This place is so cool. The service was quick and friendly. The food is above average bar food with excellent prices. If I lived in the area, this would be my go to place to hang out and watch the games. read more

We ordered the Butcher pizza and a Sprite. This was our first time here and we are very impressed. The pizza came out as hot as possible. The staff did a great job of describing the menu for us. This pace is very nice and if you are from Youngstown, you have to stop here and have a beer at the bar. read more

Missing Jimmy’s - The Butcher - Sports Bars Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Wow ... this is my kind of place. Super retro vibe. The old school "letter board" tap board is amazing. Some epic deals - i got $2 Genesee Cream Ale. Hadn't had that in a minute.!! read more

What a hidden gem! We came on a Saturday night to watch some Bball and thoroughly enjoyed the pizzas! Get the Big Fat Antnee!!! We even ordered one to take home. The Stand up guy pizza was also good!! I think I may have to work my way through the menu. The Meatball subs look Phenomenal!! Service was good. You order at the bar. Great place to watch sports and hang with friends. Cohort felt at home, he's from Youngstown area as well. read more

Missing Jimmy’s - Big Fat Antnee and Stand Up Guy - Sports Bars Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

So while I'm working out here for a few weeks, I've been trying a lot of different places and I happen to find this place one of my first nights. Great little dive bar with an awesome bartender on a Thursday night. Fun crowd. And then you get to the sandwiches and the pizza. Anything that uses the meatballs is highly recommended. The bread is so good and the meatballs have this amazingly perfect texture and flavor. The price is also great. I also got the pizza to go for the next day because the sandwich was so good. I just had to try it. Even reheated the pizza was amazing and I highly recommend it. It had a chopped meatball sauce, which was just awesome. read more

Missing Jimmy’s - Meatball sub - Sports Bars Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Loved missing Jimmys. I sadly do not have a photo to share but I was visiting from out of town and wanted to try something new. The pizza was really really good. They are individual pizzas so it is sooo nice because everyone can pick their own especially if you have kids!!! We took it to go since it is in a bar. Service was quick and efficient but most of all the pizza was AMAZING read more

Awesome food Jimmy Hoffa theme! Youngstown Cbus hangout Good beer Good pizza and other food too Lots of tvs What else could one need??! read more

See all

We were in Columbus for a wedding...had just finished an eight-hour drive and were looking to find a place where we could eat, have beer or two and simply unwind. Well, ba da bing...we found Missing Jimmy's and it hit on all cylinders. A veritable Grade A meatball sub - with pepperoni and ricotta...and my wife had the low-carb version of the same, with sausage. We just might have to move here. read more

Delicious food great service and nice atmosphere!!! Would highly recommend this place for an afternoon of day drinking with your friends

Visited Missing Jimmy's for lunch today because of the Youngstown theme. Loved it! Got the Nicky Santoro sub and had to grab a white pizza, because when it's the real deal you can't not get it. Cool chat with the bartender and a back home feel. Recommended for sure! read more

Missing Jimmy’s - White pizza - Sports Bars Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

If you are from NE Ohio you will love this place. If you like good food and a relaxed atmosphere you will love this place. You just need to find it. In Downtown Dublin walk south past DVT. You will get to a small parking lot. Missing Jimmy's is right there. Plenty of cold beer to choose from. Full bar besides that. Food options with some Youngstown connections (DeRusso's). The White pizza was thick and chewy just like I like it. The meatballs and ricotta were great and came with a slice of bread to soak up all that sauce. TVs are there but not obtrusive. Get there early as the place fills up quick! read more

Missing Jimmy’s - White Pizza and Conway's Irish Ale - Sports Bars Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

We came across Missing Jimmy's while walking around historic Dublin, but the shopping area they are located in does have its own parking lot. Fun place full of TVs showing sports, a foosball table, and some nice Christmas decor for the season. They serve up Meatball Mafia food, and it smelled great in there. We got the Nicky Santoro meatball subs to go. It was well packaged. The food was great - so flavorful, great kick from the hot giardiniera. Service was quick. We will definitely stop by again. read more

Missing Jimmy’s - Exterior sign - Sports Bars Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

The first time I walked into Missing Jimmy's I felt like I was in my hometown of Youngstown, Ohio! It's wonderful to have a place in Columbus, Ohio that represents so well the Italian history in Youngstown. Rob and Vinnie and their staff have perfected the pizza, subs, and Meatball bowls! Everything I have had there has been incredible! The Meatball bowl with the pesto pasta salad is probably one of my favorite things. The combination of flavors is fantastic! The pizza brings back great memories of growing up in Youngstown!! The Atmosphere is fun, family, friendly with corn hole set up outside and TV and sports in the inside. The staff go above and beyond to make sure that your visit Missing Jimmy's will be the first of many! The bartenders serve up great drinks and beer along with their great food to make this the perfect date night or great place together with friends!! Try out Missing Jimmy's, you will not be disappointed !! read more

Missing Jimmy’s - Classic pizza with sausage, pepperoni, and banana peppers! Delicious! - Sports Bars Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

This place has real Youngstown vibes. Pretty cool. I am excited to come back again and try all the food. I think they need to add wings to the menu though. read more

I failed to take a photo of my meat balls and sausage. This is an interesting little spot in Dublin, just off high street, away from the main thoroughfare. The theme is clear - Hoffa. Our table Was plastered with Hoffa, Marilyn Monroe, Waldo, Geraldo, Barbara Walters - just a Time Machine of nostalgia. And my favorite - a wall for photos, holding their sign like you're getting locked up. It seems it's a sports bar. We popped in on a slow Tuesday for drinks - my friends ordered pizza (personal pan size), meatballs for myself. The food is simple, unglamorized, uncomplicated. And good. Beers - they had a lot of lowbrau beers on hand, and a nice craft selection. It's a chill spot. I'm coming back, for sure. read more

This is a neighborhood sports bar that is a great place to watch a game with friends. The only negative is it can be really loud when someone scores but it also gives you the sense that you are in the stadium. Talking to the owner we learned that it was a food truck and now they have 2 locations. If you're a deep dish pizza fan you'll love the pizza here. They are also known for their meatballs which our group raved over. Since I don't eat meat I would love to see some Turkey or Chicken meatballs on the menu. The names of the drinks and food are so creative! Cocktails were delicious too. We will be back to enjoy some of the other drinks and pizzas! read more

See all

Love this place! Love the food and the bartenders are the best!! We go out at least once a week and always stop in. Such a fun bar.

Unbelievable spot. Hometown feel. Great food, drinks and service! Get here now. You will not be disappointed. read more

Missing Jimmy’s - Sports Bars Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Love this place. Came late night from out of town for a night cap. Great tunes and great guys behind the bar. Have never seen Malort outside of Chicago (except at burning man) but they got it here. Great end to an otherwise hectic travel day, thanks fellas read more

Came in for a wine and cheesecake tasting. Had a blast! We had a mushroom pizza and it was great. We will definitely be back!! Michelob ultra on draft! Everyone was really friendly. read more

This is my new favorite bar, absolutely!! I love a more, chill/relaxed bar for Dublin!! It is also not a big bar, so it's not too packed and away from the Main Street, so it's definitely a hidden gem type of thing!! They have been open for eight months now and y'all seriously need to go check it out, support those local businesses!! The prices are awesome, the drinks were good!! Your girl got her classic, a dirty Shirley!! I loved the bartender, he was so cool! I appreciate the bar/vibes you threw in here, in Dublin!! Love the mixup we ALL needed!! I will be back with friends/family, for sure! I am so excited to show them my new place!! read more

My only negative thing I can say about this place....is that I hadn't gone in sooner. The beer selection is like NOTHING else in Columbus! Where else can I sip tecate light and honey browns. All whole sports are playing every where I can see with personable bartenders. It is also a very affordable option for old Dublin/Bridgepark. Hope this neighborhood bar is around for a very long time! read more

Missing Jimmy’s - Sports Bars Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Quiet Saturday decided to try out Missing Jimmy's, sat at the bar service OK I had a beer my wife tried the wine, ( sent it back- really bad) settled on a cocktail. We didn't try any food. Left unimpressed very sterile no atmosphere. read more

Fun bar with vintage beers available and interesting atmosphere with Jimmy Hoffa as the theme. Limited operating hours so be sure to check online prior to a visit. Good food options. Meatball Mafia. read more

Missing Jimmy’s - Briar Hill pizza - Sports Bars Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Best bar and staff in all of Dublin. You guys ROCK the ShamROCKs! We make Jimmy's our final destination no matter where we start the evening. read more

My husband is from Youngstown and he couldn't have been happier when this place opened! The service is GREAT (shout out to Joe!) and the food is unbelievably delicious! Hate to say it (not really, lol) but they have the best pizza in Columbus. Amazing light crunchy crust, delicious sauce and awesome toppings!! You gotta try this place! read more

Great beer , and meatballs. They will make a custom pizza too. My son enjoyed the fooseball as well.

Great food and service! I've been wanting to try Missing Jimmy's for a while. Did not disappoint! The waitress was really kind and brought out a little water dish for our dog while we outside. The pong table and cornhole are great fun while waiting for your order or just having a friendly competition with friends :) we ate outdoors, however the interior is set up for a great little sports bar; looking forward to watching some football at Missing Jimmy's.. My husband had a pepperoni & banana pepper pizza, while I had the Torpedo Meatball Sub. Also has a Wolf Lodge margarita, beer, which was perfect for a summer day. All was really good. The meatballs were perfecto! We will be back. read more

Missing Jimmy’s - Pepperoni & banana peppers pizza, and the Torpedo Meatball sub. - Sports Bars Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Super friendly Youngstown throwback joint! Left my keys there and they had them waiting for me with a smile. Good drinks and would come back for the food. read more

Great food great time! Bartenders are great! Super fast with your pizza and drinks! Great little spot in Dublin

Get ready to be transported to 1976 Youngstown. Well in a squeaky clean Dublin, Ohio kinda way. No frills but a clean easy going joint. The beers are the star here...all your favorite, some fairly obscure, from back in the day including Black Label, Genesee, Iron City, Strohs, Little Kings, Hudy and Colt45. The pizza is just ok, some sort of a pre-made heat and serve deal, but still a decent crust. The meatballs...well they are what you would expect from MBM, the sauce really makes them. What ever you do, don't come here to be seen, this place is all about disappearing for a while. read more

What a great experience my family had at home away from home establishment. The atmosphere the hospitality and the the pizza was fantastic. The owner that was there was very hospitable the only thing I missed was the owner that is a die hard LV Raiders fan. You need to check this place out. Very cool Memorabilia from the Youngstown area. I will be visiting the establishment again, can't wait read more

Below average microwave style pizza that cost like high end coal fired hand made pizza. If wasting money is your thing head on over but your better off Missing this spot. Hilliard location is good this place not so much. Owner didn't seem to care about the feedback either so no need to cont to waste my money when there are plenty of other places in town for pizza. Part2: in response to owner: I have all the receipts of our conversation if you'd like me to copy and paste it that's not exactly how our conversation went for the record! read more

Great place to drink the beers you remember your Dad drinking (and maybe had a few yourself ;)

I have been here multiple times since it's open and food never disappoints! Everything is delicious and comes out quick and hot! Meatballs are homemade and so authentic! Pizza has a great bite and somehow the perfect combination of crisp and tender with great chew. The atmosphere is fun and casual, proving to be a great stop to relax, grab a drink and some tasty food! Missing jimmy's is a must try! read more

Great food and atmosphere! The pizza and meatball subs will definitely be a new norm for my fam