Pizzas are great, service is great and atmosphere is always welcoming!…read more Glad I have tried them because we have gone back and will continue to give them our business!!!

10/10 for everything! The pizza crust is DELICIOUS and perfect ratio to toppings and sauce. They…read morehave a thanksgiving pizza during the holidays that is TO DIE FOR.

Friendly staff, great environment, and excellent food!! One of the best cuisine spots in…read moreGainesville.

Great food. Great service and drinks. It was quiet at a family restaurant. We will go back.read more

We came to town to have work done on our car and it was not quite ready for pickup so we stopped in…read morefor dinner. The building is extremely old but the interior is nicely restored. The lady who waited on us was very friendly, answering our questions about the menu. Our pizza came and it looked amazing and the taste did not disappoint. The crust was nice and thin. We added ricotta which was soooo good. Pizza snobs from Chicago will definitely visit next time we are in town.

The food is delicious, you won't be disappointed! Please add…read morea MENU to your website! It would bring in lots of people because we're in a small town.

Dropped in for their lunch specials after spending everything from the casino. Such a cute and…read moresmall town! Immediately was able to sit down and get greeted at a table. Decor was minimal but prices for lunch was great. You pay for the portion you get! Wasn't too big. They load you up on the bread though with a bowl of butter at the table. Food was basic, Alfredo sauce was quite thin. The tortellini was better imo. The Caesar salad had too much dressing for me and it's thick.

This is the best Italian I have had in years. This would be my next best place to eat except it's…read morethree hours from home. I had the chicken marlla and the mushroom sauce was amazing over the grilled chicken.

Food is good and they were quick The service is great. They…read morepaid a lot of attention to us and other customers. I loved all the decorations

The food wasn't good. My chicken Marsala was more like a gravy instead of a Marsala wine sauce…read more The chicken over done. Vegetables I ordered were frozen veggies. My husband's lasagna had no noodles hardly. Usually a lasagna is layers and this was not. Not a good experience at all.

The food is amazing. Everything is fresh and didn't have to wait long. Food is very affordable. The…read morestaff is always friendly. Just a great place overall and always have a pleasant experience every time I'm here.

Love eating here! Super nice staff and delicious food. Can't go wrong with a hot Italian sandwich!read more

My wife made reservations at this place for our honeymoon weekend. And there are no words I can say…read morefor how amazing the food was and how amazing our waitress Cali was. She went above and beyond for us to the point where it moved us to tears . 10/10 HIGHLY RECOMMEND we're coming back to see you Cali! You are just that amazing!

Cali was the best server. We had a strict celiac diet and she had great recommendations. Most of…read morethe menu was gluten-free or able to be, and tasted just as delicious as gluten containing food. Their plates are really cute. Portions were perfect. Super cute place. We will be going back soon. Go see Kenny and Cali!!

I love their staff and always have a solid meal here. Order the meatballs, you won't regret it…read more Best I've ever had.

Maybe worth another try. After reading some great reviews, we decided to give this place a try and…read moreordered takeout for our family on Sunday evening. Unfortunately, the experience didn't quite live up to our expectations. The pizza dough was extremely dry and tough to eat, and the pasta was pretty flavorless. That said, the staff was friendly and welcoming, and the restaurant itself looked like a nice, cozy place to dine in. Hopefully, we just caught them on an off night.

This place is in the same complex as the antique mall, located diagonal to it. The name of the…read morevenue & entrances are facing away from Main st. We usually go to Bedford for NY pizza & this one is closer. Saw the raving reviews on local foodie group, so we went & got the large supreme, $24.99. It was good, but not the best NY pizza. The crust was a bit thinner than what we expected, & there was hardly any sauce, so it wasn't as flavorful as we expected. If you like your pizza with minimal sauce, you'd like it. The price was on pricey side, $24.99 for one large supreme. The dining room is small & very simple but functional. The staff were nice & extra packages of Parmesan & pepper didn't cost extra like those big chained pizza places. Will try other menu items next time.

I needed 13 pizzas delivered within 48 hours and while other places in the area said it couldn't be…read moredone, Valentinos NY Pizza stepped up. They were professional, confident, and made the whole process stress free. They absolutely saved the day! and the pizza was delicious!! I'd recommend them any day, without hesitation. One of the best ever!

The egg in the sandwich was done perfectly, and had a very healthy helping of cream cheese…read more Also loved the blueberry streusel muffin I tried, it was absolutely wonderful.

We had a heck of a time finding this place, but it definitely ended up being worth all the fuss…read more Sandwiches were fresh and delicious. Fantastic, quick service. It was a convenient stop on our way to Turner Falls, but man do I wish they had a sandwich shop like this near home!