McAlister&#x27;s Deli

Justin one of the evening managers Went above and beyond…read morethe call of duty when I lost my to go plate, he replaced it. That was really awesome. I have now come back and the daytime management seems to be wonderful here as well. Salad bar was definitely clean, fresh, & delicious and the sandwiches were piled high. Definitely recommend this place 10 out 10. :)

Fantastic lunch yesterday........simply the best. My wife ordered the Beefeater, which was cooked…read moreto perfection on one of the best rolls I have ever tasted. I had the Reuben, piled high with delicious corned beef and saurkraut that was actually sour as it is supposed to be. Definitely give this place a go, and I am planning on coming back and trying more of their offerings!

Jason's Deli New Yorker pastrami/ brisket

See all

Build Your Own Salad

The Honey Baked Ham Company

3.5(13 reviews)

1.3 mi

This is a beautiful store. So clean and organized. Always great. Friendly staff that are always…read morehelpful and very kind. The food is so fresh and always made to perfection. Can't say enough about this hidden gem in Fayetteville AR Fiesta Square. I also love getting holiday meats and sometimes meals here. The whole crowd loves it all. A special little spot for lunch during a busy week.

Arrives at 7:55 and the door was unlocked so I walked right in the threshold. Instead of saying"we…read moreopen at 8am but you are more than welcome to wait here inside we open up." He instead said, "we don't open until 8." And I asked so I need to go outside...." He said yes" and walked away." Thr. Proceeded to go in and Drink a beverage and laughing and talking with workers. This generation is unbelievable and it's hardly believable that this is the United States.

See all

Schlotzsky's

3.1(46 reviews)

1.9 mi

Good sandwiches. Clean. Good service. They aren't reinventing the wheel and they don't have me up…read moreall night thinking about their sandwiches, but I'll definitely visit again. It's reliably good. Two thumbs up.

Service with a smile, great! Love the Original still. The best. BUT will no longer get the flat…read morebread. After the last three orders, less and less toppings and the quality of toppings not good at all. Can't recommend the flatbread anymore. Used to be an awesome menu item.

See all

641.Deli

5.0(1 review)

4.4 mi

Tonight's Fayetteville Public Library Foundation used the catering services from the 641 Deli for…read moreabout 75 patrons prior to the reading by NY Times Best Selling Author Taylor Jenkins Reid. Chef Jed Smith and his assistant chef Amon Easley prepared a very delightful buffet of party foods, including some gluten free choices. Their presentation and style was very well executed.

Here is a look at the offerings today for a quick grab-and-go lunch.

See all

641 Deli head chef and manager Jed Smith with his assistant Amon Easily stand with their food assembled

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.8(16 reviews)

0.1 mi

I ordered ahead because the app said my sandwich would be ready at 6:01 PM, so I showed up right on…read moretime. It wasn't ready. By 6:10, I asked about it and was told my ticket had been cut up. What really annoyed me was that they could still see my order on the screen, yet no one followed up on it, they just gave up on the order instead of making it. I was then told they hadn't even started it, and I didn't get my sandwich until around 6:22 PM, missing a good chunk of the Bears game. The sandwich itself was really good, no complaints there. This review is strictly about the lack of follow-through. I usually have smoother experiences at Cheba Hut or Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe. The atmosphere was okay, I mean it was a jersey mikes so you kinda know what it is.

WTF HAVE YOU DONE? This $11 plus tax tuna sandwich is now tiny its not what we have gotten for the…read morelast 3 years, a chunk is missing and most likely used for a kids meal. This is B.S.. Was warned when you sold out things would go down hill and looks like that's happening. I won't be ordering from a dishonest place that cuts my sandwich smaller and is literally all bread a scoop of tuna.. DONT GO OR CHECK IT BEFORE YOU LEAVE... THEY WANT YOU TO HAVE A MEAL OF BREAD...

See all

Harps Food Stores Bakeries

4.4(9 reviews)

3.5 mi

Oh, it's good. You can guarantee here that's what you're gonna hear. Have a great selection of lots…read moreof things good food, household items, fresh deli fresh cooked foods that are prepared and ready to take home plus they have a Dunkin' Donuts inside the store and it's just an overall great neighborhood marketplace. One of my favorite harps anywhere.

Great deli chips, veggies, and friendly employees who were very helpful when looking for items as…read morewell as when checking out.

See all

Firehouse Subs

2.7(23 reviews)

1.0 mi

Person I'm assuming was the manager warned that the whole crew was new. Ordered two regular…read moresandwiches, one on garlic bread. Got charged for garlic bread but didn't get it. Sandwiches were sloppy, messy and falling apart. Bag and boxes COVERED in grease or oil, I'm not even sure. Took easily 20 minutes for cold cuts and veggies on bread? I know they remade it multiple times since I could hear the commentary. Tried to call customer service but got redirected to a website. Awful experience.

I am not going to mention names because I figure it will get people in trouble. I have visited both…read morelocations in Fayetteville. But on one visit, a man in a firehouse subs uniform came in and started yelling at the staff, calling them curse words and making a scene. This not only created a hostile work environment, it also made a hostile environment for the customers. I was going to report this person to the owner, so I asked a staff member who he was but he WAS the owner! I understand firehouse subs is a franchise, but since I don't know which store this unprofessional and childish person owns, I am boycotting Firehouse Subs.

See all

Harps Food Stores Bakeries

4.0(7 reviews)

3.5 mi

I've been gone to this harps for many years. this one and Elkins is closer to me. But Angela king…read moreused to be her name, she's been there a long time, she's a cashier, she so sweet and always helpful and everybody in that store is so nice, that. And when I go in there, they ask me if I need anything. I get money orders, Dr. Pepper, food donuts used to get alcohol, but I quite long ago, but this is a very good store the people that complain about it I don't get it, I guess they aint got nothing better in life. To do Thank you. For being there and it's always clean

My daughter's 1st birthday was coming up, and I knew we would need a small smash cake for her, and…read morea larger sheet cake for guests. I also knew it wasn't in the party budget to order from the usual pricey bakery that's popular in town (rhymes with Schmik's.) So I trotted off to Harp's and placed my order. I didn't have a specific design in mind but I had taken a printed napkin with me to show them the colors I had in mind. I just wanted something that was similar and would complement it. I was overjoyed when I picked the cakes up...they were beautiful! And the designer had perfectly replicated the design and colors from the napkin. Both cakes were delicious as well. My one year old destroyed her smash cake, and guests ate every last bite of the sheet cake. I doubt I will ever order another cake from "Schmik's" again. Harp's is way more affordable and just as delicious, if not more so.

See all

Beautiful sheet cake for my daughter's birthday. This fed 25 people and was only $25.

Harps Food Stores

3.7(15 reviews)

4.7 mi

Better than the alternative stores in the area, hometown feel and decent service always well stockedread more

We enjoy shopping at Harp's. The producers usually fresh, bakery bread is good, and the deli is…read moreexcellent. They have a good variety of products and prices are reasonable.

Carmel apples

Pretzels

See all

Store

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Amanda W.

6

5

0

19 years ago

McAlister. Mc "A" lister? I certainly did not feel like an A lister. My club sandwich looked like a kabob. Your sweet tea is good. What is all the random shit on the walls? A tricycle? What? I know you are in the south but it doesn't mean you should look like a ransacked tornado prone trailer park. Damn. read more

Noc G.

0

1

0

5 years ago

My son can't get his w2 taxes, because the GM is holding a grudge against him. He left McAllisters because they didn't follow covid cdc regulations. He wasn't fired, left on his own free will; yet Randa Payne, is withholding his taxes, out of spite; when she doesn't wear a mask herself! read more

Lauren P.

0

11

1

1 year ago

Hi it's me again, back to give you another poor rating because you deserve it!!!! I'll be praying to Satan that anyone who works for this restaurant has exactly what they deserve come to them. read more

Donna B.

37

9

6

11 years ago

Can't ever go wrong with a lunch here! Love their salads! The service is excellent; the staff comes back to your table to check on you and refill your drink. read more

Rebecca F.

5

6

0

8 years ago

Always so fresh tasting. I love their menu. I wish it was faster, but I can't expect this good fast.

Aaron E.

0

5

4

5 years ago

Still waiting for my w2 to be given to me. Randa will not release it to me, out of spite.

Karen D.

0

8

0

12 years ago

Excellent food! Have always had good service and the food has always been fantastic!

Ryan H.

Elite 17

37

114

2

13 years ago

Love the salads. Love the sandwhiches. Quick service. Friendly staff.

McAlister's Deli - delis - Updated September 2026

People who viewed McAlister's Deli also viewed

Newk's Eatery

3.6

(93 reviews)

Always good! Nice selection of sandwiches and salads,…read morefriendly staff, yummy food! Recommended!

The food was great. The service was fast. And it was nice and quiet. Apparently my three sentences…read morewere not enough. It's a great place to eat.

Potbelly

3.4

(14 reviews)

The sandwiches were good The salad was very full…read moreOne of our sandwiches...the BLTA was missing avocado...That was disappointing

Two of us, I was served the most disgusting salad I have ever had! The lettuce and cucumbers had…read morebeen frozen so the were wilted and some of the lettuce was brown and slimy. The white bread for sandwich my partner had was stale! I showed the salad to someone there, offered to make another one, which why would I??? Same nasty lettuce? He didn't really seem to care.

Schlotzsky's

3.1

(46 reviews)

Good sandwiches. Clean. Good service. They aren't reinventing the wheel and they don't have me up…read moreall night thinking about their sandwiches, but I'll definitely visit again. It's reliably good. Two thumbs up.

Service with a smile, great! Love the Original still. The best. BUT will no longer get the flat…read morebread. After the last three orders, less and less toppings and the quality of toppings not good at all. Can't recommend the flatbread anymore. Used to be an awesome menu item.

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.7

(61 reviews)

Mini tuna was great! Service was excellent as everyone was so nice and gave great advice on adding…read morecondiments. I was a little leery about ordering the tuna but it was fresh & as good as mine! The bread was fresh & smelled so good. I will definitely try Jersey Mikes when I get back to Texas. Oh, the root beer was wonderful.

This location is our go to place for subs. Consistently delivers or pick up subs as ordered. Food…read moreis fresh. Rosemary parm bread is delicious! Staff friendly and helpful. Dining room is limited but spacious. The prices are reasonable and portions generous.

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe

4.2

(89 reviews)

Food is as advertised. Tasty and toasted too. Toppings are plentiful and varied. I personally go…read morewith the Vegetarian. Oh and I drive over from Fayettville, 13 miles on the 49.

Had great sandwiches and salads today. Staff were friendly and helpful. Italian is really good…read moreand I had a turkey/ham that hit the spot. Wife had the spinach salad with balsamic which she enjoyed. Sandos are light toasted and full of flavor. Definitely recommend.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

3.3

(102 reviews)

I always enjoy eating here. Comfort food I suppose…read more Here tonight because of a death in the family and just wanted to sit down and eat without having to think real hard about what we want. Good server and service. Food was good as always.

This is the new inflation lasagna its 2 layers, nothing like is use to be and not even close to the…read morepicture they advertise. UODATE- Tried again on 27/2025 Was given mixed noodles instead of cheese ravioli YUCK.. Always hard bread when getting take out and the pie was dried on top. To go is not worth it here, I think they give old and stale food..

Danger Dave’s

3.9

(32 reviews)

Yet another place my oldest found for us per my "dog-friendly" restaurant request while I drove…read more My daughters, our dog, and I lunch dined outside on the lawn patio of Danger Dave's in Bentonville, AR on a very hot July 24, 2025. The tree shade and a can of Outlaw Light brew were much reprieve. The employee who served as our cashier, bartender, and waiter gave our dog a treat when we ordered. Order inside. Pay. Receive a buzzing pager to pick up your food. + Shrimp Po' Boy ($14) with a side of pasta salad (my youngest loved this) + Some kind of bbq sandwich with a side of chips... my oldest daughter must have loved it because she only offered our dog a piece of meat! + Cali Chicken sandwich with avocado, chicken, herb mayo, provolone, red onions, & sprouts ($12) paired with a pasta salad. Scrumptious! Live music every Friday night. Some street parking. Otherwise there are several parking lots within walking distance in the area - at least one was free after 5 pm. Cool place with fun vibes. RATING BREAKDOWN Food: 5 | Service: 5 | Ambiance: 4 | Price: 4

This place couldn't be any better if they tried. My husband and I had just pulled into Bentonville…read moreafter a long day at work and then a 3.5 hour drive from KC. We were exhausted and this was a spot that was on my list to hit up while we were there. Walking up it looked like a small, old house that was decorated with tiki torches and lights. Our kind of place. When we got inside there was fun music playing, tons of people in line, a chalkboard menu with drinks and bites and fun, talkative bartenders. We grabbed some food and ordered drinks and headed out back. There was a DJ that evening and a lively dance floor. Tables were set up in the back yard space and it was hard for us to find a spot! We finally squeezed in with a few other people at a picnic table and ended up making some really fun friends! The food and drinks were fantastic and the whole atmosphere was just so fun. Highly recommend this being a top 5 spot on your list if you're visiting Bentonville!

Lennys Grill & Subs

4.1

(65 reviews)

Kayla and the staff were super friendly. The sandwhiches here are very delicious, generously…read moreproportioned and the softest bread. I would definitely recommend this place to sandwhich enthusiasts!

Good subs. Husbands had a cold sandwich and I had a hot. The bread was fresh . Would definitely…read morego again!

Slim Chickens

3.1

(64 reviews)

Always consistent and tasty. Local business doing it right…read more If you haven't eaten here get a tenders plate like the Slim's plate. Slim's sauce is awesome. Their salads are surprisingly good too! Best on the west side of town.

Mike at the drive thru is an asshole. He talked over me the entire time I tried to order. He…read morewouldn't let me talk. Then when I got to the window the other employee was being rude too. I asked how much the total was because they didn't tell me, then they told me "$20.08", and I gave them $21 and said keep the cha-. Then, they closed the window on me mid sentence, and when she tried to give me change back I said "I said keep the change", and they said nothing in return. Then when I got my food, and I was checking my receipt, she said "It's all there". So these people are all just fucking rude as hell. Good food though.

Taziki's Mediterranean Cafe - Fayetteville

3.7

(104 reviews)