Recently had a takeout order from Yanni's during the last heat wave. I was craving a meatball grinder. But lately the grinders i have been getting from other places we're just a circle meatball and sauce and cheese. This grinder was to die for wished I took a picture of it. 18 inches of sliced meatballs, sauce, and cheese. It was something to take me back to me teen years. This was outstanding and will be getting my grinders from Yanni's from now on. read more

I'm honestly very disappointed with my recent experiences at Yanni's Pizza in Newington because this has always been one of my go-to places. The first time, I went with a friend and ordered the lobster ravioli. While eating it, I started feeling nauseous and ended up returning the dish to the server. The next day, my friend contacted me and told me that she had become very sick after eating the separate dish she had ordered. I can't say for certain what caused either of us to feel sick, but the experience definitely left me concerned. I decided to give Yanni's another chance because I've always enjoyed going there. Unfortunately, my second experience was also disappointing. I went with my girlfriend and we ordered a meat lovers pizza. The crust had what tasted like a stale/refrigerated flavor, and the crust itself was noticeably different from what I was used to getting from Yanni's. My girlfriend also thought the pizza was terrible and told me we shouldn't go back. That's what makes this so disappointing. This used to be a reliable go-to spot for me, so having two bad experiences back-to-back makes me wonder if something has changed. I really hope the restaurant looks into the consistency and quality of the food because I'd much rather be able to recommend Yanni's again. read more

I was craving a nice Greek salad with grilled chicken and I was in the area. I had a short lunch and I needed my salad fast . My waitress was very accommodating and very friendly. She even brought me a to go container, anticipating my needs. The atmosphere is very casual and it was nice and quiet. I will definitely return to try more items from the menu. My salad was perfect! read more

Yannis Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

A friend recommended this spot because he has been coming here for years. I stopped in for a midday lunch and everything was good for the most part. Their portion sizes are huge! We definitely had so much food that we ended up packing away because we simply could not finish it. I was surprised by how large the kids portion of mac & cheese was. Thankfully, we were paying attention, but the waitress sat a piping hot plate of mac & cheese down in front of a 15 month old... anyone who knows a 15 month old knows that it's very hard to take something from them once they've decided that they want it. Besides that, I feel like service was attentive. There weren't many other tables around this time of day so everything was quick. I enjoyed the California burger and fries were delicious. I'm not sure I would go out of my way to return, but it is a good spot if you're looking for lunch. read more

See all

We ordered for delivery. Chicken parm was SO dry never had a dry parm in my life had the tiniest bit of sauce. The chicken tasted good and fresh but needed seasonings. The steak and cheese was not the best. The steak had 0 salt or seasonings. The Italian was average. read more

See all

First time in Hartford area in a decade for a family celebration. First night in, we do take out; a feast from Yannis. The kids are picky eaters and it was their favorite salad and spaghetti and meatballs they've had. For me the Caesar salad with steak was nice. The baked ziti my wife had was divine. Cannot wait to get the pizza when we go back this weekend. The service was so friendly and fast. They offered a cheesecake slice to my father-in-law without even knowing it was his birthday. read more

Great people good food clean restaurant been going here for years and always consistent

What a fantastic place! The BBQ chicken pizza was phenomenal! Lots of toppings and the crust was perfect- not too thin not too thick but on the thicker side. The antipasto salad was yum too - so many wonderful veggies! Lots of olives and peppers. And the house dressing was creamy and delicious. The garlic parm wings were great too! We did take out but everything was great and those working were welcoming and got our order together in the time they said they would! We will definitely be back! read more

See all

The food is prepared with excellence and the portions are significantly larger than you might expect. Very friendly wait and kitchen staff.

Last time we went, they def forgot our kid's cheese pizza as all our food came out minus the pizza and we had to remind them when they asked if we needed anything else. But they were very busy, they do a large take out business and we were tucked in the corner. Our waitress was sweet and the food was very good. I am picky with my Italian food but there sauce was really tasty and that makes it breaks it for me. This time we got chicken parm, pizza and sweet potato crusted salmon, which was cooked perfectly. We also got the Sicilian salad which at a small, was quite large. Yanni's near home and our preferred pizza place as well. read more

Yannis Pizza Restaurant - Sweet potato crusted salmon - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

See all

Good Food and Great service! Shout out to the wait staff for everything. We brought in about 1/2 our hockey team on Sunday in between games. They did a great job with getting the boys drinks, taking orders and generally putting up with them! Food was good and hit the spot which led to a big 3-2 win!! Next time we are in the area will call ahead and bring the whole team. Thanks 2013 - 95 Giants! read more

The most amazing restaurant. All food is excellent. Friendly, efficient staff that actually knows who you are. Love this place.

Good food and service. Huge portions. A good neighborhood Italian restaurant. Booths are a bit old fashioned and tables can't be moved. Beer list is extensive. You won't leave hungry! read more

I haven't eaten at Yanni's for several years. I think it's just because I live closer to places I like that serve similar food, but who can remember at this point? I ordered an 8 inch meatball and sausage grinder with onions, peppers, sauce and cheese by phone. It was ready on time. The sliced meatballs and sliced sausage were both pretty good. The cheese was well melted and the vegetables were appropriately cooked. I could have used more sauce to balance things. The bread type was fine. It was a bit overcooked, but tasted decent in any event. I would order takeout from Yanni's again. Four Stars. read more

Yannis Pizza Restaurant - Takeout - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

A lady was very mean to my kid aggressive yelled no when he asked for a Shirley Temple and screamed at him when he was tapping on the table because he has anxiety in loud places,. This is unacceptable and I will not be here again. read more

Yannis Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Nice small place with great grinders, that's all I've had so far. The staff is friendly and take good care of customers

Good food and good service, our family has been going there for years! Wish they would include a delivery service instead of going through a third-party app read more

Good shit ! Good food, friendly person. Thanks for a good lunch! Will be back , No Cap !! read more

There's a reason places are busy. Yanni's hits all of them. Good food and good service. Dining in or picking up, you get quick attention. People waiting for orders are kept up to date constantly. The phone calls come in steady. The restaurant isn't too big, like four rows of four booths. Always loaded with regulars and locals but new customers always seem to be treated well. We've eaten here for years. You'll like it too. read more

Curbside delivery during Covid! Everyone in my family loves Yanni's. For a socially distant mother's day this year I went and picked up my mom's favorites from Yanni's-a small Buffalo chicken pizza (see my previous review, it's FANTASTIC) and an order of chicken francais (comes with bread, salad, pasta). During Covid my wife and I have picked up takeout from Yanni's several times and it was easy and delicious. The meals are HUGE, enough for 3 meals. Support this great business. read more

Yannis Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Always great service and big portions of delicious food. My wife eat half the meal and then have the other half for lunch or dinner!!

Haven't been to yannis in many years and still doesn't disappoint. Our waitress was amazing I couldn't complain if wanted to. The place isn't that fancy inside. I'm glad we got there when we did as they seems to be slammed with pickup orders when we left. We had the seafood stuffed mushrooms and fried mozz. Probably should have stopped there as I was basically full. My daughter had the chicken Marsala nice deep rich flavor on the sauce. My wife had the teriyaki grinder. All the food was amazing. I will certainly be back again. read more

See all

Really good food - chicken cutlet grinder is one of the best around. Highly recommend!!

Great service and food. The grinders are fulfilling and delish. Best recommendation from a friend

I was seriously wow'd tonight. Like "birthday dinner meal" wow'd...and it's not even my birthday. Yanni's is a family-owned/operated restaurant located in the center of Newington. They specialize in Italian, Greek and American food. I always come here for the calamari because the portion is huge and you just can't go wrong with the price. However, I think I may have found my new go to meal there tonight! Before the big reveal, here's a few things you should know. Your server will always start your visit with a basket of fresh, hot white and wheat bread. Staple. Love it. There are so many great starters on the menu, but I highly recommend trying the calamari. For dinner, my friend ordered the Meatloaf from the specials menu that came with either soup or salad and choice of a starch (rice, mashed potatoes, baked potato or pasta) and veggies. The meals are so big at Yanni's that the veggies and potatoes come on a completely different plate! I also ordered from the specials menu- Sweet Potato Crusted Salmon with a Honey Mustard Glaze. The glaze is what made it a special, but fear not, the Sweet Potato Crusted Salmon is actually on the menu. It was one of the biggest, thickest pieces of salmon that I have ever had in my life. No joke. The sweet potato and glaze paired with the salmon was amazing. Our server, Andrea told us that sometimes they even make an orange ginger glaze for the salmon. I promised her that I would be back to try that variation. Thanks for the tip, Andrea! Tonight was one of those unexpected dinners that you wake up in the morning thinking about, wishing you had left a little for lunch the next day. Sadly, it was so good, there won't be any leftovers tomorrow...lol Yanni's menu has something for everyone. So happy to see the dining room open again. Definitely a spot to put on your list of places to try if you haven't already. read more

See all

Yanni's is definitely a staple of Newington. This has been our go to spot with our move to Newington. The pizza, calzones, grinders have all been SO good. This is the comfort food to get. The portions are large and the quality is very good. Some of our favorites grinders are the chicken parm, eggplant parm, meatball, and sausage. These are also amazing in the calzone form! We're also huge fans of the greek, Hawaiian, margarita, and meat lovers pizzas. They aren't over topped nor are they lacking toppings. read more

Recommend trying the specials! Portions are generous! Service is always good. Gluten free options are a plus. read more

I have never eaten at Yanni's restaurant, but I have had their takeout and delivery. We got their buffalo chicken pizza delivered the other night and it hit the spot. It was loaded with chicken, cheese, and sauce. It came with a side of Blue cheese dressing, which is perfect for drizzling and crust-dipping. Among Greek pizzas, I think Yanni's is a great option. Their prices are good too. I wish they offered more Greek dishes, but I've been happy with what I tried so far. I've heard they make a nice Cobb salad, so I will be ordering that in the future. read more

Yannis Pizza Restaurant - Buffalo chicken pizza - hot and saucy - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

When we don't feel like cooking we will order pizza and salad from here. I've noticed Inconsistent food quality. Prices are good but you get what you pay for ! read more

We,party of 4, went to dinner last night. We waited over 45 minutes for our orders to arrive. 2 orders were their open faced turkey special. Both were disgusting in presentation, 1/2" slabs of turkey loaf and both orders included the loaf end cuts with cold blobs of stuffing. Serving the restaurant was obviously second to the take out. Yannis should decide if they want to include restaurant service or just do take out. read more

Buffalo wings were great! Sauce was just amount of heat, chicken was juicy, not overcooked. Forgot to take a pic of the turkey club which was really good. read more

Yannis Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Who could argue with nice neighborhood Pizza house that serves a lot more. I driven by countless times and more often than not I hankered to stop for a grinder. Finally, I called and ordered takeout on a lazy Sunday night. Teeming with regulars in their booths and at the tables. I was likely greeted and confirmed my order. The ever anticipated WHOLE grinder was ready and the two medium pies still in the oven. I don't mind being a little early, so I can take in the scene, scope out the behind counter action, and the plates of food en-route to the tables. The kitchen crew most young with a few seasoned veterans. Counters clean and well organized. Oh wait, "Your pies are ready." Sweet. Paid and off for home with the cache. The 2 mediums, 1 four cheese with garlic, the other Veggie. I know you've been wondering, "What kind of colossal grinder?" Well my favorite, Capicola (hot or sweet - it does not matter). Delicious! The pies, I favored the 4 Cheese over the Veggie. However, I prefer a thinner less doughy base & crust. Yup, I'll return; for another CAPI. read more

See all

I have been going to Yannis for years! The owners are friendly and accommodating as well as the staff. Food- I never have been disappointed in all of their dishes. The salads are all plentiful and the small is huge. The salads always my go to. Pizzas and grinders are delicious. Yannis also gives you bread/butter where many restaurants have stopped. The food is priced very reasonably! read more

My first time here and I did a take out. I ordered for a Hawaiian pizza and a seafood pizza. Both the pizzas had the right crunchy crust and it was packed with flavors. The seafood pizza was the best, had the fresh taste of sea and delicious. The restaurant was packed and I will definitely be back to explore the menu. read more

Yannis Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Just moved to the area and absolutely love their pepperoni pizza. We always ask for a well done pie and they never disappoint. The salads are delicious and couldn't have asked for a better garlic bread. The staff is super friendly. read more

I have been coming to Yannis since I was young and the food is incredible! I have never had a bad experience with either the service or food. The waitresses and cooks are so friendly and add to the wonderful experience of supporting small businesses! When we go to Yannis we ALWAYS get the seafood stuffed scallops, my favorite dish of all time! The pizza is amazing as well! Everything we have tried from the menu (which is a lot) has been so delicious. I highly recommend Yannis, such a hidden gem in the newington area. read more

Yannis Pizza Restaurant - Seafood stuffed scallops - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

See all

Everything is always great Food always super, great staff. Nice clean appealing atmosphere. read more

Everything here is top notch. Family owned business, super nice people, and great food.

Everything is delicious and service is prompt. The menu has variety, the specials are a favorite.

fantastic food and help they get it right every time - such good food - wonderful service