Well it was a busy night and they were touting their buck a shuck and prime rib all week so they were the main reasons we went. Ordered 12 oysters for him and 6 for me. The server came right back to the table to tell us that there were only 6 oysters left.!it was only 6:15. So very disappointing. I was not in the mood for a big meal so I had the pizza and salad both were good. His prime rib was fair not great. I asked if he would order it again and his answer .. NO. They did tell us that they started the buck a shuck at lunch which left nothing for evening diners. Hopefully they will remedy this oyster problem as we would like to give it another try. read more

See all

The food is consistently good. The service is the best! Bonnie was awesome!! It's very clean and nice inside. I'm getting old now and find it loud but that's to be expected as there is a nice sports bar there. I would eat everything there except the Italian sausage. They fall quite short on just that one item. But truth be told, we will be back, and that's the best compliment I can give them. read more

See all

I want to update my review that the business leadership reached out and said they were able to pinpoint the issues and are resolving the support for the staffing. I don't know if we will have an opportunity to return this season but I do find that when a business's leadership read and respond to concerns quickly it's clear they care about their patrons and their staff so we will definitely be back to give it another shot! read more

Mamma Mia's Marshfield - Broken glass that remained on the floor for over 30 minutes - one extremely busy bartender who no one ever came to help. - Italian Near Me - Marshfield, Massachusetts

I wouldn't go back to this shithole if it was free. Took 20 minutes to get a beer and over an hour to NEVER get a pizza that I ended up paying for just to GTFO. read more

Italian Night with some Friends, we started with Greek Salad...so good, our Mains were, I got Seafood Florentine with all types of Seafood...plus Homemade Pasta with Sauce, I did not eat the Pasta and Sauce, I could have just the Seafood Dish without the Pasta, @websterbuffa88 got Cheese Manicotti she said it was alright...too much Cheese on it, plus we ended the night with a Chocolate Chip Cannoli.....good way to end the night!!!! read more

See all

It's been several months since my review and I have to say that everything has been great, Food is good, prices very reasonable and the service is top notch! read more

Hosted my father's 90th birthday party at Mamma Mia's Marshfield. Couldn't ask for a better venue-love the new function room with a closed door to the dining area and bar. 30 guests including 7 Kids under 9. Food was excellent. Server was fantastic! Easy to plan and the manager and entire staff was very accommodating. Thank you! read more

Takeout order - Watery pasta sauce and uncooked panini no cheese and did not add ingredients that were requested. read more

Mamma Mia's Marshfield - Buffalo Chicken "Panini" didn't come with cheese, was just a chicken cutlet covered in buffalo sauce with two soggy pieces of bread :( - Italian Near Me - Marshfield, Massachusetts

Pizza was good and the meat balls we're pretty good Will be back I will try the pasta next time read more

I'll start with ambiance! TERRIBLE! So LOUD! Obnoxious. And , The DJ didn't take one break so no down time. This remodel is awful. Three longtime friends getting together after a year and we couldn't hear each other. We won't hurry back until something is changed. Our server, Rhiannon, felt the same way because customers couldn't hear her. Thankfully Rhiannon was a great server because it made up for the loud atmosphere. Lastly, the bread was delicious, the pizza was good but our meatballs were well done. read more

My husband & I went for dinner at the bar tonight. Busy but the bartender, Riganne was awesome. She was the only one on the bar but had it totally under control. Eggplant parm was yummy as was the ravioli. Trivia night was lively & fun. read more

Excellent experience with server Erin! Very attentive and personable. Food was excellent but service was better. Definitely would recommend to a friend. read more

Ordered a few pizzas online Monday night with a 40 min wait. Ok that's fine. Paid in advance and added a 22% tip. Arrived and was told it'll be a few minutes. After patiently waiting for 15 I asked about my order and was told they had no idea what happened but my pizzas weren't in the oven yet and that it would be another 15 min wait. I get that mistakes happen but this was my experience the last time I went there a few years back. And sorry to say the pizza was definitely NOT worth the wait. Soggy with no flavor or seasoning. Oh and the cashier said the manager is coming out to talk to me. Waited at least another 5 min for that person too and then the cashier said never mind not coming. Unbelievably horrible experience read more

Olivia M at Momma Mia's Pizza was awesome! Super friendly, quick with the refills, and knew the menu inside and out. She made our pizza night even better. Ask for her if you go! read more

I went for dinner the other day at Mamma Mia's and I had the most wonderful server Olivia M. She was so polite and friendly. The food was also great i'm ready to go back! read more

Great service, great food new function room. In spite of a full bar room the restaurant was quieter than before the renovation and building the function room. read more

10/10!! Iv never had a bad experience here! I was a meatball HATER my whole life, recently I tried the meatballs here and I'm in love with them!! The pizza is amazing!! Even the fish and chips slaps! Seriously this place is so good read more

Mamma Mia's has excellent Italian classics, great pizza and the most friendly staff. I consider them a Marshfield best business.

Our takeout order (one cheese & pepperoni pizza and two Greek salads with grilled chicken) was promised to us for 6:20, and we didn't walk out of there until after 7, which is completely unacceptable when you are offering takeout service. There was not enough grilled chicken for each of the salads, and I found a hair in my salad. No utensils were provided in our takeout order, which is problematic when you're eating a salad on the beach. Nothing was done to acknowledge the poor service we received which is why we will not return to this location. read more

Went for my husband's birthday- food and drinks were delicious! Our server was very friendly and attentive. Loved the atmosphere too.

I just had the worst Alfredo sauce ever. It was so watery! I had Shrimp Broccoli Penne with Alfredo sauce and though the shrimp and pasta were prepared well, the sauce was horrible. I have liked this place very much in the past and have taken guests there so I will give it one more try. But if this were my first visit there I would never go back. read more

Have been there quite a bit, but disappointed tonight. I ordered the fish sandwich which tasted off, and a little undercooked . I ate a couple of bites and finished the sides.it was taken off my bill. Now 4 hours later, I'm not feeling well. My granddaughter just ordered fries which were overcooked and tasted like the oil was old. My friend ordered angel hair with just butter; received regular spaghetti. Never been disappointed before so wondering if they had a new cook. We went to play singo and did have a good time. Will probably give it another try, but definitely won't order the fish . read more

I always get take out pizzia from Mamma Mias Years ago in the 80's I was visiting a friend in Kingston I live in Boston at the time. and he told me about the Pizzia and now I love this pizza so much. Now I live close by the Marshfield branch and I get just the plain is so awesome the sauce is very low acid and such tangy cheese its so unique. its the best pizza around trust me. read more

My friends post this on Facebook. So cute and looks so good. I want to try called some friends already . Saturday plan read more

Mamma Mia's Marshfield - OMG - Italian Near Me - Marshfield, Massachusetts

This is the first place that I have ordered takeout (in COVID) other than the Venus, where we order pizza (which is awesome) and I wish that I had used my $75 to buy 2 large lobster rolls from the Green Harbor Lobster Pound (best lobster roll ever and customer service ever!) instead. Mamma Mia's Marshfield was an overall terrible experience. My husband called in the order for takeout and the customer service person was very friendly. Also, she told us that it would be 40 minutes. We got to the restaurant on time but then had to wait in line for pickup about 10 minutes. It would have been nice if they told us to get there and we would make a 10-15 minute line so we could plan (and have our food hot). My husband made the line and came into the car. He asked me if he should check the order and I made the mistake of saying, "No". I trusted that it would be accurate. Wrong decision on my part. When we arrived home, I was flabbergasted to find that my Mom's Shrimp Scampi, which she had ordered with no tomatoes, came with pennw. I have worked in food for over 20 years and never heard of Shrimp Scampi being served with anything other than some type of spaghetti/linguine/angel hair noodle. I called the restaurant to inquire about the mistake as my family waited for me to resolve the situation and our food got more cold. The girl that answered the phone was very nice, told me that it was her mistake because they have a "no selection" button that she has pressed and she was supposed to ask us, so she would get her manager, and that her manager would give us a credit. Once the manager, Jackie was on the phone, she offered for me to drive across town (20 minutes each way) and go to get a new dish. I told her that the nice person I talked to previously told me that I could get a credit. I then told Jackie that my entire family was waiting for me to finish the call so that we could sit down and eat and that I would appreciate if she could just give me the credit. I asked Jackie if the credit was at the restaurant or on my credit card and for how much exactly. The manager I was speaking to at this point told me that my credit would be for either $2.00 for the pasta or for the $17.99 for the whole dish, but she we need to speak to her general manager about it before it could be decided. I was so distraught by this point that I ended the phone conversation and decided to do a Yelp review. I had purchased a lasagna through the catering office in the past that was good and that's why I decided to try this place again. I was tired of cooking and cleaning up the dishes, but this experience just left me wishing I had made my own Italian dishes. Worst food ever, and terrible management. read more

Mamma Mia's Marshfield - Shrimp Scampi - Italian Near Me - Marshfield, Massachusetts

See all

This is a super average restaurant. Not great but also not bad. Fair prices. Adequate service. Took us about 7 minutes for anyone to acknowledge us at the host stand. Our drinks (whatever their dessert martini thing is) were extremely over poured and took 25 minutes to come out. The chicken Marsala was actually quite good despite lacking salt. Servers (our server was training someone) completely forgot about us outside. Busser wasn't wearing a mask properly (only over mouth not nose). read more

Mamma Mia's Marshfield - Chicken Marsala - Italian Near Me - Marshfield, Massachusetts

See all

This location does not fall in line with there other locations. The food was not homemade tasting. The Alfredo sauce I got on the side was broken and gritty. The prices on the menu need to be updated. The waitress disappeared then reappeared seemingly wondering as if she had nothing to do. read more

The food was almost as bad as the service! Never going to this location again. What is happening to Mama Mia's?

Several years ago when I first tried this location, it was 3* at best. Some friends and I ate there again 2 weeks ago on a Wednesday night, at the request of one in our party. Even allowing for the fact that our waitress apologized that she was new, I'm sorry to say that everything was sub par. Each of our dinners was simply awful--I can't even remember what I ordered; one of our nonalcoholic drinks was wrong and was promised to be replaced. That never came, and wasn't taken off the bill. (The person who picked up the check didn't want to say anything.) At a house party a year or two winters ago, I enjoyed the catered dishes our hostess provided. I hate giving crappy reviews. Most of mine are very positive, because I believe it's easy to complain, many times people forget to give kudos when they are deserved. I know times are tough, but I really hope this restaurant can regain at least its 3* status. read more

Like many of the reviewers before, I have had terrible experiences with this restaurant, Because of that, I haven't frequented this place in over 5 years, Only because I received a gift card, I elected to return last night. While it wasn't crowded, we were met at the door and escorted to a table in the main dining room, It was quite loud so we chose to move to the bar. From that point forward, it was nothing but 5 stars, Our waitress, Haley, was right there to take our drink order and continued with outstanding service throughout the meal, We both had pasta dishes which were delicious, The manager, Dave, came by to thank us for being there and was most pleasant. In short, we shall return again soon. read more

I only got takeout from mamma Mia's. My family loves it and it was my first time. They got chicken buffalo pizza and a brownie , I got chicken parm with linguine. I was very happy with my meal. It lasted two meals also. The portions are very generous. I didn't try the pizza but they said it was good. The brownie was what they really wanted lol so I guess the brownies are good there read more

Mamma Mia's Marshfield - Chicken parm - Italian Near Me - Marshfield, Massachusetts

Last night Nick was our waiter, awesome guy. We waited a little while for our dinner to come out, Nick stopped and talked with us and had us laughing...finally our dinner was served!! It came out hot and was excellent. We had a Shrimp pizza with garlic and pesto, Chicken Parm and Baked Ziti with sliced meatballs (they forgot the meatballs) but Nick brought me out an order right away. Want good food and an awesome waiter...ask for Nick at Mamma Mia's in Marshfield.. read more

my husband and I were in Saturday april14th. we were promptly greeted by Steve. he was friendly and really seemed happy...It was very busy and hopping. Our server was Joan again greeted us brought us our cocktails. she was very friendly.it was extremely busy and she was working very hard. The manager stopped by to say hello his name was John. I told John how wonderful everything was. He was happy to hear it. What I didn't tell all of them is that I've been in customer service for 48 years. I've trained at least 100 people in my years and the service was excellent! Food was delicious, everything including the restroom was clean. I can't wait till we will be back in town in a few weeks to visit again. Thank you again Mama Mia Marshfield read more

The food is excellent here. This is my gf's favorite pizza in a town full of pizza places. I was not a fan of their first Marshfield site when it was on Plain St, but since they moved it has been very good. With their new site came longer waits since it seems very popular, especially in the summers. I only give it 4 stars due to multiple times having to either wait for pick ups much longer than expected and twice waiting a long time for food in the dining area. The last time we were there we actually thought our server left for the day since it took 45 minutes to get pizza after ordering it when we sat down on a seemingly not too busy time. We've been to this site 3 times for sit down and picked up 3-4 times though because the food is so good. We've gotten pasta and pizza here and was always pretty good. Once we ordered take out ziti with meatballs, and there were almost no meatballs, but it was still good. We might just go to Kingston when we want to sit down next time, but we will still order pick up from Marshfield. I would have given it 3 stars for the service issues, but the food was too good. This is the only place for pizza in town that has given us good, fully-cooked pizza 100% of the time when picked up which we are very thankful for. read more

Horrible pizza was so soggy and the cheese slid right off. Long blonde haired waitress with a ponytail didn't come back to us once when she heard us complaining of how bad it was she was sitting in the back on her phone the entire time. Me and my friend were the only ones in the restaurant and we waited 30 minutes to pay. We will never go back this is the second time we've been disappointed. read more

Mamma Mia's Marshfield - Italian Near Me - Marshfield, Massachusetts

Delicious place with a friendly atmosphere. I met my family here for an early Christmas dinner. My father is Italian and insisted this place was authentic (and he didn't disappoint). Unfortunately, I was over an hour late to dinner. The server kept my family busy and brought over bread and appetizers. I appreciated that. I ordered the chicken broccoli Alfredo with spaghetti. Fabulous!! Made great leftovers too. I also ordered the tiramisu for dessert, that's my go-to when I go to restaurants. Definitely one of the best tiramisus I have ever had. My father and his girlfriend ordered the GIANT brownie sundae and it didn't disappoint. It was INSANE. I recommend ordering that if you're sharing with the family or friends. I will be back! read more

See all

This is a long overdue review being written. I am literally baffled as to why the previous reviews for this place are so negative !! My boyfriend recently moved to marshfield right down the street from here. We have visited every restaurant in this section of town and it has gotten to the point where I no longer waste my time going ANYWHERE BUT HERE. Every item i have tried ( mamas chicken wings , buffalo tenders , steak tips ,all types of the pizza , specials like swordfish ) have all RULED. always fresh always quick. The bartender Donna is a doll! She makes the best planters punch I have ever had hands down it's honestly and truly delectable and refreshing !!! We are new regz at this joint and i don't see it getting old anytime soon !!! read more

Mamma Mia's Marshfield - Italian Near Me - Marshfield, Massachusetts

Not a fan. The bar area is huge which is great but its super loud. Food is just ok. Sometimes the specials can be very nice. We feel the pizza is ok. read more

Mamma Mia's Marshfield - Scallop summer salad - Italian Near Me - Marshfield, Massachusetts

See all

service staff is great, but the place sucks, managers kick you out at 7pm, fact 1/7/24

Best service and food I have had in months. New decor looks really nice. The host was accomodating and checked back on us often. I had a a pear salad and my wife had the cacio pasta. Our server was on top of everything. We will be back read more