Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mommy's Cookie Jar

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open Open 24 hours

    Mommy's Cookie Jar Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mommy's Cookie Jar

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Mommy's Cookie Jar

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 10,008 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Wall's Bake Shop - Mandel Bread

    Wall's Bake Shop

    4.3(144 reviews)
    2.9 km
    $$

    I do not know why I haven't been back to Walls Bakery for over 2+ years. It's is one of the best…read morebakeries in the neighborhood. Mandel bread was delicious. Four Fruit pie too. Got some cookies too - Purim poppy hamentashan & coconut chocolate rugelach.

    I grew up in Woodmere so I used to visit Walls pretty frequently! Now that I've moved out East,…read morevery rarely do I go back to my hometown but last month was one of those times, it was my chance to visit Walls again! The bakery hasn't changed at all in over 50 years, just as I remember it! There's still the incredible smell of baked goods as you walk through the door! I ordered the Chocolate Bobka and a Black and White cookie, which was a must for me! They still make the best Black and White cookies! I was not happy at all to hear they no longer make their Chocolate Eclairs! Back in the day, walking home from HS, I would always pass Walls and I would buy an Eclair to eat on the way home! They were filled to the brim with delicious custard and the dough that held the custard with the chocolate strip on top was over the top amazing! The Chocolate Bobka was a little dry but still very good! Together with a glass of milk it was a great treat that brought back lots of memories! I'm planning a repeat visit next month, the Apple Strudel and Rugalach I remember being delicious so that's what I'll be getting when I return. I hope the owner is there, I'd really like him to reconsider bringing back the eclairs!! If you're in the area, try to visit Walls! The Bakery is more than 60 years old and just a charming, real old fashioned Bake Shop!

    Photos
    Wall's Bake Shop - Cookies

    Cookies

    Wall's Bake Shop - Exterior

    Exterior

    Wall's Bake Shop - 4-Fruit Pie

    See all

    4-Fruit Pie

    Only Rare NYC

    Only Rare NYC

    4.6(26 reviews)
    5.8 kmLaurelton

    I drove past this spot several times within the last 6 Months and decided to take the kids for a…read moretreat on a rainy evening. I drive past baskin robins and carvels. Why??? Because it's black owned and I want to support my community. I like to live around nice things and I also LOVE ice cream. Surprisingly I did not get anything. When we walked in it's a cool artsy urban feel graffiti paintings of characters on the wall and like customer clothing that was cartoon or ice cream inspired. My children got the sweet stuff one of them got something with blueberry and the girl got her standard lucky charms concoction. I stood over and made little TikTok and boomerangs of them making the ice cream which is fun. They took out a torch to roast the marshmallows. It was a cool experience I guess they call it ASMR. I was in the mood for something I did not see but my children where all smiles and looking their lips and they didn't make a mess in my car so good for them. And cheers to their local lil neighborhood gem. Parking is not that trickery spin the block if you didn't find anything and try again.

    Ice cream light delectable delicious Service amazing…read moreJarred gave us great service Ambiance chill relaxing Great place to go to on a summer night

    Photos
    Only Rare NYC - Rare Cookies and Cream and M&Ms

    Rare Cookies and Cream and M&Ms

    Only Rare NYC - Captain crunch rolled ice cream with fruit loops cereal topping.

    Captain crunch rolled ice cream with fruit loops cereal topping.

    Only Rare NYC - Captain crunch rolled ice cream with fruit loops cereal topping and birthday cake rolled ice cream with sprinkles.

    See all

    Captain crunch rolled ice cream with fruit loops cereal topping and birthday cake rolled ice cream with sprinkles.

    Mommy's Cookie Jar - desserts - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...