Surprised the husband with a birthday dinner on the 4th of July! I was the one surprised as everything was so good. Bartender was a little slow with the libations but we understood. Our waitress, I wished I'd have gotten her name, was fabulous. Very professional and courteous as well. The bread was piping hot and we devoured it and asked for more. She brought out 2 trays , enough to take home. Our main course came out promptly too. Its's so nice to get what you pay for. We will be back soon. read more

Will 1st message owner before posting what will not be a positive review .... Only good part was staff trying to recover a bad experience only to be worst in whole experience in the end ..not worth the wasted time & $$$ read more

I don't often go here since it is located in an upscale mall. I've eaten lunch here a couple of times and haven't been disappointed. They have a makeshift "outdoor area" which is really in the mall. Their fresh fish selection is good and paired with a nice salad is enough for me. Service is friendly and you can see some of the seafood through a glass window. Since it is pricy I prefer to go for lunch where I can pay a reasonable amount for a meal. read more

Food is always good. Atmosphere and wait staff were excellent until we sat down. The waiter act like he was irritated. My husband made reservations for us because it's one of my favorite places to go on special occasions. The Ahi tuna poke is sooooooo good. Not to mention the gumbo and the stuffed salmon (mouth watering). We sat at the bar until our table was ready. Bar staff was amazing. Even the company around the bar was fun. We eventually decided to just dine around the bar. Kaleb ruined my Mother's Day with his crappy service and terrible attitude. I still tipped him well over 30%. I understand he's not a robot, I just wish he was much friendlier. read more

Late lunch , early dinner. Quiet, medium ambience, South Hills feel. Lobster bisque decent. Bread, nice and doughy with good crust. Slaw a bit dry but good. Fries are standard. The BLT is a nice riff on a lobster roll. Mixed drink, good read more

First time visitor here and from the door we were greeted and welcomed so nicely! Restaurant is attached to some kind of shopping plaza but didn't even realize till halfway through the meal. Food was AMAZING!!!! Served hot and fresh and at daily market prices (this is a treat for us) a little bit more expensive then your normal TGIF & Applebee's. We ordered : Two cold water lobsters served with smashed red potatoes and asparagus. DELICIOUS and appropriate serving amount to fill you but not overstuff you. You get a personal butter warmer which is cute and a nice little detailed touch. Mega Sizzling seafood combo which included : king crab legs/mussels/clams/shrimp/ potato wedges - served on a huge sizzling platter (food was grilled and lightly seasoned) at $58 a platter it was awesome to be served food not drowned in seasoning and butter !!! Our waitress was a gem and very accommodating! We will most definitely come back!!! ***only downside is where we were sitting - near the kitchen /take out area and all we could head under the candlelight glow was most of the young staff complaining/dropping/ and talking about things I wish not to hear if I'm spending $150 for dinner *** sit somewhere near a window or away from the kitchen area *** read more

Mitchell's Fish Market - Two cold water lobster tails with smashed red potatoes and asparagus - Seafood Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I like this place. It may be 4-stars, but I've only dined here two or three times. Here's my take: - The Food. I've had seafood (no surprise) and it's very well prepared and plated. Fish seems fresh and not over cooked, not dry, very tasty. - My wife tried a seafood pasta that she liked very well. The calamari appetizer is great, too - lightly fried with just a little crispy batter. - They've updated their menu and there's good variety here. Entries, soups, entree salads, and even some non-seafood pastas and sandwiches. - SERVICE: I'm seated quickly and the wait staff are good. - SETTING: It's a little bit worn; a little in need of a makeover, but it's not egregious. It just feels a little 1998 in there. My most recent visit (May, '18) was better than my previous, so I'll be back, and may add a star if it's really good again. read more

The waiter was very nice and answered all the questions we had to ask. Also they take extra precautions with people with allergies which is very helpful. read more

Mitchell's Fish Market - Shrimp Scampi Pasta - Seafood Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Worst than home cooking. I had scallops that had no sear and were so small and tasteless. The spinach that came with it was just bland with no seasoning at all. The only highlight was the mashed potato's. I was really disappointed, I had a taste for scallops and only got mass potatoes for an exorbitant price. Won't be back. P.S. The next day I bought some scallops myself and cooked them. They were fantastic. There are several Michell's restaurants, this has got to be one of the worst. read more

Updating my review of Mitchell's. After my review I was contacted by 3 different members of Mitchell's management to tell my experience. They were very apologetic and said they would mail me gift certificates that I could use at any of their restaurant's since I did not live in the Pittsburgh area. It has been over 2 months and I have not received them or any correspondence. Apparently the problem with this chain goes higher than the local employees in Pittsburgh. read more

Great food, great service and management is awesome, my husband had a health issue while we were there and the management and were so concerned and considerate . read more

Galleria location is top notch. Great selection of seafood & fresh fish dishes and amazingly fresh raw bar / oysters. Service is excellent. I have eaten at this Mitchell's multiple times and always a great experience. I have also frequently dinned at the one in Cincinnati downtown along the Ohio river when on business and they are very consistent also with high quality food and service. I can't end this without mentioning the Creme Brûlée w/berries a must try...5 stars hands down! read more

We recently hosted a birthday party in the private room at Mitchell's. Billy, Allison, Nick and Adam did a fantastic job planning and serving the event. They were very accommodating to us and we're great about our dairy allergy. Chef Matt even came out and walked us through what was ok to eat! The food was good - some better than others - and there was a ton of it! Shrimp and oysters were fresh and the seafood tower was awesome. Deviled eggs, crab cakes, sliders, spinach dip and sesame beef were delish. Could have done without the crudités and cheese platters as well as the fried calamari. Overall I would highly recommend Mitchell's if you're hosting an event in the South Hills. Great job guys! read more

A bad start...but a GREAT recovery!! We were seated and waited for a server to come over for longer than we should have. We got water to begin with and then watched our server walk by about 10 times after that as she fussed over another table that had a problem and just seemed to forget we were there. I lost my patience and got up to leave but my husband said "let's sit out by the bar" ... enter Jae & Teri at the bar - they took SUPERB care of us! Jae gave us great suggestions and we had a really great dinner! We always enjoy the food at Mitchell's and this time Jae saved the day! We'll be back...and we'll go straight to the bar! read more

Dinner tonight was great, my husband and I have been there several times. Used Mitchell's website to make a reservation, definitely recommended, or there is a wait. Our waiter, Trevor was very attentive and helpful with dinner recommendations. We ordered Chilean Sea Bass, blackened with smashed redskin potatoes and fresh steamed vegetables, it was wonderful, it came hot and delicious- perfectly seasoned. Our other dinner was Atlantic Salmon prepared Shanghai style, with sticky rice and spinach, it was delicious, tender, perfectly cooked and the Shanghai style was extremely tasty. All in all a wonderful dining experience. read more

The best place to have a sea food, my salmon was ridiculously delicious, very fresh the wood they used to keep the food warm and flavorful was perfect. I am just loving this restaurant tour at Pittsburgh . I would strong recommend this restaurant Ivanete wolstoncroft read more

Mitchell's Fish Market - My dish was a salmon very fresh,flavored deliciously delicious ! - Seafood Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Great Experience! Was looking for seafood dinner - haven't been to Mitchell's for years - and only visited the Waterfront location in the past. We really weren't impressed with that location enough to go ever back again. We went early for happy hour and were impressed with the drink and appetizers offered! I love the moscato sangria! yummm! Also Calamari was fantastic and my husband loved the fresh oysters (not on a special, but delicious!) We stayed for dinner, ate at a hightop in the bar area - service was EXCELLENT! (Jae) We tried New England Chowder & Lobster Bisque - enjoyed them both with the warm bread they offered. Husband had pan seared scallops (cooked perfect) - I had the Shang Hai Combo - also enjoyed. Can't say anything negative about this experience and we are pretty tough on restaurants. Also- being in the business - we noticed something that impressed us too. A server broke a glass by the bar, shattered everywhere - This happens a lot. You should remove all the glassware that in close range and re-wash. Most places won't do that honestly, especially during a busy happy hour at the bar. BUT, they did - we watched as someone carefully took all the glasses out and had them washed. Great job Mitchells. Clearly they have a GM who knows what's up here. We love how close this location is to our home and will continue to go here! They have a new regular customer. Thanks for a great experience. read more

I have to mention that I eat regularly at this place and always order the same dish because its quality was great. HOWEVER, the quality of the restaurant went downhill since its acquisition in January. I always order the same tilapia Shanghai style and this time the sauce was watery, the rice was undercook and the veggies were just nasty. So, the food is 1/2 bad...how about the place in general...? I was always impressed by the restrooms...oh...wow...mouth wash, great soap, and nice toiletries. Today, all gone, just a roll of brown paper remains. According to management "customers" do not need that. Even the mints and toothpicks are gone...and good luck finding a prompt hostess...as she is always on the phone taking care of take-outs. On the plus side, service is trying very hard to keep the standards. If you want an overprice place with medium quality food that does not care for its customers....Mitchell Fish Market galleria is the place to go. Save your money and visit BRGR. sorry guys....you are not special anymore.... read more

Took my wife on a date here while we were visiting family in the Burgh. The restaurant is in the Galleria mall. Nice bar area, and fresh seafood. My thoughts: 1) Oysters on the half shell - delicious. 2) King crab legs - overcooked. 3) Warm sourdough bread with whipped butter to start - addictive. Bottom line - this place was a little pricey but you're probably paying for the quality seafood. Check it out if you're in the area. Also a nice mall to walk around in before or after dinner. read more

I've eaten here before and it's very good. Delicious if overpriced. I write tonight because I am disappointed in treatment I received from the bartender. I saw they were offering food & drink specials until 10pm on a poster outside, but the bartender shoo'ed me away at 9, claiming they were closed. Bummer and I hate being treated like that. read more

Yeah, I am going all-out and giving this place 5 stars. Here's why: when I moved here in February, I moved from Hawaii. Yes, that Hawaii. With a fabulous hey-I-just-caught-this-ahi-let's-cook-this-up mentality. When I moved in the dead of winter, I wanted fish like in Hawaii. Whatdoyouknow, they had ahi from Hawaii. Let me just set up my tent and live in this restaurant! Fantastic preparations, fabulous sides and seafood flown in from Hawaii. Served up by great bartenders and waiters and I'm sold. I have been going there at least every 2 weeks since February. Now they have wahoo from Hawaii on the menu. There is a word in Hawaiian for delicious, it's ono. Ono is also the name used for wahoo. Seriously delicious. If you can, go to Mitchell's for any fresh fish, but make sure to try the ono-I mean wahoo. All the fresh fish is amazingly ono!!! read more

Went here for lunch with my Aunt this past weekend. It was my first time at Mitchell's Fish Market although my Aunt is somewhat of a regular. We started with the Spinach and Artichoke Dip for an appetizer. Since, that is such a common appetizer I can't really compare it. I thought it was good. However, for my main course I thought I'd be adventurous so I ordered the Shanghai Sampler. Which is is salmon, shrimp, and scallops on a bed of sticky rice, with spinach and a yummy Asian inspired sauce. It was awesome! Perfect portion for lunch and very tasty! It wasn't overly sauced and the seafood was cooked to perfection. Over all the food was great, as was our waiter. I will be back. read more

~~~The Deal-o ~~~ East coast version of McCormick & Schmicks w/ fresh daily fish, signature preparations..but also have a prefix option & retail fish sale Solid oyster / crab place; will come back to try the fish to see if it is all that.. ~~~The Order ~~~ -- Fresh Bread - this was real warm & good -- Spicy Asian Shrimp - sweet sticky rice, pickled cucumbers......$8.95 * BF ordered and loved, well cooked, fried/crunchy w/ sauce, lots & lots of shrimp -- Lg Oyster Sampler - 2 oysters of each of the 4 types offered....$15.95 * Liked the variety options from Chesapeake bay, WA, etc * Included both cocktail sauce & minuet sauce * Fresh & good sized; my favs were the chesapeake & G-something oysters -- Alaskan King Crab Legs - 1 lbs w/ bake potato & broccoli ....$28.95 * Legs might not look like a lot but gets you to full w/o even gettin' to the potato or broccoli * BF sub'd asparagus w/ broccoli; waitress also offered other options * BF loved legs, sweet, fresh, sliced already for him & vat of melted butter on a candle -- Sharkfin Pie - Butter fudge ice cream, honey roasted peanuts, fudge, peanut butter, Oreo cookie crust.....................................................$6.50 * Huge huge portion; side crust w/ peanuts & PB in bt/wn the ice cream --- Shanghai Martini - vodka, lychee, ginger cocktail .......~$9 * I usually don't drink martinis cuz the vodka for me is overpowering..but this cocktail was perfect. You smell the lychee vs. the vodka and still has a kick...and sweet & good. Very addictive.. * Only wish was that they would've added a couple lychee at the bottom of the glass ~~~ Service ~~~ Great service & atmosphere; extra plus for having a carafe of ice tea at the table for self refill Note - women's bathroom offers mouthwash & lotion..nice... read more

See all

Mitchells fishmarket is a small regional train with two locations in the Pittsburgh area. I have been to the one in the waterfront a few years ago and it was one of the worst experiences I have had at a restaurant in a long time. However, the experience at the Mitchells fishmarket in Mount Lebanon was much much better. Our server was extremely helpful and constantly filled up my water glass before I even had to ask him. I had the Shanghai salmon which is that one of my favorites it was prepared as I was used to at my first Mitchell's experience in Wisconsin many years ago. My husband have a broiled cod and enjoyed it as well. I topped off our dinner with a mini shark fin pie which is a delicious ice cream pie with an Oreo cookie crust. I will definitely be back again! read more

Absolutely way over priced. Service is terrible. Save your money and go to a nice place for the money

I have been coming here with my husband weekly for almost 5 years. Today I brought my mom and it was ridiculous!! I splurged and ordered crab legs. They give my 3 pieces of dried up claw, one was half empty and a section of one leg. For $60!!! So I tell my server and show him. No I'm sorry nothing. Takes the pot and a short woman comes back with NO introduction and says they are making you more but you should finish these. Finish them?!! I never touched them!!! There's no need to waste all that meat. What meat??? I showed her each little piece was half empty. It was as if they took pieces of claw from different peoples leftovers and plopped them in a pan. The waiter never reappears. Short woman brings new pot and says he went ahead and made you another pound. Like she was doing me a favor!! Waiter doesn't reappear 42 min!! Never apologizes once and asks if we want dessert. No thank u. Then he takes my check off the neighbor table and hands it to me. Why was it on their table?? They didn't give a discount, no nothing! We won't be back here! read more

If you were thinking of going to Bonefish, do yourself a favor and head over to Mitchell's instead. We always enjoy our meal at Mitchell's - food is great, service is prompt and it doesn't take 20 minutes for your drinks to arrive. Bonefish is TRASH! Haven't had a bad experience yet! Waiters are really cool and the manager always stops by to check on us. read more

Me and my girlfriend went to Mitchell's for valentine's day dinner. We chose Mitchell's because it was close, we both like seafood, and we were easily able to get a reservation. When we showed up at 7:00, there was a line to get in, which I figure is normal when everyone is making reservations for the same time. The line went quickly as everyone had a reservation and was promptly seated in the restaurant. for some reason, me and my girlfriend were seated "outside" rather than in dining room or at the bar. I use quotes because outside in this context is basically in the middle of the mall. Couples before and after us were seated in dining area so I'm not sure why were had to sit in the mall. It felt weird because they seated us by the hostess station and there were people waiting in line to get in about two feet away from us. It was also a little strange to spend this much money on dinner while staring at the Panera from across the hall. What I did like was that when I made my reservation, I told them I had a peanut allergy and the seating hostess was aware when she sat us without me needing to say anything. She told us she would tell our waiter for us. Just to be sure though, I told the waiter about my allergy and it seemed like he was hearing it for the first time. But maybe she just had not spoken with him yet. Our waiter was very nice and attentive. I ordered the Shang Hai Sampler. It was pretty good. My girlfriend ordered the cod stuffed with lobster and shrimp. She loved it. We were given complimentary chocolates and also ordered creme brule and a cappuccino. My girlfriend loved the dessert but my cappuccino had no foam by the time it came so essentially it was a latte. We will probably give this place another chance since the food was pretty good and we were given a coupon to come back. Otherwise this place is a little too expensive for the food. It is really too expensive if you are eating in the middle of a shopping mall. read more

We went for dinner and sat at the bar. The atmosphere was enjoyable, quiet but still enough going on. We received excellent service and I thought the pricing for the meals was fair based on the size of the meal. I got one of the restaurant week specials, it had an option of a salad, 3 entrees to choose from, and 2 dessert choices for about $30. read more

We were passing through the area and were looking for dinner a little more upscale then Eat 'n Park so we ended up at Mitchell's Fish Market. We sat in the parking lot for a while waiting to ensure that we were dressed appropriately, but it was a Tuesday night so it was quiet, and we figured we would give it a go. Overall, the dress for the resturant is business causal, but there were several people sitting at tables in jeans. Food was incredible! I had the salmon which is sushi grade salmon and melted in your mouth. My boyfriend had a platter with three different types of seafood in three different preparations... he said it was incredible. I was able to steal one of his Shang-hi Scallops which was perfectly cooked and the shang-hi sauce was a great salty balance to the sweet and savory scallops. I was surprised none of our meals came with a starter salad, but only a small basket of bread... but to be honest, once our meals came we hardly noticed since the main dish was so large. I just wish there was a location closer to DC. read more

We visit this restaurant 3-4 a year. We had a out of town guest we wanted to treat to nice dinner. The last couple time prior to this visit were ok. That being said we wanted to give it a shot again for our friend. We were all disappointed. The service was very slow and we went early around 5pm. Not only was the service hard to bare the food was not up to Mitchell's normal quality. My daughter grill cheese was not editable and little cheese was on it. Mostly two slices of big bread. The Shang Hai seafood platter was not worth it. Shrimp were small and dry. The salmon was cut in half almost like the butterflied it and gave me the top part only. Very weird. Scallops were cut in half. The dish was poor quality and not what you would expect from Mitchell's. Everyone's dish was just not what we were expecting. Our guest made a few comments about how long the service took especially when we were done and wanted to leave. The waitress actually complained To us about how she can't keep up with the tables. I know it's covid but they weren't that busy at all yet. As we were leaving the busy rush was coming in. Our after dinner espresso and cappuccino were cold also. Just disappointed with the service and the food. Will not recommend for fine dining esp when your bill is $300. We expect more when we are paying these prices. read more

Mitchell's Fish Market - a plate of food - Seafood Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

My husband and I had a late dinner of appetizers with my parents here on a Friday night, and it was perfect. We walked in after 10:00 pm, and were seated immediately by a friendly server who did not just ignore us because she wasn't the hostess. Very appreciated! We all had wine and beer, and shared plates of calamari, ceviche, and crab cakes. All were very fresh, and the dipping sauce for the calamari was awesome - something different from traditional marinara that had an Asian spin. The crab cakes were full of fresh crab, and the ceviche was light and refreshing, served with plenty of chips. Overall we were very pleased with the food and service, and even though my husband and I only dined here once, my parents visited three times during their stay in the area. My mother recommended the lobster roll - said it was even better than ones she has had in Maine! Cheers! read more

Excellent meal! We had a family dinner for 13 on Easter Sunday and the staff and food couldn't have been better. We had Cara as our waitress and she was just naturally pleasant, professional, and really skilled with people, from our 86 yr old dad to our 4 yr old. The seats were comfortable and there was plenty of room for us to eat. Let me start by saying they have the best clam chowder I've EVER tasted. Our dishes ranged from perfectly cooked NY strips to bourbon salmon to the trio and everyone raved about their dinners. We also got appetizers; everyone loved the civiche and the spicy crispy shrimp! And desserts, the shark fin pie was delicious. The only slight negative was the bread. It's sourdough and people in this area might not be used to how sour it is. That being said, it was fresh, hot, and crusty. I didn't care for it, but that's a personal taste issue. There's plenty of food without the bread. I'd come back here in a heartbeat for another family dinner. Everything was fantastic and perfectly executed. :) read more

This is the worst salad that I ever saw the lettuce is black it should have been thrown out days ago. . Why would they not look at it and say would I eat that. Absolutely Not! Called and talked to the mgr he said I'll take if it. He could have care less. Seriously people don't care !! Save your money. read more

Mitchell's Fish Market - Caesar salad ??? - Seafood Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

We went to Mitchell's after not having visited there for years. Previously we had only dined at the Waterfront location. We went because we used to love their sea bass prepared Shanghai style and saw that the had outdoor seating. Mitchell's did not disappoint. The service was excellent and my wife and I had the Blue Cobia Shanghai style and it was better than ever. We will be back! read more

This Review will be three parts... food, service and decor. Food... 4 stars. Food was very good. I got a filet and shrimp. Excellent but pricey. Service... 2 stars. We sat at the bar. The bartender took our order and waited on us. Although it seemed she worked here for a long time, she was very flustered and got our order wrong. She even forget our drinks at one point and we had to remind her. The bar area was not very crowded and we noticed that she made the same mistakes with other patrons. Not sure what the problem was Decor..1 star. As previously said we sat in bar to watch a football game. There are four tv's placed in very strange places with made it almost impossible to watch them. The tv's were old and needed updated. read more

What an extreme disappointment! My husband and I don't go out much due to our hectic work schedules so we planned on drinks and apps at Mitchell's tonight for a night out. The $100 inc tip we spent was completely wasted. We ordered a lemon drop martini & a Bloody Mary which were good the first round. Second round had No garnishing!! Isn't that the point of a Bloody Mary?! I had the Mitchell's salad ... supposed to have dates & pine nuts. Had No pine nuts and 1 lone date. Sad. Ordered lobster bisque and gumbo soup. Bisque was good. Gumbo was pathetically just rice & sauce. We love mussels and were looking forward to our order. They looked good and were tasty but had no broth to go with it. We like to dip the bread in the broth. So we requested more broth. It came out right away and the waitress dumped it all over the mussels. It was straight up salt. Made the mussels completely inedible. After the disappointing 2nd round of drinks, the disappointing gumbo and disappointing salad, we were just done. $83 hard earned dollars down the drain. We will definitely not consider Mitchell's for our next date night. read more

Lunch special Lobster / Shrimp Cobb salad marginal - old yellow lettuce , lack of quality or attention in the kitchen which spoiled the $23 salad. Overall an unremarkable lunch read more

Love this restaurant. The seafood is incredibly delicious. Wonderful appetizers. My favorites are the Spicy crispy shrimp and the Ahi tuna. Relaxing atmosphere with great drink menu also. It does get crowded on the weekends so call ahead. read more

My wife and I are frequent visitors to Mitchels. We always sit at the bar. There is a nice group or 'regulars' to hang out with there. Terri and Jae always go out of their way to make sure all of their guests are well taken care of. Make sure to order the shark fin pie for desert. read more