The food and service is excellent! The restaurant is extremely clean as well! We are traveling through on our way home, and decided this looked good let's stop! And we are glad that we did! Everything tasted fresh and hearty! The salsa bar was by far my favorite thing about this place! It's different, clean, and lets you pick what you'd like! If we ever come through Highway 74 again that way, we will gladly stop in everything is reasonably priced. The service is outstanding and it's a clean little place. read more

Maya’s Mexican Grill - Mexican Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Most delicious enchiladas I've had. They have a salsa bar to pick whatever salsa you prefer. Staff was friendly, quick, and attentive read more

Maya’s Mexican Grill - Las patrias - Mexican Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Really enjoyed this food. Lots of flavor! I talked to a family sitting next to me and they said they had tried every single Mexican restaurant in town and hands down this one was the winner. I ordered the beef biria tacos and a margarita. Tender beef with a consommé on the side. Also this is the first time I have ever received a bowl of pureed beans on the side of the chips prior to the meal. There was a serve yourself salsa bar to go with the chips. The marg was good as well. We are going back. read more

See all

Great service with hot delicious food that's served up fast! All of the servers are very kind and they keep the restaurant very clean and welcoming! The menu is easy to read with all of your favorite Mexican dishes including a variety of flavored margaritas and desserts. One of my favorite things when seated, is that they provide the table with free chips & bean dip! And on top of that, they offer the most delicious & fresh self-serve salsa bar that allows you to choose the right combination for your taste, offering several flavors of salsa from mild to hot! They are closed on Monday's and open Tuesday's-Sunday's. I enjoy the Taco Tuesday specials with the Chicken hard shell taco being my favorite, my husband likes the Beef! Also, it's a fun place to enjoy a birthday dinner! The staff will sing for your birthday and provide a birthday treat! I definitely recommend this place to everyone and give them 5's! read more

Maya’s Mexican Grill - Molcajete, Chips & Bean Dip, Lime Margarita on the Rocks - Mexican Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Food was excellent. Roast beef soup and tongue in green hot sauce. Service was excellent Ambiance was very nice read more

One of my all time favorite Mexican restaurants. The salsa bar is a unique experience. I really enjoy the hot and spicy salsa options. The menu has lots of options. The specials are all great. Service has always been top notch. read more

First time to Maya's for a 1:00 lunch with the girls. My chimichanga with beef and topped with cheese sauce was very good, and the rest of my plate was filled with lettuce, rice, refried beans, and sour cream, served piping hot (a must with Mexican food) Tortilla chips were warm and plentiful and you can select your salsa from the salsa bar. We also ordered the cheese dip to mix it up a bit. Servers and staff were on it, and we had an enjoyable experience at Maya's. Hop on over two doors down to Maya's Sweets for dessert read more

Maya’s Mexican Grill - Maya's is at the end of the Belaire shopping center strip mall - Mexican Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Wow! I didn't have it in me to visit any of the local fast food spots on this exit on my way to Cincinnati. I am so glad I stumbled upon this hidden gem. Server was very friendly, informative, and shared all the house specials with us. The salsa bar is something unique and there are flavors for everyone. The chimichanga and fajitas were incredible and very flavorful! We will definitely stop back by when traveling through. Only thing I recommend is that they add some windows to open up the restaurant. We thought it was closed when we first pulled up. read more

Maya’s Mexican Grill - Fajitas - Mexican Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

So glad I found this place, with the help of positive reviews from Yelpers. I was working in Shelbyville for the day and looking for a new place to try. The employees here were all very friendly and cheerful. The restaurant was very clean and attractive. My server came to my table immediately after I was seated. He brought chips and bean dip, and explained that I could select salsa from the salsa bar, and he described each salsa from mild to very hot. The salsa bar was so nice! It was refrigerated and the salsas were fresh and cold. I tried a few of them and both had excellent flavor. I ordered the veggie burrito, it was huge. Stuffed with sautéed vegetables and covered with a thick layer of cheese. The vegetables included savory mushrooms, fresh broccoli, green peppers, onions and more. The vegetables were perfectly sautéed, the broccoli was bright green and flavorful. Prices are very reasonable and servings are generous. Love this place and plan to return the next time I find myself in Shelbyville. read more

See all

Exlente. La comida muy buena servicio bueno variedades de salsas bun sabor auténtica comida Mexicana read more

Maya’s Mexican Grill - Mexican Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Some of the best food around. All the amazing reviews have me wanting to experiment outside my go to of fajitas. Excellent service every time read more

Amazing food and service! Highly recommend the quesabirrias or street tacos! Will definitely be coming back!

Love this local place. Great food and reasonably priced. Staff super friendly and nice. Definitely recommend this spot. read more

Maya’s Mexican Grill - Torta de asada - Mexican Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Food was very good, fajitas, chimichanga, and enchiladas were very solid. Bean dip and salsa bar was a great twist vs regular Mexican restaurants. The one thing we noticed that really set them apart from ANY restaurant is the cleanliness. Was able to see in the kitchen, spotless. Dining area, spotless. Restroom, spotless. I mean NO areas of dust or debris anywhere. Cleanest restaurant I've ever visited. Great job! read more

Hubby and I used to live in Shelbyville and wanted to have a gathering of friends. Why don't we try that new Mexican restaurant Maya's? So glad we did! Service, drinks, food - fantastic - especially the service. I let them know ahead of time that there'd be 15-20, and people just straggled in one or two at a time. Staff pleasantly accommodated our needs, patiently waiting to take orders among the celebration of friends, and adding seats as needed. Pass the word... this restaurant has friendly service! read more

This was just okay. Expected better from the reviews. Tasted kind of bland. I've definitely had better. The service was good and the staff friendly. read more

I had the Quesabirria tacos. They were so delicious. I recommend this restaurant. Good service and great food. read more

Maya’s Mexican Grill - Quesabirria tacos - Mexican Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Seating is so bad and the wait is quite long meanwhile the chips u have to eat are stale or taste from yesterday

Authentic Mexican food. Bean dip appetizer was very good and had a nice little kick to it. All of our entrees came out hot and delicious and the service was great! read more

Maya’s Mexican Grill - Very clean, super friendly staff. - Mexican Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Everything is fantastic here! From the owners, to the food, service and ambiance! If you come here get the el pastor quesadilla, and the quesa birria tacos! read more

Super friendly Wonderful food Salsa cart And will make fresh guacamole at your table. read more

Maya’s Mexican Grill - Chicken fajita chimichanga and choriqueso. Oh so good! - Mexican Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

Best mexican restaurant in Indiana! Great authentic mexican food, as well as drinks. Service was awesome! the owners are great people and it's also a family ran business. The ambiance was great with real mexican music as well as trending songs. The place was popping around 6 pm on a Thursday night so that was a good sign as well. Overall an amazing mexican restaurant that you should definitely check out!! read more

Best Mexican food I've ever had I got the carne asada fries and I couldn't stop eating I got to fill to eat more but I wanted to keep going the bean dip was amazing with the fresh house made chips the service was fantastic as was the prices I highly recommend this spot if you haven't tried it this is the only Mexican restaurant I will be visiting from now on read more

after a lazy Saturday afternoon and a change of plans, I realized I didn't have dinner plans in place. So I ordered here for me and my kiddos on a whim and I don't regret it! Service was quick. Less than a half hour between me ordering on the phone from home, picking it up, and getting it back home. We got a kids quesadilla, nachos, and veggie fajitas to go. When we got there to pick it up, it was super busy inside! Not a lot of standing room while we waited, but I liked the homey feel of it. Greeted by multiple people making sure we were taken care of. Great atmosphere! There's a tv with soccer on as well and a salsa bar. My veggie fajitas were spot on and my kids loved their nachos and quesadilla. We will definitely be back again! Already making plans for lunch soon. My only wish is that they had black beans as an option! No photos, because I ate it all too quick read more

Yum! The street tacos here are amazing. The price isn't too bad, the stuff here tastes better than Cholulas!

Standout Mexican food. Extensive menu with unique options beyond the usual, at the same price as you'll find with less quality. Bean dip with chips, and the salsa bar make Maya's unique. read more

Not only the best Mexican I've had in Shelbyville, but some of the best I've had. First, the salsa bar! 5 different salsas, from mild to 5 alarm! The food was excellent, prices great, and service was over the top! LOVE! read more

Wow. No doubt, best Mexican restaurant in the Indianapolis area. It's worth the drive just to eat here. The menu isn't unique, but it's executed with perfection. High-quality meat. The array of fresh salsa at the salsa bar was fun and delicious. Prices very reasonable. read more

Amazing service the waiter was so nice and they did a really cool celebration for my sisters birthdays

The food is fantastic, the salsa bar rocks, the service is always quick, friendly, and knowledgeable. The decor is great. What's not to love??? read more

This is the best Mexican food I've had in a long time. The owners and staff are super friendly, and you can tell by the way they interact they appreciate and care about their customers and what they serve. I wish the restaurant was a little bigger but that will not deter me from dining in. Oh, I can't forget the drink review! Their margaritas are outstanding, made fresh everyday! C'mon y'all, show this place lots of love. read more

The staff were great and very welcoming. The food was awesome my husband got the tacos carne asada with rice and beans I got the huevos rancheros also with rice and beans and tortillas ... absolutely delicious! And the service I could go on and on about it, it is outstanding these guys all lend a hand to make sure you've got what you need filling your drinks and things before you ask, awesome! I've never seen anything like it especially these days. Good food AND great service is lacking everywhere else we go across America! But most importantly is the price it is very affordable and this alone will keep me coming back. Because good food and service alone is not enough but the price tag is!!! So it was an all around great experience for us. read more

Best Mexican food in Shelbyville. The food and service was good. We will be back!!!!!!!

Not being from the area, we decided to take a chance and we're not disappointed! Although it felt like we were pretty close to one another, they all made it work. The food and the service were excellent!! Highly recommended! read more

I've been here couple times! Every time I've been here I've had excellent service! Very good food! Had the steak tacos! They have a salsa bar which is awesome! One of the best Mexican restaurants in Shelbyville! Will continue to come here!! read more

New entry for the Mexican cuisine category in Shelbyville, IN. The owner's special touch in serving Ben dip with the table chips and the complimentary salsa bar was a unique twist! The salsa bar had 5 levels of salsa and you can help yourself. For a Mexican restaurant the ambiance was "staid" rather than the usual festive motifs of most places. I understand it was a former family diner type place and Maya's has yet to put their stamp on it. however, I don't think they need to make this place their own...I think they're going to need a bigger space! We came at the regular dinner time and they quickly became packed with customers. The staff was friendly and courteous, checking on everyone frequently but not annoying. And the food? In a word, DELICIOUS. Fresh ingredients, well prepared, plentiful portions and delivered quickly. Will definitely recommend and will go again. We hope Maya's is here to stay! read more

Maya’s Mexican Grill - Mexican Near Me - Shelbyville, Indiana

See all

The food and service was top notch!! Everyone was so friendly and the food was sooooooo flavorful. I will drive again from Cincinnati to eat at this restaurant!! read more

Welcome Maya's! This is a friendly and festive little place with a great menu that has a nice variety of dishes that are different than every other Mexican restaurant -WITH a delicious salsa bar! The service is just as great as the food! read more