Great service super nice and accommodating, aswell as super sweet and genuine. I could say I genuinely felt at home here

So I went into marble slab, chose a design in the book and paid $50 for a cookie cake. Came back two hours later and when we received it, it was the complete wrong design. We took the cookie cake back to the store and told them this and they did not care and refused to remake the cake saying that the design number in the book is different than the one online, which means update your books in the store, idk why that's our fault? So now my friend has a random cake on his birthday. Wasn't going to write this until they completely dismissed me and my friends and gave us attitude. read more

Marble Slab Creamery - The wrong cake‍ - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

Excellent service! If there ever training needed for what customer service should look like, this is the place. From offering several samples to blowing up balloons for kids in the store, it truly was a great experience. Ice cream was delicious as well! read more

First visit to this location and it was awful! The young man that first helped us was great but the manager was horrible! She's rude and does not offer acceptable solutions to issues. The ice cream was great but the cookies were old and stale. We spent almost $25 for this experience. Too many other places to choose from. read more

Worst ice cream I've ever had literally don't recommend at all I went I had 3 bites through it out my car.

Online says they close at 10pm when I arrive at 9:15 the sign says they close at 9:30 but they are already closed. Poor customer service just to get off work a few minutes early. read more

The ice cream was delicious and the vibe was nice but the tipping policy is completely unacceptable. The manager receives the tips online and from the tip jar so I have to tip the employees directly. The manager needs to be reviewed and I will never been tipping here again unless directly to the employees. read more

DO NOT ORDER HERE! I received the WORST customer service from the Manager of the store. Our company placed an order for some ice creams as an afternoon treat at 11am, for delivery at 1:30pm to our office. 1:45pm comes around and I call to check on the order, the girl working said they didn't receive our order at all through the website but that her manager would be back at in 10 mins and would give me a call. The young girl calls back and says our order was ready in the fridge but that there were no delivery drivers to pick it up and I would have to go pick it up. I let her know that I paid for delivery and tip through their website and she is saying there is nothing they can do about refunding that because it is a 3rd party they use. She is then talking back and forth with the manager to relay information to me. I finally ask to get the manager on the phone and she says that a driver just got there and that our order is being delivered. It doesn't stop here as a happy ending..... When the delivery driver comes to deliver our order we had one ice cream missing. I call the store to speak to the manager and she was NOT apologetic either time with our order being delayed or missing one of our ice creams. She was very RUDE the whole time and not Manager material and setting an example for her workers who are hearing her talk on the phone. Instead of being professional and asking me to please hold to check her receipt she right away tells me "NO, I was the one who made your order there isn't one missing". I have to tell her "Yes, I only have 4". She then checks some paper and finally realized she did miss one of orders. She then tells me that I would have to get a refund through Uber because they delivered it eventhough I ordered through the Great American Cookie website. I ask her how and get a little frustrated that I would have to go through this whole process of getting a refund when it was her fault from the beginning. I then begin to tell her that the customer service I received from her was not great and she never was apologetic about any of this situation. She then tells me that she did apologize and to have a great day and hangs up on me. I tried getting a refund through the Uber app as she said but am unable to since I didn't place the order on the app and went through their website. I have not had Marble Slab ice cream in a very long time and was so excited for this afternoon treat but it turned into the WORST experience and will NEVER come back again. I have reached out to corporate about this and hope they do something about the manager there. read more

Ordered a small cup of butter pecan with chocolate chips & caramel. Watching the server prepare it literally turned to mush with less firmness of a milkshake. She tried to scoop it up put in the cup & the mush wouldn't even stay on the spatula, she used her gloved finger to push it on & pour it the cup. She didn't offer to try again but instead nervously handed it to me trying not to spill the full cup. No concession was made by either the server or cashier to make up for this abysmal excuse for ice cream. Will never go here again! read more

Marble Slab Creamery - Melted butter pecan mush - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

Yummy ice cream, nice employees, what's not to like! Despite the other reviews, we had a good experience.

I was excited when I saw they had great American cookie company added to the sign. Those cookies at the mall are usually really good. But these that we got from here tasted seriously awful, we had to throw them away. Also, they are never open according to their posted hours, we had tried to go many other times with no luck. Maybe the ice cream is better? read more

Loved the ice cream, service was ok. But understand how this place could have such bad reviews like this place was great in my opinion.

Gotta say this place came in to save the day for a birthday cake. The other ice cream cake place had some kinda preschool field trip there so getting in line was a no go. These guys were able to mark my cake how I wanted and had a decent selection! My only gripe is the shopping center that it's in is pretty annoying to get into read more

I ordered a milkshake and it was the consistency of eggnog. I do not recommend going here.

Some of the worst customer service I have ever received. Ordered 2 cookie cake slices and was made fun on by the employee working for requesting the cookie cake slices with a pumpkin and broom on them... I proceeded to pay in cash and was told she was going to have to give me $3 dollars in quarters because she didn't have time to get more cash in the back when there was only one other customer waiting in line. read more

Horrible and the associate sitting on the counter confirmed the "overall negative impression" I had upon entering.

Worst customer service ever!!! We walked in as one of the employees were sitting on their phone. While ai was telling her my flavors she was not giving me a chance to put any add ons and by the time she started to hand me the cup she asked did you not want any topping. I responded well you didnt give me a chance to tell what I wanted and all the flavors were mixed so it messed up the whole thing. Worse $9 ice cream ever!!! read more

So the new owners just raised the price of a quart of ice cream from $9 to $14. Folks that's a 50% increase. At this rate, a gallon will set you back $52. Idk about you, but it better have 24K gold flakes in it for that. Keep driving. There's lots of other choices for ice cream in San Marcos. read more

Showed up at 9pm. Sign says open until 10pm. They told us they were closed and closed at 9pm. Told them your sign says 10pm. They just shrugged their shoulders and wouldn't serve us. read more

Every time I visit, it never fails, I'm greeted with warm welcoming smiles from the employees. The ice cream is pricey compared to other ice cream shops but it is well worth it. And free unlimited mix ins.. What more could one ask for? Also if you are a frequent visitor, such as myself, you should definitely be part of their rewards program. After so many accumulated points you get coupons! Who doesn't love coupons? read more

Felix had a bit if an attitude. Overall it was an ok exserpense, the ice cream is awsome even though it was crap selection. They where out of almost all the flavors. read more

Always something with this place. Closing early, not open at all, out of this out of that. Go to Rhea's instead. Never once have I had a good experience here. read more

The employees are lacking customer service. The gentlemen was waving his hand at me to get my attention just seconds after the lady had taken my order. He wanted to cash me out ASAP and it was very apparent. I didn't appreciate it and the ice cream was poorly mixed. The experience was very bad read more

Marble Slab Creamery - a hand holding a bowl of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

I read the reviews here before trying them out, I was a bit sketch since there were many bad ones. I lived at the UC for a while and when I craved ice cream I thought about this place but never really had the guts to try them out. Well, one day my bf and I really wanted some ice cream so we decided to try it out. We ended up just getting a banana split since we were very undecided on what to get with all the condiment options. Well, as soon as we payed and got our banana split we ended up finding a hair in it! . I know it was not his nor mine since it was long brown and thin. He immediately returned it. Now i see why the whole bad reviews happened. read more

I showed up at 8:40 tonight because on Apple Maps it says 11. On the door is says closes at 9, I was like ooh ok 20 minutes till close I'll just go in and get something quick. No the door was locked 20 minutes early. There was a worker in there cleaning and wouldn't even look up when she heard me try to open the door. Won't be returning. read more

I wouldn't know what the ice cream taste like bc they close 35mins early. Literally customers in the store. Try to open door and they just say no. read more

This place is just gross. I've been her twice in the past 2 years with different workers each time and they are unprofessional every time. The first time we had to step behind the counter and get the guy in the back to help us bc he was sitting on his phone with his earphones in and he didn't hear us Also the uncleanliness is just unacceptable. I worked at a marble slab for my first job so I thought it was just me thinking what mine looked like but then when we got in the car my boyfriend said it was so dirty in there. i suggest another location read more

The personal was amazing! We really enjoyed this place!! My friends had so many topins to choose from that was hard to decide what to put in the ice cream read more

Very unwelcoming atmosphere. Long line and the workers were preparing the ice cream at an incredibly slow pace. They were completely incapable of scooping and mixing in the ingredients, resulting in completely melted ice cream. Trouble deciding if they weren't trained or they just didn't give a crap. It tasted all right but it was basically a sloppy ice cream soup. Also there were broken cones and napkins all over, counters needed cleaning. Eating ice cream out is too expensive to be playing around like that. read more

Love the ice cream but the workers make you want to not go back. They act like they hate their job and are very unwelcoming.

Employee wiped her nose with her bare hands then, proceeded to scoop ice cream. The ice cream scoop hadn't been cleaned between flavors. The ice cream cooler was Filthy! The waffle cones were even wilted over. Health inspector needs to go here asap read more

My eyes are always way bigger than my stomach. Their praline ice cream is my favorite. The girls who work there are nice enough but they're always talking and not exactly working, not that that matters much in an ice cream shop. Their bathrooms are decent and mostly clean. I wish there were tables outside so you could take your desert out on a nice day. Oh, and although they're a chain and this is expected, they're really pricey. 7 bucks for a cup. Yeiks! Worth it? Yeah, I guess so. read more

Marble Slab Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

Really fantastic ice cream but, they definitely mix the ice cream on a granite slab. I was expecting some Calcutta but, I'll recover. Ice cream definitely would've stayed colder if it was marble. read more

We ordered a sundae and a banana split online and paid. When we went to pick it up, it wasn't ready as they didn't know about online orders. The banana split had zero toppings just the ice cream and whipped cream and cherry. They did not fix it to go, just handed both to us. read more

I have visited once a week for the past month and the inventory is non existent. The freezers are empty, maybe five flavors to choose from. And everytime all they say is we are under new management and "I'm sorry". I hope this place closes down so maybe someone with some experience in running a business could open it back up properly. read more

Just wanted to say we saw the post that was posted by a young lady 6 or 8 days ago. they have the nerve to post that,they stood by the trash can and the ice cream cake freezer then they went outside one throw her cup in the trashcan an the other girl kept eating her ice cream there were 8 of us sitting at all the tables an a lady with her 2 children eating ice cream .. we hear the girl tell one young lady working that they found a bug in the ice cream so she called the asst.manager or manager she asked her if she wanted another ice cream or a refund She said no she just wanted to let them know that they found a bug .if they did find one they should of taken it back .An we all know Asst manager would of refunded their money back ,. They kept eating the ice cream..Besides we have been going there for awhile it's always super clean an the asst manager an employee they are nice .the asst manager she's always smiling and joking with us .plus when there's a child she goes out an jokes with them . read more

The young man working behind the counter on 10/9/17 in the afternoon had already served my family unenthusiastically but to put the cherry on top. While making dipped waffle cones he got chocolate on his finger then licked/sucked it off and continued handling cones. C'mon man... read more

Very poor I expected a lot and me and friends visited this place service is good but very limited flavors and by the time we went they almost ran out of so many flavors it's on Sunday 4 pm . We totally did satisfied . I won't recommend this place to any one read more

The ice cream I have to say was yummy, because who can mess up ice cream? Before I ordered I asked to sample the birthday cake and the worker seemed less than amused. She gave me the sample without a word and just looked at me blankly. My friend ordered her ice cream which was the same as I ordered except she got snickers. I got a small adult (2 scoops) of sweet cream, Reese's chunks, and hot fudge. When the worker handed my friend her ice cream, ice cream fell out of her cup onto the counter and my friend had to clean up the mess. She did the same with mine as well. The worker said nothing about it and didn't offer to clean it up. When checking out my friend and I had to grab 5+ napkins to clean our hands and cups from ice cream falling everywhere. She didn't say "sorry" or anything. She gave us the receipt and went. This is a place to make people happy. Having a sour attitude does not make people happy. read more

Marble Slab Creamery - The mess of ice cream that I was given. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - San Marcos, Texas

I will say that before closing to remodel I don't recall ever having a bad experience here. I've visited very frequently and it was my go to ice cream spot in town. But since the remodel coming back, I have had nothing but terrible experiences. The first time was when I showed up at 8 o'clock and all of the lights were off and the open sign was off. I told my husband that was weird because the door said they closed at 10. He open the door to find out they were in fact open, but we're just hoping that no one else would come for the rest of the night? If you want your business to be closed at eight, close the business at eight. fast forward to last night we went in at seven, and had the worst experience with the employee. First, when taking my order the employee seemed completely uninterested in listening to me. As he's making my order he grabs a waffle cone bowl after I had ordered a cone that you hold in your hand and asks me how many scoops did I say that I wanted. I politely responded that I only wanted one scoop and I actually wanted it in one of those cones, and pointed to the cone. He turned around and looked at the mini cones that were sitting there mumbled something and then continued to put the ice cream in the bowl. He had his headphones in his ear the entire time while serving me, so it's no wonder he couldn't hear me or maybe he just really could care less. They handed me and my husband our ice cream at the same time and they were both already a soup like consistency, my husband was melted so much already that it was coming out of the bowl dripping everywhere. Since when is the slab of marble not frozen enough to keep the ice cream cold? Why are you handing me a $10 ice cream that is melted soup in my cup? Completely unacceptable and just really disappointing. We won hundred percent will not ever go back to the store. So awful. It's so disappointing when a business goes from being your complete favorite in the town to the absolute worst. As I read the rest of these reviews, I see that I am not alone in my experience. I have never left a review like this in my life, much less a one star review so that should say something. read more