Been ordering for almost 2 years now.. started out really great and then one time I ordered and never got my food delivered and restaurant didn't answer phone ... took a long break.. just ordered again last weekend and food seemed different ... less cheese and different quality and mozzarella sticks were weird and hard .. too much inconsistency ... parting ways read more

This is a takeout/delivery only restaurant, so keep that in mind. I love their pizza! So far my favorite is the Supreme. A great balance of fresh toppings, with flavors that complement each other, and a generous amount of smooth, creamy mozzarella! The restaurant is under new management, and the menu has been expanded. I'm looking forward to trying their great variety! The new owner is friendly and very accommodating. I like my thin crust pizza with a pie cut instead of squares. I experienced problems with the payout system and my card, which I hope he gets straightened out, but he did tell me I could order online, have the food delivered, and still pay the driver at the door (they carry card readers). That would save me the hassle of having to go pick up my orders in order to pay in the store. He said I could also order on the phone and pay that way. I look forward to visiting my friend's house up in Rockford more often so I can explore their diverse and ambitious new menu! read more

I miss the previous Mamma Mia's as it was always delicious, and loved those wings. New owners now, and although the same name, it definitely is not the same. We tried the "Mexican" menu along with our traditional Italian and sadly were disappointed. The quesadillas looked and smelled so good, but were dripping in grease so much we couldn't finish them without feeling like we were drinking oil along with them. The wings are basic and seemed to taste like they've been in the freezer too long. Hoping they get it together and figure it out as we do miss having a local place to visit. The plus side, they couldn't be more polite! read more

Yesterday I had their Dorito Taco Pizza and it is the best Taco Pizza I have found in this town. In fact, I was waiting a Meg's coffee shop while they made my pizza and they brought it over to Meg's when it was ready. Not many places have that kind of service. My husband and I intend to try as many items on their menu as possible. I highly recommend this place. read more

My husband loves thin crust, so we were both looking forward to a nice crispy crust, and all of the toppings we ordered. The crust was so wet that it was soaking into the delivery box, and so of course the toppings wouldn't stay on because of that wet, flabby, gross crust. Half of the toppings ended up sliding completely off of the pizza. NOT the fault of the delivery person! The fault was with whoever didn't take the time to make sure the crust was baked properly! We will never order from them again. read more

I ordered the pizza with pepperonis and sausage it tasted like a microwave pizza. Then I also ordered the chicken and pasta the chicken was an extremely thin slice and was just so bad I couldn't finish it overall very unsatisfied won't be ordered again. Haven't tried the Mexican food so can rate that but hopefully it's better than the pizza and chicken with pasta. read more

we got are food and the cheese ravioli was cold the cheese in the middle was frozen and was gross

Just discovered them and they're yummy. Also, love that they have cannolis. And their salads were pretty filling for the price. Their pizza is a little expensive to me but it's nice to try something new. I'm typically into Lino's pizza, but it's good to mix it up. read more

We have ordered from here several times. But last night was the last time that we will order from here. Whenever we talk about ordering my friend asks if I think they are open since their hours are not always reliable . Last night we called at 8:20 to order a salad and sandwich. I was told they were only making pizza's since it was getting close to 9 closing time. It takes longer to make a pizza than making a sandwich. A carry out Italian place is only open till 9 is closing way earlier than any other. I cannot tell you how many times we have called during their stated open hours and they were closed. This is not acceptable! I wish them luck but we are tired of this and will not order again. read more

Disappointed. Very disappointed. I ordered pizza and a salad and two cans of coke delivery through the Alice app. The pizza is cold, no utensils for the salad along with a small cup of ranch and the two cans of coke are actually Pepsi: I would've never ordered them if I knew it was Pepsi when it clearly said Coke. read more

Tonight I ordered lasagna, don't get it. I've never had lasagna made so thin. There where two layers, literally, cheese and meat. It was thin and 3 layers at best. Have you heard of melt in your mouth, it will based on the fact it was mush. Never again will I order this dish from here Again, the only reason I gave them two stars is because the pizza is tolerable. read more

Mamma Mia's - Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Rockford, Illinois

I ordered a xlarge pepperoni pizza it was greasy and gross c and my brother ordered a cheeseburger with fried mushrooms the but the mushrooms on burger and then came back and dropped the 7 dollar shrooms back u bit in to one of them it tasted like watered mushrooms instead of fried we threw it all way called up there guy acted like he didn't care I'll never order from here again and this was our first time read more

The salad was fresh and tasty and the linguini with garlic butter was to die for. My mom got lasagna. It was great as well. Very generous portions. We could have shared a salad and entree. It was a bit pricy but close, convenient and good. read more

Mamma Mia's - the front of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Rockford, Illinois

I've only ever gotten take out pizza, in fact it's my go to Italian place when I don't want to cook. They're quick, reliable, and tasty. The 10 inch pizza is perfect to share between two people. Every combo of toppings I've had has been awesome. They put just the right amount of sauce and toppings. I love the crust here too, I could eat just the crust with some of their tomato sauce to dip in, yum! read more

Don't order from here. If u get delivery, the delivery boy will show up and shortchange you. Simple math is all that is required to understand that my $21 order plus tip would be $25. Nice tip for a pizza delivered literally 4 city blocks. But delivery guy had only $10 in prefolded 1's. Thanks but the pizza isn't that delicious read more

Never ever go there. Italian food should not taste Mexican, Pizza tasted like spicy tomto paste. Crust had no flavor. Sicilian Salad has small old clumps of pizza sausage, two small pieces of tomato, no cheese, it did not look at all like the picture online. Meatballs tasted like meat flavored bread crumb balls. Pasta sauce tastes like it should be on tacos. Italian dressing was pepper flavored oil. I paid for avegie pizza with ground beef got no meat on it. My husband threw almost all his meatball sandwich away because it had such a weird taste. It won't qualify for dog food. I could say more bad things or ask for replacement food but I will never go near the place again- They should only try one type of ethnic food on their menu(Mexican, Italian, American diner or hot dog joint) and maybe able to make one ok. way to expense for food quality and service. Not at all like the taste and quality of of food of previous owners, Gave it one star because cannoli was passable and felt sorry for their failure to do aything right. Save your money on this garbage. A frozen pizza would be much better. read more

Located north alpine near guilford road and Edgebrook Love the garlic knots. Pizza is decent, but won't knock your socks off. Average prices. The Don challenge is a nice touch for buddies that want to test their eating capacity. It's a good local stop for pizza on a weekend night. Definitely will stop again. read more

It's Papa John's/Domino's Pizza, but not served from Papa John's/Domino's-at least it is not Pizza Hut. With the lineage of the owners (supposedly from the same group/family who started Francesco's in Rockford/Cherry Valley years ago), I expected much better pizza than this, especially in Rockford, IL (where pizza is practically a religion): read my other Yelp! reviews for significantly better local pizza suggestions. My initial fears were correct-the only thing seemingly missing from here is the use of those plastic pizza pans on the chain-driven pizza conveyer oven (in which case I could add Chuck E. Cheese to the pizza list mentioned earlier in this review). This sort of pizza place can be found nationwide and is nothing about which to write home unless you are the owner/franchisee of the business (or if you work for the place). Many small town inhabitants might even really dig the sort of pizza made at Mamma Mia's simply because their pizza options are "frozen," "nothing," or "Casey's Convenience Stores'/Noble Roman's from a gas station located at the interstate off-ramp." I don't think I'll be eating here frequently unless someone else is buying/treating/insisting/demanding/holding a gun to my head/absolutely no other local pizza places exist/it's free (pick your favorite(s) from that list). That said, it definitely beats the pizza from the predecessor of the location (it was a Papa Murphy's take and bake, which closed and got significantly remodeled into the Mamma Mia's it is today). The pizza here does not taste horrid, but neither does pizza from Papa John's/Domino's--yet compared to several other Rockford pizza venues, the pizza here pales heavily. Mamma Mia indeed. :-( A bonus star is given on this review for the -very- friendly, smiling, staff behind the counter, and also for a quick completion of my order ("order to carry out" in almost ten minutes on a busy night, just like at a Papa John's/Domino's). The staff was truly wonderful-I wish more customer-facing position holders were as happy and smiling as the staff was here; too bad they have a mediocre-tasting product to peddle. Edited to fix (some of) my typos. read more

Well I was not combative.my wife both live on disability so when we order out we don't expect money to get stolen and I wanted to get the drivers name because I filed a police report As I said the manager didn't do a thing to stick up for his business. If they don't do stuff like this how did it happen . Someone there is a thief ,and if it doesn't happen I'm living proof read more

Great pizza and fantastic service. Thank you for keeping Bloom Elementary stocked with hot fresh pizza for the funfair.

Thank you so much for making a gluten free pizza that is tasty and large enough to share. We haven't tried anything else yet. But will definitely be back. My only suggestion is when u order the gluten free pizza, u do need to let it rest. My pizza needed time to set. The middle was a little underdone. But to there defense i ordered three veggies and of course veggies have moisture. Looking forward to another pie soon! read more

We got the family feast. Definitely good value for the price. Pizza was decent. Garlic knots were yummy, and the pasta was enough for a meal all on their own! My family of 3 ate one meal, had enough for a second, and still had leftovers to make lunches. Definitely going back. read more

Pizza is average, garlic knots are awesome. I like that this is one of the few places you can pick up a single slice for a great price!

Always have had delicious food from Mamma Mia's! we use to order for work a lot and they were always prompt and food was great!

Great food if you like it delivered cold, at best luke warm. This is the third time in the past 3 months we have had our order delivered cold, including one order of chicken Alfredo. This time the driver delivered without wearing a face mask. As much as we like the food, we will be ordering elsewhere. I have called them all 3 times, but things have not gotten better. Such a shame. read more

Tonight was the first time we tried Mamma Mia's and it won't be the last. Food was really good and seemed really authentic. Happy that a restaurant finally opened close to us with great italian food. Tonight we ordered the pesto linguine, tortellini alfredo and the garlic knots. The pesto sauce was very rich in flavor and very fresh tasting, it also came with seared mushrooms and they were cooked perfect as well. The pasta was cooked al dente which is exactly how i like it. The torts were very fresh and very good as well, the cheese inside tasted very sweet and fresh and had great consistency. The alfredo sauce was also very flavorful and rich. cooked just right. The garlic knots were not to dry but not too doughy. They were also delicious. So far the food was worth it and looking forward to trying other items on the menu. Definintely recommend to others as a choice to check out. read more

Best gluten-free pizza in town. They're regular crust pizzas are great as well. I'm always happy to see a pizzeria carry fresh spinach as a topping too. We've gotten 3 orders from them thus far, all promised that the pizzas would be ready within 20 minutes, and all three times they kept their word. I highly recommend this place to others. read more

The pasta dishes here are outstanding. The garlic dough knots are wonderful. We have eaten the stuffed shells and the fettuccine con gamberetti and both are delicious. The special salad with the sweet vinaigrette is sooo good! The pizza is good. But that is so subjective. Everyone likes their pizza a different way and therefore you get many different opinions. There are people out there who actually like Pizza Hut pizza. We have only tried the pizza twice but will continue to try the specialty pizzas. Have not tried the regular or stuffed crust......yet! We will be back for more! And the staff couldn't be nicer! read more

Ordered the xx thin pizza. Don't bother, I guess they have no idea of what thin crust pizza is. Nothing special here, don't waste your money. A lot better out there in Rockford. read more

I have not yet tried Mama Mia's pizza and I'm not likely to since I have my favorite pizzas and I tend to stick to them. The pasta and sandwiches however? Mama mia! Their pasta is fabulous! I love their Alfredo dishes and the cheese tortellini is to die for. I was distraught that there was no delivery/carryout pasta in town that was better than standard but Mama MIa's is IT. The pasta tastes so fresh and is always cooked perfectly. Oh and the portions are HUGE! You are definitely getting bang for your buck. I don't find them pricey, in fact they are cheaper than Macianos and the food here is far better. Their salads are standard, but fresh and perfect as a side dish. Their sandwiches are HUGE. The Italian beef is wonderful, but probably big enough to split between two people. The staff has always been very friendly to me and the food is always ready within 15 to 20 minutes. read more

Ok pizza. Just added mac'n'cheese pizza which I have respect for because any mac pizza is wonderful in my book. Crust was not my favorite, but was ok. GO MAC'n'CHEESE! read more

We had the Don pizza for our main dish for a party. It was perfect! We had 3 delivered throughout the afternoon. Hot pizza the whole party. So many compliments! read more

Love it! Great staff, great food! The owner is really nice and accommodating, as well as the rest of the staff. I highly recommend the wings, the wraps, the salads, breadstick's (Charlie makes the best), and the pan pizzas. Orders are finished in a timely fashion. They also have specials everyday and a lunch special of a slice and a pop for $3.99. Can't beat it! Glad to have Mamma Mia's in Rockford! Thanks MM's!! read more

Service is ALWAYS great and food usually is too, BUT the taco pizza was not so good. There is absolutely no flavor, very plain and the meat is bland. For the price you pay for the taco pizza, there should be flavors or more toppings to make it taste like a good taco. read more

Great stop. Not a dine in location. Very friendly. Their Italian beef is amazing. Large serving! Their tiramisu is also one of the best in Rockford. read more

We ordered a large regular thin pizza ( they don't offer a pan pizza). The pizza was uninspiring. We ordered a sausage, onion and green pepper pizza. The pizza was okay, nothing exceptional. The crust was a little soggy. The cheese was a little under done, not browned. We will not order there again. read more

We love this place for a Friday night take out when we don't feel like cooking. Have tried pizza and several sandwiches. Everything always fresh and ready on time. They have very nice kitchen with all new equipment. Everything prepared with care and well packaged for the trip home. We live close by so this place is our go to location for carry out. Don't miss the deserts, they are great too. read more

Depending on what you get, the food is decent. The mostaccioli was mediocre at best. And The service is TERRIBLE! I have tried this restaurant three times, and every time something has been wrong. First time, they wouldn't let me order what I wanted, turns out the menu is as is, no changing anything. The next time, they forgot part of my order. The third time, they let me place an order online 45 minutes before the hours posted on their website claimed they close, when I went to go pick it up ten minutes later, the building was locked and my card was still charged... I wouldn't recommend this restaurant to anyone. read more

Well, I gave them another shot and not much has changed since my first stop. The Italian Beef was dry and over cooked. This better change before Portillo's arrives. If not, then the only places for a good beef will be Marino's and Portillo's. read more

I order from Mamma Mia's frequently. I love their pizza...whoever deamed it on the same level as Papa John's is way off. Neither one of my kids like pizza but they both will eat Mamma Mias. The pastas are delicicious. Me and my daughter can order one dinner and have leftovers. I highly recommend them. I love that they have on-line ordering. And a heads up...this is a carry out place not a dine in. read more