I've been a fan of Mellow Mushroom for years. Here in Sarasota, I've experienced a crew that is a cut above the average pizza house. I very much appreciate the staff and the wonderful selections of pizza. They will go all out to satisfy even the dietary requests such as gluten-free dough and vegetarian demands. They've supplied fantastic service for large groups (up to 80 people), and a big shout out to the group organizers and staffers (Karen, Dan and the rest). Tremendous portions and so deeply committed to the craft of good family pizza-time. Take yourself, take the family, organize a group eating frenzy and you won't be disappointed. read more

I met a friend here for dinner. The building is large and the hostess was friendly. We got there a little before 6 and had no wait time. The place was never full. It's on track for their brand in decorating and the place was clean. I didn't have to visit the flush rooms so I can't review those. Our server came and got our drink orders promptly and then took our order when we were ready. The wait time for the pizzas was a little longer than we thought it would be and we saw others getting their food more quickly. We had the great white and krazy karma and it was really good. We chose the classic crust and I liked that! It was a nice evening to catch up with a friend. They have a lot of options. They can easily accommodate families and the parking is totally sufficient. read more

See all

Great place great service great food always we have driven here from Port Charlotte. Just to get this pizza.So that's how great this pizza is love.The casual ambiance. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sarasota - Back for another great pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

The "personal" pizzas are huge, but they are so good. I love that I can go here with vegan friends! The local specials were outstanding, we had a great time. Smelled and looked so good I got no pictures before delving in. read more

See all

This place is really good. All the Sarasota Stoners go here but it is for all kinds of people. We got the pretzel bites for lil appetizer and they were filling enough. But we still ate most of our mushroom extra sauce and extra cheese pizza. This place is just cool the atmosphere. Fun Fact this is where Pee-Wee Herman went to jail back in the day when it was a movie theater. This is worth the stop in Sarasota read more

Mellow Mushroom Sarasota - in front - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

I had been to Mellow Mushroom further south in Florida (maybe Fort Myers?) and loved it so I thought this would be more of the same. I was disappointed. The atmosphere not warm and welcoming like the other location. The pizza (when it finally arrived!) was nothing to rave about. Dry is the only way I can describe it. Sorry we did not go to the other 5 star place nearby, but I was remembering the other location and wanted to give this a try. Oh well. Three stars because the server was kind and friendly. read more

Just okay tonight. Table really dirty. Server was super sweet. Felt like the amount of shiitake mushrooms was lacking. Tasted pretty good tho. One Diet Coke and a large pie $46 after tip. Ugh. Not sure we'll be back. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sarasota - Holy Shiitake Pie - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

We love Mellow Mushroom! Always try to hit up a new location when we're in Florida. The pretzel bites with beer cheese are super tasty. We always opt to split the Holy Shiitake pizza and then my husband gets bacon added to his half. Their happy hour is great with lots of discounts from 3pm - 6pm and it also includes $3 mocktails! Outstanding! read more

See all

Family visit to enjoy a pizza fest. over the weekend. This spot is definitely family oriented and the pizza is very good. Moderate ambience, service a little slow but all in all a good place to go for Italian read more

Service was excellent, price reasonable and food selection varied. Friendly customers

First time to try MM. Large pizza was amazing (half was the shiitake and other half was the house special.) Both were delicious and highly recommend! Really liked the bread dough of what I assume is a wheat/white flour mixture. Veggie Calzone; delicious with plenty of fresh veggies! Cheesy bread, did not like or recommend. An open bun with melted mozzarella and a lil seasoning........ Paper straws, NOT a fan! Server Dan was excellent in all aspects! Thank you sir for your service, keep up the great work! read more

In our 48 years together, pizza had a bold tomato flavor, heavy on spices like basil oregano especially garlic with beef stock sometimes in the plentiful sauce. We lived in CT, VA and MN plus worked in the 1970's 1980's in NYC. Your life experience determines your taste preferences. Mellow Mushroom was EXCELLENT in wait staff, decor, ambiance, cleanliness and Beautiful pastry like crust. Our deluxe meat eaters pizza ordered with extra sauce came with almost no sauce, and almost zero " sausage, beef,bacon, ham". The vegetables on it were EXCELLENT. But for our palate and life experience , the overall pizza had zero flavor, and was sadly very very bland. A large came to $28. read more

I'm not sure why their rating was so low. We went there and it was great. Wings are baked and fall off the bone. The garlic parm sauce was delish... Spinach salad w apple and feta was spot on w the house vinaigrette. Manager came around and checked on things... Tvs were on sports... parking lot was nice, restaurant was clean and the main item... the pizza was great. I don't know why their rating was low... but glad my wife picked the place (based on the nicer red wine by the glass) read more

Mellow Mushroom Sarasota - BBQ chx pizza ... supposed to be for one but more than 8ne could eat - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

I enjoy this unconventional pizza place. The dough, made from Appalachian Spring Mountain water, is pretty light in texture--crispy yet pleasantly chewy and just delicious in my opinion. What really sets them apart is the creative and more unique toppings they place on their 'zas. We love the Holy Shiitake for a very unconventional, and tasty departure from the norm, as well as the Great White pie. My daughter is a fan of the cheese pizza as well as the Great white sans the basil and tomatoes. The salads are also good as well. Ordering online is a breeze as is pickup. Food always is hot and freshly made. I will continue to patronize this place as long as the desire for differently styled pizza strikes. read more

See all

Casual and warm place to grab good pizza and other fare. Friendly and attentive staff. Good drink selection and happy hour deals.

Very good food but it took a long time to get the check.Everything else was very clean bathrooms were very nice

Great pizza & beer night Great service Great ambiance Plenty of parking Reasonable prices read more

We have always loved Mellow Mushroom, since our first visit in Savannah GA. No matter what location in any state where we ate, it was always delicious. This location has great service, nice atmosphere, delicious food, nice alcohol choices too. They have a great choice for seating as well. I highly recommend this Mellow Mushroom location. It never disappoints. read more

Love the Holy Shitake Mushroom pizza it is to die for Been getting take out recently but I have never had anything but excellent service the dozen times we have eaten there. read more

About pizza this is really honestly real answer, the best i ever had so far, not joking if anyone like pizza you must tray one here,the best of best, you choose toppings . Service was also good server name is Michael,sorry if I spelled incorrectly, about ambience is nice,just tv's did not work except one,but we talk about food is excellent in every aspect, see you soon. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sarasota - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

The place is pretty nice inside, the pizza was lame, the avocado on the sandwhich was not ripe and the only good things were the wings, only get the wings if you go there. Waiter was ok he seems to have a little bit of an attitude and didn't smile at all read more

See all

I know it's a franchise but we always have good pizza here. I am a connoisseur of good pizza and I prefer woodfired Italian style pizza, but this is good. We had it delivered to our condo cuz we were too lazy to pick it up. The door dash driver was fast and the pizza was still pipping hot when it arrived. read more

CAUTION! Got a food allergy? They will ignore it. Went to MM for pizza. Ordered a large pizza and salad. Informed waitress no onions due to food alergy. Emphisized "sever allergy". When salad arrived it was covered in onions. Waitress took salad away supposedly to make a new salad. Salad returned with no onions. However, pizza arrived covered in onions. In addition, pizza was not hot but closer to room temperature. Decided not to wait for new pizza and left. Plenty other places to get pizza. MM is off our list. read more

Second visit to an MM (first was in Paducah). This place had a very good and quick lunch service, even with the GF crust for Therese H. Excellent pizza, good beer, fine service. Thanks, MM. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sarasota - House Special, small, minus green peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Initially excited to try this place after reading good reviews, but we're quickly disappointed. Now if you like Dominos, Pizza Hut, Chucky Cheese or Little Cesar's style pizza then you will enjoy this place. We'll stick to supporting our local NY or Napolitian pizzeria. For $25, we got flavorless pizza dough which lacked a crisp & crunchy crust. The pizza was doughy, soggy and undercooked and overloaded with thick greasy cheese and light amount of sauce which tasted like it came out of a jar. Wings were overcooked, fried and dry. On a positive note the staff were nice, and the ambiance of the restaurant was fun and Alice in wonderland like. read more

I recently hosted a group dinner at the Mellow Mushroom in Sarasota for 80 Sarasota High School baseball players and their moms and it was AMAZING!!! Everyone had such a great time! The food was delicious! Service was awesome! And dinning area and set-up were perfect and for our group! We'll definitely be back! Owner, Karen Atwood, is so supportive of our team! She's awesome! read more

Mellow Mushroom Sarasota - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Mellow Mushroom has a fun, funky, inviting vibe. Pizzas are always good - love the Shitaki mushroom pie! Service is great people are wonderful read more

Just had one of the best pizzas I have ever had. My husband and I went to MM for lunch today. I enjoyed a bacon and onion pizza, while he had the Super Pep. For the app we had baked garlic parm wings. All of our food was delicious. We we be coming here again soon. read more

Favorite pizza south of I-74! Thanks to Karen and her team for supporting at risk students with delicious Friday pizza donations! We value your restaurant and love great tasting pizza. ~Coach read more

Mellow Mushroom Sarasota - Delicious choices! - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Great experience and our server was awesome I wish I got his name. The food came out fresh, hot and flavorful. Great area for a large groups and booths available as well for small groups. Lots of different options are far as gluten free, vegetarian and vegan options. The place was very clean which is always a priority aside from good food. Overall I'd be back the next time I'm in Sarasota. read more

See all

The Food Is Great I loved this place before, and I still love this place. I have always been mellow. Mellow Mushroom isn't as far out as they could be, music upbeat, not Joan Baez, staff dressed normally, no headbands or beads. If you are not a child of the 60's like me, it's ok, this place is still for you. I had the same things I had when I wrote my last review, their Magic Mushroom soup and House Special pizza. The soup was again impressive, loved the flavor and consistency. As for the pizza, that was a lot of great pizza. I got the small size, a 10" soft crust pie cut into 4 large slices. Large and heavy, these were substantial slices, topped with so much stuff, so much cheese. I finished 3 and felt like I overate, bringing the last slice home. This was their small sized pizza. I should mention I saw online they offer lunch specials, typical slice and a drink stuff, one or two toppings. They also have other items like sandwiches and burgers. I'm never trying their burgers, the pizza is too good. It wasn't overly busy for lunch so I asked if they still get slammed and have parking issues. I learned sometimes yes in the evenings but not as much as when they first opened. That was good to know. If you have stopped considering them because of their popularity, you should reconsider. The food is great. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sarasota - Magic Mushroom Soup - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Their Holy Shiitake pizza is delicious and the "Large" size is huge. A little on the pricey side. They also have gluten free options, which not all pizza places offer. The service was friendly, a bit slow. But I still give them 5 stars overall. read more

They did a great job here with my pizza! The service was great. The bartender took care of my odd beer request. Everything was quite good and the experience was a great one! The pizza was excellent and cooked well (pepperoni and mushroom). The garlic knots were tasty as well. All around a good experience! read more

Came here for trivia night with some friends. Ordered the House Special pizza sans the black olives (the boss is a hater of them, I like them). Also got a Greek salad. Pizza was really good. Terrific crust, generous portions of toppings. Salad was also very fresh. Service was good for as many people that were there for trivia night. Overall, it's a good place to get a pie. I've driven by this place a zillion times and I'm glad I finally came to eat here read more

The pizza was amazing Friendly and fast service I thought the artwork on the walls was very cool read more

We LOVE mellow mushroom and are frequent visitors of this location. The workers are very nice and the vibe is always good. The food is amazing but had some complications today. My friend did not receive the custom pizza she had ordered with pesto sauce and cheese/pepperoni. We were in a rush so they were unable to remake it. Other than that, we love the location and hope to return with our families. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sarasota - Holy Shiitake Pie and Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

We loved the appetizers and pizzas. Great food, menu has a great variety & excellent service! read more

Pizza was just ok. Similar to Dominos. Crust was good but the sausage didn't taste like real sausage. They charge me for every little thing I asked for and didn't mention it would cost extra. A tiny cup of balsamic and extra dipping sauce since the first was half filled. read more

First time visiting and the food experience was superb. From the art and decorations to the service and menus, the place just gives off great vibes. We ordered the pretzel bites with beer cheese and the cloud 9 wings were floored by the flavor. Our goal was to try a couple pies and take some home so we each ordered something different. I ordered the Wild in Havana and my girlfriend ordered the Holy Shiitake. Both were so tremendously special that I'm still Thinking about them days later to write this review. I can't wait to visit again and try something new (probably gonna get the wild in Havana again, though, since there is nothing else like it) In fact: the wild in Havana is a pizza based off of a Cuban sandwich. It sounds odd, but I swear it is so good you wouldn't ever question the concept of what you're eating. It has real pork and pickles and a mustard swirl that was just too good. The dough of these pies is a star as well. It is cheesy and flavorful and stands out even cold from the fridge. I believe that is what is used in the pretzel bites which we loved. The holy shiitake pizza was also stupendous, big meaty pieces of mushrooms and a wonderful garlicky flavor make you wish there was more room in you to eat more. I do wish they were closer to where we live, but in my opinion it's worth the drive for us to get a pizza that makes you forget the other pizzas you love. read more

See all

Excellent pizza! Plenty of sauce and cheese! Roasted mushroom mix was great! All toppings were plentiful, too! read more

Mellow Mushroom Sarasota - Medium half/half pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida