I ordered via Uber Eats and enjoyed one of the best pizzas in my life. It was a meat lover's pizza, with my custom preferences. Perfection! read more

PizzaPie Wood Fired Pizza - Meat lover's pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

Food is great, everytime. Kid friendly, great music, warm and a super friendly staff every visit.

Wood Fired Pizza Co. is one of the best spots in NB if you're craving authentic wood-fired pizza. The first thing you notice when you walk in is the smell from the wood oven, which gives the whole place a warm and inviting vibe. read more

Had a free pizza coupon so gave it a try. Reminded me of High school pie. Blah. Really really blah.

Pizza is decent/ average, thin crust but not quite crispy. Staff are very friendly. Got takeout but the inside looks very nice. Would definitely give a try for drinks. read more

PizzaPie Wood Fired Pizza - Pepperoni Medium Pizza (14") - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

Super tasty pizza pie! I grabbed a couple last weekend. A plain cheese and my fav sausage, mushrooms, and pepperoni I was very happy to say the least. So delicious read more

Pizza is NOT good. Not anything about it. And it was a greasy soggy mess. Even the bottom of the crust. Never seen anything like it. DONT DO IT read more

I think the pizza could be better especially looking at that beautiful huge oven. Staff were nice enough but the pies lacked flavor.

My daughter and I stopped in here for lunch on Christmas Eve. It is a very cute spot. I like being able to see the brick oven. Really nice staff and we want to try the Gyros next door at the next visit. read more

See all

Got a Flatbread, pesto, chicken, pizza. So good, the place was immaculate, the workers were super friendly, and the prices were good. Highly recommend. read more

Half day calls for trying out a pizza place with friends. The service was perfect we each ordered individually and our food came out within 10 minutes. The whole staff was nice and very efficient. All 10 of us loved our meal, there was a huge variety of food. I got the broccoli chicken flatbread, it was honestly so good. I loved how I tasted garlic throughout it. I just wish they went a little lighter on the cheese. A great place to quickly get food and get on your way. read more

PizzaPie Wood Fired Pizza - Chicken Broccoli Flatbread - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

See all

I havent been here in a while and the last pizza was a basic cheeese takeout which was ok. This time my wife and I stopped in to eat . Took awhile to get a server to the table and we were the only ones there. Most were takeout but still there were a few servers floating that could have taken our order, Well the order was placed (House Specialty) and the pizza was brought to the table. We werent impressed. there was a piece of cardboard under the pizza that we wound picking up with the pizza since it was wet . That was our first clue that this was going to be different. When we picked it up the pizza was a soggy mess, It would seem that the vegetables and released all their water into the crust from the high heat of the oven and made a horrible mess of what could have been possibly a good pizza. Also the sauce was very sweet and not to our liking. I wish them the best and hopefully this was a one time event but if this is their House specialty I think it needs some work Very Disappointed read more

Kinda disappointed with the gluten free pizza I got. The crust was kinda dry and flavorless and not really crispy. I think it could have been cooked a little longer. The red sauce didnt have much pizzazz eithet. I also wanted to try a kumpir, which is a Istanbul street food version, of a stuffed potato. I ordered online and there were options to add various toppings and meat but I assumed it already came with an assortment of kumpir toppings. I added diced chicken to it but they didnt put any diced chicken in mine. I did take-out so I didn't really have a chance to see that until I was home. It was basically a baked potato with a pound of melted cheese on it. read more

See all

The buffalo ranch wings were a real treat, with a perfect balance of tangy buffalo sauce and creamy ranch dressing. Cooked to perfection, they had just the right amount of heat. Paired with the garlic knots, soft and flavorful with a hint of garlic, it was a match made in culinary heaven. Highly recommended for a delicious and satisfying meal. Also love the vibe of the restaurant! read more

So many reasons why this is one of our favorite spots! The pizza is phenomenal; the dough was perfect, the ingredients were as fresh and tasty as could be, and on top of it all, the service here is awesome! Friendly, courteous, and they go out of their way to ensure that you love your meal. Protip: you haven't lived till you've tried their garlic bread. Their salads are fantastic, and adding gyro meat to the pizza/garlic bread is pure heaven. Great portions too. Seeya again soon! read more

PizzaPie Wood Fired Pizza - So delish! - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

Not impressed. I went in with high expectations and was completely letdown. The layout of the restaurant is a bit confusing. I wasn't sure if it was a seat yourself kind of place...and I'm still not sure. The woman behind the counter told us to seat ourselves, but then grabbed some menus and brought us to a table by the door. Had I been given a choice, I probably would've taken a table closer to the counter. While we were there two groups of patrons had to move their table. The cold breeze that accompanied each guest that walked in or out the door, was just to much for them to handle. We laughed about it, but we were stuck at our table. My son and I were forced to wear our jackets through the entire meal. The wind was so fierce that it blew all of our napkins out of the holder and all over the floor. Even though we were seated by a waitress, it took 30 minutes for someone to notice us. That was only after a few calls across the restaurant and after no response, I finally had to get out of my seat to ask if we were supposed to order at the counter. After clearing off the table the waitress finally approached our table. Because it was late and my son was very hungry, we ordered the garlic knots. We also ordered two pies, a large Sarantino and a kid's pepperoni. After 30 minutes a woman came to check on us and I told her that we still hadn't received our garlic knots. She told us that she would check on them and then disappeared. The woman that took our order avoided our table and any eye contact with me. I was just about to walk out, when our waitress came over to tell us our order was almost ready. I asked again about the garlic knots and was told that she would check on them. Our drinks needed refilling, but were never refilled at this point. So, almost an hour later our pizzas and the garlic knots were brought to our table. My son's pizza was fine, not hot, but that's ok for a for a four year old. My pizza on the other hand was cold and soggy. What made matters worse, was the server put it at the end of the table where the frigid breeze was blowing over it every other minute. Even more disappointing was the fact that the garlic knots came to us uncooked. Unfortunately, it was my son that discovered the doughy center. Had it not been for my hungry child, I would have left right then. The waitress did take the garlic knots off the check, but no other compensation was given for the wait or horrible customer service. Sorry to say, even if someone gave me a gift certificate, I would not go back. read more

PizzaPie Wood Fired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

I love these wood fired pizzas. The crust is nice and thin with a charred edge. My favorites are the Margarita and the veggie pizza. We call, and pick up. Always fresh and hot, and delicious. read more

Wanted to like this place, the decor is nice and the concept is good. The execution was horrible. Some flatbread and hummus was brought to the table to start, I say flatbread and not pita because it definitely was not pita. It had no flavor, and a consistency of a cracker like pizza crust We had mozz sticks straight from restaurant depot, they were fried properly and cost $1/ea. That's a 600% mark up on the food cost. We got the milanos pizza. Sun dried tomato, spinach, artichoke & chicken. The chicken was drier than a menopausal vagina, and I imagine the taste was pretty similar too. The crust was flavorless and bland, and the pizza was undercooked with raw & floppy dough in the middle. The service was deadful, once our food was delivered we were ghosted until we asked for the box. My wife whispered, "what are you gonna do with that box?". I replied, "a proper burial needs a casket". I had to box my own leftovers (yeah that sounds petty, but I've never been expected to do this at any other pizza joint. It's usually taken from table, boxed, and brought back to you) I also had to bring my own check up to the register to pay so my server could watch while I wrote in the tip. Even though the service was terrible, I couldn't bring myself to jack up his tip in front of him. $35 horrible mistake. It's sad that rotating brick oven doesn't have anybody that knows how to properly use it. read more

PizzaPie Wood Fired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

See all

Fresh pizza made to order. Nice crust. Wood fired oven. The buffalo wings are pretty good too. It's a cute place with friendly servers. read more

For lunch one day we stopped here. It's amazing as it shares an open wall with a Greek restaurant. You can order from both kitchens. My wife wanted a calzone with mushrooms and roasted peppers. Somehow ended up with that and Buffalo chicken in there. We told them and the response was it happens do the Buffalo chicken being to close on the keypad. The kid had a meat lovers which she enjoyed. I myself partook in the Greek menu. This place is nice but the power show off for few minutes and the smoke of the wood fire came into the dining area. They do have some things to work out. read more

PizzaPie Wood Fired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

See all

really really clean. its casual, sit an order, grab a drink from the fridge and relax. No Beer... feels like two establishments under one roof. I like the gyro. pizza from the wood burning stove is good. and chicken wings will knock your socks off. I give it 5 stars cause it has so so many choices and all are very tasty. close early, so jump on it now now now read more

Actually went to GYRO which is connected. Had a chance to sample the hummus and babaganoush with toasted pita. The hummus had a splash of good olive oil and the babaganoush had a toasty oven flavor both were excellent. Ordered a gyro to go of lamb but they use a lamb/beef combo. The meat was tasty but didn't have that earthy lamb flavor. All in all it was way TOO salty especially the pickled beet garnish. Not a a successful lunch but may try the gigantic Greek salad at another time. read more

See all

Always felt the Pizza was fairly decent. #1) They want you to think it's Wood Fired allowing flames to be seen off to the side. It's Gas! #2) I typically get sausage on Pizza. This past time the Sausage was the worst tasting s_ _ t I've ever had, tasting more like freezer burnt hamburger with a little spice tossed in to cover the horrible taste. Will try the FirePlace next time.... I'm done! read more

Solid place, you will not be disappointed. You get a lot of food for your buck and it's delicious. Nice seating space and great vibe.

Stopped here on my way home from a volleyball tournament and the pizza was amazing! The workers were extremely nice and welcoming! Would definitely go back again! read more

$17 for a small Caesar salad with 1 Kens dressing pack and some grated Parmesan cheese, not even the real deal ‍ Let's just say I won't be back. The menu said the salad was $12.49 but the price is actually $15.98 because he said the costs went up. I told him to be sure to update his menu but I'm hoping my salad will be plentiful for that much money. Needless to say, when I opened the bag, I was blown away by the small size of the bowl. I had to take the pic next to my butter dish so you all could really get the perspective lol. read more

PizzaPie Wood Fired Pizza - a person holding a bowl of salad - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

Very clean and nice environment. Deceptively charming for a strip-mall location. The staff is very nice and work hard. They have a lot of items on the menu and something for everyone. I only tried the pizza and it was good. ... If you're ever in the neighborhood, I think it's worth a try. read more

Came here for a quick bite the other day- decided to dine in. The decor is adorable- they definitely did a great job decorating. However the most important part is the food and it's really lacking- the pieces of garlic bread were good that the waitress gave us to snack on, a bit overly soaked in oil but good. We then ordered the margarita pizza and it just lacked any seasoning or flavor whatsoever- and the tomatoes on it looked and tasted unripe and just off-- if the tomato isn't good don't use it! The mozzarella also lacked ANY salt or flavor- the only reason I'm giving it any stars is the crust was good, nice and crunchy and thin. Unfortunately we have no interest in returning. :/ read more

This place became my go-to for takeout during the pandemic. I order online using the app, it's always ready very quickly and made well. The pizza is fantastic - excellent crust and well prepared. read more

Dreadful customer service. Ordered a pizza using their online order service. Went to pick it up, and I was informed that the order was never prepared. They confirmed receiving the order with my confirmation number, but they just never made the pizza. After screwing up to this degree, any other pizza place would not have charged the customer for their mistake, but not Pizzapie in Cromwell. They literally do not care about their clientele, and pass their mistakes onto the customer. Very deserving of 1 star. read more

Wowwww!!! This place is beautiful and smells amazing the staff are very friendly and the slices are amazing! The place looks like it belongs in 2030! I will come back here again 9.5/10 you can always improve somewhere but I can't find anything so I'm switching to a 10/10. That's the review! read more

We've only recently discovered this place because we ordered gyros which we found out was attached to Pizza Pie and ended up getting some really tasty pizza, burgers and wings here. It's become our favorite place to do takeout recently. read more

Decor is extremely cute in this pizza place! Who ever designed the interior...good job to you. Place was super clean and this includes the floors, tables, and plates/utensils. The pizza slice options were limited..there was only cheese and buffalo chicken out when I went. We decided to order a small Margherita pizza. It came with six slices and its enough for two people. We both loved the taste and the crunchy crust of the pizza. The flavor and freshness was on point. Also, they added a vestibule to the entrance to prevent any cold/wind from coming inside the restaurant. Good idea. Now anyone sitting by the door in the winter won't be disturbed. Check out video. read more

See all

Good food, we got 2 big pizzas, garlic bread, 20 wings, and potato's. We ate all of it, delivery guy wore gloves, we were happy. No Coronavirus. Good. read more

PizzaPie Wood Fired Pizza - Chicken wings - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

LOVE the new addition! I think it's a great deal concept the owners implemented!! Larger variety of options, food is fantastic!!! I live nearby and will be back! read more

PizzaPie Wood Fired Pizza - Veggie 101 Grilled veggies with a drizzle of olive oil - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

Fantastic place with awesome staffing. My wife and I stopped for the first time today while our car was getting new sneakers. I got chicken wings and my wife got the Philly Cheesesteak wrap and of course a burger for our dog. Everything was wonderful especially the wrap, and took almost no time at all to prepare they even brought it out to the remote outdoor seating area. This is definitely getting saved to my favorite. read more

The place was awesome super clean I loved the pizza and the wings And they have very friendly staff . good luck keep doing the good work read more

See all

GYRO - This is a great place. Our food was good and full of flavor for the exception of our Greak Fries. They were tasty and will order them again, but they would benefit from bit of seasoning. Look forward to returning. read more

PizzaPie Wood Fired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

See all

Their garlic bread and buffalo ranch wings are absolutely amazing!!

The pepperoni pizza here is one of my favorites in the area. When we dine in, the staff is welcoming and super caring. The wings on the other hand aren't worth it. They're simply fried wings with a splash of sauce across them. Disappointing. read more