Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Maxwells Trading

    4.5 (218 reviews)
    Open 4:30 pm - 10:00 PM
    Updated 3 weeks ago

    Maxwells Trading Photos

    Business Info

    MAXWELLS TRADING ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Intimate
    Romantic
    Classy
    Upscale

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Maxwells Trading

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Chicken
    Katie D.

    4.5 Sometimes a place gets a lot of hype and you leave disappointed...this is not one of those times. Everything we had was good and I will be thinking about half of them until I can come back. Our favorites were the gnocco fritto, the eggplant, and the sweet potato. People forget how good vegetables are when they are treated with some love. The staff was friendly & attentive. The space was open & modern. Already planning return visit

    Chicory Caesar Salad
    Darci W.

    Service was spectacular (until the end, when they were clearly DONE). We had a bit of a wait to be seated after our reservation time, but the hostess offered us a drink menu and suggested we get a drink from the bar, which made us not care so much about the fact that we weren't seated yet. Cocktails were creative & delicious. The food was very good. The French onion dip was amazing (if you like truffle oil, which I do!). The chicory caesar salad was good, nothing to rave about and a little over-dressed, but good. The sweet potato curry dish was super interesting (and tasty). The turbot was okay, but definitely could've used some salt. Another Yelper mentioned tiny portion sizes & leaving hungry, but that was not our experience at all. As recommended by the server, we shared one dish from each of the 4 menu courses. We couldn't finish everything and left quite full. This would've been 5 stars if not for the very end of the meal. I had just gotten my dessert cocktail (a toasted sesame espresso martini) when the restaurant went from dimly lit to full-on GTFO brightness. Chairs were being put up on tables, and it was very clear that they wanted us OUT. I work in a wine bar. I get it. At closing time, you're ready to go. But don't let people order more drinks if you're going to kick them out 10 minutes later. I feel like last call and get out of here time are way to close together here. I would not have ordered (and abandoned most of) that last drink if I had known they'd be kicking us out so soon.

    Emily B.

    I had a really nice dinner here. The vibe and service was totally great!! The food was really good, my only complaint was that the cheese dish came with a bowl of whipped cheese and honey and only two griddle cakes, and then they charge you for any additional bread. Kind of feels like they should give you enough bread to enjoy the full dish- especially at the price. Other than that everything was great.

    Satsuma verrine
    esther h.

    Finally made it to Maxwells Trading and overall had an enjoyable meal. The menu has a lot of Asian-inspired influences, and while some dishes felt more successful than others, the kitchen clearly has a strong sense of balance, texture, and flavor composition. We started with the Prosciutto & Gnocco Fritto. The combination of the cheese and black currant-pepper jam worked beautifully together, and the fried dough was a pleasant surprise -- light, airy, and almost donut-like with a hint of sweetness. The French Onion Dip had great flavor, although the texture leaned a bit too mayo-like for my taste. That said, the grilled dipping bread was delicious and reminded me of Taiwanese scallion pancake in a good way. The Short Rib was good, though not necessarily the most memorable dish of the night. The kalbi-style flavor profile felt somewhat familiar (almost like an elevated Trader Joe's frozen kalbi), but the accompanying kohlrabi and Korean melon were unexpectedly refreshing and ended up being one of my favorite components on the plate. The standout for us was actually the Half Chicken a la Brasa. Crispy skin, juicy meat, and somehow all the different flavor influences -- ginger scallion, aji verde, yuca -- came together very well. The yuca itself was excellent. We happened to see the chef and had the privilege of chatting with him for a few minutes. He was incredibly warm and down to earth. When we mentioned how interesting the chicken dish was, he laughed and said it was basically "everything in the fridge," which somehow made us appreciate the dish even more. For dessert, we ordered the Satsuma Verrine and loved it. The meringue on top was the sweetest component, while the whipped cream stayed light and fresh. The bottom layers combined citrus jelly and maybe curd where you could actually taste the fruit itself. A very elegant and balanced ending to the meal. Debating between 4 and 5 stars. If 4.5 were an option that's what I would pick lol

    Corn pasta

    Went here after hearing so many times how good the food was. The food was pretty good, but it certainly didn't crack my top 10 Chicago restaurants. The overall rating would probably be higher if it weren't for the service, which was honestly very disappointing. It took about 20 minutes for our server to come over after we were seated, and the rest of the experience didn't exactly improve from there. It also makes a lot more sense why they bake in an automatic gratuity (conveniently, it always seems to be the restaurants with the worst service that do this). We got the whipped ricotta and French onion dip, both of which were great and definitely required extra bread. Unless you enjoy drowning your bread in dip until you can no longer taste the bread itself, you're going to need more. The short ribs were good... until a fly decided to camp out on them and eventually die there, right in the middle of the restaurant. The corn pasta was good, very strong corn flavor and pretty much exactly what you'd expect when ordering corn pasta. The steak was also good, but definitely not one of the best steaks in the city. I did like the potatoes that came with it. The experience as a whole was pretty mediocre, and at this point I probably wouldn't go back simply because the service headache wasn't worth it. The crowd was also extremely hippie and just not really our scene, although that's obviously personal preference and not really a reflection of the restaurant itself. That said, I've heard consistently great things about this place from people whose restaurant recommendations I really trust, so I can only assume we caught them on a massive off night or maybe just a bad server. Although the table next to us also found something in their food, and the table on the other side was missing food because their ticket apparently got lost, so maybe it really was just an off night. Good food, but unfortunately the service and overall experience left a lot to be desired.

    Balanced and delicious
    Susan W.

    Still an exceptional meal start to finish. The tables seem a bit closer and the two top round ones at the front don't have much room for plates, but we continue to love the food and sincere hospitality and service. Easy free street parking for now.

    Tomato & Peach Salad
    Charniece T.

    Food was extremely flavorful and intentional, drinks were well curated and service was impeccable!

    Prosciutto
    Tray

    Chicago restaurants really keep impressing me and this one is incredible. Opened by James Beard finalists Erling Wu-Bower and Chris Jung, the menu blends Asian influence with American flavors and you can taste that creativity in the dishes. The prosciutto & gnocco frito was so good!! Everything worked together so well, it felt like elevated charcuterie 9.5/10. The griddle bread with French onion dip was even better!! That truffle flavor in the dip was insane and the bread had the perfect texture 9.7/10. The tortellini soup dumplings were a little overhyped for me, 7/10. We got the bone-in strip medium and the texture was perfect. Loved the potato pavé that came with it, 7.5/10. The Basque butter cake was overhyped in my opinion and just tasted like a standard butter cake, and I'm not the biggest butter cake fan, 6/10. Cocktails were AMAZING. Sweet, strong, elevated, and reasonably priced 9.5/10. Service was perfect. Friendly but not overbearing. The vibe is dim and intimate, and even though the place filled up fast, it didn't feel too loud since the space is huge. We had window seats and it felt like the perfect date night or celebration spot.

    Basque butter cake
    Kayla P.

    We came in during Restaurant Week but didn't end up ordering the Restaurant Week menu. The space was cute and very busy! I'd heard so many great things about this place, and while I definitely thought it was good, it didn't totally live up to the hype for me. That said, I do think restaurant quality can dip a bit during Restaurant Week. We tried a lot of dishes since it's more of a share-plates style restaurant. My favorite dishes were the Suzuki Tartare, Ravioli Doppio, Pork Chop au Poivre, and the whipped ricotta. I'd happily order everything again, all the dishes were great, just nothing that felt truly over-the-top amazing. We also felt like the service was a bit cold; not rude, but not quite what you'd expect from a restaurant at this level

    Monica N.

    What a fantastic meal!! It's a perfect place for anyone who is vegetarian. The whole space is huge! It still somehow has such a homey and cosy feel to it. Everyone that worked there was very nice and out waitress was helpful with suggestions. Beginnings: we got the silken tofu and chicory cesar. The silken tofu was interesting mix of flavors and very unique! The chicory cesar was a good hearty salad that felt so fresh. The prosciutto and gnocco fritto was our favorite! The gnocco fritto with the mix of caprino/prosciutto/black currant was so so good. Griddle Bread & Dunks: we got the whipped ricotta, japanese eggplant, and french onion dip. The french onion dip was my favorite! Such a good mix of flavors, esp if you love truffle. The whipped ricotta was light and airy. The japanese eggplant was a bit more "hearty" and the flavors were great. The bread that came with the dips was so good. Starch: the soup dumpling tortellini and ravioli doppio both were made very well and were both very good. Substance: we got the mapo cabbage, turbot, and pork katsu. The mapo wasn't too spicy but perfectly balanced! The turbot was my personal favorite - the cook on the fish was perfection and the butter sauce was amazing. The pork katsu was cooked perfectly with a nice crunchy outside and well cooked meat on the inside. I do wish there was more sauce for the katsu though. Dessert: Basque butter cake was our personal favorite! The red bean brownie was such a different take on the brownie and it was very good! We opted to get more of the whiskey forward cocktails and you cannot go wrong. The "after dinner drinks" included their take on espresso martini and it was definitely spirit forward but very good. I love that their menu features a lot of what they are able to grow on their roof garden!

    Half chicken à la brasa
    Janelle V.

    Maxwells Trading is one of my new favorites in the city! Every single dish was impeccable. The melding of flavors was unreal! Plus, the service was top notch. They were incredible with allergies.

    Suzuki tartare
    Radhika B.

    Loved everything that we ate here! The ambience is nice too. It's on a quieter street and gives you a feeling like you're not in Chicago when you're inside. The service was great! Everything that we ate was flavorful. The French onion dip with griddled bread was the highlight of our meal. Will definitely go back and try more dishes.

    Linda Y.

    My partner and I celebrated our anniversary here and we had a good time. We started with the Suzuki Tartare and I loved how citrusy this was. It reminds me Southeast Asian laab. We also did the Japanese Eggplant and had a side of Griddle Bread with it. The touch of the herbs added a bright flavor to the savory-ness of the eggplant and the griddle bread reminds me of a thick scallion pancake. The Soup Dumpling Tortellini is actually one of my favorites! It just worked so well. We tried the Mushroom Claypot which seemed like a popular item. It was pretty good and had great umami from the mushrooms, but this one didn't stand out to me as much! The Pork Katsu was cooked perfectly but I wish it was crispier. Nothing stood out on the dessert menu so we went elsewhere. I liked the ambiance of the restaurant and enjoyed how spacious it is so you aren't sitting so close to others. The modern rustic design is also very nice. There is plenty of free street parking available. Overall, it was definitely something new for us and we enjoyed it. I'd be open to possibly returning when the menu potentially updates to a new season!

    Menu on 4/16

    See all

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 2

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Great food and ambiance. Everything was amazing Well deserving of the recent accolades!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Great service, excellent food, and all around fantastic dining experience. Save room for the butter cake!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Geno D.
    146
    2
    0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 6 of 6

    Maxwells Trading Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Maxwells Trading

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 65,278 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Chalet - Crab Cakes

    Chalet

    3.7(196 reviews)
    1.7 miNear North Side
    $$

    I visited Chalet for their new Brunch After Dark experience and really enjoyed it. The atmosphere…read moreis perfect for a night out -- dim lighting, fun neon signs, great music, a beautiful bar, and plenty of cute photo opportunities throughout the restaurant. The food was also a hit. The fried chicken nachos were easily one of my favorites and something I would order again. We also tried the huge brunch board, which came loaded with pancakes, waffles, chicken, eggs, potatoes, bacon, fruit and more. It says it feeds up to three people, but the portions were VERY generous and could easily be shared with a group. We also had the smothered potatoes and several cocktails, and everything we tried was good. The drinks were well made and fit the whole Brunch After Dark vibe perfectly. Overall, I love the idea of being able to have a full brunch experience without having to squeeze it into Saturday or Sunday afternoon.

    Came here for the girl dinner and we luckily had the early reservation because it ended up getting…read morepacked in there. The serving sizes were smaller than what I imagined but still was enough and I cleaned my plate. The garlic parm wings were really good just wish it was 6 vs 4. The drinks were also tasty and glad it was 2 cocktails. Service wasn't really there for me. I've been to this location a couple times to eat and for nightlife and overall it's an okay spot.

    Photos
    Chalet
    Chalet - Crab Cakes

    Crab Cakes

    Chalet - Chips & Guac

    See all

    Chips & Guac

    Arbella - Whipped feta was sooooo good!

    Arbella

    4.4(704 reviews)
    1.7 miRiver North, Near North Side
    $$

    We love Arbella!! Atmosphere inside was great, really large space! We sat at the bar, the…read morebartenders were super friendly and attentive easy to talk to and order from. LOVE the $6 cocktail of the day happy hour (M-F 4-6pm) . Our cocktail of the day was a watermelon lemon drop which was delicious!! Will be coming back next time in Chicago! My local friends new favorite staple bar.

    (Kari's Rating 8.75/10)…read more Came with a friend late on a Friday night after dinner time We were able to be seated almost immediately at a nice little private Cove table. We ordered a flight of whiskey sours, which contained whiskeys from Japan, Vietnam, and Wisconsin. I also was able to order an amaretto sour, which they made with freshly hand beaten egg whites, which was a nice cherry on the top. As far as the whiskey flights go, I think the best one was the Vietnam flight because it had a slightly lemongrass twang and was a little bit lighter than the other two. The heaviest one was the Wisconsin which came with a little bit of a bite at the end, but it still wasn't bad if you're trying to blackout on a $15 budget. I would definitely come back with a larger group this seems like a great place, but is a little bit loud- so if you be prepared to yell or wear earplugs. The bathroom took my a second to find, which should have been intuitive considering it was on the opposite end of where you come in. I blame the lighting as things are already pretty hard to find in the dark, but eventually I made it there-Pat myself on the back.

    Photos
    Arbella - DJ Adam Pecho bringing down the house

    DJ Adam Pecho bringing down the house

    Arbella - Crab rangoon

    Crab rangoon

    Arbella - Special menu espresso martini

    See all

    Special menu espresso martini

    The Dearborn

    The Dearborn

    4.4(2.8k reviews)
    1.9 miThe Loop
    $$

    This was my second visit to The Dearborn, and the food and service were both on point. We ordered…read morethe salmon tataki, fish and chips, Wellington burger, and Midwest fried chicken. Everything was well prepared, but the fried chicken was the standout, especially with the hot sauce adding another level of flavor. The staff stayed attentive throughout dinner and even replaced our plates between rounds, which was a level of service I wasn't expecting. I also respected seeing the owner personally making the rounds, stopping at every table to check on the guests and the food. Calm atmosphere, solid hospitality, and a kitchen that delivers.

    OMG! Walk, run, sprint here to get the FISH N CHIPS THAT ACTUALLY BEAT BOBBY FLAY. The executive…read morechef and now chef partner, Aaron Cuschieri, is absolutely amazingly talented. I am used to really good fish and chips... I've never had better fish and chips than Tom Douglas's Mr. Fish in Seattle, UNTIL NOW!!!! Wow, wow wow wow! Do not pass GO, do not read the menu, just order the darn fish and chips! It might be a whole heart attack on a plate... But it doesn't matter... You can walk all of Chicago and burn it off. I decided to work out before I came here for this big splurge and I'm so glad I did. I can see that this is the theater district... And you could come here before a show fish and chips and have the best night of your entire life! I can't wait to try more of this chef's food! I'm BEYOND INSPIRED! ps great beers here toooooi!

    Photos
    The Dearborn - $12 Martinis for Martini Mondays

    $12 Martinis for Martini Mondays

    The Dearborn - New Spring Menu

    New Spring Menu

    The Dearborn - Spring desserts

    See all

    Spring desserts

    Ema - Salmon bab.

    Ema

    4.3(2k reviews)
    1.8 miNear North Side
    $$

    I LOVED my meal here! Ēma (Ay-mah) brings some glamour and glitz to the Mediterranean dining scene,…read morewith an airy, elevated hotel-lobby feel that still doesn't demand a dress code. Dresscode: Smart Casual / Casual Noise Level: Medium (it gets buzzy after 5:30pm) Thursday night Happy Hour was lively, so it took about 10-15 minutes for someone to come around, but service was attentive once we got going. The food is where Ēma really shines. From the Happy Hour menu, the Charred Eggplant Hummus and Crispy Potatoes were generously portioned and great for sharing. On the main menu, the Indian-Mediterranean fusion Bhel Hummus was a party for my taste buds, while the Hot Honey Halloumi and Chicken Kefta rounded out the table nicely. The halloumi is more of a side than a main, but that sweet-and-salty hot honey combo was chef's kiss. For our finisher, the Chocolate Torte knocked us out. Decadent, delicious and chocolate with lots of depth. Overall, Ēma is an excellent spot to order a bunch of dishes for the table and get an elevated meal without feeling stuffy, and delicious without taking itself too seriously. DO's: - Make a reservation ahead, especially for happy hour 4-6pm - Treat apps like small plates, order 2-3 to sample - Entertain their wine list, they have a lot! - Bring vegetarians here, there are plenty of options DON'Ts: - Dismiss the desert menu. It's fantastic and shareable! - Forget to ask for extra pita with the hummus! - Miss out on the LettuceEats loyalty points (check-in with your server before paying your check)

    This Mediterranean restaurant has a cute, inviting interior with a nice atmosphere, and the service…read morewas very good. The food was presented beautifully and everything looked fresh and clean, but unfortunately, the flavors didn't quite match the presentation. The lamb and beef meatballs were too dry for my taste. The shrimp was okay, but the tomatoes served with it were overly roasted and had some blackened, charred areas that I didn't particularly enjoy. The salad was also fairly mediocre and didn't stand out. Overall, I really liked the ambiance and appreciated the attentive service, but I think the food could use some improvement in both flavor and preparation. A pleasant place visually, but the meal itself was just average for me.

    Photos
    Ema - Ema tables and bar

    Ema tables and bar

    Ema - Tuna & Watermelon*  june 2026.

    Tuna & Watermelon* june 2026.

    Ema - Inside

    See all

    Inside

    Maxwells Trading - newamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...