Passed by this place so many times and heard great things about it so we were pretty excited to stop for some ice cream. I got the chocolate chocolate chip and banana chip with marshmallow sauce. Honestly wasn't impressed. I was expecting it to be fabulous! The chocolate was good but the mini chips in it were like plastic chocolate. Really hard and didn't have much taste. The banana ice cream had chocolate shavings that were definitely a better quality of chocolate but the banana was harsh and very artificial tasting. I was sad that it didn't live up to the hype. The marshmallow sauce was good! Ok lesson learned on to the next ice cream place! read more

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar - Chocolate chocolate chip with marshmallow sauce - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Massapequa, New York

I cannot says enough positive things about this place! Love the ice cream and the people. I, like many, come a distance to get here and it NEVER disappoints. The ice cream tastes fresh every time because it is. All our family occasions have a cake involved and Marshall's is where it comes from. Soft serve, shakes, sundaes, cakes...all the best! I've watch most of the ladies behind the counter grow up and everyone is so nice! Almost always a crowd but it moves along ...and it's worth the wait anyway! In the summer, you can sit outside or just enjoy you ice cream in the car. This is the ice cream place you NEED to go to! read more

We were hoping to end the night on a sweet note after a so-so dinner -- and Marshall's Ice Cream Bar in Massapequa seemed like the place to do it. Quick side note: why are there so few proper soft serve spots on Long Island? Anyway, we made the 20-minute drive from Huntington, and when we pulled up and saw the place buzzing, I took it as a good sign. Parking is a bit of a challenge -- the lot is tight and feels like a Rubik's Cube, so be prepared to maneuver. Atmosphere: Classic old-school ice cream stand. No frills, exactly what you'd expect and want from a place like this. Service: Handled by a crew of young employees who were efficient and friendly. No complaints there. That said, the setup could use some attention. There's no visible menu outside while you're waiting, so unless you're already familiar, you walk in and freeze (pun intended) while trying to figure out what to order. The menu is also a bit complicated -- which slows things down for everyone, and some of the custom items take a long time to make. It's giving a bit of Starbucks energy: too many options + too many customizations = a jammed-up line. Add to that a poor exit flow -- the exit door is directly in the middle, right where people are waiting for their orders -- and it all feels more chaotic than it needs to be. Now, let's talk about the soft serve -- which is where my rating really lands. It was the Thursday before Father's Day weekend, and in addition to serving walk-in customers, they were actively making ice cream cakes (likely a nod to the Carvel legacy in the area -- anyone remember the "Whale of a Dad" cake?). The problem? Drawing that much soft serve in such rapid succession can affect both texture and flavor. When soft serve is overdrawn, it can come out too soft, melt too quickly, and lack the proper "overrun" -- that's the air that gives it its signature fluff and flavor intensity. The result is something that doesn't quite hold its shape and tastes a bit flat. If cakes need to be made in volume, I'd suggest doing so during off-hours to keep product quality consistent during peak service. I ordered a Raspberry and Pistachio twist, which was a fun and unusual combo that actually worked flavor-wise. But the consistency was way too soft -- I had to eat it at lightning speed, and even then, I was wearing more of it than I'd like. Definitely a "needs-wet-wipes" situation. Was it bad? No. Was it the best? Definitely not. Would I go back? Absolutely. There's potential here, and I'd be curious to try it again on a slower night when the machines aren't being pushed to the limit. Sometimes timing makes all the difference. read more

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar - Raspberry-Pistachio Twist - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Massapequa, New York

See all

You know how they say good things come in small packages? That pretty much sums up the soft serve here--absolutely delicious. I always stick with chocolate or the chocolate-vanilla swirl. The only downside is the staff can be a bit uptight, especially when it's busy. Try to go during off-hours for a better experience. read more

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Massapequa, New York

A premier ice cream shop located adjacent to All American in Massapequa, Marshalls delivers a satisfying ice cream experience. With an elaborate -but not overwhelming - amount of ice creams to choose from, I was in the search of a flavorful soft ice cream and landed one with a pistachio soft ice cream cone. Other members in my group ordered hard ice cream and milkshakes and everything was tasteful in adequate portions and reasonable cost. Quick service by a team of young staff, I was in-and-out of Marshall's in 5 minutes. The ambiance is limited with very few places to sit after making your purchase and wish more welcoming but overall good experience and a spot I will certainly add to my rotation. read more

Very disappointed in the portion you receive. When you order a cup of icecream at least have it so it goes above the cup line. This is the second time this has happened to us and our friends. They weigh it too. The portion felt like a taste sample other icecream stores give you if you want to try a flavor. That's how small it was. They are cutting back on their servings so much but not their prices. Won't be going back nor will our friends. read more

From a quick stop for a cone or shake to the occasional cake for a celebration this place checks all the boxes. Fresh, soft, creamy ice cream. Helpful accommodating staff. read more

I was actually trying to go to the hamburger spot next door and saw this spot when looking for parking. There was a long line for the hamburger spot so I figured I'd get a small thing of ice cream to eat while we waited. I came here on a Saturday evening around 6pm and parking was hard to find. However, there was always someone leaving the lot. There was no line for ice cream and staff was friendly. Credit cards are accepted. I decided on a small cup of soft serve chocolate ice cream (~$4) which was a good amount for one person. Full of flavor and very creamy. I would definitely return to try other menu items! read more

We wanted some ice cream so we decided to try it. My son got a small shake which looked more like a large. He enjoyed that. We got soft and hard serve in cones and cup. It's extremely cold inside but the service is prompt and friendly. Prices are very reasonable so I would return when nearby. read more

I came here last night and it was good. I had a chocolate and vanilla twist in a cup with Oreo crumbles. The service was nice friendly and fast. I would recommend it if you are in the area. The swirl was good a basic taste and the portion was generous. There are seats outside where you can eat your ice cream. read more

Three stars for a $7 modestly sized medium cup of chocolate peanut butter hard ice cream, without much peanut butter to be found. Maybe soft served is their thing. Not sure Id go back to try unless others were going. read more

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar - Medium cup - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Massapequa, New York

Marshall's ice cream bar on corner of 107 and Merrick Rd in Massapequa a landmark place with all kinds of ice cream served all kinds of ways and in the front freezer pick and choose to go. Standardly good. Nice young girls ( with long pretty tied back hair) serving the line of customers. Open late and a place to stop and get a yummy snack. read more

See all

Purchased an ice cream cake for Mother's Day. I definitely think it's better than Carvel for about the same price (which means it's a little on the pricey side). But nevertheless, the girls behind the counter are friendly and courteous while working the butts off. read more

Clean store. Super nice staff. Budget friendly ice cream shop with super basic options. Didn't see anything lush or sumptuous. It all looked fresh. Went with cookie crunch vanilla and hot fudge. A bit more wet than flavorful. Nice place for families with kids. read more

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar - Marshall's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Massapequa, New York

See all

We have been going to Marshall's for upwards of 50 years. The ice cream can't be beat (have you tried the pistachio??) and the customer service is second to none. Mr. Marshall is such a kind man and is very patient with my cake orders. I love peanut butter and they have the best peanut butter topping anywhere. If you see a line outside, it's worth the wait. Be patient and know that this family run operation is obviously run with heart. read more

It's good ice cream tastes like carvel and over priced . I don't feel you get enough quantity for what you spend

Honestly was really disappointed by how bland their classic flavors were but at least their staff is nice read more

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar - a person holding a cone of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Massapequa, New York

It's not bad. It's gotten more pricer recently and may no longer be worth the money. If you're someone who's lactose intolerant or prone to allergies or whatever, you may want to consider going elsewhere. I get a reaction everytime I go there but do not with other places. read more

Service, no big deal, friendly girl, BUT, apparently it's been there forever, I really don't see the big deal, got a small soft serve, just to rim of cup, fine, I don't need to eat more, taste, totally nothing special and especially for the amount and price... I'm not a big ice cream eater, but when I indulge I want good rich flavor and I want a full cup !!! read more

When in Massapequa there are two 'Must Do' things to do. First is All American Burger. And next is right across the parking lot, Marshall's Ice Cream. Best I've cream in town with the same nostalgic fee as AAB. read more

Open Air Drug Market in the making. Marshall's used to be a good place for families to come by and get some ice cream. Now, however, there is always an ever-present smell of marijuana in the parking lot starting in the afternoon. There are clearly deals for "recreational and stimulative" ingestibles going on all over in the parking lot shared with "All American" burgers. Very sad what's become of the place. Used to be a 5-star spot. read more

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar - Fit a small ice cream in a large serving! Clever cheapskates... - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Massapequa, New York

After you've had a great burger at All American, what makes an excellent nightcap is to walk 50 feet to the opposite side of the parking lot to grab a scoop from Marshall's. The shop has about 10-15 flavors on rotation as well as their own ice cream sandwiches for you to choose from. While not the largest selection, what they do have is excellent. The ice cream seems to be homemade so you definitely get the quality. Tried the spumoni and it didn't disappoint. There were bits of chocolate and cherry mixed into the ice cream. Prices are really reasonable and its definitely worth a try. Thumbs up. read more

See all

Service was great, quick and friendly. Not many flavors to choose from. Ambiance is ok.

I got the classic vanilla cone with Sprinkles & and ate it way too fast! I got a brainfreeze but it was worth it! read more

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar - a cloudy blue sky - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Massapequa, New York

See all

LOVE LOVE LOVE this place!!! Walked across the parking lot after having All American, line moved well...Inside is so clean and staff is super nice and quick! So many great flavors, I got the small pistachio cone...i was beyond happy! Great flavor and creaminess! Also great prices! Unlike any other soft serve I have ever had...i think i will be dreaming of this treat for a long time! read more

See all

It's always well worth the drive to go to Marshall's. Their soft serve and cakes are unreal. Specifically, their pistachio soft serve is hands down the best I've ever had. The line is typically long during the summer but moves fairly quickly. Great customer service too. If anything, it's incredibly difficult to resist driving here every night. read more

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Massapequa, New York

Went here yesterday for the first time in a while. There were quite a few people behind the counter and only one person being served. It took quite some time before anyone acknowledged us, & our server seemed to be annoyed when I pointed out that she misheard my order. All in all, the ice cream was great, but the service was just slightly disappointing. read more

You like ice cream? Think carvel but way way better! They have soft serve vanilla, chocolate, low fat vanilla & pistachio! Not to mention a bunch of other flavors in the regular hard ice cream, birthday cakes, etc. Be prepared for a line but its worth the wait. read more

Came here after getting a burger from their neighbor. Got a cookies and cream milkshake. It was very delicious and the regular size was pretty big. I recommend this place for a decent shake. read more

So, my wife called for a cake on Thursday of Labor Day weekend to be picked up on Sunday. The owner said they need 3 days notice. My wife indicated that it is, and the owner said no, because they said they were treating Thursday like Friday, which would be two days notice. I called and then the owner said they are no longer taking special orders. When I asked why, he laughed at me. When I asked why he was laughing at me, he replied, that no one had ever questioned him before. Needless to say, there are better ice cream options than an operation that talks down to customers. read more

Biggest "small" cone ever. It was so refreshing to get such a big scoop, especially compared to other places I've been that have the nerve to charge $5 for a puny scoop. I had the Peanut butter Fluff hard icecream and it was delicious. Great mouth feel and texture. I wish there was a little more PB swirl but it was still delicious. I didn't taste any Fluff. All in all, a great experience and I would be back. read more

Wonderful ice cream. So creamy and delicious. Can't go wrong with any flavor. Ice cream cakes were going off like 1 per minute. I don't mind waiting to get ice cream from this place. It is worth it. read more

Always amazingly delicious homemade ice cream. I love every flavor all the hard and soft serve ice cream the hot fudge and whipped cream is also yummy. read more

See all

Small ice cream shop with just a few flavors, but what they have is delicious. Don't expect anything fancy, just the basic flavors with a few specialties. The black truffle raspberry is my absolute favorite - it's the only flavor I get when I come. They also have soft serve, including pistachio, which is a favorite of the rest of my family. Their ice cream cakes are the other reason i come. They can custom make the cake or they have premade ones. Way better than carvel and worth the extra trip for me to pick up a cake. I always have extra room for ice cream and that's because of Marshall's. read more

The best ice cream for miles and miles and miles. Family owned business that used to be a carvel but the owner wanted the best ice cream for the customer and big corporate carvel wasn't cutting it. MUST try the black raspberry bonnet (trust me) and the soft serve is truly authentically creamy and delicious. Hard to come bu these days with all the trendy ice cream shops out there. Must go! read more

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar is located adjacent to All American Hamburger Drive In, an old-school fast-food joint that has become a Long Island staple. After countless visits to All American, I always remembered that there was an ice cream spot next door. During the day of my visit, I was craving ice cream and headed to Marshall's. Normally, my go to ice cream order is a chocolate shake. Marshall's gives you the option of soft-serve ice cream or hard ice cream. Since this was my first time here, I listened to the recommendation of the staff and the hard ice cream won by a majority. What caught me by surprise was that Marshall's puts physical pieces of chocolate in their shakes. The ice cream was 100x better than the ice cream you'd typically receive at places like Carvel and Baskin Robbins. I'll definitely be returning soon and highly recommend others to visit Marshall's if you're craving high quality ice cream. read more

Don't let the line out the door and around the corner scare you away. The line moves fast. Our server was very friendly and helpful. They had a few soft serve flavors and a few hard ice cream flavors. I had nonfat vanilla soft serve in a sugar free cone and my husband had pb ice cream in waffle cone. We enjoyed it. By the way, if you are claustrophobic, there will be a brief loss of personal space while in the shop itself. read more

Visit Date: July 25, 2019 So I've been having lots of trouble with WW, it works for some people and when I started it was great but than it started to drive me nuts. Even though I am kind of locked into paying for it until September, I may be done with it and I might try calorie counting on August 1. So I'm on another tracking break (like my 50 millionth since June lol). So for this break I am trying to do my best, I'm trying not to shove in treats just because it feels like this might be the last time I can do it, I'm trying not to have binges just to get things in for the last time. Basically I'm trying not to be a mental case with food. So I'm doing half decent on my own but I still wanted some ice cream because I want ice cream almost every day and decided to finally try Marshall's. Despite the fact that it was almost 10 PM the place was pretty crowded with people getting ice cream. It is a small place though. There's no seating you just go in get your ice cream, pay and leave. I got a small chocolate cup with peanut butter sauce. It was pretty good, I would say a touch better than Carvel for the soft serve. I will always love MORE peanut butter sauce but they didn't do badly with a peanut butter sauce to ice cream ratio. Overall I did like Marshall's and would recommend stopping in here. Looks like they offer more basic stuff but they're obviously really good because every time I pass there's people lining up to get some ice cream. read more

Ice Cream = Good Marshall's Ice Cream Bar = OK I like ice cream like anyone else, but Marshall's is just OK. I had a Chocolate Brownie Sundae which was tasty, but decent. Ice cream was your standard Carvel soft style over a warm brownie with chocolate sauce and whip cream. I guess I have been having some higher end brands and flavors these days. Industrial style brands like Marshall's just are so middle of the road. Can whip cream is only good in the bedroom. I need that fresh stuff. It makes a huge difference. If your in the area, Marshall's is a decent choice. It won't wow you, but it will satisfy your sweet tooth for a moment. Small one any way. read more

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar - Front door. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Massapequa, New York

See all

Nice local place that is like Carvel but small business and more reasonably priced. Ice cream measured on scale for size consistency. Had chocolate vanilla twist with petite chocolate sprinkles which had a nice crunch. read more

Marshall's Ice Cream Bar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Massapequa, New York