Schiavoni's Market is family-owned market. It is a hidden gem for all your grocery needs in Sag…read moreHarbor. They provide a fresh selection of meats in the butcher section. Additionally, they offer salads, lunch meats, vegetables, produce, cheeses, and much more. It is an excellent place to pick up something when heading to the beach or returning home.

So over priced and you ALWAYS need to check the dates on products. Spent $6 on a small kombucha for…read moreit to have expired in November 2024. Thank god I noticed it looked weird and checked the date before drinking. It's happened more times than I can remember that there has been expired food on the shelves. I've also found produce that has mold contaminating whatever fruits and veg that they are next to. It's ridiculous to have such expansive items that are already expired on the shelves. I've gotten sick from the hot plate food and everything is soaked in grease. Also rude workers.

Provisions Natural Health Food Store in Sag Harbor offers an extensive selection of health foods,…read moreincluding supplements, groceries, and prepared meals. The store features a dedicated section of organic produce, as well as a wide variety of gluten-free and dairy-free products. Customers can also enjoy a refreshing shake or sit-down meal on the premises.

I came into this store every day during my stay in Sag Harbor. Today, the shop was nearly empty and…read moreI ordered three of the same juices for my family. When I let the staff know they had made the wrong juice, I was treated with hostility, accused of being rude for simply clarifying my order, and banned from a store I had loyally supported all week. An older blonde woman - who I've ironically seen be unpleasant with customers all week - was irritated the moment I questioned the order. She snapped at me for inspecting it. When I explained how it red instead of green, she ordered me to taste it, then seemed annoyed when I told her it contained ingredients that weren't in what I had ordered. I tried to explain what I'd ordered and the substitution I'd made, but she and another brunette employee became increasingly hostile. As they all began bickering amongst themselves about what was in each juice on the menu, so I offered to write down my order to help - at which point the older blonde woman told me I was being rude and said to the other employees that she was "ready to fight me." Over kale and chard... at 9:30 a.m.? Her behavior was so disturbing I just walked away and sat down with my husband, mother, and my baby - all of whom had been watching all of this unfold in shock as we waited for the amended order. Then, while we were sitting quietly, she told me I was banned from the store. Both my husband and my mother - dumbfounded asked why clarifying a juice order warranted being banned. Her response? To my husband, she snapped, "What are you, the boyfriend?" and to my mother - who was with our baby - "I'm not speaking to you." And the manager? He didn't ask a single question or review video footage. He simply said he was going to stand by her wishes. The reality is, I'm just passing through. We were genuinely excited to stock up on some of the great products before heading home -- but now I'll just order everything online. And frankly, it's a shame. This kind of unnecessary hostility in customer service is exactly what drives people away from supporting small businesses.

I like king Mullen very much. The price is right and the products that I've purchased there have…read morebeen fresh. I was delighted with the produce there the blueberries, strawberries, apples, bananas, carrots, celery, or very fresh and perfect for family, snacking. I was also good Sal on Coffey and Tea that I was able to stock up on. The environment is clean Free from any hazardous or dangerous items in the aisles

Deli staff is rude. Every time I travel and go to a real supermarket it's depressing to have to…read moreshop at King Kullen when I return.

Laura and team run the best Farmstand in the Hamptons. The freshest of local fruits and vegetables…read more The seafood is right off of the boat and their homemade products are amazing. As to the few negative reviews, I say that you get what you pay for. Go shop at King Kullen if you want less expensive but inferior food.

Ridiculously overpriced and underwhelming goods. 9.50 for a punnet of raspberries? Mass market…read morebrand, non organic bulging baby carrots, usually around $1.50, almost $4 here. Puny herb bunches, make Sciavoni's offerings seem generous.

Friendly staff! Fresh quality groceries! Clean store. Would go back. Had everything we neededread more

Just don't. Chaotic and not good. Fried chicken was inedible and vegetarian options non existent…read more This is our biggest regret on sag harbor and it was my choice to try it. I did order something vegetarian and it was an absolute tragedy. Husband will not let me live it down, that is how bad it was. He is teasing me as we speak and he will probably continue to do so for years to come -- the worst food we had in our 5+ year relationship. Yes, I deserve the teasing for suggesting this. Just don't. Don't listen to Reddit about the amazing sandwiches here. They don't live here. Infinitely better options nearby.

I absolutely love this place. Incredible tortas, sandwiches, and smoothies. If you have a banana…read moreallergy or hate banana, mention it, because they've added banana at times to smoothies that don't mention them in the ingredient list. Friendly service.

real good. Wasn't immediate but the sandwich was fresh and rolls were great. Authentic viberead more

Javier, the sweetest soul I've ever met, helped me find everything I needed for my family's dinner…read more He was incredibly attentive and patient with my limited knowledge of cheese. I'm glad to know that Citerella hires such a great team!

The pre-made breakfast sandwiches were very disappointing. They are extremely expensive at $8…read moreapiece and lacked flavor, tasting like powdered eggs. The other pre-made items also feel mass-produced and appear to use low-quality oil. Given how convenient this location is for me, I really wish the quality matched the price.

Cute and convenient market in the heart of the Hamptons! They have a very convenient market that…read morecaters to your food, groceries and household items. They have a natural juice stand inside where you can also get fresh matcha green tea, and other natural juices. The variety of foods is incredible and they carry lots of delicious baked goods, and other prepared foods. FYI, bathrooms are upstairs. It took me a few minutes to find the bathroom until I asked and had to go up the stairs. The bathroom is not very clean but it is what it is. Not what you would expect from the area (Easy Hampton). The service is ok they are working very hard so they treat you like they don't have time for your questions..I was a brand new customer and even asking where the restroom was made me feel a bit unwelcome maybe they only cater to the "regulars"!

I went there to get some fried chicken, I've had it before and it was very good. Only this time I…read moregot just one fried chicken thigh. Well it was $6.00,, SIX DOLLARS!! for one thigh! seriously!!! I purchased it but was not pleased. It was very good as usual but not worth six dollars. It's not that I can't afford it, but at these prices I won't be back soon. And I'm telling everyone I know about this. They should be ashamed! They'll go out of business at this rate, especially in the winter when there's not enough people here to support them.

Best eggs round town! Ambiance is great, not too musty smelling like my local stop and shop. I will…read moresay again really beautiful egg selection.

We were missing a fee items we needed while camping nearby and ran in to this store not long before…read moreclosing on a weeknight. The produce area smelled amazing. Any employee I saw was engaged in cleaning, stocking or checkout. I needed help finding an item and not only was I told which aisle to look in, but an employee helped me locate what I needed.

Excellent seafood at fair prices. Good service and rough-but-clean shop. We return frequently.read more

I had the absolute best tuna salad I've ever had in my life... And I am a huge tuna salad person…read more I also had the best lobster bisque soup I've ever had there. It had chunks of the good side of the lobster. Not just the leftover crap... lol !