I'll add same thing most reviewers are saying "s-l-o-w". They should teach servers to not say "gonna be a bit of a wait, kitchen backed up", "thanks for your patience". Fix the problem, and you can quit with the BS excuses. Trivia nite, locals were loving it, so it was busy. I had a decent sandwich but not worth the wait. Server was friendly enough, but I'm looking for food, not friends. read more

McCall's Tavern - Bars Near Me - Lady Lake, Florida

The pizza is horrible. Good place for a drink and to listen to a band. The food is average at best - fried in canola oil basket food. - just standard bowling alley food. read more

What can you improve on? Everything! Absolutely everything! We sat on the patio, ordered off the QR code and waited over an hour for a cheeseburger, club sandwich and a chicken sandwich. The burger was okay as well as the club sandwich. The chicken sandwich was overcooked and had been under a warmer too long. Not impressed. Ordered the garlic Parmesan fries which didn't happen. We only finally got our order when we asked for our money back. The prices aren't bad if you get what you order and in a timely manner. Not impressed at all! It was nice to sit on the patio and listen to the music in the square. That's the most positive I can say. ***Additional note***As we were getting ready to leave, I was brought an order of the garlic Parmesan fries! read more

A bit of a confusing place. You walk up and it's seat yourself. That's fine and all but there's no servers to be seen......anywhere. So I walk back up and see a QR code to use to place an order. It asks for my table number but nothing is on the table. So I walk inside and see a salt and pepper holder with a number on it, quite a few actually, somewhat hiding on the hostess stand. I grab it and start placing my order but then a server comes out to take my order. After we order (burger, quesadilla, kids hot dog, kids pizza) it took over an hour for the food. The kicker.....my kids orders weren't correct. We got the "trivia night, kitchens backed up" excuse I read in the comments. Took 30 mins for the check after asking. All in all about a 1:45-2hr experience.....SLOW. read more

Wow, talk about a bad experience! Bad service! Bad food! Bad atmosphere! They were short handed and the bad attitude bartender didn't help the situation. She appeared to be having a bad day and it showed. When we finally got waited on it took at least 30 minutes to get our drink. Our waitress had to make them as the bar tender was having a meltdown and doing nothing. When we finally got our food it was bad. We will never go back even though our waitress apologized for the service! read more

Five Stars as long as Adam or Beverly are working... Great place Great people Management needs to be more involved when events or crowded atmosphere as the wait time is discouraging... read more

Service was MIA - could have easily dined and dashed after several attempts to ask our waitress for the bill Wing were not as extra crispy as asked for Beef on weck was okay - roll had too much salt and no caraway seeds We are from buffalo ny so we know what we are talking about The waitress made excuses that she got busy because trivia started an hour after we arrived read more

We wanted to give this place a second chance as our first visit was not the best. Wednesday evening ...6:00 pm. Seated outside and waited a very long time for food. We ordered after another table by us and got part of our total order ahead of them (mind you this was a 45 min wait for even that). I guess when music bingo is happening inside (which we didn't know), don't plan on eating. Ridiculous. Our food was not priority. Tables around us that ordered before us are leaving. Never even got their food. How we got some of ours is a mystery. We paid for what we ate and drank, but left unsatisfied. I feel bad for the waitress. She was nice, but I'm sure got screwed on tips. Won't be back. ***Even the wait to pay our bill was ridiculous. Good thing we are honest people. My husband had to go in and find the waitress to pay after a long wait. How do you stay in business???????? Another waitress gave my husband a huge attitude while he was waiting to pay. C'mon....really? And while that was happening, another customer came to sit outside because he was tied of waiting for what was 50 minutes for his order inside! He said they only had two waitresses....ok, but then tell us BEFORE YOU SEAT US. OR DONT SEAT US! read more

Nasty nasty nasty. People love the free meal on their birthdays so I've been for numerous parties. The food is not my genre but people love the fried chicken. Jam night is fun however so McCall's is a mixed bag sort of establishment. read more

Great fried chicken but don't go there on Mondays, they have terrible old people trying to sing Karaoke! It's awful!

Arrived with a party of 5 and were seated outside. 3 Ordered cocktails but everyone ordered water. Cocktails arrived but no waters. 5 Minutes later 2 waters arrived but still missing 3, and so it goes. Food ordered and arrived but no silverware. Server was unresponsive so I went inside to retrieve our own but none was up front where it should be so I headed to the kitchen to get it for our table. Several other tables were also complaining about the same things to who we think was the manager but he was unresponsive as well. Just an overall bad experience. Please save yourself and go elsewhere. read more

I walked in & stood at the hostess desk waiting to be seated.  There were at least 4 servers walking around pretending not to see someone was waiting to be seated. I was not aware it was open mike night.  The host was good, the others, not so much... I ordered the Ruben & a beer. The beer was served in a timely manner but the Ruben took at least 30 minutes to assemble. The corned beef in the Ruben looked like fried bologna, was tough & tasted worse. All in all, it was a bad experience. I couldn't finish the Ruben & had to leave because of the people screaming into the mike. My server, Linda was good. read more

Food isn't good , it's like being in the North Pole so cold in there . I moved from New England to get away from the cold and this place is like freezer read more

Worst restaurant we've been to in Florida. Fried cauliflower took almost an hour and it was horrible made my wife not feeling well. The server was a real nice girl not her fault. read more

The food quality has really gone down under new management.....only thing I will eat there is salad...let's face it, anyone can make a salad. Used to eat there all the time, until they were always out of foods on menu, and drinks are often not available....what bar runs out of beer, gin, and even ice tea before 5:00 pm ? The good servers are mostly gone....should one have to ask for napkins, silverware, straw , etc.? read more

I used to like their food, even though the ambiance is less desirable (dungeon). But the new ownership has destroyed the menu and are charging $4.99 for an iced tea. One in our party was looking forward to the fried bologna sandwich (no longer on menu). I asked to have onion on the burger (was told they have no onion). I think it is obvious why there were only 2 other people in the restaurant at lunchtime. Last time our group will eat there read more

Well, not a particularly great experience tonight. We set ourselves out on the patio since it was a pleasant night and the waitress said find a table that was clean. we saw they were busy so we ordered via there app on the menu since it said scan to order and pay here QR code. After about 20 min, we went in to the bar to ask for our drinks at least. They brought them out 5 minutes later. About 10 minutes after that, they brought out our dinner, the fries were cold and my wife's nacho order was supposed to be without jalapeños but guess what it had. Also it came out in white cartons. We asked for it to be replaced. Not happy with the service. Be careful not to order with the QR code. read more

Their old menu is much better than the current one. Their service is extremely slow. I go there because I play trivia and we have to purchase food. We have had food come out after we were done playing. They need another person cooking on trivia nights, and maybe another waitress serving. read more

Chris 1 contribution Only go if you have plenty of time to wait! Feb 2025 * couples We arrived around 5:15 and we sat at the bar. You can tell they are understaffed so we took that into consideration. Our bartender Amanda was great but she was being pulled multiple times to wait on patio tables. Here's were we started having issues. We ordered flatbread and a pork tenderloin sandwich. This took OVER 45 minutes (closer to an hour) to receive our food. AND it was not what we ordered, tried to order some shots and was told by the other bartender that Amanda would have to handle. Mind you Amanda is running outside every other minute. The other bartender did give us ourshots but we had to tell Amanda to add our shots to our bill. We were going to a show so time wasbecoming an issue. Got the bill and paid without really reviewing, shame on me. When I looked at the bill the next day I noticed they charged us $13 then $8.49 for 2 of our cocktails...mind you they were the exact same cocktail. Being a former bartender I completely understand being short staffed but there was no communication about how backed up the kitchen was, had we known we would have gone somewhere else. It did not make for a relaxing dinner before the show. Would have to think long and hard before going back. read more

Waited 25 minutes at table. Waitresses walked past us. Not one of them acknowledged us. We were sitting outside. Went in to ask for someone but not one employee was in sight. read more

McCall's Tavern - Outside table at McCall's Tavern - Bars Near Me - Lady Lake, Florida

We were here on a Tuesday night, which is jam night. The band was pretty pathetic. They let people come up and sing and play their instruments, their abilities were below par. The band should be smarter about who they let play and sing and when they allow them to do so. Our waitress lost our tab and caused us to wait an extra 5 to 10 minutes because she couldn't find it. She knew what we ordered and she searched everywhere high and low for the check, but I don't see that it's right to make the customer wait because you don't know what you're doing. I won't return unless they get a new house band that plays well. read more

Our server Linda suggested the fried chicken...it was excellent! She was too! If you look online the menu is the same but she explained the place was sold about 2 years ago and they can't change the website so she gave us a second menu with added items. read more

The ambiance of this tavern was very welcoming. The beers were cheap and the bar tender was great! We will go back! read more

McCall's Tavern - a can of beer on the bar - Bars Near Me - Lady Lake, Florida

First yelp post and I am sorry it is a negative one. Waited 45 minutes for a table but they were busy so ok. Sat down ordered drinks and did not get those for 40 minutes. After nearly two hours waiting for our food we were so frustrated we left cash on the table for our drinks and walked out. I've never done that before and felt guilty for doing it but at some point you have to draw the line. Will not be back. read more

District manager was very rude and denied her customers an option to use that is a safe and cheap way to get home when they have had too much to drink. read more

Absolutely terrible service rude manager rude bartender horrible food. Never been so disrespected.

10, for sure. I've had several reservations for 20-25 twice monthly. I'm going on my 4Th, why because you do an incredible job! Thanks so much! read more

I have eaten here twice. They are known for their fried chicken and IMO it really is great. You also know that it takes 20 minutes to get an order of fried chicken. They even tell you that. Yesterday we went back to Mccalls. Looking forward to their fried chicken. We got there at 6:20 The restaurant was not full. After waiting 20+ minutes without having a waitress even approach us, we left and went elsewhere. It was very disappointing to not even be offered a drink or menu within that timeframe. Sadly, I will rethink ever going there again. BTW they have entertainment every night except Wednesdays. I am reviewing their service on a Wednesday night. read more

I was looking for fried chicken for a friend. Saw several not so good reviews but decided to try McCalls. Good decision. The chicken was excellent. Servers were very friendly and it seemed like a great neighborhood type bar and restaurant. read more

This used to be our favorite spot in The Villages. They had great lunch specials and chicken.... not any more... new owners got rid of all that is good...no more lunch specials and the prices got hiked way up. And our go-to for the best fried chicken now is the Metro Diner. Sad to see the place deteriorate read more

Service was terrible. 40 minutes to get a glass of warm wine and one and a half hours to get two hotdogs! Dirty tables!

My Reuben sandwich was good, drinks were pretty good, servers were very strapped, kitchen behind, and although the live performer was excellent, the music was a little loud. (Couldn't communicate with server or others at table.) read more

It's been awhile so we thought we would try it. Actually not bad. The menu definitely has changed. The chicken sandwich was ok. Too much mayonnaise on the sandwich, made the roll fall apart. Lots of fries came with it. Service was good. The pork sandwich I was told was very good. Service was good. read more

Beef on a Weck was awful. Roast beef was like Rubber and tasted like rubber. Extremely slow service.

I've been going there for years, I just got back after being gone for seven months and was craving McCall's chicken without a doubt this use-to be the best chicken around absolutely after they changed hands. it was the worst chicken wings I've ever had in my life. I'm not sure how you can order garlic and Parmesan chickens and they are tasteless and over cooked. I know it's under new ownership, but at the rates are going it'll be closed within a year read more

Came here due to the rave reviews for their fried chicken. It did not disappoint. Husband said it was the best fried chicken he's ever had! The chicken dinner is 4 pieces of chicken with 2 sides for $13.99. The breading on the chicken was super yummy and the chicken came out hot and crispy. Just like we like it! We did the mashed potatoes and the corn medley. We shared the meal and added a side salad for $3.99. The corn medley wasn't what we thought. It also included black beans and red peppers. But it was good. We also had 2 beers for $3.50 each Our total bill was $27. Great meal and great deal! read more

McCall's Tavern - Chicken dinner that includes 2 sides with lots of choices - Bars Near Me - Lady Lake, Florida

Great Fried Chicken Dinner, juicy and hot, didn't wait that long for the meal either. The server was very attentive, polite (Doris) Don't pass this Restaurant up! read more

Horrible. Love coming here for the food but service is horrible. This evening, waited 25 minutes outside and never acknowledged. Saw a waiter and let them know we were outside. Still not acknowledged. They were not overly busy compared to typical Monday evening. Looked like plenty of wait staff compared with number of customers. Might be a hard sell to go back. read more

My wife and I went to McCall's on a Friday evening. They were not very busy. Service was extremely slow. The waitresses were waiting tables in the restaurant and taking orders from bowlers at the adjoining bowling alley. We waited 45 minutes for our food after ordering. The waitress told us 3 times only a few more minutes. I had the turkey dinner. The turkey, mashed potatoes and stuffing were about what you would get from a supermarket frozen food section. I do not recommend and will not be back. read more

They have authentic Beef on Weck sandwiches here (Very hard to find outside western NY). It gets high marks just for that. It's my little oasis of home in the Villages and one of the few places in town that's not a corporatized cookie-cutout hedge fund investment. Come watch the bills games here in the fall. read more

McCall's Tavern - Beef on weck. Not easy to find outside western NY - Bars Near Me - Lady Lake, Florida