Great thin crust pizza! We've ordered twice since becoming Berwyn-ites! It's very easy to pick up & the staff have been so friendly. Ambiance inside is a little stiff w all the Fox News & sweepstakes machines. I'll stick to picking up & am already thinking about our next pizza night. read more

Hours on both Yelp and Google showed open until midnight. Attempted to enter right before 11:15pm - door was locked and the place was empty with lights turned off. Would have loved to give it a try, and updating hours online is so easy. read more

Michael Anthony's Restaurant & Bar - Entrance - missing business hours - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

Michael Anthony's is such a reliable, cozy spot for a delicious meal. The food is always fresh, well-prepared, and full of flavor. Whether you're stopping in for pizza or one of their daily specials, you can expect something comforting and satisfying. The atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, and the service is always attentive without being overbearing. A great choice for a casual night out or a family dinner, definitely a Berwyn gem. read more

Michael Anthony's is really good and it's a hidden gem if you are in the neighborhood stop by and give them a try. The service was amazing and the food was amazing and the beer was super cold and don't be shy and give them a try read more

Attended a birthday get together and had a great time! We've been here a few times for bday celebrations and have always had a good experience. Great food and a nice little private space. The workers were on top of drinks and food. Will def be back! read more

Local bar and casual restaurant with tavern style pizza. Came here for a kids birthday party and they have a nice space to host. Our waitress was attentive and the drinks kept coming. Wish the sauce on the pizza had a bit more flavor too. But I appreciate cracker thin crust! After the party we went to another bar. The male bartender working that night had an attitude and it wasn't even busy. One of the adults had gone up to the bartender to get a drink and he refused and told them to ask our waitress. read more

Michael Anthony's Restaurant & Bar - Happy 10th Birthday Emily! - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

See all

It's been three years since I've been to this pizza spot in Berwyn and it still taste the same. Great flavor from the crust to the toppings. The pizza thin crust is perfectly crunchy. The sauce has such great flavor and they added the right amount of sauce to each bite. The Italian beef was so juicy and the side dipping sauce had such a great flavor. read more

See all

Nice woman on the phone. Ordered a 1/2 cheese 1/2 sausage medium pizza along with an order of gravy bread. Pizza was cold, not warm, cold. But after nuking it, tasted good. The gravy bread was inedible. If their beef tastes like the gravy bread, I'd pass on the beef. I'm not sure if I would order from here again. read more

Pizza was a heartburn tonight kids come over every weekend and they are my go to ! Tonight they said we need a new place !!! And whoever made the boneless wings needs to be checked for a food service cert! Any one can take chicken nuggets and soak them in Louisiana hot sauce with some extra apple cider vinegar just saying .... come on man !!! read more

Have not ordered a stuffed pizza here for awhile and I'm not sure why. Eating one right now after picking it up and still awesome.

Service was excellent food was very good. One star less cause I didn't care for the sauce on the pizza was bland but sharp with no real Italian seasonings in it. But the other ingredients pizza on the pizza were excellent. Will go again if in the area. read more

Me and my family have had many celebrations there! It's a family friendly establishment, everyone treats you like family. I have a little guy and it's hard to eat out with a 4 year old. He absolutely loves Michael Anthony's. The service is always great, food is always great and let's not forget the great hospitality. This was Mom's favorite place for years before she passed. So if your looking for a place to sit, eat and drink around a table with your people, this is the place. read more

Best place ever you can enjoy it with your friends with your family by yourself food the bar everything is great customer service amazing love it for more than 20 years read more

Went there with my family last week on Monday. Got say by a rude and unwelcoming server who was focused on my kids. Took our order for 2 beers and never came back. She was half naked which is fine and all but doesn't have service. We came before and was treated well but with this time we decided to never come back. We went to paisans and they had a wait as well but the waitress was way nicer. I really wanted to give a small business a chance but they treated me like I didn't belong there. To make matters worst they only had 2 groups of customers, not like they were slammed busy, I would understand. read more

Just for the bar: We stopped for a round of drinks (14) and Taylor and Danielle made us feel like regulars as soon as we sat down. I'd be there a lot if I lived in the neighborhood. BONUS good value TIP excellent TV watching for sports read more

Ordered a Large thin crust pizza (14 ") with sausage total with tax was $18.50 it wasn't hot like I'd expected after picking up in 18 minutes as they suggested. The pizza was fair. Sausage portions were generous but the layout was sloppy as well as the cuts. The pizza was not oily ( my photo is after I added Giardiniera ). I'll go back and try something else like Italian beef. read more

Michael Anthony's Restaurant & Bar - Large 14" Thin crust pizza with sausage - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

I began coming here in my teens for lunch on Fridays when I worked in this area during the summer of my H.S. years. Fast forward, almost 25 years later and honestly not much has changed. That's a good thing in this case! Took Mo here since we had to go to McNeil to visit my cousin. We ate at the bar and immediately had a feeling this is a friendly neighborhood bar. The clientele reflected how Berwyn has changed over the past decades where we saw a mix of Polish, Lithuanian and Mexicans at the bar/restaurant. I ordered a pizza while Mo ordered a Grilled Chicken sandwich. Both we cooked to a medium well type taste including the French fries. However the chicken breast was still juicy and delicious. The sausage on the pizza was real tasty. Not sure if it's homemade but wherever they get it, keep it up. The bartender was friendly and the prices were reasonable. Plenty of parking is available along Ogden and the neighboring side streets. read more

Michael Anthony's Restaurant & Bar - Exterior shot - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

See all

this is the best pizza in berwyn. hands down. there are a half-dozen pizza places on ogden (in berwyn), but this is the one you want! they do not skimp on toppings, unlike paisan's. read more

I decided to just go and call in an order of the sausage thin crust large pizza and I was glad I did it. This pizza is easily in my top two for this area. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Great Family Atmosphere!!! Food is amazing as always, especially the pizza!! Bingo on Tuesday night which is a great time. My daughter loves the claw machine and the prizes she get in it. The service is great and the owner Melissa has done amazing things with the place since taking over!! read more

Been going here since 2002 we have had about 4-5 family parties and they have always been great with the banquet service. Their meatballs and meatball sandwich is the best I ever had and I'm not a big meatball fan! Their pizza is a very thin crust it's good but not my favorite. The Italian wedding soup and the tortellini soup are amazing! Their oysters are yummy too! The staff is always nice and friendly! read more

We recently ordered pizza from Michael Anthony's for a small birthday party and everyone at the table loved it. We've ordered it before but then started trying different places maybe forgot how good it was. It is definitely a pizza that we all agreed was marvelously tasty. It is a thin pizza but with sooooooo much flavor. All the other restaurants we have tried come with mixed family reviews, too thin, too well done, too thick, too much sauce, yada yada, Michael Anthony's was just right. I don't have a picture because we dug in and then there was nothing left to photograph. Try it, you'll like it! read more

My family and I left and went to Paisan's instead thanks to the bartender Susan. She is rude and unprofessional. We had a party of 7 and left. She's rude! We have been customers for 30 years. We will never go back ever again. She was taking pictures of my children and I after I told her she had terrible customer service skills!! I've been serving for 10 years and never treated anyone the way she treated us! read more

Great pizza always amazing service when I go there never a complaint about a thing at Michael Anthony's

Last three times we ordered pizza thin crust and it wasn't the same. Very bad. Wouldn't recommend it.

Terrible service. The waitress was very rude to start. As we were sitting an older couple were walking out and the elderly lady fell because the railing was loose. My sister got up and walked her to her car. A lot of loud drunk girls at the bar. Shame is the food was good but a lot of ignorant employees. read more

I had never ordered from Michael Anthony before. I won't again. Not a terrible pizza just not what I was looking to get. Just trying a new place. On the plus side, there side orders were solid. Jalapeño poppers, and zucchini sticks. I ordered the larger quantities and they both were good still hot on delivery. read more

Wow! Great place, great food. We got an XL pizza and Buffalo wings. The wings were crispy on the outside and juicy and tender on the inside. The pizza has just the right amount of sauce and cheese and the crust is crispy. I couldn't stop eating it. Rachel served us and she was very nice and displayed excellent customer service. Bring your kids! They can color on the tables! We will be back real soon! read more

Cute place, easy, and blue collar with cheap drinks, friendly service, some wings that smell pretty killer. Could it use a facelift? Sure Should it get that facelift? Hell no. This place reminds me of family dive joints that only Chicago area businesses know how to do right. I'm not sure if they do a Friday night fish fry, but it sure looks like all the food hall bars that my parents would drag us to as kids so they could dig in on the FNFF. The pizza looked good and though I stuck to the same bottled beer, they actually had a decent variety of low to mid-level beers and even a few on draft. They've got casino games and it also seems like a great place to watch, 'the game' if you're into that sports ish. read more

Thank you Michael Anthony's for another great pizza in record time!!! My pizza was done in 20 minutes and it's delicious!! Still operating during this pandemic for takeout or delivery. One of the best spots in Berwyn. read more

The service here is horrendous. The food is usually good but seems like quality is declining. Susan the bartender is the rudest lady i've ever encountered. I'm not sure how she can pay her bills working for tips acting so unbelievably rude to customers! Wow! Been a long time loyal customer but they don't seem to care about the business anymore why should I. read more

Yea, the food here is not great. However, the drinks are cheap and the space is large. So when the faculty needs to party this is often the first stop. We ended our school year, ascended upon this space and drink our way into the summer. It's kinda like three or four different restaurants in one. There's a bar with a jukebox and one of those computer trivia game things that I can never figure out. There is an outdoor spot for smokers and and two open airy spot with booths and tables to sit and have a meal. You can have a small gathering in the smaller dining area if you want a private party feel. The bathroom is nothing to brag about but it's always clean and I appreciate that. read more

I called ahead last Friday night to make sure they had availability, they did since the previous place we tried going to had over a 30 minute wait! When we get there the waitress remembered our last name via caller id, And properly welcomed us, and seated us. Even in the dining hall, they had a huge screen TV playing "the Hawks game" .... definitely an added bonus.... food was ordered exactly how we wanted, appetizers were awesome! Very enjoyable experience, definitely going back..... maybe chill at the bar area next time kid less ;-) read more

Thin crust is "OK", but I've had better. It is a bit doughy/chewy. Wish it was crispier. I do not like their stuffed pizza at all - the sauce is not very good and the crust is not very tasty either. Sometimes I've got it overcooked and burnt - do they take a look at it when if comes out of the oven? read more

I go because this is the spot my old school mates choose to have our bi-yearly get togethers. Pizza is just ok. Havent had anything else on the menu. Sorry, its just not on my list of great eats. read more

We have ordered pizza from them before and were pretty happy with it, so we decided to go to the restaurant and have dinner. Very nice casual place and the service was great. Very enjoyable dining experience. read more

See all

Solid food and friendly staff that makes you feel at home. It has that "family owned" atmosphere. No frills, just good food.

The bar is loud and the patrons spew obscenities every other word. We were in the dining room, but we might as well have been in the bar--the volume of the people in the bar was so loud! The food was average--not what I'd call authentic Italian. It was what you'd find at a greasy college dining hall. The service was more like a venting session than a job. read more

Michael Anthony's is my sons favorite place for baked clams. We're regulars, all the server know us by name and are very tentative. Rachel already knows what we're going to order, she's so good to us. My son likes black olives on his pizza, sometimes she will bring him a little bowl of olives on the side. They treat you like family here. We love Michal Anthony's. read more

Its been our new favorite spot to order from. We enjoy the pizzas due to their nice, crispy, thin crust. The sandwiches are quite yummy. They have been doing their very best this last year to adjust to the Covid precautions. Sometimes, I go and pick up and I will see someone cleaning the bar top or table tops. They are doing a great job separating customers and keeping everyone as safe as possible. When we have food delivered, it is the same as eating in at the restaurant. Thank you to everyone there for your hard work and keeping us fed! read more