This sub shop was a random find while driving east on I-80 through Pennsylvania. It was dinner…read moretime and we were getting hungry. I suggested looking up sandwich shops and of the list of places, Newberry Sub Shop, was the random pick. Located in a picturesque area of Williamsport, PA, and a decent trek off from I-80, Newberry is a local, mom & pop type shop that is popular among the locals. Their menu offers a nice variety of sub sandwiches which is what we were interested in. The shop is a counter-service type establishment. Menu is on the wall and also on paper near the ordering counter. There's a small dining area inside the shop and also, an outdoor seating area. We were taking our food to go. We ordered 1) cold Salami Sub and 1) Mushrooms and Bell Peppers Cheesesteak with cherry (hot) peppers. We also grabbed a local brand of spicy jalapeno flavored potato chips. We received good, friendly service. The staff was helpful to us in deciding what we wanted to order. The menu items were reasonably priced and you got good bang for your buck. The sandwiches were huge and loaded. Both the sandwiches were good. I got the cheesesteak and it hit the spot. The meat was well-cooked and flavorful, and the veggies and the cheese added a delicious taste. My only gripe about the cheesesteak was that the bread was very soft where the sandwich fell apart due to how hot (temp.) the cheesesteak was, thus making for a sloppy eating experience. But that's why you have utensils like fork. The Salami sandwich was also delicious. The chips were okay. They were a bit salty for my liking and not quite spicy. Overall, this was like a hidden gem of a find for us (since we were visitors passing by and not locals). I would like to have more of their other offerings. I am not sure when I'll be back in that area but suffice to say that I will be going back to Newberry when I return to this part of Pennsylvania in the future. Check out Newberry. Definitely recommended.

Small clean unassuming shop with great AC in the summer time plus nice round picnic tables with…read moregood umbrellas, and gorgeous flowers all around the exterior. The food!! We've been getting cheese steaks from here for years, though this is my first visit. Overflowing with yummy cheese steak, with fresh toppings to order on perfectly soft roll. We haven't tried anything else but surely it's aa good! They have a Pepsi fountain, both Utz AND Middleswarth chips! And a cooler of even more beverage choices. Plus well labeled recycling for the eco nerds like me. TIP: good food takes time. And they could run out. You can call ahead or we even used the website and it worked great! One very clean bathroom

Great food. We get the Lineman and Tuna subs frequently. Would definitely recommend for a quick and…read moredelicious meal. They also usually have homemade fudge, cookies, peanut butter eggs, whoopie pies, or other treats from the area.

Very pleasant experience polite quick service. Food prepared well…read more Regular sub- fresh flavorful ingredients nothing overstated well blended flavors. Cheesesteak- the boy said tasted good a good amount of meat in every bite again well blended. Meat was not dried out and was well cooked. Thank you.

I was skeptical because, on the outside, it could use a little curb appeal, but this sub shop had…read moreone of the best cheesesteaks I've ever tried. We bought one large with everything and had leftovers to take home. We were waited on promptly and the food was ready quickly even though they were busy. It's definitely a "locals" regular spot, and while it's nothing fancy, there were tables inside and it was air conditioned to escape the heat of a hot day. Not sure about the other menu items (although they looked good) but the cheesesteak was excellent!

pickup online order : 6 perogies for $6 says on menu ..but I got a handful of tiny perogies, was…read morenot impressed with the Italian sub either. The lunch meat used was cheap and lousy. would not recommend. Also offered paperplates on take out order and they didnt have any.

Similar to newberry subs these guys make a huge cheesesteak, which you basically have to begin…read moreeating with a fork before you can pick it up. Works best as a pick up and go type sub shop but there is a few tables you can sit in and eat. Over all not a bad sub shop.

Ordered a grilled chicken salad. The chicken tasted like it was sitting out for a long time and was…read moredried up like a leather shoe. Not good. Why serve that? If the cook or the server had taken a look, they should have asked themselves, "would I eat that?" I assure you the answer would have been a resounding no.

Just the best ! A gem in the community -great food, donuts and ice cream -the grocery and sliced…read moremeats are also wonderful

Crazy good place! Not a lot of sandwich options for vegetarians, but omnivores will leave…read moresatisfied. Killer donuts; good coffee.

I should start this off with a disclaimer that I feel indebted to write the review because I didn't…read morerealize it was cash only prior to eating the whole sandwich. The staff was far too okay with me being 50 cents short. Aside from the guilt and shame of shorting the restaurant, the food here was definitely noteworthy. I was pleasantly surprised that the simple grilled ham and cheese sandwich I ordered went the extra mile in terms of the ciabatta bread and ingredients. 5 dollars went a long way into the quality of the sandwich and side I got with the meal. I will go back if I'm in the area and hopefully I am reviewing the correct location because I don't think, It's Hoagie Time is the right name. The location is interesting as it's set in the middle of a neighborhood and looks like just another house pulling in. The experience was also similar to visiting someone's house for a good lunch.

I've been going to Humpty Dumpty since I was a kid and although the decor has changed a lot (for…read morethe better) the food is still amazing. Having traveled the world in the Military for many years I can say that beyond a shadow of a doubt the "Grinder" sub sandwich at Humpty Dumpty is as good as it gets. A marvelous take on the classic American sub, oven toasted to a crisp perfection and served with a rushed, but heartfelt smile. As far as sub-shops go, this is my personal favorite and one that I would strongly recommend you try.

I have been going here for years, and this used to be one of my favorite spots. Unfortunately, the…read moreattitude and level of service I've experienced recently have really gone downhill. My last two interactions have made it unlikely that I'll be going back anytime soon. Example 1: I called at 7:23 p.m. and specifically asked how late they were open because a friend and I wanted to get cheesesteaks. I was told they were open until 8:00 p.m. We arrived at approximately 7:35 p.m., only to be told that the grill had already been turned off and they were no longer serving cheesesteaks. I noticed there was a sign stating that the grill closes at 7:30 p.m., but that information was not mentioned when I called. If I call ahead to ask how late you're open, it seems reasonable to mention that the grill closes well before the actual closing time. Otherwise, saying you're open until 8:00 is pretty misleading when a major portion of the menu is unavailable by 7:35. Example 2: A few days later, I came in with another friend to get food. After ordering, I sat in the chairs and waited. When I saw my food come out from the back to be finished and wrapped, I stood up and walked toward the counter to get ready to pick it up. I had been standing there for less than three seconds when I was abruptly yelled at for being too close to the counter. What made this especially frustrating was watching other customers approach the same counter, stand there, talk, and place orders for considerably longer without receiving the same treatment. Less than 30 seconds later, my food was ready, meaning I had to approach the counter again anyway. If there is a rule about where customers are allowed to stand, that's fine post a simple easy to read sign then just politely ask customers to wait in a particular area. There was absolutely no reason to yell at someone who had simply stood up to collect an order that was visibly being finished. I've supported this place for years, which is why these experiences are so disappointing. Good customer service require only a little clear communication and basic courtesy. Providing that minimal quality of service would have made both situations nonissues. Unfortunately, after being treated this way twice in such a short period of time, I don't have much desire to return anytime soon.

Food is always good. Large . Food is always made the way I order it. Made quick, rarely a wait.read more

amazing food, prices and service…read more amazing food, prices and service amazing food, prices and service

Fell upon this little jewel in the rough. We were greeted and warmly. The place was clean and…read moreshowed some organization. The menu has a lot of choices to choose from. The ingredients appear to be fresh and tasty. I had the chicken Parmesan sandwich which was good. The slaw fries were a fun treat and different. The pile high fries were a little too much but doable to eat. Want to try other things on the menu if ever in the area.

When they're open, def a worthwhile place for a bite. The open hours are not the best. The pizzas…read moreare very good and the subs are where they shine. I especially love their homemade chips/fries.

The was a great place for drinks and food! Great time and the staff was wonderful. I would highly…read morerecommend for a good time.

Great view and a great big bar inside with an outside patio and bar to drink at. They do have…read morerooftop seating available. We stopped in basically off a couple reviews and found parking difficult as we don't live in town. You need to park in a lot just off the bridge and then walk over railroad tracks. The side lot I believe is for an apartment building and there are tow signs everywhere, but a welcome door into the establishment? The bartender was very welcoming and the bar has a great view of the Susquehanna river. They have tvs but they are hooked to some Roku thing so you'll never see anything live. They have a decent beer menu, probably bigger than they need. They offer a Sunday brunch menu which looked delicious but we ordered off the regular menu because it was 1pm. I had the crab cake sandwich. Not bad but mostly filler. The homemade chips are a plus. My wife had the shrimp po boy. She loved it. My wife's mocktail was tasty, she said. I get what this place is trying to be and it could be awesome. They have a lot of promotions posted. This reminds me of restaurant/bars on a river or an inlet except they had a dock or marina near by. The drinks were good.