright needed to cook a little longer, at least the delivery driver was very good. I don't recommend anything other then pizza (well done) and garlic knots because it is such a disappointment and a waste of money!!! read more

Mama Lisa Restaurant - Greasy Gnocchi - Pizza Near Me - Mastic, New York

See all

Food and service is excellent. You won't be disappointed. A true diamond in the rough.

they charge $6.00 for using a credit card. later when confronted the guy said there's a sign at the register...like we're going to see that as we're being seated! next, the food stinks. For an Italian restaurant you'd think they'd make good pizza...do not get the rustica pizza...it was totally dry and the prosciutto was a gray color. we ended up throwing the whole thing out. that pizza cost $32 for a serving for ONE PERSON! we didn't complain because we were with a big party. never again read more

Best seafood ever !!! I highly recommend their seafood platter which is my go to meal. It is a huge portion, super fresh, and always presented so beautifully. we ALWAYS start our dinner off with an order of baked clams and a fried calamari as well. Very generous portions and the prices can't be beat! We love Mama Lisa :) read more

Mama Lisa Restaurant - Lobster platter - Pizza Near Me - Mastic, New York

See all

So disappointed in the meal we picked up today. Ordered Chicken Parm & Eggplant Parm. Chicken was so thin you could not even see it. Cheese was burnt on top, sauce was like paste. The Eggplant parm was just stacked on top of each other and burnt mozzarella on top. Again the sauce was like paste, don't know if it was old or what. Please do not flatten the chicken it was gross!!! read more

Terrible customer service and I order from them frequently, I actually ordered through Uber today and ordered a grilled chicken Ceasar slice and winded up getting a wilted tossed salad slice instead , I called and spoke to manager and he said there was nothing he could do ... meanwhile it was his staff that made a mistake not Uber read more

Mama Lisa Restaurant - Wilted Tossed salad slice with chicken ( obviously no Ceasar like I ordered ) - Pizza Near Me - Mastic, New York

Nice ambiance friendly employees food is amazing. The pizza is very very good not the over oily type but still cheese and tomato sacude make up for your typical NY PIZZA flavor. Best place for weekend get together with family or friends read more

Nice atmosphere, good Italian, food, professional staff fair prices try the eggplant rotini read more

Amazing! My husband and I were looking at houses all day so when we saw our last he said let's try somewhere new which is how we came across Mama Lisa's and I'm glad we did! We got there at like 4:50ish and we sat right away everyone was very friendly! We ordered the zucchini flower it was better than I thought it would be for dinner I had chicken parmigiana probably one of the best I've ever had it melted in my mouth. My husband had the swordfish special lets just say he cleaned his plate! We will definitely be visiting again. If you are in the area this is a must!! Ps just want to add when we left the restaurant was packed!! read more

Mama Lisa Restaurant - Zucchini Flowers - Pizza Near Me - Mastic, New York

Extensive menu, very friendly staff. Food was delicious. Pizza not my favorite, but my kids liked it. Nice place to visit, very spacious and clean. read more

I'll take some pizza with that salt next time. Thanks. This seems to be the most popular place in the area so I doubt my criticism will make a dent, which is good because I support small business owners -- plus I can only judge by the 3 slices I've ever had there (pepperoni, mushroom, eggplant). All the other food might be fantastic. The ingredients seems quality enough, and I appreciate the heaviness of each slice -- but really some of the worst $30+ (for a pie) I've spent and 1,000 calories (2 slices) I've gained. LOL. Just left me feeling heavy and unsatisfied. Oh well. read more

A unexpected hidden gem in mastic. The food was fantastic and full of flavor. The portions are large with more than enough sauce on each dish. The service was good, the waitress was 10/10. However, you can see and hear the boss yelling at the busboys to fill up glasses of water and get to work. Inside the restaurant there is a pizza portion and in the back a restaurant portion. I would say it isn't a very fancy Italian restaurant and it is very loud in there when everyone is talking. Overall, I would recommend mama Lisa's for its food. Expect good service with a semi loud atmosphere. read more

This is a must stop if you are in the French Quarter. I've been coming here for 30 years, and still can't beat the charm and homemade flavor. read more

Mama Lisa Restaurant - Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Mastic, New York

A piece of metal was in my pizza, last time I eat in Mama Lisa restaurant.I also know how it happen.

Ordered a half pepperoni pie for delivery. With tip it was $25. Unfortunately we could only eat about 1/3 of our $25 pizza. Apparently sometime between being boxed and delivered, the pizza was tossed around like a frisbee. All of the cheese and pepperoni had slid off making half the pie intolerably soggy and greasy and the rest of it lacking cheese and pepperoni. The slices that weren't ruined were sub par. Typical, average oily pizza with ragu-esque sauce, undercooked cheese and an overcooked, burnt bottom crust. Called up to see if management could comp our next pie at least. They offered 20% off the next order. Considering over 50% of the pizza was ruined... that wasn't a great remedy. read more

Mama Lisa Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Mastic, New York

See all

Food is consistently very good and well portioned. In particular, a huge fan of their chicken parm plate and the hero's!

To make a long story short, there's nothing here I don't like. From the fresh food, to the really accommodating staff. I live in the area, & eat here quite often. It doesn't even matter if I do delivery, or come in at eat. If I do come in, and enjoy my food at the actual establishment, I 100% do what I can to sit at the little bar, with Joe. My friends & I come here for quick beer & apps or a slice of pizza, and we all look for Joe! Fantastic service, personable, and ensures you'll have all the right things to make your meal enjoyable. As a whole, I doubt you'll be disappointed with any choices made here. Rice balls are always a solid choice if ever unsure!! 10/10 would recommend read more

Good food and service prices are fair, I will eat hear again when I come back to visit mom

Not as good as it used to be use go there once a week now not so much starting charging extra for pamasean for a eggplant Parm hero

My wife and I have been customers once a week for 12 years. 90% of the time through delivery. I ALWAYS tip well! We have noticed over the last few months that the quality has gone way down. Uncooked shrimp parm etc. Last week we both had Combo dinner 3. The Sausage was tough and horrible, the Veal Cutlet had Not been pounded and tough. The chicken Cutlet was extremely DRY! I would recommend that you stay away. Either the chef has changed or they are now buying inferior quality. read more

One of our favorite Italian restaurants. We knew the family when they were a small pizzeria and one of the owners wives were the waitresses. Dedicated family operation. read more

I really wanted to like this place, even after we walked in and saw the very sad looking pizza. The waiter sat us promptly, which was nice and came over and recommended a few dishes. He said that the carbonara and the fettuccine Alfredo were the go twos here and they were staples. I can attest that they were anything but that. The Caesar salad was very good. However, everything fell apart from there after. The carbonara pasta could not have been more overcooked. The sauce was OK but very very liquidy. The fettuccine Alfredo was in edible. There was no cheese or salt or pepper or garlic, it was just cream. Also it took almost an hour to get the food. The waiter was friendly but it seems like the kitchen needs to figure out how to operate correctly. Not a good experience whatsoever. I would only come back if they straighten the kitchen out. read more

Great pizza. The grandma's pizza is awesome. Delivery service was fast in comparison. read more

Been going to Mama Lisa's for years, literally before they were a larger restaurant further up the road. Food was always very good and great price. We dine in or takeout. The folks are friendly and the service is great this is a great little spot to enjoy a great Italian meal. Bon Appetite read more

I love Mama Lisa's their food is delicious especially my favorite pizza!

This place is amazing always come here for dinner! Also the best Sicilian pie on Long Island hands down read more