Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mandy's Cafe

    4.5 (6 reviews)
    Open 4:00 pm - 8:00 PM

    Mandy's Cafe Photos

    Business Info

    MANDY'S CAFE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    More like Mandy's Cafe

    Recommended Reviews - Mandy's Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Spike S.
    83
    1060
    8855

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Larry H.
    15
    59
    48

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Chris C.
    1
    157
    97

    4 years ago

    The food is always fresh and seasoned well. This is the best place I've eaten in Ponca. The manager and staff are super friendly as well!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Pam H.
    0
    54
    38

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Mandy's Cafe

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Vintage Steakhouse - Mesquite Chicken

    Vintage Steakhouse

    4.1(40 reviews)
    38.7 mi

    Imagine owning a business where you allegedly pay all of your staff under the table so you can…read moreallegedly avoid paying federal taxes, but on top of that, you allegedly don't allow them to clock in/out and you don't allow them access to see or count or question the tips collected daily because you allegedly pool their tips and then YOU tell THEM what they made at the end of each shift. Imagine these servers being college students and single mothers. Also imagine that each one of these servers is on to your alleged theft and deception and they collectively decide they've had enough of you stealing the money THEY earned while you're allegedly putting in a beautiful, brand new pool at your home. Then imagine they allegedly start keeping their own numbers and accounting for their earnings which allegedly do not match up with your VENMO payout each day. Imagine one of them is my 21 year old daughter, who is a college senior and allegedly rallies the entire staff to stand up for themselves and finally question you. Then imagine in the meeting that allegedly every single word was recorded, YOU FIRE HER, after allegedly cussing her out, and refuse to show her, or any of them, your accounting. That's such a wild concept to me! You fired a 21 year old who questioned her earnings because you knew you were caught, Brittany Rupp. As for dining at The Vintage Steakhouse in Morrison, OK, (where the FB reviews are turned off ) I would strongly discourage you from spending your money there.

    Any tips that you give to your servers will not get to them. Its really sad but the owners refuse…read moreto pay servers properly, they dont see any tips at all and have to get paid with venmo. The food is really not all that great either

    Photos
    Vintage Steakhouse - A nice waiting area....but we did not have to wait!

    A nice waiting area....but we did not have to wait!

    Vintage Steakhouse - Rotting salad

    Rotting salad

    Vintage Steakhouse - Ladies' room

    See all

    Ladies' room

    Kat's Steakhouse - Ribeye steak and kat's house potatoes.

    Kat's Steakhouse

    4.5(83 reviews)
    49.9 mi

    This family owned and run restaurant is far and away much more than one would expect to find in a…read morevery small farming community (pop. 300+). Kat greeted us. We chatted with her grandpa who eats there a few times each week. Her banker, farmer, entrepreneur father, who grills the steaks, came out to say hi, too. Other times when we have eaten there, my spouse and I have enjoyed the steaks and various potato preparations; all delicious. Tonight, being Thursday night, we chowed down on Kat's homemade lasagna, asparagus, and house salads. Everything was scrumptious. Our server was very attentive, and we had another wonderful meal. The decor features many authentic photographs that depict life in this small town through the decades. Kat's grandma, bless her soul, captured a sense of understated elegance that makes the restaurant a home away from home.

    We go to Kats steakhouse twice a year only because it's one hour and 20 minutes away. The ribeye…read moresteak was great as usual. Tried the house potatoes with the tremendous salad to start. Wife had the steak kabobs with grilled carrots. We both had leftovers for at least another meal. The owner who also cooks the steaks stopped for a visit. We finish with the cherry cobbler which had ice cream. Everything was excellent. We love the restaurant because it looks classy and unlike other steakhouse is quite so you can talk. The second server was friendly and did a outstanding job.

    Photos
    Kat's Steakhouse - Photo of the place and some cool art work!

    Photo of the place and some cool art work!

    Kat's Steakhouse - Creme Brûlée

    Creme Brûlée

    Kat's Steakhouse - Ribeye, company potatoes, roasted carrots

    See all

    Ribeye, company potatoes, roasted carrots

    Rusty Barrell Supper Club - Filet - potato - mushrooms

    Rusty Barrell Supper Club

    4.1(126 reviews)
    22.6 mi
    $$$

    This was the best steak in NE Oklahoma! An excellent cut of meat cooked to perfection!!…read moreThe staff were very friendly and accommodating. Make a reservation if it's on the weekend; the place is quite popular. C. Pannell

    So I wasn't going to leave a bad review for a place I love so much, but having my leftovers…read moretonight, I just can't believe they would serve a steak like this. I made the grave mistake of ordering the senior ribeye. I mistakenly thought it would be like a regular ribeye cut in half. No it wasn't. I have no idea what this meat was, but it looked like skirt steak. It was 1/6 inch thick. I measured it! I ordered it medium rare which is laughable, because you literally couldn't cook it to anything besides well done because it would take probably 20 seconds to cook. I received this steak after waiting about 50 minutes for our food. My boyfriend on the other hand, ordered a prime rib medium, and his came out not even rare. He couldn't eat it. They did comp the prime rib but we paid for mine. To make all this worse, it was SO HOT upstairs I couldn't stand it. Granted it was very warm that day, but if you get overheated quickly, do not eat upstairs in the summer.I'm afraid this will be the last time we go to my beloved Rusty Barrel. We have celebrated so many occasions there including me and my love's very first date together. I am heartbroken.

    Photos
    Rusty Barrell Supper Club - Upstairs seating area

    Upstairs seating area

    Rusty Barrell Supper Club - 16 oz rib eye loaded bake potato. Yum !!

    16 oz rib eye loaded bake potato. Yum !!

    Rusty Barrell Supper Club - The alley way to get in

    See all

    The alley way to get in

    Frank & Lola's - Chipotle Aioli burger with fries

    Frank & Lola's

    3.9(275 reviews)
    38.1 mi
    $$

    First of all it's loud, which makes it hard to have a conversation with your group. I got over it…read morewith a Mimosa champagne with a splash of orange juice. My brother had the breakfast burrito. His comment was " I feel like I should ask for forgiveness ". He was happy and ashamed he ate all of it in one sitting. I had the burger- it was seasoned so well and not dripping greasy. You know the burger is perfection when you don't need Ketchup or mustard. The cheese grits with two eggs were so delicious but needed a to go box . My favorite brunch dining experience hands down

    I've been told that this is a Bartlesville favorite and I can see why they have that reputation…read more Went for lunch and another customer overheard that it was our first time there, she couldn't help but to interject in excitement and tell us everything that was worth getting on the menu and told us that brunch was a must at this spot. Located in the heart of downtown, this spot has a hometown feel with bikes hanging as decor. Service was nothing short of amazing and helpful, and most importantly the food was AWESOME!!! I ended up getting a chipotle aioli burger with fries. Simple dish but I can't say enough how good everything I had was. If you happen to be in Bartlesville, this is a must stop for lunch, dinner, or a weekend brunch. Almost forgot... Homemade ranch was delicious. I judge very critically in this area which will make or break a review.

    Photos
    Frank & Lola's - Interior sitting at the bar

    Interior sitting at the bar

    Frank & Lola's - Pico Burger

    Pico Burger

    Frank & Lola's - Kitchen view

    See all

    Kitchen view

    Sterlings Grille - 8 ounce filet mignon with sweet potato

    Sterlings Grille

    3.7(60 reviews)
    39.7 mi
    $$

    I'm so thankful Sterlings offers gluten free food. It's not marked on their menu but many things…read moreare already or can be made GF. I've tried all of their steaks (including the bison), the salmon and shrimp. I have 2 favorites the salmon and the filet. The salmon is absolutely perfect every time and the sauce that is on the salmon takes it to another level. DE-LI-CIOS! Tonight I ordered the filet with a baked potato and green beans - to go. The steak was cooked to perfection and was loaded with flavor. I'm not one to go on about green beans but let me explain...they're cooked the old school way with onions, bacon, and spices, mmm, mmm. I will agree with some of the reviews, there are times when a steak's flavor is not what I expect BUT most of the time (like tonight even ordered to go) it's very good. No reactions here! If you need to order GF and have questions just ask one of the kind and helpful wait staff. The majority of them have been working there for years and can answer all questions you may have. We have a great experience every time we go or order to go. (By the way, My husband loves their burgers!)

    Came in on Saturday night. No one was at the hostess area. After a bit someone stopped and was…read moreasked if we had reservations. I said that we did not and after looking on the Facebook page and website we did not see anything saying we needed them. She then stated to us "that you can't just walk in". I explained we didn't see anywhere to make reservations and she said it was on the Facebook page. I continued to look and never found it. It would have been better to just tell us they had no availability instead of scolding us and being rude. They were not very busy and there were at least 10 empty tables. Very unprofessional behavior on her part. We should have left but she sat us in the bar area, which was fine. Our order was taken quickly and we received our salads however no silverware. She brought that to us with the main dishes which were good but not what we ordered. When I sent mine back(she admitted the mistake was her fault) the wait for the new dish was almost 30 mins. By then my husband was finished so we paid our check and left. Additionally we ordered an appetizer that we never received. Our waitress then said she had bought my dinner because of her mistake. Long story short, what we did receive to eat was good but not worth the treatment and hassle. Will not be making a reservation to go back.

    Photos
    Sterlings Grille - Chicken piccata

    Chicken piccata

    Sterlings Grille - My 'to go' order: Filet, Delightful Old School Green Beans and a Baked Potato - KAPOW!

    My 'to go' order: Filet, Delightful Old School Green Beans and a Baked Potato - KAPOW!

    Sterlings Grille - Apple pie with shortbread crust

    See all

    Apple pie with shortbread crust

    Mandy's Cafe - steak - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...