I stopped in most of the jewelers in Salt Lake City looking for something fairly specific with a limited timeframe. The folks running this place are a family affair and were very helpful and accommodating. I feel they gave me a pretty decent deal too. After looking around at the remaining other shops I came back and purchased the item. It needed to be set into another piece they had in inventory. It was ready early the next day. They earned my business and I will likely come back here in the future. In short I am very pleased with the service and the piece. read more

I popped in to take a look and get my ring size. Great selection of jewelry. Sandra was very sweet and helpful. I was impressed with their wall of married couples they displayed! read more

See all

I couldn't be happier with our experience with McKay! After a sketchy experience at another local jeweler, we went to McKay to design my engagement ring. They educated us immediately about the clarity, cut, and color of diamonds. This made us realize the other jeweler had greatly over quoted us for a very low quality diamond. McKay was so patient with us, extremely fast with the process, and always reached out to us when the new changes to the design were ready. I asked them to make several changes to the ring design and they were so kind and patient throughout the entire process. They genuinely made my dream ring, and found us a nearly perfect diamond for a fair deal. I will always recommend Mckay to anyone I know! Thank you guys so much! read more

See all

McKay Diamonds never misses! I had my wedding band crafted here and just had another ring made from an antique family cameo. Absolutely slayed it! I'm so happy with the service here and I will continue going back as long as I'm in Salt Lake City! read more

McKay Diamonds - Wedding band and Cameo ring - Jewelry Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

McKay Diamonds made me an absolutely stunning engagement ring for my fiance. Shopping with them was hands down the best customer service experience I have ever had. Joe, Kim, Sandra, and Alan were fantastic from the start. Over the course of several months they taught me tons about diamonds, gold, and ring crafting, and went through several ring design changes with me, without question. Joe is a talented jeweler, and provided insight and customization that cannot be found online. They had a collection of beautiful stones and rings, and he could custom make any design I could want. Both in person and over email, they were incredibly responsive, honest, and helpful. I had met with several jewelers/stores in SLC, and they were hands down the best. They run an amazing family business and provide really personalized service. They also offer a lifetime warranty, including cleanings, resizing, and maintenance. If you are looking for a custom ring, this is absolutely where you should go! We will be returning for our wedding bands in the future. read more

McKay Diamonds - Jewelry Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

I really can't express my gratitude enough for what Mckay Diamonds did for me. I came in after trying to replace my lost diamond in my engagement ring through insurance with another jewelry store. It had ended up being 3 weeks of me calling multiple times to see if they had even ordered me a stone yet, which they never did. They just kept promising me that it would be done by "the end of the weekend" and then just never called me, leaving me pretty upset in the wake of an already unfortunate experience: losing my diamond. I came into McKay and told them what happened, and they were immediately sympathetic and eager to resolve my bad experience. They instantly had a diamond that was the perfect fit already in store, gave me all their contact information and kept my ring to start working on. Just barely a day later, my ring was ready and so much more beautiful than it even was before. They made sure I had my beautiful ring good as new before I left to travel home to Christmas, something I thought was going to be impossible. They worked with my insurance with absolutely no issue, and were AMAZING at communicating quickly and professionally. This lovely business is a reminder of how kind people can be to one another. read more

The diamond in my ring fell out so I took it to McKay's to have it repaired. When it was done, I don't remember it looking this sparkly brand new. I am very pleased with the work. When I picked it up the son of the owners helped me he was funny, professional and polite. If I ever need a jeweler again I will 100% go back there. No wonder they've been in business for so long. Highly recommend them! read more

McKay Diamonds - Jewelry Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

I have been here several times (and so has my mom) for a variety of reasons: buying new jewelry, fixing or resizing jewelry, as well as designing new pieces from an old piece and have always received top notch service and end products. The owners of this store are lovely, knowledgeable people and I love to give them my business. read more

I have been taking my jewelry to Joe, the owner of McKay diamonds, when he was the owner of the White House in Taylorsville, Utah. I trust the work he does with my most valuable jewelry. I have never had someone take such care to repair it so meticulously and perfectly as Joe. I live in st. George Utah and there are many good jewelers here, but they are only good. Joe at McKay Diamonds on Regent Street in Salt Lake is the only place I will go to buy or repair my jewelry. He is very honest, he won't fix something that doesn't need repair, he charges the most fair prices even after all these years and he is truly gifted at his work. It is a family business (I can't remember the family name) but his wife is equally astute at what she does for the Company as is Joe. It is friendly and welcoming. Just a very pleasant experience. He fixes the smallest pieces to the most elegant and expensive pieces. Parking on regent street looks tricky but you can park directly in front of the store on the little bricks. If those spaces are occupied, there is a parking garage almost next door and they will validate. As you can tell I highly recommend this store. read more

This place is absolutely great! I needed batteries replaced in my two watches and it was inexpensive and fast! One battery replacement was only $15 And the other had a battery leak and the cleaned, added a new gasket, and new battery for only $75 I was very satisfied and definitely recommend this place. On top of that the staff was friendly and helpful. I will definitely be going back. read more

Ultra exceptional craftsmanship is the only phrase I could come up with to describe my experience with this jeweler. If possible, a ten star rating would still not express my gratitude for the work performed on my loved one's platinum piece. All of the positive reviews on this site led me here and this review is quite simply validation of every positive statement expressed. Thank you McKay and Yelp for making my decision stress free! read more

Amazing local jewelry store with the kindest owners. Beautiful selection and store. Highly recommend!

I had a special antique ring that needed a diamond replaced and resizing. I reached out to various well-rated jewellers in the area (McKay, Morgan, Shane Co, AAA) and McKay was the only one who bothered responding to my inquiry. They were incredibly professional and did an amazing job with my ring! The owners were very friendly and helpful. 10/10 read more

We purchased our wedding rings from a different jeweler in Salt Lake. My ring was a bit snug when we bought it. Because my hands have a tendency to swell, I really needed to get my wedding rings resized. I was concerned about who to take my rings to. If I would need to leave the rings to have them resized, and if they were honest! My diamond is a .50 k flawless diamond that had been in my husbands family for years. I kept searching the internet for a quality jeweler in Salt Lake. The one with the highest rating was McKay Jewelers. So, we decided to pay them a visit! I had them do the resizing and also soldier the two rings together. We picked up the rings 2 days later. The work was perfect! My rings were just like new again and fit perfectly ! The owners are very nice and easy to deal with. We now have a reliable jeweler for future needs! Big thanks!! read more

I have found my jeweler for life! The jewelry is gorgeous and one-of-a-kind! I am so thankful I was able to meet these wonderfully kind folks! I needed a ring resized and the jeweler was willing and able to do it within 15 minutes! I was amazed! He took such good care of the ring, it is perfect now. He even offered to check the prongs on my other ring. While I waited I was able to talk with (his daughter?) who was warm and friendly, it made my quarantine day! Also, Price is Right was on the TV in the office, I mean, great people! read more

I had a ring that needed to be resized from a 8.5 to a 9.5 and they resized it perfectly on the spot in 1 minute fit $30. They also said I was able to come back in within 30 days to adjust it for free if it still felt too tight. They were really nice, very quick, and affordable. I highly recommend. UPDATE 9/1/2019 I recently stopped in to size my ring up to a 10 from a 9.5 and was surprised to be told it was $60 this time. Same adjustment, double the price. Seems a bit odd. read more

If you haven't figured it out yet, buying a diamond engagement ring at McKay is a great decesion. Joe recommended we buy our diamond (emerald cut) onlne at Blue Nile to get the best diamond for our money. We narrowed it down to a few diamonds and he helped us make the final decesion. From there we discussed the type of engagemnt ring we wanted him to make. Joe was very easy to talk with and guided us through the decesion process. We always felt like we were in control of the design and he did a great job steering us to the right decesions for our ring style. Simply said, the ring turned out great. I would recommend Joe @ McKay to anyone looking for a diamond in Utah. read more

McKay Diamonds - Jewelry Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

I needed to get my ring resized and they were able to get it back to me in 24 hours. You can't even tell it's ever been worked on. If I ever need work done on my ring I would definitely come back. read more

McKay Diamonds - Jewelry Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

My fiancé and I spent a whole day going to several jewelry stores in Salt Lake City. We selected McKay Diamonds because their reviews were fantastic. Now we know why! Shortly after arriving Joe the jeweler came out and was very personable, knowledgeable and direct. He helped us design the perfect ring and told us that he personally is the jeweler that would be building this ring for us. He gave us a quote on the spot. All the other stores took at least a week to get with their ring builders and get back to us with a quote. By then Joe had built our ring and it was guaranteed; if we didn't like the ring, he would build one we did like! We were not obligated to purchase the ring unless we liked it! All of this was with no money down, just simply a phone number! When we returned to see the engagement ring it was beautiful and he had upgraded the diamond but did not charge us for it. He stuck with the quote and gave us a certificate showing the ring was worth more than we paid for it! Unbelievable customer service here. We returned to have the ring resized a week later and he shortened a necklace that was purchased elsewhere for free. All this in about 15 minutes while we waited. All at no charge. Ring resizing or any adjustments to it are free for life. We will definitely recommend Mckay Diamonds! read more

My soon to be husband and I met with Sandra and Joe to plan our wedding rings. Mine is completed and I am SO IN LOVE WITH IT! From the initial meeting, it only took about 2 weeks (less) to complete. He is now working on the groom's ring which should be done shortly. Sandra and Joe are amazing people, they are both really friendly and down to earth, not your typical jewellers! Joe has incredible talent and it shows, he takes pride in his craft and wants to provide the ideal piece of jewelry for his clients. I will forever continue giving them my business and recommend them to everyone, such a fantastic experience. He worked with my vision and advised me on what was practical, realistic and also worked in our budget. I can't believe it was so easy and fun to design my own ring! Having a meaningful and one of a kind ring is priceless. When the mock up was ready, I came down to view and approve the making of the actual ring, I felt so included in the process and never once, felt like he was trying to upsale me or rip me off (unlike all my other experiences elsewhere). The finished ring exceeded my expectations. I'm sure we'll also be pleased with my fiancee's ring which is pretty different and off the wall, too. I ended up going with a natural ruby, in a half bezel setting, with a European shank and intricate hand engraving. It is so beautiful and no picture can give it any justice! I get so many compliments on it and know it is a quality ring that I will forver cherish. read more

McKay Diamonds - Joe made me a custom ring with a natural ruby, in a half bezel setting, with a European shank, and detailed hand engravings. - Jewelry Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

This family that runs this is so sweet, thorough, knowledgeable, and were so quick (I was in and out in 10 minutes)! I went in for a repair because I bent my band and possibly messed up my diamond setting. They took a very good look at it, cleaned it beautifully, and straightened out my band. It looks perfect and was $45 which I thought was reasonable . Highly recommend! Thank you Joe:) read more

My fiancé gave me my Grandmother's ring when proposing to me, I can't even begin to explain how meaningful this was for me, but the ring was much too large for my ring finger. I took the ring into McKay to be resized and have the bars repaired to ensure my diamonds and rubies were secure. The experience was comforting and easy, it wasn't the easiest to hand over my Grandmother's ring to be extensively worked on, but I am so glad I did. The ring turned out beautiful and I'm in love with it all over again like I was when I was little. read more

I took my engagement ring to get sized to McKay diamonds. It was worth the drive from herriman. Joe sized it while I waited. It took about 20 mins and it looks perfect, I didn't have to leave it at the store and wait 2 weeks. Joe wants his wife Sandra are very knowledgeable and helpful. I'll definitely be shopping with them again. read more

They were very helpful and professional, and did a great job resizing my rings. They even did all 3 of them same day. I will definitely go there again! read more

Family owned shop in a great historic location. The owner really knows his stuff, and was super helpful in sizing some tricky rings I had. I couldn't be happier with the results, and even though I wanted to change a few things after, he was more than willing to do what it took to make me happy. I'll continue to use him for all my jewelry work. read more

Joe is the best Jeweler in the County. He customized the best engagement ring for my fiancé. A Three-stone moissanite (Asscher center, emerald side stone). read more

McKay Diamonds - 2 carat asscher center, .58 emeralds sides - Jewelry Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

See all

I took a ring to Shane Co to see if they could resize it for me. They said they couldn't because the diamonds were pressure set, and that requires a custom jeweler. I found McKay on Yelp and took it in to ask. He told me the same thing, the pressure set diamonds are very tricky to resize, especially going down from a 7 to a 5. After about ten minutes reviewing the options, he decided it was worth a try to see if it could be done. It took about fifteen minutes for him to cut it, size it, and reset a couple diamonds that did pop out. I had the plating redone as well. In under an hour he had the ring looking like a million bucks. Incredibly talented, honest and personal service. I wish I could give more than five stars. read more

McKay Diamonds - After shot of ring, post resizing and plating. - Jewelry Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

Walked in to see about cleaning and tightening the prongs on my wedding ring. The shop owner was extremely thorough and detailed when he looked it over. Ended up finding a diamond that had gone crooked and could have fallen out at any time. He made sure to show me through the magnifying glass and explain everything. He only charged me $30 to fix the prong and clean both my ring and band. I highly recommend going here for any and all jewelry needs! read more

McKay Diamonds - Made my heirloom ring sparkle! - Jewelry Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

See all

I had the most pleasant and honest experience with Joe, Sandra And Kimberly! Joe's custom precision and meticulous repair on my earrings was amazing. His shop has many beautiful pieces of jewelry. Support this local business and meet these genuine people! read more

Last night I got engaged to my best friend, and while we might be a perfect fit, the ring was unfortunately not. McKay Diamonds got us in the morning and I had my ring back in just a few hours! The work is flawless, you can't tell it was sized up at all. I'm so happy to have my ring in time for thanksgiving and all those nosy relatives ;) Thank you, I cannot express how happy I am with your work! read more

If you are attending an event at Eccles Theater, please stop by beforehand to drop your jewelry off for a cleaning. They also fixed a broken chain during this time. I'm so happy to have a sparkling engagement/wedding ring. Let's do all we can to help keep them in business. Please support local businesses! read more

I had a silver bracelet that needed to be reshaped after I bent it by resizing it myself. I was walking by while I was wearing it so I stopped in and he reshaped it on the spot, looks perfect now. They are so lovely and I love this shop on Main Street, after this experience McKay Diamonds will be my go to shop for all my Jewelry needs. read more

Unlike other places that will charge for inspection if you did not buy the ring there, McKay didn't charge me a cent. I lost my ring couple days ago at a parking lot. Luckily a lady found it and she said it might got runover couple times. Eventually, I needed an inspect on the ring to check if it was damaged or not. My fiancé found McKay on Yelp and it was the only one has good review. McKay is a pretty narrow store. I almost missed it and went to the wrong store. The store salesman greeted me even though he was helping couple customers. While the customers was looking through the booklet, the salesman came over and asked how can he help me. I told him my story and it needs an inspection. He took the ring and took a look at it under the scope. He replied, "don't worry. Everything is fine. Not even a scratch on the metal." He didn't charge me anything, I thank him, and I left. Maybe I got lucky because he was still busy with other customers. Well, they still have my business if I need inspection or jewelry cleaning. Btw, parking might be a problem because it is on main street. read more

Amazing experience just like all the reviewers. I was looking for a real deal jeweler I could trust with my family heirloom ring. Trusted the reviews and I'm so glad I did. He did an amazing job restoring and rebuilding the setting on my ring and resetting the diamond. I really really wish I knew of this place when we made my engagement ring. We went to a chain (Jared's) and had a terrible experience. As long as I'm in Utah I'll be coming here for any jewelry needs! read more

I went to McKay to repair a broken link on an antique necklace, that has a lot of sentimental value. I dropped off the necklace Monday night, and was told I could pick it up Wednesday morning. I went there this morning - and the necklace was beautiful! The cos to repair it was inexpensive, and the owner cleaned it free of charge as well. While I was there, I also decided to have my engagement and wedding ring replated as well. The cost was very reasonable, and below what you would expect to pay at other jewelers. The owner replated the ring and cleaned it while I waited. All in all, I was out in ten minutes! Cute little shop, and friendly owners. Happy customer. read more

We had such an amazing experience here! We had the engagement ring custom made and we worked with Joe through each step of the process. He made exactly what we wanted. I am seriously amazed at the fantastic job he did. Not to mention the price was absolutely reasonable. Highly recommend! read more

McKay Diamonds - His and hers rings made by Joe. - Jewelry Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

Cool historic shop on Main. Feels like a Manhattan jeweler. Very fair prices on repairs, and he is willing to take on any custom project! I've used them several times now. Great service, fair prices. Highly recommend. read more

Joe and his lovely wife were wonderful to work with! My wedding ring center diamond was crooked and Joe explained that the store we bought it from put a princess cut diamond into a setting that wasn't intended for it. He showed me a beautiful princess cut setting he could replace mine with for a very reasonable price. His expertise in this field was obvious and I felt confident in his ability to make this change to my ring. It was done within a few days and when I saw it I was beyond pleased! He truly did a magnificent job! I love it, he exceeded my expectations. I definitely recommend going to McKay Diamonds for any jewelry related need. (Old setting on top in the picture) read more

McKay Diamonds - Jewelry Near Me - Salt Lake City, Utah

This is the BEST jeweler in Salt Lake City! My husband and I purchased my engagement ring out of state and it did not fit. I took the ring to another shop in salt lake and was given an outrageous estimate to resize. I brought the ring to McKay and they were wondering. They charged me a fair price and did everything to make me feel comfortable. This is an amazing family owned and operated business. I wouldn't go anywhere else in salt lake for jewelry! read more

Wish I could give 10 stars to such a professional and kind family business. They were able to see me right away and fixed my earrings immediately. Patient, excellent customer skills, and we all could use that during a pandemic. Beautiful jewelry I should add, you can tell they care and take care of their customers. Highly highly recommend them. read more