Similar to newberry subs these guys make a huge cheesesteak, which you basically have to begin eating with a fork before you can pick it up. Works best as a pick up and go type sub shop but there is a few tables you can sit in and eat. Over all not a bad sub shop. read more

Ordered a grilled chicken salad. The chicken tasted like it was sitting out for a long time and was dried up like a leather shoe. Not good. Why serve that? If the cook or the server had taken a look, they should have asked themselves, "would I eat that?" I assure you the answer would have been a resounding no. read more

Stopped in to pick up a sandwich for lunch, corned beef with sauerkraut, very disappointed. One slice of corned beef on rye, lots of sauerkraut. This restaurant needs to learn a lesson from Jacks in East Baltimore. There was also six potato chips (stale) and the worst tapioca pudding ever. Will not be back. read more

I've eaten here for years. The food has gone down hill. The lady taking our order and then bringing the food to our table wasn't wearing a mask. I questioned her and she said she can't wear them because she gets light headed. Then you SHOULD NOT be working in the food industry! So disappointed. Wont return! read more

Food is great and so unique! I love the Heather! Only downside is hours make it so you can't pick up or eat there after 3.

My go to when i want a perfect club sandwich. I have been coming here for years, and i can't ever seem to try anything else, because i love the Maseto's club sandwich so much, it's just fantastic! The other dishes look fantastic, and some day, i will do it, but damn. That club. It's perfection. One club is way more than one person can eat, so its a great sandwich to share. Perfectly toasted bread, mayo, fresh sliced roast beef, turkey, bacon, and amazing Cole slaw. You have to scrunch it down a bit, to get it in your mouth. Served with homemade chips, and a side of your choice. I always get the tortellini salad, its wonderful. Service is always friendly, and prompt. I have to say i'm a little disappointed that they are not going to be taking credit cards any longer, as many times i don't have cash on hand, and i don't like paying the fees that the ATM charges to get money at the restaurant. Thank you Maseto's for being consistent, and making the most perfect club sandwich I've ever had. read more

I've been here a couple of times now and you really can't go wrong with this place for lunch. Sandwiches are delicious and quite big portions. I'm usually put off by places that don't serve fries with their sandwiches, but their assortment of sides in their place are great. Love the Heather's Favorite with a side of tortellini pasta salad! My boyfriend always enjoys his Reuben. read more

Maseto's Deli - Heather's Favorite with tortellini salad. - Delis Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

None of the staff--front of house or back of house--were wearing masks. None of their patrons were either. I've filed a food safety complaint with the Pennsylvania health department for follow up. I hope the staff at Maseto's become educated on the importance of masks as COVID counts are skyrocketing right now and show that they care about their customers by respecting them enough to wear a mask. read more

This place is a great, an old favorite. I think their club sandwiches are the best. The prices are maybe a little high but once you see the sandwich, you know why... they are huge, I think they put a 1/2 pound of meat on them. Could honestly make two meals out of them. You also get one of their deli sides, I usually go for the broccoli salad but the tortellini salad is also very good. Staff very friendly, service has always been good for me. read more

Maseto's Deli - Delis Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Great place to stop and eat! We got off the highway and lucked out because this was the first place we saw. First off, it's quaint and has a pretty unique setup. And the people! Some of the nicest people I've ever met. They were extremely kind, really happy and very attentive! The food was really good! We started off ordering the reuben chowder soup unsure of what it would taste like; it was surprising good! The soup tasted just like you'd imagine a reuben tasting like if it were a soup. I ended up ordering a meatball cosmo. The meatballs were huge and the bread was fresh. More importantly, the meat to bread ratio was just right. And there was a good amount of cheese. Honestly, the experience overall blew me away. I wasn't expecting much and it was a real treat! I will definitely be stopping in when I'm traveling through the area again. read more

I dream of Maseto's sandwiches! Unfortunately, I live out of town and can't eat their deliciousness on the reg. But, anytime I'm passing through, I make sure to stop in and pick up a Heather's Favorite. The coleslaw and bacon on the sandwich really take it to the next level. The broccoli salad is also one of my favorite sides. If you haven't tried Maseto's yet, what are you waiting for?! Stop by and get any one of their delicious sandwiches. You won't be disappointed. read more

This is a great little breakfast/lunch food spot. They sport a morning clientele and are known for good breakfast foods. Lunch choices are also delicious! Their salads, soups, and classic signature sandwiches have become staples in the Williamsport area. Some businesses have even mimicked the sandwiches on their menus, but if you want the originals, visit this lovely spot in the Garden View area. The food is prepared well and they accommodate any tweaks or food requirements- just ask. read more

FAN. TAS. TIC. I loved walking into the place and asking the lady at the counter, "What's your favorite?" and getting a somewhat disbelieving, "Oh, honey..." back. She then proceeded to tell me what her favorite was, and, well, it's now my favorite, too. I went down to visit a (hopefully future) customer and they work nearby. I was told that this is the best place for lunch around, and I am jealous that they have such a great place to eat nearby. With any luck, they will be a customer and I will enjoy other favorites at Maseto's. read more

I may have just eaten the best cheeseburger I've ever had! The rodeo burger is a must! I'm only in the area once or twice a month but this will be a sure stop for me! read more

Found this place by pure luck! Driving from Niagara Falls to Washington DC we were looking for somewhere to have lunch in Williamsport. I had the rodeo burger and it was fantastic. I highly recommend Maseto's if you want a homemade meal. read more

Went to Maseto's just recently (have been a number of times in the meantime since my last review). This visit I finally branched out from just getting the 'Karen's favorite' sandwich. Needless to say the Italian Combo hit the spot as well (I'd definitely recommend adding the seasoned oil) and Maseto's continued to impress. It was the busiest there I've seen yet and the service that night was especially friendly. If you're lucky you can find their 'Buy 1 sandwich, get 1 50% off' coupons in the local paper, too. read more

Sooo good!! Maseto's sandwiches are one of a kind, the salads are huge, and the soup is hearty! At our last visit my son ordered the chicken planks, but they tasted like fish sticks. The waitress noticed and came over to ask him if they could get him anything else. Then another woman (an owner I believe) came over and insisted he order something else, on the house. She refused to take no for an answer from my shy son. They were so sweet and didn't make us feel guilty about not liking what he ordered. I Love Maseto's!! read more

Great sandwiches. Stumbled upon this gem when we were originally en route to McDonalds to grab a quick bite to eat while traveling. Glad we saw this instead! Service was friendly and out to-go order was ready in about 10 minutes, even during the lunch hour rush. I got Karen's Favorite (w/o pastrami) and recommend it highly. read more

Found this place while in town one day and very pleased!! The sandwiches are amazing! They are huge and super tasty! We shared the heather and it was plenty for 2 people! The staff was very nice and helpful. Will definitely be back and anxious to try more options! read more

The food here is excellent but the system of serving and placing your order is completely unproductive. Especially at lunch time. Placing the order at the counter causes congestion as well as confusion and only two girls to take orders, ring people out, and bus and deliver food is a terribly long process. I waited for over ten minutes just to cash out. Prob will not go back during lunch since I am on a time crunch to get back to work. read more

We stopped here on a road trip because of the good yelp reviews. Sadly the service was terrible and the food was below average. I had the club. It was 8oz of turkey with literally 1 slice of bacon. Side of chips included was literally 8 small chips. Other sandwiches ordered were a ton of bread and not much else. Pasta salad was good. As a whole this was a waste of $80 for our family of 5. read more

I always liked this place as a child for their delicious tortellini salad. Now, as a gluten free adult, I was concerned about what I could eat. I asked for the sandwich inside, on top of a salad. The staff was very attentive and considerate in making sure my order was done correctly to accommodate my allergy. The salad came out delicious. Tasted great, hit the spot and the staff was very considerate. Thank you! read more

I recently stopped by Maseto's for a sandwich shortly after lunch time. I ordered what was basically a toasted turkey club sandwich that is dressed with coleslaw and some thousand island dressing. I ordered the sandwich to go and my house was no more then 3 blocks away. When I opened the box and grabbed the sandwich the bottom slices of bread was spongy and soggy. The amount of un-drained coleslaw and thousand island dressing was absurd. Crafting a sandwich takes care and thought, but its not rocket science. I wonder if the cooks at Maseto's would pay for, and eat what they served me? I doubt they would, yet I was charged $10 for a sponge of a toasted sandwich and broccoli salad that was comprised mostly of stems. To many of Williamsport's great places to eat have fallen tremendously. Its as if the owners and/or managers give up after the first few years of business and begin to think that: "its good enough". Maseto's is now guilty of the "its good enough" mentality. read more

Fast great service ! A perfect lunch spot. They have fantastic sandwiches, soups, sides, salads, etc. the potions are large so know what you are getting ! Love the old school ordering system that provides some charm to the place. read more

Went here for a easy and casual dinner with parents. It's a no frills, pretty good food type of joint. I ordered the home-style meatball sandwich, which was hearty with decently flavored meatballs. The variety of sides: broccoli salad, applesauce, pasta salad, tortellini salad, etc. are a nice change from the usual chips and fries. All in all, Maseto's has a good variety. Parents ordered a Reuben and turkey & pastrami with coleslaw on top. Both seemed to enjoy it. My Dad, being a dad, finished his entire plate and helped me with my side of broccoli salad. Parents both had Imperial IPAs, the option of getting a beer is always great with deli sandwiches. I can also see this being a go-to take-out place to grab some dinner and a 6 pack or two on a Friday night after a busy week, if I were still a local. I'm giving this 3 stars because it truly was "A-OK". Is this my new favorite sandwich shop in Williamsport? No. Would I go back next time I'm in town? Sure! read more

Maseto's Deli - Home Style meatball sandwich - Delis Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Solid sammy. A hoppin place at lunchtime on a Wednesday. Stopped here on our way back from Upstate NY. I got the Jennifer's Favorite sandwich. Turkey, bacon ---Cole slaw, and special (Russian?) dressing. Worth the detour off the main highway home. read more

Quick and delicious stop in Williamsport! Quick, friendly service. Sandwiches were on good bread with good fillings. Bathrooms were clean and the decor was cute. Excellent, thanks! read more

Very good soups and sandwiches. They have one of the best cheesesteaks in Williamsport, good meat, well seasoned, fully stuffed sandwich. Their sausage potato soup is amazing, and they have an assortment of sides that are delicious. read more

Amazing sandwiches! Love the Heather's Favorite! I've always enjoyed their homemade soups

Been going here for years for their fresh pasta on Friday night. They just started serving breakfasts and the omelet with all the veggies is the best I've ever eaten. I've eaten plenty omelettes in my day. Prices and service are great too! read more

Terrific food, nice looking place, fast and friendly service. Good people and great food. No other sandwich place in Williamsport compares. read more

Horrible experience!! Ordered a grilled chicken salad to go with no tomatoes. Picked up my order and when I got back to work (Which was only 2 min away), realized my order was completely wrong. They gave me chicken salad on a salad. I called them and asked them to make me a new salad and deliver it for me, or give me my money back. I spoke with the owner on the phone when I called even. She stated that I said chicken on greens when I called..hence...grilled chicken on a salad. She said they would make me a new salad and could pick it up because they couldn't deliver. My office manager stopped to pick it up for me and they made her pay for the new salad unless we could give the old one back to them. First and foremost...usually when a restaurant screws up your meal they give you your money back and new food. You never have to return food! So I ended up paying for 2 salads, and 1 in which was screwed up. There customer service was awful, and as much as I loved there food, I will never go back again!!!!! read more