The food I had was delicious. The service included the server being very kind and consistent. I…read morefelt bad because we were the only people in the building for such a wonderful place, and the ambiance included organized knives and forks!

We were greeted at the front door and warmly welcomed. The…read moreserver, Jen, was right at our table with menus, water and fresh warm homemade bread soon followed. The food was fabulous. Authentic delicious Italian food and plenty of it. Finally, we were treated to Mara's beautiful voice as she sang O Solo Mio. This place is a treasure!​

Family owned traditional pizzeria, pizza was delicious & reasonably priced. Ready on time & staff…read morewas very friendly. It was a busy night & close to closing. They weren't pushy or annoyed.

First the staff: they were very nice and it looked like they all were working very hard. So no…read morecomplaints. Now the pizza: I was originally going to say it's just an average slice of pizza that you can get anywhere else, but that wouldn't exactly be true. I don't know what it is, but there's something in the sauce that adds just a hint of heat to it. And the crust, for as thin as it is, was great. Very crispy and tasty. I will definitely have to go in there and try some other food from them. But for a couple of quick slices, you probably can't beat it for the area.

Tony's is a great local pizza spot. It's busy any time I've gone there. It has a few interior…read moretables and I believe outdoor seating as well. I have not eaten in yet, just picked up take out. Staff is very friendly and accommodating. Portions are a decent size and the food is good. I thoroughly enjoy their antipasto salad. Their pizza hits the spot when you want that non-chain restaurant pizza slice. Nothing against chains...I adore Pizza Hut...but as anyone with a favorite corner pizza spot will tell you, there's just nothing like a hometown slice. When that's what you crave, I say give Tony's a try! I will post pictures on my next visit. I keep forgetting to take pix of my food because I'm usually starving and I dive right in.

Stopped by on the way to bethany beach, very convenient location! The pizza was SOO good, we got…read morethe tonys special and i absolutely loved the pickled pepper (?) topping. We also got dough bites after smelling someone elses order... A MUST GET. So fluffy and soft but chewy, perfect for the continued car ride to the beach. Unfortunately I wasn't a fan of the pasta, it was a bit watery and overcooked.. still filling! Nobody greeted us but just took our order at the register, so we assumed we could just sit at the tables afterward. They informed us later if you sit they do restaurant style with a waiter, so make sure to let them know if you intend on eating in. Nevertheless workers were the absolute sweetest. I would've stopped by here again on the way back from the beach.

Our server provided very high quality service. For an Appetizer the Cheesy Garlic Bread was simply…read moreamazing. I ordered the Gnocchi Carbonari and my wife ordered the Lasagna. The Lasagna was served in a very generous portion. Having not had Gnocchi since I was very young, it took me back to days long ago in NY. While the entrées were delicious, I was disappointed when I found out the NY Style Cheesecake was made in-house and the wedge served to me was undercooked, slightly runny, missing the tart afterbite of known NY Cheesecake (Juniors as an example). It wasn't bad but it certainly wasn't the quality I would expect a Bronx native to sell in a family owned Italian restaurant.

Such a nice spot! Definitely a gem here in Rehoboth Beach. We came on a busy night but were able to…read morebe seated right away. Food came out pretty quickly and was absolutely delicious! Our waiter was kind and very attentive. Stop by if you're in the area and craving Italian!

Ordered pick up here, so I'm referencing that only…read more The pizza wasn't great. The crust was just off, way too soft and the sauce didn't taste right. The mushrooms were definitely not fresh and canned and the calzone (nic-o-boli?) was way too oily. The salad was just some lettuce with with huge slices of cucumber and tomato. It advertised as having cheese - it came with no cheese and just 1 packet of one of those commercially made dressings. Couldn't be bothered to have actual oil and vinegar as the dressing on the side, as requested. I don't know if this is considered "good" by DE standards but coming from NJ/NYC (and I think without me being a very harsh critic!) it was disappointing.

Been eating here for years!! Great pizza. Excellent Fat cheesesteaks !!…read moreHighly recommend!!

Great Pizza!! Friendly staff. Large menu with great dessert available. Definitely will continue…read moregetting my pizza here

Too cheesy and not enough sauce- tastes like cafeteria pizza - acceptable on vacation but not good…read moreeven reheated. Dough is soggy. Boneless buffalo chicken is an odd texture. Meatball sub was fair.

Not a lot of family run Italian Pizza Shops left. The pizza tastes like you never left New York.read more

The food and service here are outstanding! The ambiance is very family-oriented, adorned with…read moreplenty of family photos. Although the space is quite small, it feels cozy and welcoming. By the way, there is no seating, just a counter and a small space to stand and wait. REGARDLESS, The "Grandma's Pizza" is one of the best pizzas I've ever had in Delaware and rivals many from New York! It's incredibly fresh, and its crust is the kind that you can't resist eating! :)

Service was superb. Food was very good. The atmosphere was pleasant and clean. Nice place to stop…read moreby and get something to eat and drink.

I had made a reservation through their website which brought me to open table. On Open Table it…read moresaid they were doing a "new" happy hour during my requested visit. However, when we arrived at the location there was no happy hour going on. This was my first visit here. The ambiance was bright and roomy with New York deco and photos. The staff were friendly and courteous. Our server who was also the bartender greeted us in a friendly manner and told us the specials of the day as well as recommendations of best sellers. We opted for the $30 special for 2 which was a choice of Greek salad, Caesar salad or soup to start for each person and then a pizza to share. The pizzas are 12". We ordered the Greek and Caesar salads and the Arugala Bianca pizza. We also ordered the Smoked Burrata as an appetizer. The Caesar and Greek salads were fresh and rather large portion. The Smoked Burrata doesn't come with any bread so you have to pay extra for $3 for that. I feel it should be included. Delicious! The roasted red pepper pesto is very tasty but does have a little bit of heat. The bread is made in house and served with an herb butter. Very yummy! Definitely a must have! The pizza was nicely layered with toppings. It comes with a truffle oil but because I am allergic to mushrooms we did not have that. It definitely needs a little more of something. A balsamic drizzle would have been perfect and probably the truffle oil. It was nicely cooked with a crust crunch with each bite. Everything so fresh on it. Yummy! Definitely of the NY style type of pizza. Overall we were pleased with the meal and experience. We will be back to choose a pizza with some sauce on it.