Incredible shop with over and above service. We were visiting from out of town and had our alternator light come on, which is a huge problem, and horrible timing. Called around everywhere and no one could help me, but finally called Mike's and within minutes confirmed they could get me in same day. The price was competitive, they fixed everything in one afternoon, and our van was in perfect condition again in time to take our family back home. We even got a warranty on the service, which I feel great about. Some of the nicest guys too. Thank you all for saving our day! Would highly recommend! read more

I'd been having recurring cylinder misfires for months. I'm no stranger to mechanical work and did everything I could think of to resolve but needed another eye on it. We're 40+ mins away from the nearest BMW garage so I found Mike's Auto which is within 10 minutes. They specialize in import repair according to their site so I brought it in for a diagnostic. I just needed to know what they thought caused it and could probably do the repair myself. I'd already done turbos, O2 sensors, ECU, throttle body, Vanos, etc. The guys were very accommodating but communication was poor, I had to call for any updates or to find out they needed me to authorize a repair. Three weeks and $1800 later I pick up the car and don't even make it a mile before all the misfires come right back. This, despite their assurances that it was test driven multiple times. Right back I go. A week later I'm now told a catalytic converter was plugged and causing faulty readings for air/fuel mix, creating misfires. It made sense, the tech even sent me a video showing his gauge reading. He was confident. Cats were about the only thing I hadn't changed. They estimated 8-9 hours book rate so I took it home and installed some brand new cats myself (3 hours real time.) Car made it several miles this time before the same error messages appeared. So, the diagnosis was still incorrect. I won't be bringing it back. The guys tried hard but it's clear they don't possess any specific import knowledge or experience that will help me out. I've wasted $1800 to get back where I was a month ago, but with a pair of shiny new cats now. They're probably fine doing standard work like suspension or oil leaks but anything more complex seems beyond them. read more

DO NOT TAKE YOUR CAR TO MIKE AUTO - SPRING 2023 If I could give a negative rating to mikes auto repair I would. DO NOT TAKE YOUR CAR HERE. A standard radiator replacement was completely BOTCHED by the mechanic leaving (rookie mistake) The transmission on My Wife's car permanently damaged. Mikes AUTO conveniently came up with an excuse ; and I was offered no restitution for the botched repair job that ruined the transmission on the car. They still have not contacted me to resolve this terrible situation after numerous attempts and the initial visit to tell them of the problem where they admitted to making mistakes. Check out their bad reviews on other sites and with the Better Business Bureau TAKE YOUR CAR TO MIKES AUTO AT YOUR OWN PERIL read more

My mom lives in Lake Geneva and always uses Mike's. They take great care of her car and that makes me feel good being that I live far away and she is elderly. They know her by name and treat her with kindness and respect. We trust them to give her an assessment that is on point and a price that is fair. She recently went in with a flat tire which they took care of in a timely manner. To exemplify how much she appreciates them, she took them all a homemade lunch today to thank them. I would recommend Mike's to anyone! read more

My initial 2 experiences with Mike's were pleasant enough and addressed basic maintenance issues for my car (oil changes...). However, when I returned to seek their help with what I suspected was a more serious issue with starting my car (which I'd discussed on the previous visit), the rep was dismissive. Either didn't have time to deal with it (should have told me) or didn't care to make the effort. I said I'd check with the dealer to see if they had any suggestions and he dismissed the idea that it could be a known issue. I ended up with an appointment at the dealer and found out that I have 2 serious issues which were contributing to the problem. If Mike's had even bothered, they would have noticed a malfunction icon. Bottom line is while I think Mike's is adequate for oil changes and basics, I won't rely or recommend them for anything beyond that.More than likely I'll go elsewhere for future service. read more

Reliable and responsive but watch his "add on" suggestions...those can run up the price and might not be necessary. Get a second opinion like at your dealership. read more

ALWAYS stellar service. These guys go above and beyond with repairs and customer service. Honest, trustworthy, and no BS, ever. Simply the best. read more

These Michanic's are useless they diagnose that my car needed and engine cause me to almost sell the car as scrap after the quoted me a engine replacement cost of 7500 only to find out that all the car wanted was a relay thanks to youtube I fixed it myself wasted 1150 bucks for them to tell me crop thanks for changing the battery because that's all they did read more

Prompt and good repair work on my two cars, and at a reasonable price. Friendly and professional.

i brought my BMW M4 here because I had a slow leak in the passenger right snow tire. In less than 1 hour they had the tire repaired and I was on my way. These are reputable honest people. Shout out to Jake and Gary. Take your car here. You will not be disappointed. read more

Would not recommend! Diagnostic test cost $143.00 and the codes did not match the recommended repairs they claim were needed on our vehicle. Their estimate on needed repairs was around $1400.00! We ended up taking it to an honest mechanic who informed us that certain repairs quoted were totally unnecessary and our total bill was $512.00. read more

Brought in a Mercedes, upon their representation that they had the tools to work on foreign cars. They didn't, and attempted to charge me for the diagnostics when they didn't have the tools or certification to repair/address the issues. Bad business practice. read more

On behalf of all United States military veterans stay far away from this guy ! This guy totally fucked me over not only that he was completely disrespectful and inappropriate yelled at me multiple times I told him I was a disabled veteran on limited income he promised that what he was doing would fix the problem in my suspension it did not do anything just as bad as it was when I dropped it off. When I brought it back to him he freaked out refused to look at it any farther refused to reimburse any money and told me to fuck off literally!Guess I'm gonna have to take him to small claims court read more

My extended family has been using Mike's for years (all types of purchases, repairs, tires, etc.), and give this business an A+ rating. Always honest, always professional, always fast... read more

They assessed my vehicle quickly, identified the issue, and were clear on communication and price. I will definitely use these guys again!

My 1st time to finally Try Mikes and they Pass with AAA in Service, Personal Service of Taking me Home and Back while ReStoring my Car , that was so poorly neglected by the Dealer for yrs...Mikes IS THE Place to go to in Wonderfull and Friendly Lake Geneva, Wi. Thank You Josh and His Team! read more

Mike/ Josh have repaired and serviced my vehicle several times. Timely service, very professional, very fair pricing. What more can one ask? read more

I had a nail in my tire and this neighborhood shop helped me out that same day so I could drive safely. Caleb was so great to deal with - ask for him with any questions! Highly recommend this company! Joanne P read more

Customer of many years and I wouldn't go anywhere else! I am always greeted and treated so kindly and the service to all my vehicles has always been top notch. I would recommend mikes auto to anyone I know. Thanks guys for all you've done to keep my car safe and up to great standards!! read more

Mike's Auto is totally awesome. My Honda always went to the dealership. Moved to Lake Geneva and my Nephew recommended Mikes. There customer servie and technicians are so friendly, they explain everthing and the service is top notch! Love my Hond "Blue Bonnett" and they take "very good" care of her. Thank you Brandon and Andy! http://www.mikesautorepairlg.com/#!testimonials read more

Mike's Auto Repair - Mikes Auto Repair - Auto Repair Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

Really appreciate all they do. Cody and Josh are always so accommodating and helpful! Our #1 go to place!

We wasted over $500 replacing a part that was found to be fully functional because of their diagnosis. We took it to another mechanic due to a $200 less price tag for the same work. The problem was in fact just a high pressure power steering hose. We wasted all that money/time and then had to pay a further $380 dollars to replace the hose due to their misdiagnosis. Mike's Auto Repair refused to even help replace the hose at a discounted rate. Huge disappointment as $500 is a substancial sum to us. read more

The guys at Mike's Auto are always willing to help. They understand that owning a car can sometimes be a pain and sometimes the simple fixes aren't always what they seem. They have good prices and do a great job! Recently I thought I cracked a wheel bearing. When I took it in they did preliminary tests and found out it was just loose lug nuts. They tightened all my wheels up and didn't charge me a dime. Give them a try next time you have to get work done on your car. read more

So grateful for fast, attentive service I received late in the day for a flat tire. They put on the spare, ordered new tires and installed two days later. They genuinely care for their customers and their services are priced right. They will have my future business. read more

Have taken several of our vehicles to Mike's. Always quick courteous service ... Great estimates, without the usual gouging for unneeded repairs. They can accommodate larger utility trucks, as well. Between Mike's and Del's Lake Geneva is covered! read more

Mike saved us from spending extra days in Lake Geneva. He squeezed us in on a Saturday even though he was booked. Price was excellent , service was fast. read more

I don't think I've ever had such a good experience with a repair shop much less a simple oil change. Thank you Josh for all the knowledge and getting me in and out quickly! I recommend if you want that old school customer comes first service. read more

I was getting ready to head back to Chicago from Lake Geneva and noticed that my tire was almost flat after hitting a pothole. I saw Mike's and drove in to see if they could help me out. Although it was 10 minutes to closing time, they were willing to change my tire to the spare and did it with a genuine smile and great attitude. What great guys and great service. I highly recommend them and I will be back! read more

My wife has been going to Mike's for 6 plus years now. They have always given us great service and prices on tires, oil changes, brakes etc... we have had serviced by them. At the last oil change - they found a leak by the timing cover and a leak by the right axle. Josh told me about both which I never would have found myself and said it should be under your warranty and to call them. I was able to take it to Kia and have it fixed UNDER the warranty that we had only 4 months left . I was so appreciative that they take the time to give my car a once over like that when it was only in for an oil change. Thanks guys for caring about my car!!!! I would reccommend them for your service. read more

We were in Lake Geneva the coldest weekend of the year, about -4 F, and we had a flat tire. The friendly guys at Mike's were nice enough to drive us back to our hotel and pick us up when the service was completed. I recommend this place if you ever have any car trouble in the Lake Geneva area. read more

Moved to the local area 6 mo ago, found this shop online, they have done two oil changes for me now. Courteous, friendly, good prices, coupons online, no hassles. will use again. read more

Never do business here! My wfe took her Subaru Baja here while I was out of town. We were told the turbo was going bad and needed replaced. Eight weeks and four supposedly faulty turbos later we got the car back. This happened to be the week we were moving so we were packed up and left town. Two hundred miles and two breakdowns later we had the car towed to a Subaru dealership where we were told the turbo was installed wrong (they even showed us where all the bolts were not even put back in) so much damage was done to the engine that Subaru says it needs a new engine to be right. Mike's Auto said they had done everything by the book and it wasn't there fault the engine blew. TWO HUNDRED MILES and they take no responsibility that to get our car fixed now we're out thousands of dollars! read more