Been coming here since they opened. Never had anything that was not exceptional - quality is…read morealways amazing. Steaks are the best I've ever bought anywhere, period. Always prime quality. Pork and chicken are phenomenal too.

Received meat in november 2025. I have tried every cut and am disappointed. Hamburger is horrific…read moreeith large chunks of ?gristle. Steaks are tough. Was promised certain cuts and when picked up was informed that the person who bought the bigger part of cow wanted the better cuts. Hello, i paid for my meats too!! The owner is very personable and likeable but the meat is not very good. I really wanted to like this but....

Came here for the first time, was a wonderful experience. They sell chicken, lamb/goat, all types…read moreof fish, and more meats. The store was clean, spacious, and was definitely very hygienic. The two employees upfront were extremely kind and helpful. I asked about their food and they showed me what the different meats looked like, and explained their various pre seasoned and marinated meats that they had ready-to-go. Definitely recommend coming here!

Ordered a 4-bone Prime Rib for Christmas. They separated the bones and trussed it together!! We…read morehave never cooked one before and were very excited!! This was a Choice cut and came out delicious!! Thanks guys!! You made this a great experience!!

We got catering trays for a graduation party: brisket, potato salad, coleslaw, baked beans,…read moreassorted individual bags of chips, and a vegetable tray. So delicious, great service. There were so many wonderful looking things in the shop-my only sadness is discovering this place as my kid is graduating and leaving Bloomington!

Hours are a little off (closed Monday and Tuesday) and this is the other butcher shop in Avon…read more Walked in, immediately greeted by the owner, she was totally cool with us looking around figuring what we wanted. Any questions we had she immediately responded. Everything looked so fresh we ordered some "better butter burgers" and some premade salads (ham, pasta, potato). Cooked the burgers on the grill to a perfect medium so good. Love supporting our local butcher shop. Gold cleaver is where it's at!

The place is small inside but they pack a bunch to check out. I purchased 2 choice ribeyes, 2…read moresmoked chops, some smoked bacon and shrimp. I am normally a big steak cooker, but wow, were those chops tender and smoked great. The bacon had some SERIOUS smoke on them. i ended up slicing the bacon into finger bites as an appetizer. The next time im back i will of course stop here to get what i need.

Service & selection is always top-notch! Old fashioned butcher shop combined with a cheese & meat…read moredeli case. They don't really make any sandwiches but can cut & slice meats to order and have some of the best prepped meatballs and frozen meats around. Just get back the Bison Italian Sausages, please! Next time you are prepping for a grill session I highly recommend Kincaid's, particularly the SoBro location on Illinois Street in the heart of Butler-Tarkington! Cheese & proteins awaits!

I don't know what they put in the marinade for their flank steak but I think it might be crack…read more That stuff is absolutely delicious. We generally get one every other week or so. Don't need to season it out it on the hot grill for a few minutes each side, slice and serve. The potatoes in the picture came from there too because I was running late and didn't have time to walk across the street. One of our favorite local businesses to support.

Employees are knowledgeable and helpful when making selections! Good product. Good location!read more

Always excellent! We're bought steaks many times & the quality never disappoints. This weekend…read moreit's ground chuck for burgers on the grill. Fantastic!

Very clean shop. Lots of specials for anyone. I ordered the economy bundle and the price is…read moredifferent than online. online it said 106 dollars and here said 115 but it was still a good deal. I also got 3 pounds of chicken legs and two of the pork fritters because they were $1.50 today. The young man who helped me was very helpful and let me swap out one of the items. he also let me know where their meat was sourced from. I believe they said the pork and chicken was from Delphi and the beef was from Midwest. They were all friendly while very busy. After I ordered, there was a large group of people, so I guess I got in at a good time! I loved my last bundle and I'm sure this one's going to be equally as good. The prices May be going up a little bit shortly, but right now they're honoring the prices that are listed on the boards. They also go through each of the orders with you to make sure you have every item in your bundles. Go check it out!

Well i bought a steak bundle less than a month ago and every pack ive thawed has been bad so far…read morethats three in a row so i threw all of it away up till now ive been recommending this place to everyone I know great prices ,great employees with excellent attitude but i cant risk bad meat yuck and dangerous so definitely a thumbs down and i wont be back ill go to value meat market in moorseville indiana from now on never had any bad meat from this place.

I have purchased from the Simpson Family Farm several times in 2014. I will continue the routine…read more In the warmer months, I purchase from them at the Binford farmer's market in Indianapolis. In the colder months, they are setup in the downtown farmer's market. I know you can also visit the farm in Martinsville, I have yet to do so. Why... Why is it getting 5 stars and why will I continue? It is good meat. I have bought Chicken, and Beef from them. And, now that Thanksgiving is past, Turkey from them. My family is trying to buy as much organic, non-processed, "real-food" as possible. We had been buying organic chicken from the grocery. But, one day at the farmer's market, my friend said, "try this meat, it is the best." I bought a package of chicken. I was blown away. The meat was still on the bone, but to cut it off was like cutting butter. It sliced so easily (raw or cooked). And there was no - none - null - fat in it. The chicken from the store always seems to have a bit of gristle in the middle. Not this. And the taste - It was juicy and flavorful. So much better. Next I tried the beef - same thing. All grass fed, all great. The man said, if you like this, you should try our turkey. So, this Thanksgiving, we did. Everyone commented how flavorful the turkey was - and all I did was rub butter, salt and pepper with a little rosemary on it. Easy and the best ever turkey! Read the company's website on how they describe themselves as "better than organic." And, if you can, try it out. When my family cooks meat, we want it to be Simpson Family Farm meat!

Nice small store with a amazing meat counter, do yourself a favor and go... they run specials on…read moreall kinds of meats and you can't go wrong there.

Old school meat market. Fresh custom cut meats, better quality with half the price of the big box…read morestores. Breaded tenderloins twice the size of the bun for $.89 each! Supporting local.