I tried Martiny's BBQ for the first time--my fiancé had the brisket sandwich, and I had the pork. The pork and Ribs were decent, a bit in between juicy and dry, but the buffalo sauce helped a lot (I'm not a fan of vinegar-based BBQ). Both sandwiches were super hot, so we ended up eating them open-faced. Styrofoam also melted. The mac and cheese was tasty but light on noodles, and the baked beans were solid. The place is small but quiet. Overall, decent. We'll try it again in the future. read more

Martiny's BBQ - Pulled Pork Sandwich - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

The food was okay, not as hyped up as people made it out to be. We had the brisket and ribs boxes. The German potato salad was too sweet. The mac and cheese was okay but nothing to scream about. The meat was also okay but needed the BBQ sauce. Service was very strange and the man taking my order at the window didn't seem happy to be there. read more

Martiny's BBQ - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

I saw this place being advertised by someone on social media so I decided to check it out. From the outside, it looks intriguing. It's a wooden cabin located right in front of a drive thru store. The parking lot has some spaces but it definitely needs some work done - a lot of potholes due to the weather. Once you get out of your car, you can smell the smokiness of the bbq place. Inside, they have wooden picnic tables but space is limited - there are only 4 tables. It definitely gives cozy cabin vibes. They have a screen next to the menu to place your order. There was only one gentleman behind the counter fulfilling orders. Although not many people were eating in, they seemed busy with takeout orders. Due to the lack of workers, tables weren't being wiped down and there was some trash on the floor. Anywho, we tried their kitchen sink and a half chicken. The pulled pork was my favorite. It was so juicy and had the perfect smokiness to it. The ribs were good too. I was excited to try the brisket but was left disappointed after the first bite since it was cold. The mac & cheese also had good flavor but it was also barely even warm. The chicken had the smoky taste too but it lacked seasoning. Overall this place has potential. If they fixed their food temperature, improved the cleanliness, and friendlier customer service, this place would be a 5/5. read more

See all

Update April 30 2025: Decided to take a short drive up Rt23 towards Delaware. Right before Shannahan Rd on the left side you will see a Log Cabin shack. This is Martiny's BBQ. The owner is Michael Martiny. I met him a long time ago when he first started out in a Food Truck. His food was good then but he's doing great things now. This is quality smoked meats at its finest. I ordered the Brisket, Pulled Pork, Pork Burnt Ends and Pork Ribs. Also for sides I had Coleslaw, Macaroni and Cheese and Baked Beans. The pulled pork was nice and moist, I added some of his sauce but it didn't need it. Brisket just pulled apart with a ton of flavor. The ribs were easy to pull the meat right off the bone, sauce it up a little and yummy. Everything was phenomenal but the star of the meats were those Pork Burnt Ends, OMG!!! Cooked perfectly and the sauce that coated them was so good. I could have sat there all day just eating them. On to the sides, he has a nice creamy coleslaw, flavored perfectly. The Mac N Cheese was nice and creamy and made with several different types of cheese. And for me the Baked Beans were the star of the show. Made homemade with several different kinds of beans and a totally different flavor of sauce than any other BBQ place. It's addictive. I think the perfect ending to the meal was actually talking about his and my own journey through the BBQ world. If you want to have some of the best BBQ around stop and check his place out. read more

See all

This place has been there forever and I finally got to taste it and it was horrible smh...bake beans was hard and the ribs was so tough I couldn't eat them. It seemed like they gave me a bad plate on purpose, because I can't believe they been around this long smh... That's all Im going to say. Just terrible!!! read more

Don't take my 4-star as a ding, I just rarely give a 5-star. I had the pulled pork. It was great and had no need for any sauce. The green beans were delicious, with a little spice to them. I also had their delicious cole slaw. It was creamy, just like I enjoy with the right amount of cabbage. Service was very good, although it was only counter service with delivery to my table. The place looks small from the highway, but there are several picnic tables in the dining room. read more

We just visited Martiny's BBQ for the first time and it was a 10/10, no notes! If you live in Lewis Center or Delaware, you're probably familiar with this iconic little log cabin along 23 that has been a pizza place, purveyor of Venezuelan street food and now a bbq joint. The first thing you notice is the amazing aroma of wood-smoked meats emanating from the enormous, custom-built smoker sitting just outside of Martiny's. Michael tends the smoker and feeds it wood all night long to ensure the perfect result - and boy, can you taste it! My hubby is notoriously picky when it comes to ribs and he called these the most tender and flavorful he's ever had. I loved the pulled pork and brisket. And the sauces and sides are fab here! My favorite was the authentic warm German potato salad - utterly delish. We will definitely be back. I'm so glad to have top-notch Texas wood-smoked barbecue so close to home! read more

See all

Amazing little joint with just perfect que. House made sauces, wood smoker, order online and pick up at a convenient window. We loved the burnt ends and ribs that literally fell apart. The Mac and cheese is house made and just what you need with the meats and the baked beans delish. Just a couple of tables inside so might be best as takeout but go on in and order too just to meet the proprietor! read more

Martiny's BBQ - Burnt ends - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

Some people always feel the need to qualify themselves. Like if they "know" real barbecue, they'll tell you if something tastes good or not. But people are complicated, and they like what they like. We came here on a whim - close to closing, as a pit stop before hitting up CRMD. It's a small, unassuming shack, and the smoker was running as we pulled around to park out front. It's a wooden building, with limited seating - so don't bring a huge group unless it's to-go. A little cast iron stove in the middle of the wall, feels like you are hanging out in a different place. Ordering: touch screen. There was one dude working ("are you ordering the shredded pork? I'll need to shred some up if so!") so this made sense. And yes, half the party ordered shredded pork. I opted for the brisket - and it was perfect. The fat? Rendered like butter. Pickles and pickled onions, a roll, coleslaw (not super creamy or overly vinegary), and baked beans (that had the texture of actual beans, not something that's sat in a can). My date had her shredded pork on a baked potato - "like it was oven fresh, coated in salt and butter and pepper, just amazing." A solid offering - bottled water and sodas available, and sauces on the table (and he brought out their white sauce, to boot). It's an unassuming place, but we enjoyed the barbecue, and will have to visit again! read more

Martiny's BBQ - Brisket Box 1/2024 - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

Bbq craving satisfied!!! Mahalo Martiny's Bbq for amazing bbq meats, sides and sauces 10/10. To add to the experience, 23 drive thru right behind is a perfect combo! Great bbq and drinks for lunch in Columbus!! We ordered--THE KITCHEN SINK 3 RIBS, 1/2 LB PULLED PORK, 1/2 LB BRISKET AND 4 SIDES! $35 Support local business and order your bbq from Martiny's Bbq read more

Martiny's BBQ - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

Martiny's BBQ is sure to please. It's a stop for me when I see BBQ and after coming here once. I will be a fan of mine favorite from now on. Just look at the pictures, enough said! read more

See all

Got the brisket box. Brisket you can tell by the pictures was extremely dry. Definitely not fall apart tender. Absolutely needs sauce. Then I got Mac and cheese which was okay ....and the German potato salad( liquid mush) just no, don't get it. read more

Martiny's BBQ - German potato salad and mac and cheese - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

I had been craving BBQ for a while now and we live pretty close to Martiny's so decided to give it a try. I literally wanted to try a little bit of everything so I ended up ordering The Kitchen Sink. Ribs fell off the bone, and everything was pretty tender and delicious. There's a few places to sit inside and a table outside. We opted to sit outside since it was such a nice day out! We will be back! read more

Martiny's BBQ - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

Is there a new owner in place? I have had this twice food was ok but the hospitality was terrible. The owner seemed like a miserable guy that would rather not be there. The number one pillar of BBQ is hospitality if you can't get that down your business is destined to fail. read more

Brisket and pulled pork were phenomenal-the mop sauce was a vinegar base which was delicious. Meat is melt in your mouth good! The chicken was a bit dry and underwhelming as were the sides...we will be back for the brisket for sure! read more

If you're looking for a BBQ spot that checks all the boxes--flavor, service, atmosphere, and overall experience--look no further. This hidden gem of a BBQ joint delivers a top-notch bbq experience that left me thoroughly impressed. From the moment I walked in, I could tell this was a place that takes its food and hospitality seriously. I've been all over Texas, Memphis, Georgia, and the Carolina's and these ribs as well as sides are consistently some of the most amazing BBQ I've had. Let's start with the food. Every bite was a revelation. The ribs were absolutely tender, with the meat pulling off the bone effortlessly and boasting a smoky, juicy flavor that clearly comes from hours of slow cooking. The brisket? Perfectly seasoned, with just the right balance of char and tenderness. What I loved the most was the smoky depth of flavor, which you could tell was the result of expert smoking techniques. The pulled pork was equally impressive--juicy, flavorful, and just the right amount of sweetness in the sauce to complement the richness of the meat. The sides were no afterthought either. The mac and cheese was creamy, with a good mix of sharp cheese and subtle smokiness that added a nice touch with the perfect pepper touch. The coleslaw was fresh, crunchy, and balanced, providing the perfect contrast to the rich meats. What truly elevated the experience, however, was the service. The staff was friendly, attentive, and genuinely passionate about the food. From the moment we sat down, they made sure we had everything we needed. The man working walked us through the menu, offering great recommendations, and checking in at just the right times without being overbearing. It's clear that customer service is a priority here, and it made the meal even more enjoyable. As for the atmosphere, this BBQ spot manages to strike the perfect balance between casual and cozy, with rustic decor and an inviting, warm vibe that made me feel right at home. Whether you're here for a quick bite or a leisurely meal with friends, the space is comfortable and laid-back, allowing you to truly focus on the food. If you haven't been here yet, you're definitely missing out. From the perfectly smoked meats to the exceptional service, everything about this place is designed to give you the best BBQ experience possible. Highly recommend making the trip--you won't regret it! read more

I went awhile back and had some of the best BBQ I could ask for. The owners who I talked to were also nice people.

Martin's very much reminds me of the small town BBQ joints I frequented in Texas when I had a job that took me towns in both texts and Southern Oklahoma. So... Ambiance, you got to be kidding me it's a barbecue joint nothing fancy just good old down home, five stars for this. Service is serve yourself. Now for the food. I've had the brisket, the ribs, the chicken, and the burnt end. The brisket and the ribs are a solid 5 stars. Juicey for the brisket and fall of the bone for the rib meat. I would give the chicken 4 stars. It's meat, even the breast, was juicey but it's skin was not to my liking for some reason. The burnt ends were no big deal. Sides,... The best 2 are the "cheese" and mac. Note that I put cheese first because it is heavy with with cheese. My favorite are the BBQ beans. I've been known to get a double helping. read more

It's always nice to find a new local business, especially one pumping out good food like Martiny's. Barbecue has always been kind of hard to find in Columbus and you're usually stuck with City Barbecue which has gotten really corporate. The building that they operate out of looks like a log cabin and it really fits well with the cuisine. As you pull into the parking lot you can smell the meats smoking on their giant smoker. According to the chef, they use hickory which gives the meat a really good and unique flavor. I went with the pulled pork on this visit and it was juicy, but not greasy or fatty. The sides were also delicious, I had the mac and cheese and cole slaw. They've only been open a month, so if you haven't tried them out I say go for it, you won't be disappointed. Word to the wise, the pickles are good, but they have a kick. read more

Martiny's BBQ - Pulled Pork, Mac and Cheese, Cole Slaw, and Spicy Pickles. - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

Wow. This place is so delicious. Everything on the menu is so tender and juicy. They have a variety of sauces and sides. Great portion sizing and quick service. There is a small seating area as well if you want to eat in but I recommend this place as a new go-to BBQ place. This place is definitely a must if you visit the area. read more

My grandparents and I had an amazing meal(s) at Martiny's BBQ! We tried the brisket, pulled pork sandwich, mac & cheese, baked beans, and German potato salad. Everything was delicious--especially the brisket and pulled pork, which were juicy and tender. The sauces were great, and the guy at the window was super friendly and even gave us a variety to try. The baked beans and coleslaw were also a hit. Martinys is so cute, cozy place and feels like home. This is my grandparents' favorite BBQ spot, and now I see why. Highly recommend! read more

Awesome takeout yesterday for the family. Bbq was delicious. Added an extra portion of ribs.

I have been in the front lobby to order food and felt like I was bothering him. I have gone through the drive-through and I can be there five minutes before he recognizes that I'm out there. I have been treated horribly calling in. Or pulling up to the drive-through. He has complained that nobody else will work for him. We went one time over a holiday weekend and he acted like he was above working on a holiday.. the food was great at first. And then it went downhill. I used to recommend your place all the time. And I feel bad that I did. read more

This guy is a nut job. He has threatened me personally to take down my review. The food was disgusting I totally understand how brisket is best served. My husband didn't go through the drive thru he went in and was ignored. We did t get any burnt ends. So his claim of his camera on is bogus. And he wasn't busy at all except for his pals. read more

A very good option for BBQ. We got 'The Kitchen Sink' which gives you brisket, pork, and 3 ribs along with samples of all 4 sides. Cost was $35 which certainly was worth it. The meats were good! My favorite was hands down the brisket, which had a great bark and lots of flavor. The slice held together well as we took off pieces and tried all of their different sauces (I'll comment on those later). Great job on the brisket. The pork was also very good. The pulled pork has lots of the really tasty flavor used on the rub and it gives it a unique taste for Martiny's. Was not dry but cooked perfectly. The ribs were good but my least favorite of the trio. Sauces were good too! The Virginia vinegar based spicy option was my favorite. A unique flavor with spice and great on the meats! The sweet mustard and bbq was good too. I liked the white but I think it could be a little more creamy and more pepper. It was a little too much mayo compared to some really good white sauces I've had down In Birmingham AL area. But great job dude you're killin it. Sides were also great. My favorite was surprising to both me and my wife, the German potato salad! It was loaded with great flavor and another unique item on their menu! The mac and cheese was awesome. Coleslaw great. Beans were ok didn't blow me away but they were good. I haven't left a Yelp review in quite a bit but wanted to give a shout out to Martiny's. Welcome to the neighborhood!! read more

Martiny's BBQ - The Kitchen Sink. Great variety pack to taste all their flavors! - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

Delicious. Chicken was juicy, smoky, and the white BBQ sauce was delicious. Pulled pork was tender and a generous portion. Owner was super nice and welcoming. 10/10 will definitely be back. read more

Friend found this (relatively) new BBQ place and we met for lunch. Pulled up right as they opened. Smelled amazing, outside and then inside. Parking is mainly around back, though there are a couple of spaces in front and to the side. It's tiny. It's a shack. A couple tables inside and one or two outside, plus a drive-through. Sweetie doesn't like to eat stuff from shacks. To me, they're the best- they are focused on the food, not decor. And this place does it right. The usual meats, brisket/pulled pork/ribs, etc. By the pound or the "box," with a couple sides. And each meat and side was great. I saw burnt ends, and if those or rib tips are on the menu I always get them. They're a little uncommon, and always good. My friend got the Kitchen Sink or whatever they call it, brisket/ribs/pork plus lots of sides. The burnt ends were excellent. More on the tender and fatty side than most, not overly "burnt." Juicy, flavorful, amazing bits of meaty goodness. They came with two sides and I got baked beans and German potato salad. It's not the standard cold creamy potato salad we usually do around here, it's served hot, and a mix of almost-mashed potatoes and onions, etc. Different, and good. The baked beans were also different and good- fairly dry, not soupy, and with a strong savory flavor, not the standard heavy brown sugar type. My friend said his meats were all good, especially the brisket and pork, and he also liked the beans. I think he also got mac and slaw, and said they were just okay. The meals came with a little roll, and some sliced onions. Oh, and the sauces: a pretty standard but good house, red with some zip. An orangey, chili-peppery one that we both really liked. A Carolina mustard that was darn good. And an Alabama with horseradish, and farther off-white than most, that we both really really liked. They are working on a sausage. Service was friendly and fast. One guy was working carryout, drive-through, and the two of us dining in. It's way out of my way, but I will get back eventually, and it's closer to my friend's neighborhood so he said he will be back often. Prices were competitive, for good BBQ. Get here. read more

Smoke meets meat, and with a deft hand you have magic. Smoky porky, beefy, chickeny magic. This tiny place houses one big smoker- and boss man knows how to use it! Burnt ends were fall apart delish, pulled pork solid with a robust bbq sauce. Mac, beans and potato salad all good. The dark horse at Martiny's? The green beans!! Move over mush- This queen of green is snappy, bacon and onion with zippy spice- chef's kiss. We will be back. read more

Wonderful bbq. Service is nice enough; worker is usually busy and not chatty but gets the job done. Meats are unreal. Juicy, soft, real bbq. Sauces are tasty. Sides are great. Kinda pricey but worth it. Tiny place with just a few seats to sit, but cozy and clean enough to eat there. read more

That is some righteous bbq! I had the kitchen sink, which is brisket, pulled pork, and ribs. I couldn't pick a favorite as all were done to perfection. Brisket was glistening it was so moist. Pulled pork was super moist as well. Spare ribs were probably softer than I make mine, but the flavor was off the charts. Easily among the best bbq places I've ever had. The beans were my favorite side, but all of the sides were on point. The beans were sweetened with molasses, which I loved. They served it all with 3 sauces but no sauce is needed. I suspect the kitchen sink was meant for 2 because it was a massive amount of food. I'll be back again soon!!! read more

Martiny's BBQ - Kitchen Sink - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

Great slow smoked BBQ. Simple menu no frills. Just tender meat served fresh. You know you are close-by when you smell the smoker.

Crazy good food. We got this catered for a funereal. Wasn't sure what the price was per person as it was catering but well worth it regardless. Would highly recommend and return to help a local business. read more

Great spot for bbq!! We ordered and dined inside, food was ready in less than ten minutes. With it being our first time we opted to get the 'Kitchen Sink' which seemed to give us a little bit of everything and was the perfect option for two adults. Favorites of the variety were the pulled pork, mac n cheese, and brisket! All meats were super tender, juicy and flavorful. In talking to the employee that was working it had cooked for 15 hours, and it showed!! We will be back. read more

Martiny's BBQ - The Kitchen Sink : Ribs, Brisket, Pulled Pork, German Potato Salad, Mac n Cheese, Baked Beans, Green Beans and Rolls. - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

The food was great, and the burnt ends were delicious. Small dining area that was a cool atmosphere- service was really quick and friendly. Don't let the location deter you, I'll be going again read more

First time having food from this place today. The kitchen sink box was great. They also have a drive through, so you can order and pick it up. Will definitely eat here again. read more

I ordered the Brisket with a side of Mac n Cheese! Mac n cheese sauce was amazing and pasta was cooked well, that's all I have to say about that pretty simple! The Brisket was juicy and tender! The outer parts of the meat at the just right amount of "chew!" For bbq food I'd say the price was reasonable! Service was quick and the gentleman allowed me to try a sample! The vibes of the place made me feel I was in a cabin in the woods! I'll be returning or driving across Columbus to visit again! read more

Martiny's BBQ - Brisket sandwich - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

Stopped in on father's day coming back from camping at Delaware St. park. The location is a small shack next to Motorcycle Max. Seating included three nice, new picnic tables outside and a maybe 4-5 small tables inside. Business was steady, but not booming. The operator said he has only been open for two months, though, and he was happy with how things are going. I hope it continues to go well for him because this is the type of place that I want to succeed. Even if it doesn't fit my tastes, it might work for you and legit, small-batch BBQ is a treasure that we should nourish. My party tried all four of the available sides - German potato salad, bbq baked beans, cole slaw, and mac n' cheese - across two plates of meat. The first plate was brisket and the second plate was ribs. The brisket was easily my favorite of the two meats, but my wife preferred the ribs. Neither was standout, though, and had problems for us in their own way. I generally prefer a fatty brisket, but this brisket was so incredibly fatty it makes me wonder if it were trimmed properly. The ribs were meaty, but still had the silver skin on them which is also a trimming issue that knocks points off in my book. On the positive side, though, both had beautiful smoke rings and the smoke flavor came through perfectly in the brisket. I was missing the smoke flavor on the ribs which I think came from them being held for a bit too long. Other meat choices included your usual pulled pork, chicken, etc. but notably they had burned ends on special that day. Would have liked to try them, but didn't need more food. Maybe on a later visit. The sides all had good points and some less good. In order, we preferred the German potato salad, beans, mac n' cheese, and slaw. The flavors on the first three were on point. The beans were a bit firm for my taste and the mac a bit mushy. The slaw was competent, but very basic. I think the slaw would be great on top of a pork sandwich NC-style, but it was forgettable by itself. The potato salad had the right bacon and vinegar flavors, but was served in kind of a mashed potato form that I found odd. Not bad, but not the scalloped cut I usually expect for German potato salad. I'd definitely get it again if I go back. They had a lot of your typical sauce options. They didn't ask and we didn't specify, so we were given the sweet sauce which had very strong notes of molasses. I got some spicy to go, but haven't tried it yet. On appearance, it looked very different from the sweet with much more red color to it. I will update when that happens. The sweet was different enough to be memorable. Maybe not the best sauce I've ever had, but I liked that it was doing its own thing. Prices IMO were fine. We paid a bit more than $20 for each meat and two sides plate. I had Legacy BBQ in Hilliard recently and paid $20 for less food, so I call Martiny's a bargain in that regard. read more

Nothing special. Had the brisket with the side of mac and cheese. The brisket was maybe a notch below what I would consider a baseline like City BBQ. The mac and cheese was mushy and all I could really taste was black pepper. read more

Martiny's BBQ - Brisket with double side Mac n cheese - Barbeque Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

We ordered take out this weekend, and this was our 3rd visit to Martiny's. Everything was over the top delicious! I ordered a bowl with mac & cheese and pulled pork, and I ate every bite. My son and husband ordered burnt ends and brisket and both ordered mac & cheese. We all agree that their mac & cheese is the best we've ever had! The meats were all cooked to perfection and the portions are very generous. Will order again soon! read more

My family and I hate the opportunity to try this new BBQ place. I have to say I was a bit disappointed. We had pulled pork and chicken with beans and mac & cheese as sides. the pulled pork had quite a bit of fat in the meat to the point we could not finish it. The side were good but small in comparison to competitors. It was all a bit pricey too at $16 for a box. The folks were great people but be prepared that this is all self service. They are geared for carry out not inside dining. parking is a challenge as well especially if you have a handicapped member if your party. this place is not for me but maybe your experience will be different. read more