Only stopped by here because of their $5 and $10 margarita slushies. We decided to order at the bar and had to find/catch a table outside. This is what I picture when I think of a spontaneous New York moment. Yes we were on our way home, yes we saw the sign, yes we optimized. The warm weather, crowded streets and great company made this outing exceptionally enjoyable. The one slushie got me good and I just needed one to keep that buzz going for a while. Overall, I liked the price point - kinda stressful if you are looking for a table but people came and went and hey - what's there to complain about. read more

Pros : Fun Friendly staff Decent food Lively ambiance Crowed $5 frozen margaritas Cute security Cons : Subpar margaritas read more

Mickey Spillane's - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Always have to make time for happy hour! After dinner drinks, happy hour was still happening. Went on a night for Margaritas for $5, crowded place, sports bar, cozy corner of a bar in Hell's Kitchen. Indoor outdoor seating, indoors for winter of course. Mix crowd, inviting overall. Happy to walk in there with ease. Bouncers of course check for ID. Servers are somewhat attentive, no hard selling of drinks, whatever you want. Reasonably priced drinks. Watch out for offers of single and double on your drinks, price can go up double if you accept. read more

5$ margaritas is the only reason for being there and Force in one day. Good atmosphere while in there but again 5$ and a great buzz. read more

Mickey Spillane's - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Have you ever been lectured to at a dive bar?? As someone who's previously left great reviews here, this is an honest reflection of an unfortunate situation: Picture this - a group of 3 orders a pizza. A pizza comes, is plopped directly in front of us - and we start eating - because it is pizza at the end of the day. Now picture this. An irate person with disheveled look from back of house comes in and starts lecturing us about selfishness, about eating food that we didn't order... I was honestly so taken aback by the whole thing that I was left breathless. We offered to pay for our mistake, but we still got berated read more

#Whereisweekes......Experiencing a new place for Happy Hour. The wings was very good but a little salty from the Buffalo sauce, fries good and the $5 Margeritas was hitting the spot. I think it's safe to say it's a gay establishment. We had a great time. What I really like was that they have many hostess walking around making sure your drinks were being refilled, the status of your food order or bringing out your food order. Alexis Jones was doing the damn thing!!!!!! Yessssss.... making sure we was good at all times. I want to thank you soooooo much and good looking out. The ambiance was a great cool vibe I like for an afterwork outing. Drinks flowing , music on a chilled vibe not to loud. You can hear yourself talking amongst your group. Overall, Mickey Spillane's I recommend for afterwork vibe. Even though we are straight women, we had a great time at Mickey Spillane's. We will be going back. Also, I want to give Jordan F another host who's body was giving the most a shout out as well. read more

See all

This is my first time coming here and l'd come back again based on how friendly the bouncer was, how delicious the food turned out to be, and the two servers that waited on me and my friend one Sunday night. Totally forgot about taking good pictures, not really I just wanted to enjoy watching Sunday's Super Bowl Halftime Show. I also wanted to enjoy the food since we came hungry. There's unisex restrooms, a good amount of food served, full bar, and the highlight was that you share tables with people coming in and out, it was an amazing and enjoyable night! read more

See all

I love coming here to meet people and talk. There's definitely not much space in the bar to sit but there is a small seating section inside. The music and people are great. The frozen margaritas are phenomenal. There's only a few bartenders managing an overcrowded bar, but they seem like they're doing their best. Looking forward to coming back! read more

Great staff, especially the bartender and cook! My friend and I stayed way too long because they seem to have an endless happy hour. I'll absolutely be back again!!!! read more

Yummy food, good people watching, happy hour drinks were tasty but not strong, small cups of water, slow service, festive atmosphere. I do wish there was more seating outdoors with backs rather than benches, just a personal preference. The prices here are very fair and I enjoyed my lunch with a friend on this beautiful Saturday. read more

See all

Cool dive bar if you're looking for cheap drinks and food. The server was really friendly (girl with blonde/black hair). Not a fan of their frozen margaritas. The food is decent. Around 5pm, the place starts getting packed. read more

I had a fantastic time here! The drinks were so good and cheap, especially during happy hour. I went with my friends, and we all loved the wings. Highly recommend this spot for great drinks and tasty food! read more

Mickey Spillane's - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Amazing food and drinks ! Cool vibes The service is amazing. We can't forget about the music !!! read more

The vibes in here are just always good. Truly it's just a classic spot to go to for some great drink prices (we love cheap $5 drinks yasss). I've been here a few times but every other time it was either packed with people or I was intoxicated and just forgot to take my phone out, so I couldn't actually take in place and moment. The spot gives very LGBT sports bar vibes, and we live for it. I was actually watching the playoff game on the TV screens while enjoying a frozen marg! Def a cool spot for drinks and when seated at a table they are very attentive to us, even on a Saturday night which impressed me. Like I said, this is one of those classic staples in Hell's Kitchen, I'll always be back here. Sidenote-- When he gets packed on the weekends, there is actually someone manning the line for the bathroom so I appreciate that they have some order even in a small space! It's usually every man/woman for themselves read more

Mickey Spillane's - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Hey, it's a late night spot. They open late. They sell drinks at a good price and they strong if you wanna go someplace we're gonna put double and basically drinking soda of water. That's on you but for my dollar I'd come here. read more

Love this place. New manager is the cutest girl I've ever seen. Gonna call her bobby because of the bob and bangs, makes everyone smile !! Served by Brent and Sam at the bar - loved them both, sweet and funny. Great experience, great music, great frozen margs. A fav spot - will be back this weekend !! Boss knows what's up read more

One word to sum this place up... YAAASSSSSSSSS!!! Went there last night with one of my new favorite people in life. Once he mentioned 4 dollar drinks I was like "sign me up!" Good drinks, good food, good times! Looking forward to enjoying this place again. read more

Mickey Spillane's - Doible Tequila Sodas - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Centrally located in health kitchen... Come for a drink and stay for the food! There has been more than a couple times I've been there and had wonderful conversations with Bella. Make time to support this local establishment... read more

Micheal was the best server ever! Definitely come here!!!!! The cheapest best drinks !!!!!!!

I can for the $5 frozen margarita happy hour and they delivered! Very strong drinks and refreshing, great idea with friends and coworkers read more

Mickey Spillane's - Frozen watermelon marg - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Amazing Place !!! this was love to first sight ! Amazing place, Amazing people , service is great , prices are spectacular !!! We were eating near this place and one of my friends suggested to come here. We came , the place was not crowded so it was very easy to find a table inside. They checked our temperature and we went in. We used the scanner to get the menu , something new that every restaurant in New York is doing, and we starting to order. Shots and Drinks 4 dollars!!! in NYC ! this is gonna be my new spot!!! for sure hahaha. We ordered some Nachos with chicken , they were Great! Drinks - Sour Apple Margarita! 10 of 10 !! if you like Sour this is your drink! it was perfectly made!!! kudos to the bartender. Tequila Shots! - 4 dollars!! you cant top this price. lol Lime Margarita - 5 of 5 ! great Flavor This is a great spot, it was clean, bathrooms were spotless and the service was great!! Extremely recommended read more

Mickey Spillane's - Halloween! - New American Near Me - New York, New York

HOMOPHOBIC!! DO NOT GO HERE!! My friend (gay) and I (straight) went here a couple of days ago and had a horrible experience. While the frozen margaritas were good and the bartender was nice, the waiter was horrible. My friend and I stood outside in a corner away from the crowd talking amongst ourselves figuring out what to do next when a waiter approached us and said in a rude tone "you guys look lost". I responded saying we were fine and just figuring out our next plan to which he rudely responded "this is a gay bar" and immediately ran away. I will never forget the look on my friend's face -- who recently came out -- being essentially told by the waiter he did not belong here and neither did I. I would never have expected my friend or I to feel so unwelcome in a bar that preaches about inclusion. Still upset thinking about it to this day, do better Mickey's. read more

This is a fun place to hang out. Service is friendly and fast. The $5 frozen margaritas taste great, and are very refreshing on a hot day. Highly recommended. read more

My friends and I always love coming here for inexpensive drinks! They have lots of drinks from $4-5 all day. The frozen margs are my favorite! They have added a lot of outdoor seating to expand the seating options during Covid. We came here often before COVID and are enjoying the new outdoor seating options, especially as the weather gets warmer! Their food is pretty solid bar food. I really like the buffalo chicken nachos! They don't take reservations and their formula for seating people is a bit all over the place. There is no way to put your name on a list when all the tables are full which I find really strange. I hope they start taking a waitlist, especially since it's crowded on the weekends. Other than that, we love it here! read more

My go to for a night or weekend out with my friends. The servers are honestly always amazing. Idk about the other reviews but I always have a great time here, unless it's crazy packed and it's hard to get the bartenders attention -- if so then I sit down somewhere and call one of the servers -- Henrique is the sweetest!!!!! He always comes By our table to check up on me and my group and always asks if things are going great. read more

Honestly the best neighborhood bar! You want a guy that pays attention to your bar needs? You got the guy! The owner of this bar is one in a million and he's gives the best service. I was blown away with how he noticed what we wanted and responded in a heartbeat. You can't get that type of service often in NYC for such a great deal. My boyfriend and I are regulars here purely because the service is efficient and attentive and the prices can't be beat. Recently we got the wings and they were the perfect late night snack. You wouldn't normally expect GOOD food at a bar but somehow this bar does it which adds to their popularity. So next time you are in Hell's Kitchen consider Mickey's a neighborhood staple. read more

The food is decent, the drinks are good and the service is okay. Took about four reminders for them to bring out water and even then, they kept forgetting to bring enough for everyone. The bouncer/owner is a little nuts. We were seated outside and saw a tiny rat. He came over and started stomping everywhere despite us telling him to stop. Try the thin crust pizza and the spicy margs and come prepared for an interesting time. read more

Mickey Spillane's - Outdoor seating - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Good service, nice bartenders, drink prices are very good compared to the area. $5 frozen margarita. Very diverse crowd and music

I came across this bar by recommendation from Mr.Biggs bar and grill. Everyone at Mr.Biggs were very sweet. My friends and I were having a great night visiting bars in the area with amazing staff. I am visiting NY for work (NYFW) and wanted to spend my night off, out with my friends. Unfortunately when I came to the door at this establishment, the door man looked me up and down, accepted my sister, then rudely stated "I can't do it"with no explanation when seeing me. I wouldn't have come to this bar if it wasn't recommend to us. There are many other bars to enjoy on this street with amazing service and sweet servers. I don't recommend this bar if you are looking to have a great night. I wish I looked at Yelp reviews before coming to this establishment. read more

Great drinks and cool music Which they can make the soft shell taco but the corn beef is delicious. Amazing prices without breaking the bank read more

See all

My friend and I came here after having dinner down the block. We had some time to kill before seeing a play that was starting in a few hours. We saw the sign outside that said $4 drinks $4 beers and $4 margaritas. Hmm... $4? You can't go wrong. We went inside and we were greeted right away. We were only doing happy hour, so we didn't need a table. We went right to the bar. The bartender also greeted us right away. He told us what the drink specials were. We went with frozen margaritas! It was $1 extra for a flavored one..but we went with that anyway. We both started with a watermelon margarita. Pretty decent. I got one more before we left. I went with strawberry. I liked the strawberry one better. Service was great at the bar. He continued to clean the bar area and make sure we were good with our drinks. I would have preferred more interaction from him, as he is a bartender...but I'll take what I can get. read more

One of my top favorites! Till yesterday I was in shock and deeply saddened about how rude the service was. My good mood disappeared in a second. read more

While walking out of my Airbnb, I could not help but notice MS. The flashing lights and the crowd inside. It looked hopping and the rainbow sticker was all I needed to see to venture in. I don't like to dine to close to Time Square. Wanted to go where the locals go. Nice place. Great musics and a friendly staff. The first dinner crowd had left so I basically picked my seat. But soon people filtered in and out. I started with the Brooklyn Lager but found it to be not what I expected and a bit more like a Bud. I ordered the pizza because it would be hearty to prep me for then Parade work tomorrow. Anyway, the pizza arrived and was fantastic. I could order another one and even with the beer, I am still very happy. The music playing is awesome. Found myself dancing in my seat. The 3!TV's over the bar would be great for any sporting game or the Tony's. I am actually sitting at my table watching people walk by and enjoying the environment. Thanks read more

Mickey Spillane's - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

cute and lively, 5$ frozen margs. spicy watermelon marg was also rlly good. server was sweet

his took alot of thought to post but do not give this place your money if you are black. I went in responding for an add looking for bartenders, servers, and cooks. I went in to apply for bartender. The host and 2 servers said and I quote " omg yes, we have been looking and the manager is here". "I saw this in passing, and I should really get my resume" said. The server would not take no and asked me to wait whike he talks to the manager. In my direct line of sight i see them having a pow wow with another gentlemen I did not meet in which im assuming was the manager. He looked up from the group we locked eyes, he then sent his servers to walk over instead of himself (poor managment skills) to tell me all positions are filled. CLEARLY I WAS PROFILED. read more

Go to this place for cheap drinks. But the bartender was the worst to me. I have never had an encounter like this and it was uncalled for. Be careful of the rude bartenders there. The bartender all of sudden said, "shut up your being annoying." I was trying to order drinks for my friends and I didn't know if he had heard me because he was being extremely dismissive. I loved this place until right now. read more

Great staff. Very friendly. Had an issue with a drink not tasting right. Server was helpful in trying to resolve the issue. Manager came over with a huge attitude and basically asked us to leave. He then berated his staff and said You should never defy me in front of the customer. We will NEVER go back there. read more

I came here on a Sunday afternoon with one of my friends and I think we may have arrived a lot earlier than anticipated because we were the first ones there. We sat outside since the weather wasn't that cold yet. Our server was brand new and he wasn't sure about certain items on the menu but did his best to make sure we were taken care of. The food was a lot larger than it looks and the drinks were served in what looks like small cups but I guess that's what $5 buys you. read more

Mickey Spillane's - New American Near Me - New York, New York

It was prettier outside than inside but it was still pretty inside. I had a frozen margarita, they have margaritas all day- I can't believe it bro it's crazy. It was in a cup, a cute ass cup, my girlfriend said it was sweet, it was sweet. It was sweet. The service was um.....very nice, I feel like she was hitting on my girlfriend a bit but that's okay because I would also hit on my girlfriend. All in all 4/5 stars - why? It was dark, I don't like the dark :( read more

Love Mickey's!! Can't beat $5 margs. Yes they're a little sweet/fake flavory, but they're $5??? The servers are always super nice; sometimes it can get crowded so don't be afraid to flag them down if you need something. Even if it isn't "your" server they'll always help/put orders in. Met the owner a few times back and he was a great guy as well. Love sitting outside, definitely more vibey night life inside. read more