Amazingly great pizza great service, family, family business it's oh so good light bcd kgsf read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

Excellent service, very nice and helpful staff. Pizza with regular crust is greasy and floppy, desperately needed salt. They had it on the table so I wonder if they know that. read more

We had Mellow Mushroom in Orlando a long time ago and recalled it was pretty good. Tonight it was amazing! really good pie with great choices for toppings. Out sever was so friendly and helpful. Surprisingly busy for a weeknight which points to good food and service IMO. Pizza after duck bowling for the win!! Fun vibe here. read more

See all

The service was amazing, quick but you never felt rushed. We were in a hurry but that was our fault not theirs... the hostess was friendly and the manager checked on us more than once! Best service we've had in Fayetteville to date. The food was spectacular, the medium sized pizza is massive, my daughter's sandwich was amazing and the avocado was fresh. Just absolutely wonderful all around! read more

Food was great! Service was prompt and professional. Natalia was awesome! She was friendly and personable. Good job. I will always return, especially if Natalia is there's! read more

DoorDash ordered. Pizza pie is very nice. We ordered the same pizza flavor all the time. l may say that, these folks are serious about making you satisfied on your pizza pie order. read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - Fresh untouched - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

See all

First time here was impressed with how good the food was. The restaurant was clean and had a nice ambiance. Our server was really nice and attentive The holy shiitake was delicious. spinach and artichoke was delicious. I did not like the great white pizza read more

See all

I hate leaving negative reviews because Mellow Mushroom used to be one of my favorite places to eat, but unfortunately we had another really disappointing experience today. The service was awful from the start. Our appetizers came out, but we had to ask several times just to get blue cheese. Then we eventually realized our entrées had never even been put into the system. The food we did receive was cold, and after waiting so long with no resolution, we decided to leave. We offered to pay for the apps we had already eaten, but I will say the manager was very kind and comped them, which we appreciated. Still, this is the second bad experience we've had there within the past year, and it really bums me out because this place used to be a favorite for our family. I truly hope they can improve the service and consistency moving forward. read more

Greasy pizzas, tasted like cardboard. The reason that I've given it three stars is because the waitress was very good. But other than that, the food tasted terrible. Definitely not coming back. read more

The aesthetic of this place is standard, groovy ston3r paraphernalia and honestly, I wanted a staff shirt by the end of the meal. The pizza itself is mediocre, but the "pretzel" bites (just tasted like leftover dough) with spicy beer cheese were pretty good despite not actually being pretzels. Draft list had 1-2 local options, but it was mostly imported brews. Overall, wasn't really impressed but wasn't horrible. Waitress tried her best and she honestly earned a whole star out of the 3 I'm giving. read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - House Special - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

As your friendly neighborhood pizza connoisseur........I didn't expect Mellow Yellow was gonna hit like that, but wow. Best pizza in town (literally), service was great, and the vibes were chill. If I could give it 6 stars I'd give it 7. read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - Mighty Meaty, and kids Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

The service and prices were good. The pizza was awesome! The 60s hippy vibe was fun. Glad to find these restaurants in the cities I travel to. read more

I have had Mellow Mushroom in the past and have enjoyed it very much. But for some reason this time it didn't live up to the glory it used to be.. I didn't remember how expensive this pizza bistro really was! It's a lot. To build your own pizza the charge for ingredients being almost $3 per topping is a lot. Then on top of the meats costing the equivalent of 2 other toppings it's just a lot. Then the size of the pie is disappointing. The pizza tasted really good that's true, the veggies tasted fresh. The service was great too! Our waitress was very attentive and helpful. The ambiance was fun and whimsical! Heavily enjoyed the transformer in the front yard haha! It's a good spot, I think probably better for brewery but I'm not a fan with the cost at all. Sorry :/ ! read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - BYO Pie - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

This was the best pizza I have ever had. If you're looking for a place to eat, Mellow mushroom is the place to go. W

Only ate here twice but really enjoyed the roasted chicken mushroom sandwich. It was clean and servers were pleasant.

Delicious, fresh food - always good with fast service. The ingredients taste high-quality, and the pizzas come out hot and flavorful every time. The atmosphere is fun and laid-back, perfect for families or a casual night out. Staff is friendly and attentive, and we've never had a bad experience. Highly recommend! read more

Mellow Mushroom is a very yummy experience for any human on the earth to take in. Truly, their pizza changed my life significantly and I haven't been the same since. We love you, Mellow Mushroom. read more

This place has gone downhill. Leaving this review March of 2025. The staff just stood around and did nothing. We waiting for 15 min before being spoken to and the place was dead. Five employees just stood around chatting and not doing anything. A lady named Shelby was the only one who helped us. Food wasn't bad but hard to enjoy it when you wait for 40 min to eat and have to ask for your own plates, then ask for napkins and utensils. Not coming back to the Fayetteville location. read more

The female manager here is amazing and gave me the best service I have ever got she is very respectful and treats you like family and not to mention the food is amazing and so is the atmosphere I felt very comfortable and satisfied after eating here. read more

Disappointing. My husband and I were telling my mom (who was in town visiting) how every place in Fayetteville is packed on Fridays but for some reason Mellow Mushroom never is, which is convenient. Well, we soon figured out why; my husband was served a warm beer and it took almost an hour to get 2 small pizzas and a Caesar salad. I always liked their pizza, which is why I recommended going there, but the pizza had so much cheese it was hard to even eat and the Caesar salad looked like someone just stripped a head of lettuce and didn't cut it. For $70 with a tip, it's another Fayetteville restaurant that proves you're better off cooking at home, or in this case, ordering Hungry Howie's. read more

My son is a hardcore pizza lover, so we knew that for his 8th birthday we had to take him to get some, so my husband recommended Mellow Mushroom, as he had been there several times himself. Let me say right now, MELLOW MUSHROOM IS *THE* PLACE TO GO IF YOU LIKE PIZZA. We knew we were in for something special and unique when we pulled in and saw the giant statue of the Transformer. When we got inside, we were greeted by a very pleasant hostess and were seated right away. The ambiance is so cool, with lots of colors, posters, and even artwork on the walls made out of bottle caps. As you can see for yourself, there are practically limitless choices, whether you want to get one of the pies on the menu, or make one from a (very long) possibility of choices that are listed. My son ordered his own, with extra mozzarella, pepperoni, and mushrooms. My husband and I get the Veggie pizza (sans onions) every time we go. When it comes to appetizers, I HIGHLY recommend the meatballs. Adult beverages are also served at Mellow Mushroom, my favorite being their Sangria. IMHO, it's the best sangria I've ever had. The service is just as stellar as the food itself. We are always treated with kindness, courtesy, respect, and friendliness. Brio is our favorite, and we always look for her when we go. I wish there were way more people like her in the service industry. Mellow Mushroom is NOT to be passed up! read more

See all

As a long time vegetarian I've always had a deep love of mellow and this one didn't disappoint. We ordered online and it was pretty simple (don't close or leave the browser though- it restarts). You can even tip on there. We got a salad- enlighten spinach one. It was great- lots of cheese and nuts and the balsamic dressing was plentiful and delicious. Packaged well too. The veggie pizza with thin crust was also a bit- tons of good cheese and veggies. Pick up was fast but next time I want to eat inside. The restaurant was busy and looked so well decorated. Pups allowed on patio. Great lights and parking. read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - Pick up area. - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

This place is so legit, manager is awesome. She gave me a free pepperoni pizza and she was very nice! read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

First let me start by telling y'all that IF you're wanting to try some wings order their "cloud 9 wings" DO IT ! but my go to is always the avocado hoagie and add chicken. Service is good. I always do pick up orders and my food is delicious everytime. It's a bit pricey but I guess they aren't the only ones. read more

Very attentive customer service .They were quick to take my order and the place looks clean and smells great. read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - Menu is so eccentric!! - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

See all

Psst... you over there checking out this place and wondering if it's a go or a no, I have something to tell you. Why am I talking in a whisper? I may loose my "Midwesterner Card" if anyone back home sees this review. So let's keep it quick because I like the best of both worlds...shhhhhh! Lean in...this place is great! The service is prompt and friendly, the manager always makes the rounds to check in with you too. The beer selection is plentiful and updated according to the season. Quick!!! Duck down!!!! I heard another nasally accent nearby! Don't let them see me! The pizza options are unique and I LOVE their Thai Pizza option. Yes, I said Thai Pizza. Also, get their cheese bread cause it's a delicious appetizer just to hold you over until the main course arrives. What was that?? What did you say? Too much carbs and bread? I'm smh, clearly you don't know how it's done, I'll send a Cubs fan your way so they can teach you the meaning of life. So, to conclude you should definitely come here. They have sweet chalk artists too and the work is displayed throughout the restaurant. Oh, you'll get to meet Bumblebee on your way in too. Alright. I'm gonna stand up and walk this review off while taunting the Cubs fan. Shhh! This never happened! Go-Go White Sox! Go-Go White Sox! read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

Beware of this establishment make sure you write the clearly and take your receipt. My waitress forced my ticket by changing the tip amount. I called the manager and he didn't even apologize he was like I need your card to give you the difference. I found out this because my card company notified be of the weird amount of tip. read more

This is my first time at this restaurant , the service was very bad. We were 7 three adults 4 kids , one of the kids order pizza from the kids menu one order meatballs, and the other macaroni and cheese and the adults order pizza and chicken wings it took like 30 minutes to bring one pizza of the little kids from the kids menu and the server never came to the table and check on us. They only came to take the order and deliver the food. read more

I use to love coming to Mellow but haven't been in a few years. Something definitely happened to the pizza, they changed the sauce and the crust. Red sauce on the pizza was horrible. Ordered a side salad, had to send it back because the lettuce was wilted and slimy. Wait staff very nice and apologetic. No way I will go back to this location. Will try another location next time to see if its the same food quality, if it is good bye mellow mushroom. PS the place also needs a thorough cleaning, especially the windows inside and out. Floor was sticky too. read more

Consistently difficult to order from. I'm not excited about a pizza place that seems to put output under performance

My second visit. I took my sister for her birthday. It was really good. The Holy Shitaki pie is my favorite. read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - Took my sister to Mellow Mushroom for her birthday. We truly enjoyed our meals & they made a birthday pretzel for her. - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

This place never disappoints. I am lactose intolerant and they have vegan cheese, so I can actually enjoy pizza.

We had a party of five, we were seated immediately, after being greeted warmly. The waitress took our drink and appetizer order and we were promptly served. We ordered three medium pizzas and two small salads. All three pizzas were excellent and tasty, the salads were fresh and the dressings were piquant and delish...the manager came to our table three times to check on our level of service and satisfaction. She was very friendly and cordial! read more

delish food! service was quick and good came out decently quick. i would like to see more fresh ingredients used instead of canned stuff (we had canned jalapeño & pineapple on our pizza) but overall it was good! read more

I ordered a delivery. My food came still hot and delicious! The Great White is an amazing flavorful pie! Cloud 9 wings were crispy and tender. Very satisfying. read more

We where stranded for the night in Fayetteville. Thankfully our hotel was close to mellow! The gluten free pizza was fresh and flavorful! We ordered takeout and the timing on delivery was less than 30 minutes after ordering! Great service! read more

I ate dinner at this Mellow Mushroom the other night (07/30/20) and I came with a party of about 13. I believe our server was Kaitlyn. The only thing that disappointed me in the slightest bit was that we had to sit at two separate tables. We made it work. I'm not even upset about it because rules were put in place for a reason and I am actually glad that they are implementing these safety measures. When there was a small issue with my order, my waitress was very understanding and fixed it in a heartbeat! All of the staff mewere wearing their masks as they should, the service was great considering how large my party was, and the food was great! I a highly recommend the Holy Shiitake Pizza with chicken added! Thank you Mellow Mushroom, I will be returning!! **Friendly reminder to be nice to your waiters and waitresses because when there is an issue with your food, it's likely the kitchen that is at fault and not them :) ***UPDATE*** I went here for dinner again last night (08/01/20) and our server was Tierney! She was super sweet and energetic and the overall experience was great!! Also, I HIGHLY recommend the spinach artichoke dip with pitas!! read more

See all

Go for pizza and beer! We had a large cheese pizza and 2 cold pints of beer. The pizza was hot and fresh. The beer was pour right and was cold. All the better in a hot Florida day. We didn't stay too long but had a good time! read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - Cold craft beer - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

Good pizza dough, good pizza options and topping, good beer and drink options and with a great friendly staff that keeps on top of things.. Quickly has become my favorite pizza place in Fayetteville. read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - Cosmic Karma With Bacon and washing it down with a Shiner Bock! - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina

See all

Was hesitant first walking in but the food was well worth it. Service was good. Atmosphere was calm as well while eating. Can definately see myself coming back. read more

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville - Buffalo Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, North Carolina