decent pizza, not a bad place to get your fix. I wouldn't say anything sticks out above average. Owner was at the front, really friendly guy. read more

Amazing Pizza. Good fresh toppings. Crust is good. Love it. Highly recommended. Owner cares about his business and willing to satisfy all of his clients. He personally delivered my pizza due to living in a brand new development. read more

We found these guys quite some time ago... We moved to El Mirage in 2006 and found these guys a few years later. Been our favorite since.

They have really good pepperoni pizza and wings.... but I don't know about the other toppings. I was really craving a meatball pizza the other day and ordered one from Mario's. It had a meatball flavor but the mystery meat chopped up on top of the pizza did not seem like meatballs. It was interesting but personally I probably will stick to pepperoni. read more

The pizza and wings are delicious ! I'm so happy to have found a spot right next to my job! They have great lunch specials and they deliver too. They are always super friendly. I recommend 10/10! read more

Pretty good. Not gonna lie. Got a marios special medium and jalapeño poppers. Jalapeño poppers are delicious. Pizza was mediocre but very well priced. read more

First time eating their pizza and wings and I am glad I've tried it. Pizza was very good the crust was perfect not too soft with a bit of a crunch. We ordered a plain cheese pizza and my kids loved it. The wings are good and a good price. The menu on their website doesn't work so it's hard to figure out what to order. The only menu you can see online is their specials and that's what we ordered since we couldn't see the rest of the menu. I plan on making this our new pizza place from now on. read more

Ordered a pepperoni pizza slice, once I got someone's attention at the counter. What I got was a previously made cheese pizza slice with pepperoni and a scattering of cheese reheated. Super greasy and cardboard taste. Sticky table. Will not eat here again. read more

My weakness after a long day of work is definitely is Mario's Pizza . They create pizzas as an art and the way they cook their flour gives a greater harmony with the sauces they use. They are super friendly and prices aren't bad. Even their cheese pizzas take you on an adventure . P.S. After writing this review, I am more than likely to order their pizza after imagining its deliciousness and it is only 9 a.m.... read more

Our family does enjoy Mario's. If you stick with cheese and pepperoni pizza you will probably be alright. Their honey hot wings are also good. This time we ordered a Mario's Special pizza (supreme) they obviously hastily through extra toppings on an already made pepperoni pizza and folded the crust so it would fit in the box. This particular pizza was awful, we just threw it away. read more

Mario's Pizza - Mario's Mario's House Special Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - El Mirage, Arizona

See all

We avoided this place, for the first few months after it opened, just because it is hard to make a left out of the plaza that it sits in. Mistake! I really like the NY style pizza (by NY style, I mean crust is neither really thin nor really thick, really tasty sauce use sparingly, and lots of cheese), and just love their wings - nice and vinegary, with as much heat as I want or don't want. The service is always pretty fast, the restaurant is spanking clean, and there are big, flat panels hung around the place... and there's always a game on. They were running good pitcher specials, whenever the Suns played. I've not had their Sicilian style, sandwiches or pasta dishes, but from watching other patrons enjoy them, they must be good! The most expensive item is NY style steak pizza or a specialty Sicilian, around $18, and a pitcher of beer is about $7-8. Wings run about $6 (10 piece) to $15 (30), and they do have an everyday special - the usual large pizza and 20 wings for under $20. I recommend this place, for the locals. Time to dump Domino's, Pizza Hut, and Papa John's... this is a local business that is worth supporting! read more

Just moved to the area and we looked up the highest rated pizza place near us to get a pizza delivered. This was a terrible idea. The pizza got here quickly but that is the last good thing I can say. We got the Mario's House Pizza but were really disappointed by the toppings. The crust is nice but canned mushrooms? That is nasty! The sausage is shaved so thin you can see through it and the sauce is just bland as can be. I have only thrown out one pizza in my life until this. Now it's two. If this is the best pizza around then we may be in trouble. The fried zucchini was pretty good I have to say. Not much of a meal after a long day of moving but it's always nice to end a review with something nice to say. read more

I'm from NY, Mario is from NY. Pizza is really good but this weekend when I went with my family I decided to change it up and ordered a hot chicken parm hero. It took me back man, circa 1987 in Manhattan working a late night. One of the best pizza joints in the Phoenix area. If you don't like them, eh, go somewhere else. LOL. read more

I love love love Mario's! I've only ever had pizza and wings (and beer of course) but delivery or dine in, it's great! The crust on the pizza is perfect and they have great deals, too. The owner (Mario) is pretty much always there and he's a nice, friendly guy. I would have given 5 stars, but last time we ordered wings they were TINY! I was super disappointed because I love their wings so much and usually they are a pretty good size. All in all, this is my favorite pizza place. Forget Pizza Hut and Dominos! read more

They deliver, so I had to give 'em a try :) It was actually difficult finding their on-line menu or website, so I called them to ask for it. (http://mariospizzeria.weebly.com) They don't have small pizzas, but they do sell pizza by the slice. I ordered a medium Hawaiian pizza & a small order of hot wings. The pizza was ok. The wings were small, but they were decent. Neither was anything I could really rave about. The delivery time was 1 1/2 hours. They did tell me ahead of time that they couldn't get it to me before then. I agreed because I wanted to see if it was all that & a bag of chips. Not all that & no chips :( read more

Mario's is still great but still only getting 4/5 because - Soda: Still iffy on the carbonation Sicilian: Not the best I have ever had Jal O Peno Popers: Are FANTASTIC The NY style pizza is still in my top 2 of all time so do not pass Mario's by just because of a couple short comings. read more

I loved the food and the pizza and the rest of Mario's Check the you web site mariospizzaelmirage.net read more

I just moved to the area and was looking for a good pizza joint. I ordered pizza and a salad and it was awesome. When I walked in both the lady at the counter and the guy making the pizzas greeted me. He was preparing dough as I walked in so you know the pizzas are fresh. Highly recommend this place. I will be back. read more

some of the best pizza i've ever had. genuinely, SO good. and it got to us fast too! only took about 25 minutes to get 2 giant sized pizzas. 100/10 recommend you stop by this place. read more

as local pizza goes this place kicks the pants off of chain pizza places. yea the decor is dated and the place doesn't impress visually, but last i checked pizza should taste good! i love their crust, their sauce, their cheese, and the way their pizza reminds me of east coast yumminess! the staff isn't the chattiest staff, but they make your food fast and bring it to your table. they are polite and that's all that matters to me. i don't want chit chat. i want to stuff my face with your greasy delicious pizza! the pizza is so good my 13 yr old will actually offer to buy the whole family dinner with his saved money if i take them to marios. when a 13 yr old will part with cash just so he can eat pizza you know it's good! the wings are decent, the pizza is great with generous toppings, and the sandwiches are yummy too. the kids love the french fries, but i don't think you can mess up fries :P read more

This was our first time trying Mario's. We had the pepperoni pizza, chicken Alfredo, baked ziti, side of meatballs and salad. Everything was delicious and fresh. The marinara sauce was amazing. I can't wait to try the other menu items. read more

I hate to write this review--I don't want anyone else to know how good this place is, because then I might have to wait longer for my order! I love pizza, which is odd, since I've worked in pizza restaurants for over 15 years, off and on. The pizza I love more than any other? Mario's! Mario's pizza starts with a crust that's excellent. it's never over-worked, too sweet or too yeasty. It's a perfect, chewy, crunchy base. The meats on Mario's pizzas are excellent. I've never had a better all-meat pizza! And there's just enough gooey cheese to hold it all together. My suggestion is you ask for a side of the marinara to smother your crusts in. There are chunks of tomato, subtle spices--not too sweet and not too spicy--and I'll fight anyone for the last bit in the bowl. The best part about Mario's is the feeling you get when you're there. The staff is friendly, welcoming and just flat-out nice. I usually don't put tips in the tip jar when I just get a carry out meal, but I always do at Mario's. That's the kind of place it is. Give Mario's a try...and then add the number to your speed dial list. It's just that good. read more

I live near here and have come around a few times for dinner. Overall, the pizza quality is great! Really great tasting pizza here in that New York style. The wings are decent, but aren't anything to brag about. However, no complaints there. The inside of the restaurant is in need of a makeover. The inside has that "run down" feeling to it. Some of the chairs and tables need replaced/fixed. Additionally, the people at the counter aren't exactly the nicest. Every time I've been here, it's usually, "What can I get you?" I can't say I have ever made small talk with the counter help, which is rare given my outgoing nature. This usually leads to that awkward meal where you and a few friends eat, but feel uneasy about staying in the restaurant. All-in-all: The food is great and is what will make you return; the price is above average (think Papa John's pricing); and the counter help could use a personality change. read more

Again, I gotta hype the (good) local shops and this is as local as it gets as it's within biking distance. I started coming into Mario's right after they opened and haven't been disappointed yet. Whether you order a whole pie or by the slice, their pizza kicks ass. Like most pizzerias, they give you more bang for your buck and are usually cheaper than most places that deliver. Every time I've been there, Mario is behind the counter and always greets me. I get the feeling that members of his family work there as well including his wife. Bottom line: Mario's is my first choice for pizza because of quality, price, location, and the people who run it. read more

Ordered pizza again and again perfection.One of my kids actually fought over the last piece for school,I lost.The cheese is awesome ,crust,perfect,great job guys. read more

My families Favorite Pizza place. We are from NY and struggled to find a NY Style pizza we liked as much as the ones we got at home. Others in the area aren't bad.....but not as close as we liked. We discovered Mario's 10 years ago and have been there at least once a week ever since. Prices are great, pizza is excellent and if you want some sandwiches/subs or other things like Calzones, Pasta dishes, etc...they have them too. I love the WINGS.....simple and effective. Just like home! Adrian and Destiny are wonderful at the front counter and "Dad" in the back is always cooking away! Did I mention the beer is ICE COLD.......Try the garlic pizza too! It's awesome! read more

New favorite pizza place! We got the pizza and wing special with pepperoni pizza and it was amazing. Crunchy chewy crust, perfect amount of sauce and the topping were amazing. The wing were very good to. Definitely will order again and will recommend to everyone read more

Good food. Huge lasagne! It could be more flavorful- it's a bit bland imo but it's good & you get generous portions. Nice folks there too.

amazing pizza and super nice people there. me and the family go here often and the pizza makes for good leftovers the next day!

Súper friendly service, great food and nice atmosphere. Perfect for our large group to be accommodated while still being able to distance and keep Covid rules followed. Staff was awesome from start to finish! Good pizza and wings! We will be back! read more

I ordered a medium sausage, green pepper and onion pizza for delivery. When it arrived, the pizza was lukewarm and the vegetables were actually cold like they were in the refrigerator. The pizza crust was delicious, but the sausage was very thin and flavorless. There was not enough cheese and sauce. The overall price was reasonable (no delivery charge) but I will not order again. read more

Slice, the site the Mario's goes through for delivery there's a spot where you fill in your address and it kept auto populating the wrong address. I tried fixing it multiple times it wouldn't do it, so I even left a note in their "direction section" saying that it was El Mirage not surprise. They called me basically acting like it was my fault even though their website can't even put in the correct address so I will never be ordering from them again because they were very rude on the phone. Also their pizza is mediocre and tastes like a lesser version of Peter Piper Pizza. read more

Stopped in first time last week and LOVEDDDDD IT! This will be my second time eating from Mario's and it's delivery this time. Hoping for another delicious pizza & wings (first time trying) read more

Our Men's 55s tennis team from Dallas came here 3 nights in a row during Nationals.. Super nice friendly owners and employees and great food for the price. Marinara sauce was delicious on the Meatball Sub and Spaghetti and Meatballs. All 8 of us enjoyed our dishes. One guy got the stromboli 3 nights in a row. Thank you Mario's!!! Hope to see you next year. read more

If your looking for a place to bring your family this is the spot. The food was great but the service went way above and beyond.

Best service we've had in a long time!! Great place to get out of the heat on a tournament weekend, accommodated our large group, fast & tasty. Good food, beer on tap, games on tv & awesome service. We'll be back for sure!! Thank you!! read more

We showed up with our baseball team without notice. They rocked it! Food was awesome and so was the service!

We are from out of time and needed a pizza place that delivered. The pizza was great (I'm from NJ and this pizza is almost as good as home). Delivery was fast and our order was correct. Reasonably priced and great food. read more

Tucked away in a the back of commercial complex. Always good service and fantastic New York style pizza. Fast delivery.

This is our go to pizza spot. The pizza great and warm. The only downside is that they charge 5$ for a cannoli, idk if that's normal but it wasn't worth it due to the fact that it tasted like it had been sitting there. Either than that, they're awesome. read more