I have heard many wonderful reviews about this infamous bakery, even going out east in Suffolk county. Now, for any holiday, we prefer their No Sugar Cheesecake. It is the first item to disappear at family events. The service is very good as well. It seems like all employees enjoy working here. Big fan of Whistle Stop! read more

Went to the bakery based on reviews I have read. Was quite disappointed. It was overpriced. I have tasted better Italian cookies from supermarkets and the cheesecake... Bland. I'll stick to Juniors and the Cheesecake Factory. read more

Whistle Stop Cheesecakes are the creamiest cheesecakes I've ever had. My favorite has always been their Triple Chocolate Cheesecake. Be on the look out for the sign on Lawson Blvd. It is a bit chaotic in that area but the parking is ample. Customer service is decent. There are plenty of other options & the inside is decorated so cute! There's an Instagramable Caboose prop right by the register too. read more

Whistle Stop Desserts - Lots of options!! - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

The best cheesecake ever!!!! Only thing that's not so great is the location and how small the shop is. It's such a popular bakery i thought they would've expanded by now. They don't take orders over the phone so be prepared to come in early and wait in line. Every time I bring their cheesecake to a function people love it!! read more

It's been at least 5 years since I've been here last and they absolutely have not lost their touch when it comes to the crumb cakes. The apple crumb cake is my favorite but the regular is just as good. I got one of each and they were both extremely moist and flavorful. They were a hit at home and in my office. It's very easy to drive past as it's a somewhat industrial area but the staff is friendly and the cakes are excellent read more

Whistle Stop Desserts - Plain Crumb Cake and Apple Crumb Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

3/15/25. The cheesecake lives up to their reputation. It was creamy, soft and had such a great flavor. The crust and topping were tasty and added to the overall taste. The cheesecake is a definite buy!! The rainbow cookies were average though. read more

Whistle Stop Desserts - 3/15/25 plain cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

All the years of driving by and not knowing I was missing these fantastic pies! Ten people in line and it only took a couple of minutes and even though they didn't have my pie on display, they had it in back and that's awesome! I will say that this place is amongst all the factories and easy to miss and I kinda love that. read more

Whistle Stop Desserts - Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

Came here through a recommendation from their neighbors across the street (Bella Italia Granite that just did work for me) and boy are these desserts amazing! We got the classic cheesecake. Went home, everyone enjoyed it that we had to go back again the next day and get another as we had family coming over to check out the work done to our house and wanted to serve a sweet treat. Great service from the employees behind the counter. I'm glad Bella Italia Italia sent us here and we will continue to recommending and coming back ! read more

Beat cheesecake around. The other cakes and pies and cookies and cupcakes are great. Try the Ice Cream cakes made to order and great.

The desserts here are great from cheeesecake to pies of every flavor you can't go wrong. During the holidays the line is out the door but it goes quick. The place is huge but the main entrance is tiny. Once in a blue we get a bad pie (too hard or too sweet) here and there but very rare. read more

See all

I've never been to New York but my neighbors in Dandridge TN are from there. Every time they go up to visit they bring us back a cheesecake from the Whistle Stop. It is by far the best cheesecake I've EVER had. So grateful for this delicious gift. What fantastic neighbors. Thanks Jim and Anna Laperuta and the Whistle Stop Desserts shop. read more

I haven't been inside here but I got a box of their chocolate macaroons and oh my damn were they delicious. And I don't even like macaroons. Enough said. I'll be back for more. read more

See all

Snow ball cookies are so good but it seem like they don't have them all the time. Staff was so friendly and sweet. But the other customers were so rude and pushy that the second time we came, I didn't purchase anything. There are cookies and cakes to choose from. read more

Whistle Stop Desserts - Snowball cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

The cheesecake. Holy good golly the cheesecake! It was so good. I think so could have eating it all by myself. You have to get it. Just do it. Do not hesitate. It was the best ever! The crust on the bottom and the topping were spectacular. The. The cheesecake itself.... So flavorful! Melt in your mouth goodness! read more

See all

I was headed to another local bakery to pick up dessert, but it was closed. I checked yelp! And found Whistle Stop Desserts and noticed the favorable cheesecake reviews. When I walked in, another customer was completing her purchase. I asked her what she recommended and she said "everything is so good!" I asked if she had had the cheesecake and she said "yes, the cheesecake is delicious"! So, I picked the chocolate swirl cheesecake and it was a definite hit with our group. read more

best cheesecake ever especially the cherry cheesecake and the chocolate mouse cake is my daughters favorite

Their cakes are moist and not too sweet! A friend orders from there a lot and so I ordered a chocolate cake with choc mousse for my party as well! Highly recommend! read more

The greatest bakery in the world. Cheesecake at a different level than anywhere else. I discovered it living in Long Island and when I moved to Florida I had it shipped read more

My favorite cheesecake place in Long Island, it's a cute place and they do social distance by having 4 people at time to go in the bakery. And the price for the desserts are reasonable. I usually get the 7" pineapple and strawberry cheesecake but I wanted to try something different this time. I ordered; 1. Brownie 2. Pecan tart 3. Strawberry cheesecake 4. 7" eggnog cheesecake read more

See all

A good friend recommended this bakery and I understand why. It's small inside but they bake an incredible amount of goods. We have tried the regular original cheesecake, strawberry (I think) topping cheesecake, key lime, mini original cheese and mini cupcakes. All good, fresh baked items. I really like the cheesecake - light, not too sweet, right amount of crust, light zippy taste of cheesecake. Done SO well. Seriously, thumbs up. The mini cheesecakes are great because you get to try a little bit of everything without having a lot leftover and not feel so guilty and weighed down. They said they can literally top it with anything you want since the base is the original cheesecake. Also makes for great gifting and sampler sizes for gatherings. The mini cupcakes were pretty good and still really fresh three days later. Comes in red velvet, chocolate and vanilla. Definitely a fan and can't wait to come back to order more. Friendly service, popular location (sometimes there is a line) and they can add writing to your cheesecake if you want a message....beautiful penmanship, too! read more

Very good cannoli cake. I bought for my son birthday party everyone love it' going to buy more today ;)

Everyone knows this is the best cheesecake what could I possibly add ? I wish the parking was a little better but it's worth it !

good cheesecake, very nice customer service, very efficient and clean place. Friendly service

This is not easy to find. It is buried in a commercial area, but it is worth seeking out. Everything I have had from here is delicious. Went today again and got a gluten-free vanilla pound cake that is soooooo good. And also got a Raspberry lindzer tart that is one the best things I have ever eaten. I am dreaming about having more of it right now. And the Mississippi mud cake is so decadent that you will want more...... Definitely worth the trip from anywhere. read more

The pastries are delicious, especially the cheesecake. It's an establishment that you could easily miss as you drive down the street because it sits back a little. Also, remember that they are closed on Sunday and Monday. read more

One of the best cheesecakes I have tasted. I ordered a total of three items, a mini red velvet, a mini chocolate crust cheese cake, and a full size apple crumble cake. The mini red velvet and apple crumble was amazing!! Must do, leave in room temperature for 15 minutes before eating. It makes a world of a difference, the cheesecake becomes so soft and creamy, absolutely amazing. Mini chocolate crust cheesecake tasted like it was in the fridge for longer than the other two items. The mini cheesecake tasted a bit like freezer burn (-1) read more

See all

Someone brought a strawberry cheesecake from this bakery for a birthday. It is a delicious American cheesecake. I prefer a light cheesecake. I haven't found a bakery that makes a light cheese cake yet. This place serves up a lighter cheesecake than Juniors. It's not overly sweet which is a huge plus for me. It's very creamy. I wouldn't mind trying other goods from this place. read more

Great cakes. Known for cheesecakes. Highly recommend Whistle Stop. Great variety of pastries. Plenty of parking read more

The cheesecake is excellent. The key line pie was also very good. I think they were called mud pies and they were delicious. Everything I've gotten there has been fabulous. Service is always good. read more

Delicious. Fresh! And customer service is actually stil in existence here!!! Check out the carrot loaf. Yummmm

Amazing! I was craving a chocolate cake and remembered eating one at high school a few years ago from Whistle Stop. We were able to get in and out of the bakery within 3 minutes tops. There are little boxes of cookies as well as a huge selection of cakes and pies. Their tiramisu was a bit frozen on the inside, but the outside looked good. I usually go with the chocolate mousse. It was perfect. Not too sweet, light, and very rich. I've also tried the carrot cake which was great. I'm excited to try their cheesecakes! Will definitely be back. Mmmm! read more

See all

This bakery is hidden between commercial buildings. What caught my eye was the line right before Thanksgiving as I was driving to Costco. I stopped in one day and oh my! absolutely the best cheesecake & pie! The staff was very friendly and they have a lot of different desserts to choose from. Definitely worth the drive! read more

I haven't had something I didn't enjoy 100% yet, and every time I bring a cheesecake to a function it gets rave reviews. (I always buy myself a personal slice too hahaha) Whistle stop is my first choice when I need to "bring a dessert to someone's house" because, manners. And I am often tempted on my weekend errands to snag a slice or two, wink wink ! Just for me ! read more

Excellent service, outstanding bakery goods and plenty of choices. I certainly recommend Whistle Stop to anyone.

Best cheesecakes, great variety of cheesecakes - so many you can't even imagine, super coconut pie, and the fruit pies are excellent. Worth the trip. If there is something special you want, or you are afraid that they might run out, call ahead and order it. read more

I found this shop when searching for a birthday cake for my mom. I decided on getting a cannoli cake so searched some bake shops near me. I decided to try the whistle stop bake shop and was not disappointed. I stopped by on my lunch break so the place was empty. The staff was extremely friendly helping me choose and wrote happy birthday on the cake for me. I also decided to get a small cheese cake additionally since they're known for it. Both the cheesecake and cannoli cake tasted light and fluffy. My family loved it and couldn't stop eating it. I would love to try some more options so I'll be coming back! read more

See all

The BEST key lime pie ever!!! I haven't had their cheesecake in a while but have read other reviews and it's a must next time. My husband's absolute favorite dessert is key lime pie and I have searched far and wide for the best, this is IT. I specifically ask for a frozen one and we keep it in the freezer, it cuts easily and it's perfect to eat right out of the freezer if you like it really cold. It's the perfect summer treat! Their location is unassuming and easy to miss but don't pass this place up, you won't regret it. The staff is always helpful and this place has been around since I grew up in Lynbrook, some, umm...time ago read more

The absolute BEST strawberry shortcake; who knew?!?! Cheesecake from here is famous and always a hit.

The Best Red Velvet Cake In Town Hands Down I have yet to get something that was not terrific. You can't go wrong at Whistle Stop. Even my hardest to please friends love everything I've bought from there. It's my go-to item to bring when I go to dinner parties. The guests ALWAYS ask where the cake/pie is from. They make the best Red Velvet Cake in town hands down with just the right amount of buttermilk and don't over do it with the chocolate like others do. Yellow Cake w Chocolate icing, Rainforest cake, Carrot Cake, Apple & Pecan and Cheery pies, & all of the cheesecakes are great! read more

This easy to miss bake shop has hands down one of the best New York style cheesecake's in the Northeast. Was literally so good that we finished a full cheesecake between 3 people in their parking lot. They also have a wide variety of flavored cheesecakes, pies and other desserts all of which are excellent. Highly recommend! read more