Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Melilli Pizzeria & Catering

    4.4 (13 reviews)
    Closed 9:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Order Melilli Pizzeria & Catering Takeout or Delivery

    Melilli Pizzeria & Catering Photos

    MELILLI PIZZERIA & CATERING ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like Melilli Pizzeria & Catering

    Recommended Reviews - Melilli Pizzeria & Catering

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos - Melilli Pizzeria & Catering

    Turkey Club
    Djuana B.

    Ordered Turkey Club and Chicken Parm grinders for lunch via delivery. The subs were generous and good size portions for the money. However, the chicken cutlet was dry and there wasn't enough mayo on the turkey club. I would give them another try and order something else next time.

    Turkey Club 8"

    $1 an inch! Yes please. Delicious, fresh, customizable. Totally worth the price! Now we have two great Melilla's to choose from, and we are right in the middle. Can't wait to try some salads and grab some fresh rolls to go! Much respect for the grace you showed during the recent split. Working with family is hard, I know . So congratulations

    Freshly prepared meals as well!!! Very reasonably priced!!

    The pizza is some of the best in the area. But don't miss out on all the freshly prepared food in the cold cases! Everything high quality and house made!

    Sicilian Bomber

    See all

    2 months ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Great food!! Amazing people!! Easy dinner or lunch! Will be back again and again! Chicken parm is so good!!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Great food with AMAZING service! All the women there are so friendly and accommodating! Highly recommend this little gem!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Josephine M.

    Josephine M.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Love this place! Great chicken cutlets, excellent sandwiches, and super friendly staff! A little pricy on the sandwiches

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Everything is excellent , but very pricey, it's not a place that the average customer could do often

    Business owner information

    Photo of Josephine M.

    Josephine M.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    Ask the Community - Melilli Pizzeria & Catering

    Review Highlights - Melilli Pizzeria & Catering

    The bread was soft, yet crusty and the marinara sauce had to be made by a Nonna, it was so good.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Mondo

    Mondo

    4.3
    (602 reviews)
    2.2 mi
    $$

    Our neighbor raves about Mondo, so we thought it was high time we paid a visit…read more Mondo is fairly easy to find; our only error was accidentally pulling into the wrong parking lot. They do offer a free lot in the back, but judging by all the cars, Mondo is very popular on a Friday evening. Sure enough, there was a big line of people picking up orders, but we walked right in and were seated immediately. We started off with a beet salad, which was surprisingly delicious, combining candied walnuts and sweet orange and green apple slices with salty feta and tangy balsamic over a mountain of mixed greens. We then moved on to paninis, generous portions of meat and toppings on freshly baked, crispy bread. One of us chose more mixed greens tossed with dressing while the other chose crunchy French fries. We also ordered a third panini to go, the Mondo combo. We asked for fries; the kitchen accidentally gave us a salad. Our server, Heather N., saved the day by noticing the error and giving us both side orders. Mondo is family friendly, and there were plenty of children during our visit. As such, the volume was a tad loud and boisterous, but nothing obnoxious that would prevent us from returning.

    There's a reason why Mondo is at the top of Middletown's pizza pyramid year after year…read more Speedy, friendly & competent service Consistently excellent food Unbeatable value They are my go to when anyone asks for pizza in my house. We've been countless times since my last review and I've never left with buyers remorse. Mondo just knows how to treat its customers right, keep it up!

    Photos
    Bar area
    Bar area
    Sherry Salad
    Sherry Salad
    Restaurant

    See all

    Restaurant
    Sicily Coal Fired Pizza

    Sicily Coal Fired Pizza

    3.8
    (303 reviews)
    1.9 mi
    $$

    I love going to Sicily Pizza and last night my friends threw me a fun birthday dance party!…read more One of my favorite bands was playing there NUGR We are lucky to have a great server named Paul, who really spoiled us with making sure we had plenty of drinks in the most delicious food recommendations. We need more Paul's!

    I've come to Sicily on numerous occasions since they opened…read more The first couple of visits were decent and I had high hopes that Sicily would become a go-to spot, but it just never panned out. Over the past 2 years the service & food quality has been in steady decline. My most recent visit was inexcusable and I won't return. We decided to visit for "reverse happy hour" as an alternative from our usual thirsday night visit to Esca. We had Michael for our server and sat upstairs in the lounge. We were brought menus as we were sat and we ordered drinks to start, but weren't sure on food yet. Our server then proceeded to visit our table 4 times over the next 15 minutes to ask if we wanted to place a food order. It felt rushed. The vibe : awkward. The music was so loud I couldn't hear my server, my date or anything else besides the droning voice of Amy Grey. She had no spacial awareness and didn't know when to shut up. Incessantly talking over every song and not realizing that a bar gig is inherently different from the radio. The food : mediocre. We ordered steak frites from the happy hour menu which noted that the steak was "marinated". The 4 piece of tepid steak that came to our table were covered in this cloyingly sweet sauce that tainted the entire dish. Since the steak was served atop the fries, this sauce caused the fries (straight from the Sysco box) to become soggy and absorb the sauce which made the fries not so appetizing. We followed that up with a Cheese Pizza which was pretty good. The pizza here is their saving grace, and this place would do much better as just a slice shop. The drinks : abysmal. I started with a Skittles fruited sour from Transcend Brewery that Sicily had on tap. I was excited because it's rare to find their beer on tap outside of the brewery. It was served in the wrong glass. The F&B manager at Sicily needs to do a better job at making sure the bar is properly serving drinks. Teku glasses are essential for fruited sours. It didn't taste the same as it did in the brewery, however, for $6 I decided to just chalk it up to inexperience. I followed the beer with a Paloma, which was advertised as $5 for happy hour. When I ordered from my server I pointed at the menu showing the tequila listed for $5. As soon as I tasted the drink that was brought to me, i knew it was way off. I asked my server to ask the bartender what was in the drink because it didn't taste right. He told me that the bartender said "grapefruit juice", which is not the proper mixer for a Paloma. A Paloma only has 3 ingredients - Grapefruit Soda (Squirt or Jarritos are acceptable), Tequila & Lime Juice - it's a very simple cocktail. If you didn't have grapefruit soda, which is the main ingredient in the drink, just tell me that... I would have picked something else. The service : Impersonal & rushed. When i sent back the drink, the affect of our server visibly changed, almost as if he was angry or insulted that I would send back a drink that wasn't made properly. He asked if I would like something else, but my confidence in the bartender to make a proper drink had waned and I stuck with water for the rest of the night. My date continued with a 3rd glass of wine. About 10 minutes after this, my date got up to use the restroom, and our server came over and handed me a box for the remaining pizza, without asking if we would like anything else or if my date was done with her wine. He whisked away the half full glass and dropped our check effectively ending our visit. We weren't ready to leave. My date came back to the table and asked where the rest of her drink was and I explained the our server cleared the table and dropped the check. She said "I guess it's time to go". The nail in the coffin was when I picked up the check to see that I was charged for a $16 "Casamigos" cocktail. So i suppose if i had continued to drink the Paloma he would have been happy to charge me $16 for a $5 happy hour drink. The whole experience was off-putting and we didn't feel welcome. It felt as if our server was just trying to turn tables as fast as possible. I won't be returning and recommend others to stay far away.

    Photos
    Dance Floor
    Dance Floor
    Brussel sprouts and eggplant frites
    Brussel sprouts and eggplant frites
    Strawberry basil jalapeño cider

    See all

    Strawberry basil jalapeño cider
    Little Rendezvous

    Little Rendezvous

    4.3
    (242 reviews)
    6.8 mi
    $

    I'm going to skip past all my typical narrative about the restaurant ambiance, this is pizza, and…read morethe pizza is amazing!!! If you like New Haven style pizza, which is arguably the 'esemplare' of all pizza, then visiting The Little Rendezvous is a MUST visit if you live within 90-min. Plan a trip to visit some store you want to go to, a beach visit or whatever, just find a way to circle The Little Rendezvous into the trip! The crust is thin with a crackery-crunch, the sauce is at a another level and the mozz and roni are high-quality deliciousness! Rendezvous stands tall with any of the well known top-3 pizza joints in New Haven. Dave's score of 9.1 (if you are unaware of the reference, then pizza isn't your thing) is right on point, and I'd go as far as scoring it slightly higher at a 9.2 based on my visit. The building is something out of folklore. The building is all of about 20ft. wide, and when you enter, it is immediate, Steve (owner/chef) is all about the pizza. To be clear, most will consider Rendezvous to be take-out only. There is zero decor, less signs made with cardboard and sharpie notifying you that wait times of hours are real..... so be sure to call ahead. You walk past the most basic seating area of 3-4 small tables with bare walls, and then proceed to walk down an oddly long and narrow sloping hallway which leads you to the service counter/kitchen which houses the 130-year old oven! It's honestly something you could only imagine out of a movie...... the hole in the wall that is creating high-quality, delicious pizzas! Why or how you ask? The answer is simple, Steve! The guy clearly has a passion for making pizza and has dedicated his life to doing so. I met the 'man-the myth-the legend' on my visit, and he kindly even took the time to chat with me. Bucket-list item checked off! Overall score = 5.0!!!

    Great spot. Not what I expected, I once lived in New Haven and am used to destination pizza. This…read morewas much more unassuming and better set up as a take out, but did not disappoint. We arrived early on, what I thought was off hours and ordered in person, the wait time was 4 hours. I don't live far so it was easy to come back. The dining area is tight and pretty basic, so plan on wooden bench in limited space if you are dining in. I would also recommend calling way in advance with your order. As far as pizza goes, I have had the opportunity to sample most of the high profile places and understand why this place deserves to be on the list. The crust is pretty fantastic and overall a really good pie. When we went, there was no line. The grab and go was super simple, cash only. Order ahead, plan accordingly, and enjoy.

    Photos
    The dining room.
    The dining room.
    Tomato pie
    Tomato pie
    Service counter and kitchen

    See all

    Service counter and kitchen

    Melilli Pizzeria & Catering - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...