I genuinely don't understand how this place doesn't have better reviews. The pizza was SO good, easily some of the best we've had in Petoskey. Everything tasted fresh, the crust was perfect, and we loved it. On top of that, the staff/owner was incredibly nice, friendly, and welcoming. Such a great experience all around. This place deserves way more love and we'll absolutely be back! read more

Mighty Fine Pizza Take Out - Pizza Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

Best pizza in town by far. Great service. Always have slices hot and ready to go. Definitely a must try

Great deep dish. Soft crust, just enough sauce and generous cheese baked perfectly. Reasonable prices. Efficient and friendly staff. One little table and chairs outside- that's it. Parking available in a nearby lot. Great pizza! Great stop read more

We ordered pizza here and it was fabulous!! Gluten free options were terrific. Best pizza and breadsticks around.

Incredible pizza and great people working there. So much flavor from such a small spot.

Amazing pizza!! If you are in the Petoskey or Harbor Springs area and looking to order pizza look no further!! Some really good choices...we had the Might Mack, the Northsman and a pepperoni & bacon pizza. All of the pizza was excellent and the crust was perfect! We are looking forward to trying more options the next time we order. This place is a gem!! Also, the pizza was ready in less than 20 minutes on a summer Saturday!! Amazing!! read more

Mighty Fine Pizza Take Out - Mighty Mack - Pizza Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

See all

Yes! This PIE is Mighty Fine. Who would have 'thunk' Petosky would have world class pizza ? Thin Crust, Gluten Free, Original; it's all very delicious. A little heads-up, these guys are so efficient plan on your order being done earlier than specified. On average our orders have been ready for pick-up earlier. Enjoy the Pie!! read more

Mighty Fine Pizza Take Out - Store Front & Sign. - Pizza Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

Stopped by at 9:30 on a Friday night for our first time. We are from out of town and were in the mood for a good late night pizza. We ordered a classic thin pepperoni pizza and some boneless wings hot flavored. We got home opened the pizza box and saw a perfectly beautifully cooked pizza. I grabbed a slice, took the first bite and thanked the stars for wandering around and finding this Pizza joint. My wife and I are from Muskegon and rank the pizzas we have tried there and your pizza blows them all out of the water. I'd say it is in my top 3 pizzas I have tried world-wide. We are here for a week and will surely get another pizza before heading back home. read more

Tried to order delivery. Got put on hold and they never picked up. Didn't get to try the pizza, but the customer service needs to improve.

Unfortunately the pizza and breadsticks tasted like plastic. We've had it before in previous years and it's been delicious but this time the crust on our two pizzas and breadsticks tasted like it was bad. read more

Mighty Fine is essentially a mini room for pizza takeout, right off the main stretch of Downtown Petoskey. You pop in this country door to snag your pizzas, and out you go -- there's no tables to eat in. The owners and staff are all really nice and were friendly when we went to pick up our za's. Don't be confused by the menu -- you can either order "single" or "double" pizzas in size small, medium, or large. Essentially they're giving you a deal if you buy two of the same size pizza (a "double small pizza" is just two small pizzas" for a different price). That tripped us up at first. We ordered a large cheese, medium BBQ chicken, small vegetable pizza, tossed salad, and order of breadsticks. They also had cookie dough bites and brownies in their shop that looked great. The breadsticks were super doughy and good (definitely greasy too), the salad was delish (we all LOVED the ranch), the cheese pizza was good (great doughy crust, but almost no marinara sauce present), the chicken BBQ was the fav pizza (note that it comes with onions, peppers and tomatoes on top) and the veggie one was a hit as well. I would've loved to have more sauce (almost seemed like there wasn't any?) on the cheese pizza, but it was good nonetheless. Thanks, Mighty Fine! read more

See all

There is nothing but an order counter inside so be prepared to enjoy great customer service, place your order, and have a place to eat your food once it's done. Their pizza is loaded with large chunks of fresh high quality ingredients. It tasted great and we loved it. Don't want pizza? They have more than that! Give them a try when you are nearby. read more

Mighty Fine Pizza Take Out - They're storefront with street parking and only the pictured table to eat. - Pizza Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

See all

Tuesday, April 29th. The worst pizza ever i got tonight. Only thing right was mushrooms and onions. Sorry, I did order 15 minutes before closing, but still quality was not a priority. Very disappointed. I want my money back, please. read more

Best Pizza in Petoskey. The grinder sandwich was also amazing. We've been on the hunt for a pizza place since moving to town. Most of the places have been subpar. Mighty Fine Pizza lives up to its name! Friday pizza nights can commence in our home again! We're happy and can't wait to place another order. read more

Really good pizza. Fast prep and made to order. The crust is the best part to me. Family enjoyed it for lunch today. Old lady got the side salad. Don't expect cucumbers. The finicky kid even had some praise for this selection. Oldest pizza in Petoskey from what we are told. This place is take out only. I'm sure during warmer months, it's cool to grab a pizza and bring it down to bayside park read more

Great pizza. Extremely friendly owner and local staff are nice. Always love to see a "mom and pop shop" excellent at their work. Would recommend read more

For service alone they get these stars. Called right as they were closing and they brought the pizza with a smile. The salad was literally one of the BEST salads I have ever had. Makes me want to drive 5 hours to get it again. Pizza ingredients were fresh and pizza was hot. Salad had some cherries and sweet crunchy things that I cannot explain but were delish. read more

Tiny, tiny, tiny space so absolutely no eat in . We stopped to pick up pizza and wings for our overnight stay in Petoskey. Friendly staff for sure, thanks for the smiles guys! We ordered a meat pizza with thin crust...tasted great, nothing spectacular but it's have it again for sure. The wings not so much in my opinion. We ordered buffalo and it had a different kind of spice that I couldn't put my finger on the name but I didn't care for it. Honestly I didn't taste any buffalo at all. If you're adventurous go ahead and try the wings but the pizza is good. Price was average and parking can be tricky if it's busy. read more

Mighty Sun Par is a more accurate description. Beyond flavorless. Was hoping for average at best and didn't even get that. Hard pass.

We ordered carryout while staying in Petoskey. We wanted to try a local place. They answered the phone quickly and the person who answered was friendly. We got an XL create your own pizza with cheese stuffed crust and sausage and pepperoni. We also got pepperoni and cheese breadsticks and those were very good. I had the Mighty Fine salad and it was really good! The mango dressing was completely different but very tasty. The pizza was delicious. Fresh and lots of toppings. read more

After years of dining in the Petoskey area we finally tried Might Fine. The pizza truly is Mighty Fine. Great menu and very fun employees make this our new go to for take away pizza. read more

Always consistent. Perfect quality every time. I especially appreciate that they will sell me their pizza dough for use at home.

I wanted this pizza to be good. Unfortunately, the crust is just not good and way too much of it. I ordered the large Northman. Toppings were very ordinary. So, will not be back. read more

Pizza for dinner tonight at Mighty Fine Pizza in Petoskey, Michigan! Options are delivery or take-out, great menu selection, and friendly service. Our pizza had generous toppings and was nice and hot when we picked it up! Best pizza in Petoskey! read more

Outstanding pizza! Enjoyed the quick and correct delivery! Cheese breadsticks were fantastic

Amazing experience! Our family just got a very simple order - pepperoni pizza and mild boneless wings, but wow did we enjoy it! Great place and we will be back! read more

Granted this is only the second time we've tried this place but nobody's talking about the salads! They're better than the pizza imho. We might try the thin crust but if you get a large regular pizza, the crust is way too thick, again imho. Personal pan size is perfect however. The salads are fresh and the ingredients are thoughtfully included (I never would've put fresh mushrooms on my caesar but it was delicious!). The Chef salad I got last night was equally good but be advised the "small" is a far cry from being a side salad and enough to feed two. Take out the crispy croutons before you put it in the fridge (if there's leftovers) to keep them crunchy (a lesson I learned the hard way). We'll definitely be back. read more

Stacked veggie pizza was pretty good. Loaded up with a ton of fresh veggies and the crust was the perfect complement for it. Just wished there was slightly more pizza sauce. Service was quick for a call ahead and pick up order. read more

Fantastic pizza!!! We were all so pleased with this place which was a perfect meal post day of skiing, located close to Nubs Nob. This place is takeout only, so keep that in mind planning ahead and order in advance. They were very very busy, showing how popular the pizza is with locals. read more

Maybe dominos quality. Wasn't that impressed with this pizza for the $24 price, very minimal mozzarella, lots of banana peppers, and small amount of meat. Their strategy of making you pay 4% to cover credit card fees is not smart and was irritating. I was going to tip on receipt, but since the owner forced extra cost already on an expensive pizza I decided not to. read more

Mighty Fine Pizza Take Out - Jans specialty pizza, feta and mushrooms only on half - Pizza Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

Every time we order from here, the order is messed up. If you like rolling the dice and like the potential of getting someone else's order, this is definitely the place for you. The pizza tastes mediocre at best. I'd go with mighty average pizza over tombstone, but lil ceasers or the gas station is better quality read more

Fantastic crust! Nice and thick yet not overly sweet. Plenty of toppings and great customer service. read more

Mighty Fine Pizza Take Out - Pizza Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

See all

Great service and great pizza hit the spot! Driver was quick and very nice. Certainly worth spending money on over a frozen pizza!

Just came back from picking up a pizza. Walked in, ordered and paid for it. The man said it will be ready on 10-15 minutes. No problem. Went next door to a health food store. Came to pick up my pizza. The man at the counter ( Mr. RUDE as hell) said, hey, you have to pay for it. I said, I already paid for it. Who rang you up? I told him. He left the counter to verify that I indeed paid for it. He had to ask three people. Now, this is my first time ordering from you guys. And it might be my last. You guys need a system of when a person pays for their pizza, write on the ticket "paid". Or "PD". Whatever. And secondly, I can easily take my money to another business. You need to learn how to treat customers with respect. Don't be rude to me. I was never rude to you. read more

I usually am dubious of pizza in a tourist town. It's cheap and easy to make. Everyone from the corner has station to the fanciest Italian restaurant serves it. I was working late, got back to my hotel room, and didn't want to move. I searched and found Mighty Fine Pizza. A very brief scroll down the menu and I saw the BURNT pizza. I had to try it. It surpassed all expectations. Love it and will be back for more. read more

Mighty Fine Pizza Take Out - BURNT pizza Yum - Pizza Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan

Amazing pizza! Loved the generous serving of cheese & right amount of sauce! Crust was fantastic! Thanks for staying open a little longer to make us our first ever Mighty Fine Pizza! We will be back for-sure!! read more

Staying in a nearby hotel, after driving all day we were not in the mood to go to a restaurant....the hotel reception "guy" recommended Mighty Fine Pizza and it did not disappoint! The sauce was great, ingredients were fresh ...overall excellent!....the order was taken politely, delivery was prompt! Highly recommend this place! read more

Delicious local pizza joint. We ordered the Northman: Pepperoni, Ham, Green Pepper, Onion, Bacon and cheesy bread which was the perfect amount of cheese and bread. It was moderately priced for a medium pizza and breadsticks. read more

I was in town for vacation & tried this place. It's one of the best pizza's I've ever had. I got a regular pepperoni pizza which was very good, then I got the burnt pizza which is phenomenal. I didn't think I would like this, but it's very flavorful. I would drive back up north just to get this pizza again. read more

Their is an interesting selection of specialty pizzas. Tried the Meatball and Northman but they did not deliver. The crust was mediocre, dense and doughy. It didn't seem the oven was hot enough as the whole pizza was pale. Also they skimp on cheese. Overall the pizza is nothing special. read more

Mighty Fine Pizza Take Out - Top half is Meatball bottom is Northman - Pizza Near Me - Petoskey, Michigan